SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I doubt this will satisfy you but there is only one infallible Being in the universe and that is God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). The Bible doesn’t tell me to let another human being infallibly interpret Scripture for me. It does tell me this:
JL: He who hears you hears me

1Jn 4:6 We are of God Whoever knows God LISTENS TO US and he who is not of God does not listen to us BY THIS WE KNOW the spirit of TRUTH and the spirit of ERROR

John 1612 I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now.
13 Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.
14 He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you.
 
I doubt this will satisfy you but there is only one infallible Being in the universe and that is God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). The Bible doesn’t tell me to let another human being infallibly interpret Scripture for me. It does tell me this:
JL: LK 10:16 HE THAT HEARETH YOU HEARETH ME and he that despiseth you despiseth me and he that despiseth me despiseth him that sent me

1Jn 4:6 We are of God Whoever knows God LISTENS TO US and he who is not of God does not listen to us BY THIS WE KNOW the spirit of TRUTH and the spirit of ERROR

MT 18:17 And if he shall neglect to hear them tell it unto the church but IF HE NEGLECT TO HEAR THE CHURCH let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican 18 Verily I say unto you WHATSOEVER YE shall BIND on earth shall be BOUND in heaven: and WHATSOEVER YE ye shall LOOSE on earth shall be LOOSED in heaven

HB 13:7 REMEMBER THEM WHICH have the RULE OVER YOU who HAVE SPOKEN unto you THE WORD OF GOD WHOSE FAITH FOLLOW considering the end of their conversation 8 JESUS Christ THE SAME same yesterday and to day and FOR EVER Hb 13:17 OBEY YOUR LEADERS and SUBMIT to them for THEY are KEEPING WATCH over your souls as MEN WHO WILL have to GIVE ACCOUNT Let them do this joyfully and not sadly for that would be of no advantage to you
John 1612 I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now.
13 Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.
14 He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you.
JL: Christ is speaking to the apostles, only in a secondary way is he speaking to all. If he were speaking to all primarily we would all have the same conclusion or be infallible.
 
Originally Posted by WindGirl
I doubt this will satisfy you but there is only one infallible Being in the universe and that is God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). The Bible doesn’t tell me to let another human being infallibly interpret Scripture for me. It does tell me this:

JL: Just a P.S. Yes there is only one infallible Being in the univese and that is God. There is only one who can Heal and that is God, there is only one who can forgive sin and that is God, there is only one who can walk on water and that is God, It is God alone who can give and does give these gifts to man.
 
Originally Posted by WindGirl
I doubt this will satisfy you but there is only one infallible Being in the universe and that is God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). The Bible doesn’t tell me to let another human being infallibly interpret Scripture for me. It does tell me this:

JL: Just a P.S. Yes there is only one infallible Being in the univese and that is God. There is only one who can Heal and that is God, there is only one who can forgive sin and that is God, there is only one who can walk on water and that is God, It is God alone who can give and does give these gifts to man.
May I add that God also gave us the gift of Himself as man in the Incarnation of Christ? And he even used mud to heal a blind man. I think if we can deny the use of man to infallibly interpret Scripture we could just as easily have denied that Jesus was God since He was in human form. Indeed many did deny Him. If I were the blind man, and Jesus had spit into the ground and swiped up the mud to put on my eyes I may have said “What are you doing? Mud can’t heal me! Neither can a man! Only God can do such things!”
 
Christ is speaking to the apostles, only in a secondary way is he speaking to all. If he were speaking to all primarily we would all have the same conclusion or be infallible.
Just like if it were up to all to compile the canon of Scripture we might come away with 30,000+ different versions of the Bible. Yet for some reason there wasn’t much contention over the canon that was decided by the Church. Why is that? And who could possibly have had the authority to decide. If all were given the same Holy Spirit as a guide, the Scripture would never have needed to be formally decided. It would have been easily recognizable to all. If protestants can excuse their 30+thousand different interpretations of Scripture, then wouldn’t you also expect 30+thousand different interpretations of inspired Scripture? We don’t find this though, b/c the early church recognized the infallibility of the Church. If we can argue today against this infallibility then we’d better go back to all the historical writings and figure out which ones are REALLY inspired.
 
