SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Here of course you are dead wrong…again.

If those sins were not meant to be confessed to one another
i agree we are to confess our sins to one another - it says so in the Bible.

What I disagree with is a priest being able to forgive sins as God does. It contradicts Scriptures, therefore, your interpretation is wrong.
 
i agree we are to confess our sins to one another - it says so in the Bible.

What I disagree with is a priest being able to forgive sins as God does. It contradicts Scriptures, therefore, your interpretation is wrong.
This is just an assertion. You have provided no evidence to support your argument.

No one questions that God can and does forgive sins.

What you have failed to prove is that Jesus did not give this authority to the Apostles when He said AND I QUOTE:

“23If you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven.” (John 20:23)

Jesus did not say, “If you preach the gospel and they believe you, they are forgiven; if they do not believe, they are not forgiven.”

Again, we know that the Father sent Jesus with “all authority” and that Jesus sent His disciples with that same authority (“as the Father sent me, so I am sending you…”).

Ginger, you want desperately to deny that the Catholic Church is correct in its teachings (all of them, not just about confession to a priest), but you cannot PROVE your assertions.

Either you have not studied enough to make your case, or your case cannot be made because the facts are against you.

Perhaps you might want to stop visiting the anti-Catholic websites that you rely on and put aside those books by reformed theologians like R.C. Sproul and James White and others, and concentrate instead on what the Holy Spirit, the early Christians (like Clement, Polycarp, Ignatius, Irenaeus and Justin Martyr) and the Catholic Church actually have to say to you in their own words.
 
You addressed the post to me. How was I supposed to know you were talking to Windgirl? 🤷

I believe this is the 3rd time I have answered this question 🤷

Please see posts #253 & # 351.
You misunderstood the question, Ginger. He was not asking for a list of doctrines that you think are essential, but the actual list, defining which are essential, and which are not.
 
I said, "These basic beliefs are **found in the Holy …

So, it is God who has given us the foundation for the Christian faith. **

We are in agreement about God having given us the foundation for the Christian faith. Where we seem to disagree is how that foundation was given. Catholics believe that Jesus founded a Church. He appointed the Apostles as authority in His Church, and they ordained faithful men who would be able to teach others also.

Eph 2:19-22
citizens with the saints and also members of the household of God, 20 built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the cornerstone. 21 In him the whole structure is joined together and grows into a holy temple in the Lord; 22 in whom you also are built together spiritually into a dwelling place for God.

In His Church is the foundaton of His revelation to us. Through His Church, He inspired the writing of the Bible. It’s words are not to be separated from the foundation which produced them.
Ginger2;4594121:
Maybe it’s time to get back on topic…

A priest cannot retain my sins - no matter how desperately the RC wishes he could.
This is on topic, Ginger2. If the foundation of the Church is not upon the Apostles, then the authority He gave them to forgive or retain sins is void. That means, the authority they passed to their successors is also void, and your assertion is true.

On the other hand, if Jesus did build His church on the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets, and He did authorize them to forgive and retain sins, the the priest DOES have authority to forgive and retain your sins.

Does the Scripture mean what Ginger2 thinks it means, or does it mean what the Apostles believed an taught? That is the question
God will forgive me on His terms and there is nothing you or anyone else can do to separate me from God.
Yes, God will forgive you on His terms. The terms He provided was through those authorized to forgive.

You are right that no one can separate you from the love of God, but your sins will separate you from Him, and your refusal to accept what He has provided to you for forgiveness will separate you. It is not “anyone else” but you yourself! The only reason a priest would not forgive your sins is if you refuse to repent.
Romans 8:38 For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers
, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, 39 nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.

Oh God will love you alright. he will love you as you pass the gates of hell, and weep that you separated yourself from Him.
 
