SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Once again the Scripture you are referring to is being misinterpreted:

2 Peter 1:
We ourselves heard this voice come from heaven while we were with him on the holy mountain.
Moreover, we possess the prophetic message that is altogether reliable. You will do well to be attentive to it, as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts.
Know this first of all, that there is no prophecy of scripture that is a matter of personal interpretation,
for no prophecy ever came through human will
; but rather human beings moved by the holy Spirit spoke under the influence of God/B].

These verses state the the Scripture, given to us by the prophets and written down in what we call the Holy Bible, is the Word of God and not opinions of men.

Catholics interpret it ti fit their man-made doctrines.

Now my family has started to arrive for Christmas I will not have time to chat in CAF - at least not for awhile.

May you all have a Merry Christmas and a prosperous New Year!Footnote from the Douay-Rheims translation:

20 Understanding this first, that no prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation.

20 “No prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation”… This shows plainly that the scriptures are not to be expounded by any one’s private judgment or private spirit, because every part of the holy scriptures were written by men inspired by the Holy Ghost, and declared as such by the Church; therefore they are not to be interpreted but by the Spirit of God, which he hath left, and promised to remain with his Church to guide her in all truth to the end of the world. Some may tell us, that many of our divines interpret the scriptures: they may do so, but they do it always with a submission to the judgment of the Church, and not otherwise.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is. I do not believe the church was ever like the RCC of today. The term catholic means universal and Christ’s church is universal in that sense. Borrowing the term and turning it into an official church tital doesn’t make any one group alone Christ’s church for the Bible reveals His church to be believers.
Borrowing the term???

If so, it was “borrowed” a very, very long time ago…here are a half dozen or so quotes from the Early Church Fathers prior to 250 A.D.

Ignatius of Antioch

“You must all follow the bishop as Jesus Christ follows the Father, and the presbytery as you would the Apostles. Let no one do anything of concern to the Church without the bishop. Wherever the bishop appears, let the people be there; just as wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.” (Letter to the Smyrnaeans, A.D. 107, [8,1])

The Martyrdom of Polycarp

“When at last he had finished his prayer, in which he remembered all who had met with him ant any time, both small and great, both those with and those without renown, and the whole Catholic Church throughout the world.” (The Martyrdom of Polycarp, 8:1, [A.D. 156]).

“And certainly the most admirable Polycarp was one of these [elect], in whose times among us he showed himself an apostolic and prophetic teacher and bishop of the Catholic Church in Smyrna.”(The Martyrdom of Polycarp, 16:2, [A.D. 156]).

Irenaeus

The Catholic Church possesses one and the same faith throughout the whole world, as we have already said (Against Heresies 1:10 [A.D. 189]).

Tertullian

“Where was [the heretic] Marcian, that shipmaster of Pontus, the zealous student of Stoicism? Where was Valentinus, the disciple of Platonism? For it is evident that those men lived not so long ago – in the reign of Antoninus [AD 138-161] for the most part – and that they at first were believers in the doctrine of the Catholic Church, in the church of Rome under the episcopate of the blessed Eleutherus [AD 175-189], until on account of their ever restless curiosity, with which they even infected the brethren, they were more than once expelled. . . . Afterward . . . Marcian professed repentance and agreed to the conditions granted to him – that he should receive reconciliation if he restored to the Church all the others whom he had been training for perdition; he was prevented, however, by death.” (Demurrer Against the Heretics, 20, [A.D. 200]).

**Clement of Alexandria
**
“From what has been said, then, it seems clear to me that the true Church, that which is really ancient, is one; and in it are enrolled those who, in accord with a design, are just. . . . We say, therefore, that in substance, in concept, in origin and in eminence, the ancient and Catholic Church is alone, gathering as it does into the unity of the one faith which results from the familiar covenants, - or rather, from the one covenant in different times, by the will of the one God and through the one Lord, - those already chosen, those predestined by God who knew before the foundation of the world that they would be just.” (Stromaties 7:17:107:3 [A.D. 202]).

“… There is one true Church, the really ancient Church into which are enrolled those who are righteous according to Gods ordinance… In essence, in idea, in origin, in preeminence we say that the ancient Catholic Church is the only Church …”

Cyprian of Carthage

“They who have not peace themselves now offer peace to others. They who have withdrawn from the Church promise to lead back and to recall the lapsed to the Church. There is one God and one Christ, and one Church, and one Chair founded on Peter by the word of the Lord. It is not possible to set up another altar or for there to be another priesthood besides that one altar and that one priesthood. Whoever has gathered elsewhere is scattering.” (Letter of Cyprian to All His People 43 (40), 5 [A.D. 251]).