Just like if it were up to all to compile the canon of Scripture we might come away with 30,000+ different versions of the Bible. Yet for some reason there wasn’t much contention over the canon that was decided by the Church. Why is that? And who could possibly have had the authority to decide. If all were given the same Holy Spirit as a guide, the Scripture would never have needed to be formally decided. It would have been easily recognizable to all. If protestants can excuse their 30+thousand different interpretations of Scripture, then wouldn’t you also expect 30+thousand different interpretations of inspired Scripture? We don’t find this though, b/c the early church recognized the infallibility of the Church. If we can argue today against this infallibility then we’d better go back to all the historical writings and figure out which ones are REALLY inspired.
Dang!, now i’m really confused,>> dude were you just playing “devil’s advocate” all along, or were you skeptical, and have changed your mind on the subject?
 
Dang!, now i’m really confused,>> dude were you just playing “devil’s advocate” all along, or were you skeptical, and have changed your mind on the subject?
I guess you could say I was enlightened. I was tackling some of my remaining doubts when I entered this thread and my error suddenly was realized a few days ago. Don’t know that I’m 100% “there” yet, but things are definately a lot clearer. 😃
 
I guess you could say I was enlightened. I was tackling some of my remaining doubts when I entered this thread and my error suddenly was realized a few days ago. Don’t know that I’m 100% “there” yet, but things are definately a lot clearer. 😃
Praise God! 😃
 
Protestants do confess directly to God. But we also go to the person(s) we have wronged, apologize and do whatever we can to repair the damage and be reconciled to our brothers and sisters in Christ.

In all the years I was Catholic, I was never asked to do anything more than say x number of Hail Mary’s and y number of the Lord’s Prayer for penance.

I find it much more humbling to talk to God directly and go directly to the person who may tell me off and not accept my apology.

So, I don’t feel any need for a priest as God is the one who will decide whether or not I am forgiven. God knows that I am truly sorry and God knows the best way to set things right again.
Confession is commanded in the Scripture and the Sacrament of Reconciliation has been taught and practiced by Christians since the time of the Apostles and ever since. All Christian Churches had it even after the reformation. It is only in the last few hundred years that some Protestant churches have lost it.

I’ll pray for your return to the Church and the Sacraments. Please give this a look: youtube.com/watch?v=hl-08atFqzc

Your servant in Christ
 
I guess you could say I was enlightened. I was tackling some of my remaining doubts when I entered this thread and my error suddenly was realized a few days ago. Don’t know that I’m 100% “there” yet, but things are definately a lot clearer. 😃
Good for you Pilgrim.
I’m a cradle Catholic, and a few years ago I wandered away from the Church. I was one of those “cafeteria Catholics”. Although I had spent 12 years in Catholic schools, I never really understood my faith the way I should have.
I wandered away, and a few years ago attended an orientation at a local Baptist church. It was supposed to be “a comparison of various faiths”, but it turned out to be Catholic bashing.
The pastor would say “Catholics believe…”, and I would think, “No we don’t”. This went on for a couple of hours.
When I got home, I dusted off my Catechism and other literature and told my wife that I didn’t only feel he was mistaken, he was blatantly lying, as much as I hate to admit it.
Well, that’s when my lightbulb clicked on.
Since then, I have spent every available hour learning more about the Catholic faith, and it has done nothing but strengthen that faith.
Now, I’m a rookie shade-tree apoligist!!!
Here’s where your journey starts. You had the “light bulb” moment, so it’s time to rock and roll.
Just remember to always be compassionate in your discussions.
Ginger and Windgirl are as convinced of their beliefs as we are, and they (I believe) have as much concern for our souls as we do for theirs.
Always remember to focus on our similarities, not our differences.
And always treat them as God’s children, our brothers and sisters.
 
Good for you Pilgrim.
I’m a cradle Catholic, and a few years ago I wandered away from the Church. I was one of those “cafeteria Catholics”. Although I had spent 12 years in Catholic schools, I never really understood my faith the way I should have.
I wandered away, and a few years ago attended an orientation at a local Baptist church. It was supposed to be “a comparison of various faiths”, but it turned out to be Catholic bashing.
The pastor would say “Catholics believe…”, and I would think, “No we don’t”. This went on for a couple of hours.
When I got home, I dusted off my Catechism and other literature and told my wife that I didn’t only feel he was mistaken, he was blatantly lying, as much as I hate to admit it.
Well, that’s when my lightbulb clicked on.
Since then, I have spent every available hour learning more about the Catholic faith, and it has done nothing but strengthen that faith.
Now, I’m a rookie shade-tree apoligist!!!
Here’s where your journey starts. You had the “light bulb” moment, so it’s time to rock and roll.
Just remember to always be compassionate in your discussions.
Ginger and Windgirl are as convinced of their beliefs as we are, and they (I believe) have as much concern for our souls as we do for theirs.
Always remember to focus on our similarities, not our differences.
And always treat them as God’s children, our brothers and sisters.
Thank you for your encouragement. As good as i feel right now about my new “vision”, I am still unsettled. I feel as though I have “enough” faith right now to reconcile with the church again, and I’m hopeful this will be my last time. I’ve been on a roller-coaster faith ride for a few years now. Just when I think I’m understanding something that “vision” is gone and I’m left again in limbo. I really thought I was on my way out of the Catholic Church for good when I suddenly found myself arguing (nicely ;)) with the evangelist at the Mennonite church I’d been going to the past few years. In all our discussions, it seems they aren’t quite sure why the believe what they do. Sometimes their conclusion is just “well, we just don’t believe that” or “well, we see it this way” without really seeming to grasp what I’m trying to explain to them. They seem to dismiss logical reasoning just b/c “our ways work”. I agree that their way works well. They are outstanding Christians. But if they don’t have the fullness, well, then they are missing out on a richer relationship with God and the opportunity to grow to even greater spiritual heights. And what kills me is that these people have the potential for sainthood! Ok, so they probably are saints at some level, but they could potentially be even more for God’s glory. They love God, they abhor sin, their whole lives are immersed in their spirituality…