I want to tell this story because i think its funny, I went to confession this morning, there was a line, but not a long one, the line was moving slowly cause we were short one priest, he was doing a funeral mass.
The Priest that was doing confession was doing a good job, he must have been counseling everyone who went in the confessional, well the people waiting outside the confessional to go in were acting very impatient, their faces were grimacing, body language etc. I thought to myself, these people are commiting sin waiting here to go to confession. I am not really judging, Just thought it was funny, but thats human nature. I think its great that the priest was taking time with each penitent, to do a proper job of confession:)
 
All your questions are off topic and were first brought up by Catholics, not me.

Since I have answered all these questions several times either in this thread or other threads that were about those specific topics, I am not going to continue to repeat myself to no avail.

However, The question below, which has sprung from your apparent inability to comprehend what I have written, seems not to have been asked in this manner before.
Is adherence to a creed essential to the true believer? IOW, is a creed binding upon the consciences of all believers, and if so, which one?
No. The Bible, which is God’s Word, is binding. The Apostles Creed is nothing more than a summary of the doctrines found in the Holy Scriptures. It is not inspired. It is not a detailed story or paraphrase. It is a summary of those doctrines found in the Holy Scriptures which church fathers found important enough to emphasize.
Where is the Apostles’ Creed found in scripture? Or is that creed itself a “tradition of men”?
This is so basic and easy to understand yet you continue to accuse me of not answering. Do you really not understand? :confused: Here it is for the last time.

I believe in God, the Father Almighty, the Creator of heaven and earth, Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
and in Jesus Christ, His only Son, our Lord: John 3:16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son,

Who was conceived of the Holy Spirit, Luk 1:35 And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God.
born of the Virgin Mary, Luk 1:27 To a virgin espoused to a man whose name was Joseph, of the house of David; and the virgin’s name [was] Mary.
suffered under Pontius Pilate, Luke 23:16 I will therefore chastise him, and release [him].
was crucified, Luk 23:23 And they were instant with loud voices, requiring that he might be crucified. …24 And Pilate gave sentence that it should be as they required.
died, Luk 23:46 And when Jesus had cried with a loud voice, he said, Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit: and having said thus, he gave up the ghost.
and was buried. Luk 23:52 This [man] went unto Pilate, and begged the body of Jesus. 53 And he took it down, and wrapped it in linen, and laid it in a sepulchre that was hewn in stone, wherein never man before was laid.

etc.

Each line of the Apostle’s Creed can be traced to Scripture. Each line is paralleled to an easy to understand corresponding Scripture.
 
I want to tell this story because i think its funny, I went to confession this morning, there was a line, but not a long one, the line was moving slowly cause we were short one priest, he was doing a funeral mass.
The Priest that was doing confession was doing a good job, he must have been counseling everyone who went in the confessional, well the people waiting outside the confessional to go in were acting very impatient, their faces were grimacing, body language etc. I thought to myself, these people are commiting sin waiting here to go to confession. I am not really judging, Just thought it was funny, but thats human nature. I think its great that the priest was taking time with each penitent, to do a proper job of confession🙂
Yes and no. I used to think that, but I read a book by Dubay about choosing a spiritual director, and he said that Confession should be brief. The penitent should go through their sins without a lot of detail except for mortal sins, when the Confessor asks for the details. (For example: "I took the Lord’s name in vain inadvertantly, I gossiped, I was angry with my spouse, etc…) Similarly, the Confessor should give brief instruction for mortal sins. The rest is proper to spiritual direction, not Confession.

Which is better? Really “good” Confession for 10 people and 10 turned away, unable to receive absolution for their sins (perhaps a couple of them in serious moral sin)? Or, efficiently done Confession for 20 people, placing them all in a state of grace?
 