“Peter speaks there, on whom the Church was to be built, teaching and showing in the name of the Church, that although a rebellious and arrogant multitude of those who will not hear or obey may depart, yet the Church does not depart from Christ; and they are the Church who are a people united to the priest, and the flock which adheres to its pastor. Whence you ought to know that the bishop is in the Church, and the Church in the bishop; and if any one be not with the bishop, that he is not in the Church, and that those flatter themselves in vain who creep in, not having peace with God’s priests, and think that they communicate secretly with some; while the Church which is Catholic and one, is not cut nor divided, but is indeed connected and bound together by the cement of priests who cohere with one another.” (*Letters *66 A.D. 253]).
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is…
Thats not the point. The Bible is infallible, but your interpretations are not. THAT is the point.

The Magisterium infallibly hands on and inteprets what Christ taught.
 
Infallibility, (in general) exemption or immunity from liability to error or failure; (in particular) in theological usage, the supernatural prerogative by which the Church of Christ is, by a special Divine assistance, preserved from liability to error in her definitive dogmatic teaching regarding matters of faith and morals. In this article the subject will be treated under the following heads: I. True Meaning of Infallibility; II. Proof of the Church’s Infallibility; III. Organs of Infallibility—(A) ecumenical Councils; (B) The Pope; IV. Scope and Object of Infallibility; V. What Teaching is Infallible?
oce.catholic.com/index.php?title=Infallibility

The Bible cannot be infallible. The Bible is inerrant, as determined by the Catholic Church. The Pope and Magisterium possess the charism of infallibility under very particular circumstances.
 
Footnote from the Douay-Rheims translation:

20 Understanding this first, that no prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation.

20 “No prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation”… This shows plainly that the scriptures are not to be expounded by any one’s private judgment or private spirit, because every part of the holy scriptures were written by men inspired by the Holy Ghost, and declared as such by the Church; therefore they are not to be interpreted but by the Spirit of God, which he hath left, and promised to remain with his Church to guide her in all truth to the end of the world. Some may tell us, that many of our divines interpret the scriptures: they may do so, but they do it always with a submission to the judgment of the Church, and not otherwise.
I shouldn’t be on here this morning :eek: I haven’t the time. But, since I am…

The DR Bible is wrong, but that should come as no surprise.

The word used in 2 Peter 1:20 is “epilysis”. I think this is the only place it is used in the NT.

It means “unloosening”

Other places in the NT that read "interpretation use the word “diermēneuō” which means
  1. to unfold the meaning of what is said, explain, expound
  2. to translate into one’s native language
“diermēneuō” is used in reference to those who can interpret tongues.

“hermēneuō” is used to
  1. to explain in words, expound
  2. to interpret
    a) to translate what has been spoken or written in a foreign tongue into the vernacular
So we must consider the entire passage rather than one verse for which we have no comparisons to clarify its meaning:

2Pe 1:21 **For the prophecy came not **in old time by the will of man: but holy men of God spake [as they were] moved by the Holy Ghost.
 
Ginger and WindGirl, can you prove that confession of sins to a Priest is expressly forbidden in the Bible?
 
How do you know? Is the Vulgate wrong? I bet St. Jerome would not agree with you.
Here is an excerpt from the decision to revise the DR Bible from Pope John Paul II:
"In realizing this revision, “the old text of the Vulgate edition was taken into consideration word for word, namely, whenever the original texts are accurately rendered, such as they are found in modern critical editions; however the text was prudently improved, whenever it departs from them or interprets them less correctly.”

Here is the link:

ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JPTHESAU.HTM
Apostolic Constitution SCRIPTURARUM THESAURUS
Pope John Paul II
 
Ginger and WindGirl, can you prove that confession of sins to a Priest is expressly forbidden in the Bible?
I did not say it is wrong, nor claim it is forbidden.

As a matter-of-fact, I think it is good. The Bible says we should confess to one another. But the priest cannot absolve us of our sins.

Now, I need to get to work. I have a deadline on an article, pies to bake and company coming tonight. Tomorrow is Christmas Eve!!!
 
Here is an excerpt from the decision to revise the DR Bible from Pope John Paul II:
"In realizing this revision, “the old text of the Vulgate edition was taken into consideration word for word, namely, whenever the original texts are accurately rendered, such as they are found in modern critical editions; however the text was prudently improved, whenever it departs from them or interprets them less correctly.”

