SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My point is that the Bible contains information, it cannot “tell”, only people can “tell”. You have a right to whatever you want. You look a little silly acting like you didn’t understand what I meant so you could avoid answering the question, but whatever.
You see, the problem is that Ginger2 and WindGirl are in need of someone to interpret what you posted. They aren’t able to figure it out on their own and/or came up with their own interpretation. 😛
 
You see, the problem is that Ginger2 and WindGirl are in need of someone to interpret what you posted. They aren’t able to figure it out on their own and/or came up with their own interpretation. 😛
Ahhhh, so that’s how it works :rolleyes: .
 
Why stop there? why can’t I ordain myself as a priest, or better yet declare myself an infallible pope… i think we just stumbled onto something here…
Hey, that would be nothing new. Protestants have been declaring themselves infallible for a long time.

How?

They claim that the Pope and the Magisterium are not infallible.
But since they agree that the Holy Scripture is infallible then they have had to agree that the Catholic Church was infallible at some stage (during the cannonization of the Bible but not before or after that.)

But how do we know that they were infallible during the cannonization and not before or after? Why because the protestants have infallibily decreed they were so 😃

For them to accept the infallibility of the Bible they will have to make themselves infallible.

So there you are. Take a number with regards starting your own church, there’s quite a queue:D
 
My point is that the Bible contains information, it cannot “tell”, only people can “tell”.
That is far too logical an argument I’m afraid.
You have a right to whatever you want. You look a little silly acting like you didn’t understand what I meant so you could avoid answering the question, but whatever.
I really must make a count on the number of times this kind of observation has been made:D .
 
I was surprised to come across this thread by Ginger2 when another thread on the very same subject, to which Ginger2 is an active “participant”, is going strong and has not been terminated.

Again, the question that comes to mind is why? I asked Ginger the question on the other thread: Why are you insistent in posing the same question regarding the “inability of priests to forgive sins and that it is unnecessary to confess to a priest” Why are you on these forums? You are not discoursing or debating - you are arguing. You talk as though you are an authority and reject outright the explanations of people who take the trouble to answer you patiently and painstakingly. You respond with “Wrong!” “False!” and total rejection. I have not been very patient although I did try. I have to work on being more patient.

Here are some passages which should answer the question and I will be surprised if they are not all rejected outright because they will not conform to the Gospel according to Ginger2:

*John 20:21 - before He grants them the authority to forgive sins, Jesus says to the apostles, “as the Father sent me, so I send you.” As Christ was sent by the Father to forgive sins, so Christ sends the apostles and their successors forgive sins.

John 20:22 - the Lord “breathes” on the apostles, and then gives them the power to forgive and retain sins. The only other moment in Scripture where God breathes on man is in Gen. 2:7, when the Lord “breathes” divine life into man. When this happens, a significant transformation takes place.

John 20:23 - Jesus says, “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven. If you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” In order for the apostles to exercise this gift of forgiving sins, the penitents must orally confess their sins to them because the apostles are not mind readers. The text makes this very clear.

Matt. 9:8 - this verse shows that God has given the authority to forgive sins to “men.” Hence, those Protestants who acknowledge that the apostles had the authority to forgive sins (which this verse demonstrates) must prove that this gift ended with the apostles. Otherwise, the apostles’ successors still possess this gift. Where in Scripture is the gift of authority to forgive sins taken away from the apostles or their successors?

Matt. 9:6; Mark 2:10 - Christ forgave sins as a man (not God) to convince us that the “Son of man” has authority to forgive sins on earth.

Luke 5:24 - Luke also points out that Jesus’ authority to forgive sins is as a man, not God. The Gospel writers record this to convince us that God has given this authority to men. This authority has been transferred from Christ to the apostles and their successors.

Matt. 18:18 - the apostles are given authority to bind and loose. The authority to bind and loose includes administering and removing the temporal penalties due to sin. The Jews understood this since the birth of the Church.

John 20:22-23; Matt. 18:18 - the power to remit/retain sin is also the power to remit/retain punishment due to sin. If Christ’s ministers can forgive the eternal penalty of sin, they can certainly remit the temporal penalty of sin (which is called an “indulgence”).

2 Cor. 2:10 - Paul forgives in the presence of Christ (some translations refer to the presences of Christ as “in persona Christi”). Some say that this may also be a reference to sins.

2 Cor. 5:18 - the ministry of reconciliation was given to the ambassadors of the Church. This ministry of reconciliation refers to the sacrament of reconciliation, also called the sacrament of confession or penance.

James 5:15-16 - in verse 15 we see that sins are forgiven by the priests in the sacrament of the sick. This is another example of man’s authority to forgive sins on earth. Then in verse 16, James says “Therefore, confess our sins to one another,” in reference to the men referred to in verse 15, the priests of the Church.
*1 Tim. 2:5 - Christ is the only mediator, but He was free to decide how His mediation would be applied to us. The Lord chose to use priests of God to carry out His work of forgiveness.

Lev. 5:4-6; 19:21-22 - even under the Old Covenant, God used priests to forgive and atone for the sins of others. *

It is very interesting and instructive to come to these forums. I recognise those who are diligent, knowledgeable and willing to share and impart knowledge. I appreciate them - they are not all Catholic. Ginger2 could adopt a better attitude - one of good-natured appreciation towards the participants who take the time to provide answers to questions which are sometimes difficult for those who have little or no knowledge of the Catholic Church. I assume that is why people come on these forums of Catholic Answers Forums (CAF) - they are unfamiliar with our faith and look for explanations.

They have every right to adhere to their beliefs but to tell us that we are Wrong! and that the CC doesn’t know what it is talking about is, quite frankly, offensive.