Yes, God will forgive you on His terms. The terms He provided was through those authorized to forgive.
God Himself is authorized to forgive. After all, He is God. What other Priest do we need other than Christ? I wonder if Catholics realize the significance of the veil in the templ being rent from top to bottom at the moment of Jesus’ death.
You are right that no one can separate you from the love of God, but your sins will separate you from Him, and your refusal to accept what He has provided to you for forgiveness will separate you. It is not “anyone else” but you yourself! The only reason a priest would not forgive your sins is if you refuse to repent.
If Ginger has put her faith in Christ and been born again, she has not refused what He’s provided, just what YOU say.
Oh God will love you alright. he will love you as you pass the gates of hell, and weep that you separated yourself from Him.
Disagreeing with the Catholic system of doing things doesn’t equal separating ourselves from Him.
 
No. The Bible, which is God’s Word, is binding.
Please show, using the Bible, which books belong in it, and how these books qualify to be in the bible.

Please explain what “binding” means.

Please explain how the decision is made about what in the Bible is “binding” and how it is applied.

For example, how is this applied?: Judg 17:6
"all the people did what was right in their own eyes. "
The Apostles Creed is nothing more than a summary of the doctrines found in the Holy Scriptures.
Actually, experience has made it quite clear that other “doctrines” can be found in scripture contrary to what the Creed states. The reason it was developed was to combat heresies. The modern day incarnation of the Arian heresy (JW) uses the same scripture to prove that Jesus is not God. This is clear evidence that it is not what is in the Scripture, but how it is understood that matters.
It is not inspired.
How did you come to this conclusion? Was this revealed to you by God?

Did you use a certain set of criteria?
It is not a detailed story or paraphrase. It is a summary of those doctrines found in the Holy Scriptures which church fathers found important enough to emphasize.
Well,yes and no. It is an affirmation of what was believed and taught by the early church. It was formed to combat heresies.
This is so basic and easy to understand yet you continue to accuse me of not answering. Do you really not understand? :confused:

Each line of the Apostle’s Creed can be traced to Scripture. Each line is paralleled to an easy to understand corresponding Scripture.
I think it is you that does not understand, Ginger2. You already believe these doctrines, so they are easy for you to see. But to those who reject them, they are not easy to see. Try to convince a JW that Jesus is God!

The word Trinity is not found in scripture. It is a doctrinal development of the early church.
 
God Himself is authorized to forgive. After all, He is God. What other Priest do we need other than Christ?
I think it is difficult for those who have not received priestly ministry to understand what they are missing. Jesus knows what we have need of before we ask it, that is why He gave priests to the Church.
I wonder if Catholics realize the significance of the veil in the templ being rent from top to bottom at the moment of Jesus’ death.
Without this, then there would be no Christian priesthood. 😃
If Ginger has put her faith in Christ and been born again, she has not refused what He’s provided, just what YOU say.
Ginger2 is obviously doing the best she can with what she’s got. She is woefully unable to defend her beliefs, however.

The both of you can deny what Jesus provided to the church, and continue to function without His gifts in these areas. You are free to reject any and all of what Jesus provided. They are just that, gifts. They are offered freely, and rejected by many.
Disagreeing with the Catholic system of doing things doesn’t equal separating ourselves from Him.
Since we are standing in the Apostolic succession, you will please pardon us if we see it differently:

Luke 10:16

16 “Whoever listens to you listens to me, and whoever rejects you rejects me, and whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me.”

From our point of view, when you reject the Apostolic succession, you reject Christ.
 
Of course I’ll pardon you for disagreeing as I hope you’ll pardon me with disagreeing with you. 🙂
 
I think it is you that does not understand, Ginger2. You already believe these doctrines, so they are easy for you to see.
Tell me what is hard to understand about: Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.

Do you think some people might interpret this to mean that aliens created the earth or that the earth developed by accident?

Some people might believe those things, but they can clearly see the Bible says, “God created the heaven and the earth”
But to those who reject them, they are not easy to see. Try to convince a JW that Jesus is God!
I’ve already stated that. :confused:

The Bible says But if our gospel be hid, it is hid to them that are lost: 2 Cor 4:3

Those who chose not to believe don’t understand.

1Cr 1:18 For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.
 