Here is the link:

ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JPTHESAU.HTM
Apostolic Constitution SCRIPTURARUM THESAURUS
Pope John Paul II
I accept the “Apostolic Constitution SCRIPTURARUM THESAURUS
Pope John Paul II
Promulgated on April 25, 1979”
 
Let me just say first of all that this is an excellent thread. I think both sides have done an excellent job at explaining their faith. I can totally see both sides of the argument here (which doesn’t really help me get out of this “limbo” state I’m in :rolleyes: )

I just have a few things to ask after having read through the entire thread.

One scripture and one thought repeatedly come to mind when I consider the idea of an infallible earthly authority (aside from the Bible):

The Scripture is this: But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

Paul’s statement here definately seems to dispel the idea that he is or is part of an infallible magisterium. If even Paul is capable of preaching “another gospel” in stands to reason that a lineage within a church organization is not a guantee of infallibililty.

And my thought is this: When Jesus was amongst us there was no one between He and common man - no one to help explain things. And at times people did misunderstand Him. Many times people simply walked away because His were “hard sayings”. Considering this, I tend to believe that the discontinuity within Christendom arises from our inability or unwillingness to believe and/or obey what is contained within Scripture. Man sees what he wants to see and hears what he wants to here. “He who has ears to hear let him hear…” Of course these thoughts can equally apply to the Catholic Church in her claims. Perhaps those from the outside are the ones not “seeing”.

But Paul did not consider it impossible for him to preach another gospel. People failed to understand or obey God even when He walked this earth. The fact that the gospels were written at all indicates some concern that the truth might be lost had they not written them **3It seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write unto thee in order, most excellent Theophilus,
4That thou mightest know the certainty of those things, wherein thou hast been instructed. ** Scripture also says error and deception will arise from within and there will be (or would be) a great falling away. It does not say when this will or did happen. So although it seems good and necessary for there to be an infallible, earthly interpreter/authority, I also see the distinct possibility that God intended for Scripture to be that “certainy of those things” which, if looked at in humility and honesty can be believed, understood and obeyed sufficiently for our salvation.

As for confession, many people here keep asking “how do you know you are forgiven” implying that if you don’t here those words from a priest you can never know for sure. But Scripture tells us that if we confess our sins God will forgive them. We have faith that they are forgiven. As a Catholic I looked forward to confession as obedience to the church, and also as a means to restore grace or obtain grace to overcome those sins. So I guess my question about priestly confession is in the possible efficacy of the sacrament. As for how sins are retained, well, I liken that to shaking the dust off of one’s sandles so to speak. IOW, those who hear the gospel and refuse to believe will not be forgiven. Please tell me how a priest can retain sins. A priest cannot necessarily even determine the intent of one confessing - he cannot know one’s heart so how can he actively, knowingly retain sins?

Thanks~
 
can you prove that confession of sins to a Priest is expressly forbidden in the Bible?

I realize that it is not forbidded, and I agree it can and is good. The question is whether or not it is necessary or part of the “fullnes of truth”. The problem is whether or not it is efficacious as the CC claims it is, or, at least, more efficacious and necessary than confessing to good and holy people who are not priests or to those we have offended, or to the church community, etc…
 
can you prove that confession of sins to a Priest is expressly forbidden in the Bible?

I realize that it is not forbidded, and I agree it can and is good. The question is whether or not it is necessary or part of the “fullnes of truth”. The problem is whether or not it is efficacious as the CC claims it is, or, at least, more efficacious and necessary than confessing to good and holy people who are not priests or to those we have offended, or to the church community, etc…
It boils down to whether or not you believe what the Catholic Church claims and if you recognize and submit to her authority.
 
It boils down to whether or not you believe what the Catholic Church claims and if you recognize and submit to her authority.
Okay, so, I see veracity in both arguments but I should just put my faith in the CC and submit???

If the non-Catholic argument is correct it raises some very big concerns about the claims of the CC. If the CC is not an infallible, earthly authority, if the pope is not the vicar of Christ, if it is unnecessary for us to confess to a priest, if the eucharist is not the body and blood of Christ, if we should pray to the father through Christ and not to Mary and the saints, etc., etc., then it seems all these things are being put in the place of God. In all these circumstances we see God substitued (if these things are not true). It is a very important question. It is very difficult to believe what the CC claims and submit to it when it is equally possible (in my mind anyway) that it is the exact opposite of what it claims. I don’t mean to sound nasty in saying that and I’m not prepared to say I believe that right now because I feel literally like I am teetering on the top of the fence about these things. When I can’t draw conclusions either way about these issues (for now, here, confession) I tend to lean toward the non-Catholic side just as a precaution. The Catholic argument is thought-provoking and often does make sense to me, but the other argument is far clearer to me. In fact, it was clear to me in my first-ever reading of the NT from front to back. Over time I have discovered that a great majority of non-Catholics are in agreement about this interpretation (not that it makes it true or that they are all successful in putting it into practice). It takes a lot more investigation and “brain-power” to come to find and possibly understand the Catholic p.o.v. which also raises a red-flag in my mind. What about being like “little children”? What about “You have hidden these things from the wise and intelligent and have revealed them to infants.”? Considering the extent one has to go to in order to attempt to understand that Catholic doctrine possibly doesn’t contradict Scripture - well, quite frankly it makes me wonder if I’m being convinced by clever human philosophies or some sort of deception 😊 .