When I was Catholic - devoutly Catholic - before all the doubting, I had the richest faith and greatest sense of peace I’ve ever known. I’ve never been anchored like that since I left the Church. I had NO community. I lived a very sheltered life. I didn’t get really involved in church activities. I always felt like an outsider in the parish. I felt more at home at the Franciscan monastary. But I devoted every day to Mass and adoration and I was so solidly anchored to Christ (or so I thought). What happened? I’m really not sure. I had to give up daily Mass and adoration. I no longer have access to daily adoration. The weekly exposition of the Blessed Sacrament in town here has also been ended. I can’t go to daily Mass anymore b/c of the times that school start for my children. I suppose I could go to noon Mass but I’d have to take an infant and a toddler with me 1/2 hour away (at naptime) to the Franciscan Friary (don’t think I could do that to them: the children OR the Franciscans!). I’ve also developed Celiac disease these past 4 years and communion is a big problem. I’ve been giving a lot of thought to the new parish center about to open here which will have an adoration chapel.

Anyway, I think I battle mainly with fear of deception. I really, really thought I was on my way out - even just recently. I thought I had it solidified in my mind that I could never remain Catholic. Then out of the blue the past month or so I find myself defending Catholicism in one issue after another - like the lightbulb just came back on - yet I wasn’t really realizing that I was solidifying my faith in the Church. I think I just had it in the back of my mind that although I see valid arguments to defend the CC, the bottom line is that I “see” something else in Scripture. Of course, that “vision” just totally fell apart as I realized that I have absolutely no reason to believe in my interpretation, b/c I really have no right to even believe in Scripture unless I will acknowledge Church authority. I already knew the Church at the time was very Catholic. I’ve read the ECF.

I think from there all the walls just came tumbling down at once.

Going to talk to a priest tomorrow. We couldn’t go to Mass Christmas as one of my sons was sick.

Know what is crazy? Everytime I think I want to return to the Church our family battles an illness, or a freak accident freak or some other bizarre circumstances will prevent me from going to confession. Since the doubting started I even developed the Celiac and reception of communion became impossible at first and a real problem ever since. God doesn’t ever seem to be on my side about this. You can call it coincidence if you want to, but I am dead serious - my family and I seem cursed whenever I attempt a return to the Catholic Church. 😦 I guess you could say I’m still a little hesitant considering my past experience with it.
 
Wactchfulpilgrim, What exactly is it you fear you are being decieved on?

P.S. check you PM
 
Know what is crazy? Everytime I think I want to return to the Church our family battles an illness, or a freak accident freak or some other bizarre circumstances will prevent me from going to confession. Since the doubting started I even developed the Celiac and reception of communion became impossible at first and a real problem ever since. God doesn’t ever seem to be on my side about this. You can call it coincidence if you want to, but I am dead serious - my family and I seem cursed whenever I attempt a return to the Catholic Church. 😦 I guess you could say I’m still a little hesitant considering my past experience with it.
Ahhhhh, this is no coincidence. I don’t think this is God, but someone who really wants to keep you away from Him, and away from His Church, if you know who I’m talking about. Sounds like some last ditch efforts to me, don’t let them get in the way!
 
If you have been following this thread closely, you would recall that WindGirl, you tag-team partner, tried to explain the glaring disunity among Protestants by means of an article.