I wonder if Catholics realize the significance of the veil in the temple being rent from top to bottom at the moment of Jesus’ death.
WindGirl, please explain to us the significance of the veil being rent, and what it means. Thanks
 
Tell me what is hard to understand about: Gen 1:1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. Do you think some people might interpret this to mean that aliens created the earth or that the earth developed by accident?

Some people might believe those things, but they can clearly see the Bible says, “God created the heaven and the earth”

I would love to, but I am not going to encourage you to derail your own thread. You seem to have a lot of trouble focusing, so I am going to try to help you. If you want, you can open an new thread.

I would take it to “Ginger2’s thread for off topic posts” but it got closed!

Let’s try to stay on topic, shall we? Do you want to take a stab at the question, where in the NT is there an example of an Apostle retaining sin?

Or, here is another one closer to the topic:

James 5:16-17
16 Therefore confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another, so that you may be healed. The prayer of the righteous is powerful and effective.

This statement is made in the context of calling for the elders (priests) to be present. What is hard to understand that confession in the presence of the priest is healing?
Ginger2;4594959:
1Cr 1:18 For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God
.

So, would it be correct to say that people who do not understand the bible the way you do are among the damned?
 
I realize it’s a possibility. Btw, I knew I shouldn’t have said that after I did. It really isn’t fair to attribute things like this to God. I probably now look too hard for these things to happen b/c I expect them, when they probably occur just as often any other time of the year.

It’s just that there are 365 days a year and 2 out of 3 of the past Christmases someone woke up sick. But if I’m going to complain about it then I am just being one of those people who expect only good things to happen to them b/c they follow God’s will, when often what we consider “good” are not the things that teach us virtue.

Peace~

P.S. I’m attempting to go to confession today. :dancing:
I knew what you were saying, I knew you were speaking out of frustration and not really attributing these things to God. Just trying to encourage.

Sometimes confession is hard to get to, even if it’s just getting up from the pew to the confessional door.
 
WindGirl, please explain to us the significance of the veil being rent, and what it means. Thanks
You won’t agree with me. The veil was to hide or block he way into the holy of holies in the temple. Where the ark and mercy seat was. The priest only went in once a year I believe. We now have no need of any human priest going into the temple and continuing to offer animal sacrfices because we now have a permanent, eternal high Priest that ever lives to make intercession for us before the Father. I have direct access to the Father any time, any where becaues of Christ.

gotquestions.org/temple-veil-torn.html
 
You won’t agree with me. The veil was to hide or block he way into the holy of holies in the temple. Where the ark and mercy seat was. The priest only went in once a year I believe. We now have no need of any human priest going into the temple and continuing to offer animal sacrfices because we now have a permanent, eternal high Priest that ever lives to make intercession for us before the Father. I have direct access to the Father any time, any where becaues of Christ.

gotquestions.org/temple-veil-torn.html
The Catholic Church would agree with some of that, but not with all of the conclusions you and others seem to have. Certainly, the Apostles (including Paul) and the Early Church Fathers did believe in individuals called to priesthood, in addition to the priesthood of believers. Here are a couple good articles to give you a better understanding.

catholic.com/thisrock/2004/0404sbs.asp
catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0503fea4.asp
 
The Catholic Church would agree with some of that, but not with all of the conclusions you and others seem to have. Certainly, the Apostles (including Paul) and the Early Church Fathers did believe in individuals called to priesthood, in addition to the priesthood of believers. Here are a couple good articles to give you a better understanding.

catholic.com/thisrock/2004/0404sbs.asp
catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0503fea4.asp
In the first link it jumped out at me when it said priests reconcile people to God. I disagree. Christ reconciles people to God. You believe He does it through Catholic priests, obviously, and non Catholics do not.
 
In the first link it jumped out at me when it said priests reconcile people to God. I disagree. Christ reconciles people to God. You believe He does it through Catholic priests, obviously, and non Catholics do not.
Yes…and we are right. 👍 😉 😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top