:confused:

So you see, it is not that simple. At least not for me.

Now, on the other hand (the Catholic one ;)) if I say all these things are taking the place of God, then I am denying some very obvious facts from Scripture (although I don’t know if it applies). Like, for instance, the fact that God choose 12 apostles to begin with. Using my reasoning it doesn’t even make sense for God to have done this b/c in a sense they are taking God’s place, right? He gave ordinary men authority. Of course, they also performed miracles. Maybe that was necessary for the propagation of the faith. Otoh, maybe it was proof of their authority which ended with their ministry and lives on through Scripture. We don’t see much opposition to the obvious Catholicity of the very early church (pre-canon) but maybe orthodox believers were few as the truth often is unpopular and Jesus’ flock He said was “little”.

But then to look at this reasoning I am doing exactly what I accused the CC of doing with all it’s complexity. It is far clearer to me that Christ’s church was the CC when I look at history. Everything else is pure speculation. 🤷

Anyone else dizzy? :whacky:
 
When I can’t draw conclusions either way about these issues (for now, here, confession) I tend to lean toward the non-Catholic side just as a precaution.
I would think it would be the other way around. Of course, I’m wearing Catholic lenses. I would think as a precaution you’d want to lean towards Catholicism when you can’t draw conclusions, just in case the everything the Catholic Church claims is true.

Do you believe the Catholic Church was guided by the Holy Spirit when she determined the Canon of Scripture? If you do, it stands to reason you should believe all that she teaches because the Holy Spirit guides the Church into all truth and all of her doctrines and dogmas. That same Holy Spirit that guided the Church when determining Scripture also guides/guided her in *all *of her doctrines and dogmas.
 
I would think it would be the other way around. Of course, I’m wearing Catholic lenses. I would think as a precaution you’d want to lean towards Catholicism when you can’t draw conclusions, just in case the everything the Catholic Church claims is true.
I used to. I don’t anymore firstly b/c if the church’s claims are false, then I am submitting to a system full of substitutes for God (a really bad thing, don’t you agree?), and going against my conscience (“let everyone be convinced in his own mind”), and at the very least, I’d only be considered one of the “seperated bretheren”. I have spent more Sundays with the conservative Mennonites than at Mass. They are morally more conservative (and more biblically traditional) than the CC, at least in this area.
Do you believe the Catholic Church was guided by the Holy Spirit when she determined the Canon of Scripture? If you do, it stands to reason you should believe all that she teaches because the Holy Spirit guides the Church into all truth and all of her doctrines and dogmas. That same Holy Spirit that guided the Church when determining Scripture also guides/guided her in *all *of her doctrines and dogmas.
I’m not really sure what I believe about the canonization process; whether the church at that time simply recognized scripture or was guided in some way or whether their being guided would mean they were being guided in other ways. Also, the books of the NT were being circulated before the canonization so the church was never without Scripture.
 
Of course, one does not need a priest in order to confess sins, but to receive absolution and sacramental reconciliation, one **does **need a priest.

A priest can refuse absolution, if he does not believe there is true contrition (which would include that there is something that can be done to rectify the wrong that is being held back, like an apology and other restitution).

Additionally, if I am going to confess my sins, I’m pretty sure I want to do it to someone bound to secrecy by the seal of confession.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is.
The DR Bible is wrong, but that should come as no surprise.
Don’t tell WindGirl! 😉 If the DR Bible is wrong, how do you know which one is right?
Okay, so, I see veracity in both arguments but I should just put my faith in the CC and submit???

…]

:confused:

So you see, it is not that simple. At least not for me.

…]

It is far clearer to me that Christ’s church was the CC when I look at history. Everything else is pure speculation. 🤷

Anyone else dizzy? :whacky:
Oftentimes! Pray for guidance, I’m pretty sure I read somewhere that God loves you! 😉 He won’t abandon you, keep praying for guidance, it will come.
 
I guess if the DR Bible contradicts a protestant then of course it’s wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top