I will provide one also:

Disunity on Essentials
By Jimmy Akin
catholic.com/thisrock/2003/0312bt.asp
You addressed the post to me. How was I supposed to know you were talking to Windgirl? 🤷
Could you please point me to the scripture which outlines the doctrines which are essential? Or would it be easier for you to tell me which verses I can ignore since they are NOT essential?

Or is the whole idea of “essentials” simply a smoke-screen to hide the fact that non-Catholics really have no doctrinal unity and that this is why the number of Protestant denominations now numbers well into the tens of thousands?
I believe this is the 3rd time I have answered this question 🤷

Please see posts #253 & # 351.
 
Ahhhhh, this is no coincidence. I don’t think this is God, but someone who really wants to keep you away from Him, and away from His Church, if you know who I’m talking about. Sounds like some last ditch efforts to me, don’t let them get in the way!
I realize it’s a possibility. Btw, I knew I shouldn’t have said that after I did. It really isn’t fair to attribute things like this to God. I probably now look too hard for these things to happen b/c I expect them, when they probably occur just as often any other time of the year.

It’s just that there are 365 days a year and 2 out of 3 of the past Christmases someone woke up sick. But if I’m going to complain about it then I am just being one of those people who expect only good things to happen to them b/c they follow God’s will, when often what we consider “good” are not the things that teach us virtue.

Peace~

P.S. I’m attempting to go to confession today. :dancing:
 
You addressed the post to me. How was I supposed to know you were talking to Windgirl? 🤷

I believe this is the 3rd time I have answered this question 🤷

Please see posts #253 & # 351.
And I believe this is the 3rd time I have asked for a real answer after reading post #253.

All you have said is "anyone who deters from those fundamental beliefs that make us Christians, are Christian in name only." Okay. Who gets to make up the list of what is “fundamental” and what is not?

Is Infant baptism a fundamental? It is to some Protestants.

How about “King James Onlyism”. Some Protestants insist the the KJV is the only accurate translation and that this is fundamental to the faith. Others don’t. Why is there disagreement if the same Spirit is leading both groups?

You also quote some passages in support of the Apostles’ Creed. Are you saying that the Apostles’ Creed represents your list of essential Christian doctrines?

Fine. Using the Apostles’ Creed or the Bible Alone, please answer these questions:

Some Protestants ascribe to a creed or confession while others claim “no creed but Christ”. Since these Spirit-led Christians hold contradictory views, how can both camps be correct?

Is adherence to a creed essential to the true believer? IOW, is a creed binding upon the consciences of all believers, and if so, which one?

Where is the Apostles’ Creed found in scripture? Or is that creed itself a “tradition of men”?

Finally, is it possible to lose one’s salvation or do you ascribe to the view of salvation that believers are “once saved always saved”?
 
And I believe this is the 3rd time I have asked for a real answer after reading post #253.

All you have said is "anyone who deters from those fundamental beliefs that make us Christians, are Christian in name only." Okay. Who gets to make up the list of what is “fundamental” and what is not?
I said, "These basic beliefs are **found in the Holy …

So, it is God who has given us the foundation for the Christian faith.

Maybe it’s time to get back on topic…

A priest cannot retain my sins - no matter how desperately the RC wishes he could.

God will forgive me on His terms and there is nothing you or anyone else can do to separate me from God.

Romans 8:38 For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, 39 nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.**
 
…Maybe it’s time to get back on topic…

A priest cannot retain my sins - no matter how desperately the RC wishes he could.
**
God will forgive me on His terms and there is nothing you or anyone else can do to separate me from God. **

Romans 8:38 For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, 39 nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.Here of course you are dead wrong…again.

If those sins were not meant to be confessed to one another and to a person who has the apostolic authority to absolve or retain them, the why would Our Lord have even bothered to tell the apostles this?
My Reformation Theory
Catholic Confession

How’s it going Janet/Alfie?
 
I said, "These basic beliefs are found in the Holy …

**So, it is God who has given us the foundation for the Christian faith. **

Maybe it’s time to get back on topic…
Ginger-

Don’t think that it is not obvious to all that you are not answering the questions posed to you. Of course, we also understand why…because you cannot answer them. There is no good answer for the disunity among the thousands of Protestant groups.

**
A priest cannot retain my sins - no matter how desperately the RC wishes he could.
**The only desperation I sense is from your failure to respond adequately to the information presented.

**
God will forgive me on His terms and there is nothing you or anyone else can do to separate me from God.
**
Romans 8:38 For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, 39 nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.Only you can separate yourself from God by your sin and your obstinate refusal to embrace His Church on His terms and not your own.

One last attempt at getting a substantive answer from you:

Did Jesus give real authority to the Apostles or not?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top