Having said all of the above I wish to add that I too am learning - my knowledge is far from substantial but I do know right from wrong. I will try to learn as much as I can and hope that next year I will be a better contributor.

Please Ginger2 - try to be nice. Read what the posters respond to your questions and comments and show a little respect.

Happy New Year! To you all! You are always in my prayers

Blessings
Cinette
 
Protestants do confess directly to God. But we also go to the person(s) we have wronged, apologize and do whatever we can to repair the damage and be reconciled to our brothers and sisters in Christ.

In all the years I was Catholic, I was never asked to do anything more than say x number of Hail Mary’s and y number of the Lord’s Prayer for penance.

I find it much more humbling to talk to God directly and go directly to the person who may tell me off and not accept my apology.

So, I don’t feel any need for a priest as God is the one who will decide whether or not I am forgiven. God knows that I am truly sorry and God knows the best way to set things right again.
But John 20:23…“if you forgive…if you retain”. They stand as custodians for God.

CCC **1441 **Only God forgives sins. Since he is the Son of God, Jesus says of himself, “The Son of man has authority on earth to forgive sins” and exercises this divine power: “Your sins are forgiven.” Further, by virtue of his divine authority he gives this power to men to exercise in his name.

God bless you,
 
IOW…you couldn’t figure out what she meant either? Why do you figure that your personal interpretations of the Bible are correct, when you can’t even understand what the word “tell” means? :confused:
 
These men you quote aren’t Scripture, are they? If what they say disagrees with the real ECF’s whom God used to pen His word, wouldn’t it stand to reason that they’re wrong?
JL: Yes, If what they say disagrees with the scripture. Point is they don’t disagree.
 
My take is that the non-Catholic antagonists in this thread have run out of arguments and are falling back on assertions.

Time to move on.
 
It’s kind of odd that Jesus would say to people “search the Scriptures” if they don’t tell us anything. :confused: You know I have just as much right to believe I’m right about something as you do to believe you’re right.
Questions:

a) If you believe you are right about the Scripture and

b) Bookgirl (based entirely on her own understanding) believes she is right about the Scripture and

c) since you claim the Holy Spirit guides those who reads the Bible,

then which one of these conclusions is correct:

a) The Holy Spirit knows what He is talking about, so only one of you is correct, but which one? And you cannot say the one who was guided by the Holy Spirit because that is what we are trying to establish here.

b) Both of you are correct so the spirit is one mighty confused spirit which would contradict the Bible.

Clue: Christ promised that He will send His Spirit to guide His Church into all truth. Not to believe that would be to call Christ a liar.😃
 
You’re going to find fault and say that any explanation that doesn’t agree with what you believe is unsound even though there are other explanations. There’s just no way Catholics will agree with any explanation that is not the Catholic one. That’s a given.

justforcatholics.org/a08.htm
Second reply:

Why should we believe anything else when Christ promised to guide His Church into all Truth? Not to believe in His Body and Bride would be to disobey Jesus. After all, he said to His disciples, whoever hears you, hears Me.

If you want to disobey Christ in this regard, that is fair enough. That is why we have free will. It is our choice to obey or not.
 
Questions:

a) If you believe you are right about the Scripture and

b) Bookgirl (based entirely on her own understanding) believes she is right about the Scripture and

c) since you claim the Holy Spirit guides those who reads the Bible,

then which one of these conclusions is correct:

a) The Holy Spirit knows what He is talking about, so only one of you is correct, but which one? And you cannot say the one who was guided by the Holy Spirit because that is what we are trying to establish here.

b) Both of you are correct so the spirit is one mighty confused spirit which would contradict the Bible.

Clue: Christ promised that He will send His Spirit to guide His Church into all truth. Not to believe that would be to call Christ a liar.😃
Wonder if you’re going to get an answer for that one.
 
My take is that the non-Catholic antagonists in this thread have run out of arguments and are falling back on assertions.

Time to move on.
And this is a very typical Protestant way of debating.

You go from point 1 to 10. At Point 10 they have no comeback so invokes point 1.
 
But I do hope they will exercise the grey cells and try.

At the very least, one day when they least expect it, the question will nag, then …
Let’s hope so!

Do not be discouraged, though. There are a lot of lurkers, some of them Catholic that needed this thread.👍
 
when christ founded His church in matt 16:18, did christ intended that his church will have an official name? what is the official name? is ist the church of christ or church of god? rome 16:16, 1 cor 1-2?
delaacecruz said:
when christ founded His church in matt 16:18, did christ intended that his church will have an official name? what is the official name? is ist the church of christ or church of god? rome 16:16, 1 cor 1-2?
It has been called all of these. Scripture also refers to it as the Catholic Church. What has that got to do with confession to a priest? Do you believe that Jesus gave the Apostles authority?
 
In my honest opinion I think the problem is that everyone has a Bible. Everyone is born into this world just assuming that everything has always been this way. So many Christian denominations and people being born into it just accept the way things are.Never questioning it. Then there are those who are compelled to look into it more deeper. To research not only Scripture but Christian history.

We can reveal where the Ministry of Reconciliation a.k.a. Confession a.k.a. Penance is in Scripture but some people refuse to see those verses for what they are. Because if they did accept the Ministry of Reconciliation they would be accepting something that goes against everything they were brought up to believe. That is scary for anyone.

Read the Bible and see where Jesus says He will build a church…
one church…and promises to be with His church** forever**…
from that time 33 a.d. past 2008. Look up when each church was founded and who founded it. Because you know that a church that started in the 1900’s isn’t the one that Jesus left us.And just to get anyone who wishes to research started I’ll give you a starting point…1521a.d. a date in history that marks the begining of a protest. The Protestant Reformation. The History Channel was helpful in getting me started.

God Bless you on your journey!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top