Hi everyone,
I saw the program. It can be watched retrospectively on BBC iplayer, but I am not sure if North American viewers can get it.
Try here:
bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01cl83g/Catholics_Priests/
I was personally left unsure about the program. I liked that it showed the seminarians discussion topics like their vocation/celibacy, abortion etc - it didn’t preach the Catholic viewpoint, but gave enough of the discussion such that viewers could clearly understand the Catholic stance.
I didn’t like other aspects so much. The creepy background music they would often play - as if to suggest the students were odd / quirky - the large amount of time given over to spurious topics - quizzing the students about their clothes / vestments etc, it seemed to me to try to portray them as trite fashion victims or something.
I did like hearing from the students themselves, one was especially sardonic - really not the stereotypical image of a Catholic seminarian.
I think parts of the show played somewhat to anti-Catholic stereotypes: the men were portrayed in debates / offering opinions etc, talking about the style of robes they would be wearing etc, and this was then juxtaposed with prolonged footage of a lone woman cleaning an empty church building.
I guess I give it a neutral review overall - I liked bits, others not. I think it received some favourable reviews mainly because it was a noticeable break from the normal of overwhelmingly negative coverage of Catholicism.
The (UK) Guardian gave it a typically derisory review, saying the priests training comprises “water sprinkling and frock buying” and even managing to mention sex abuse in their review of the show.
The UK’s Catholic Herald also gave a favorable review to the program.
Hi Dale,
I saw that article you linked to, but note that another columnist for the paper was left a bit cold, like me: (he only gives it a quick paragraph or two mention, in a larger article).
I myself did not know what to make of the documentary. There were certain things I found distinctly odd about it, such as the background music, which made my spine tingle a bit – perhaps it was meant to. And the camera did dwell at considerable length, or so it seemed to me, on various items of religious statuary; and there was an awful lot about vestments and clerical dress. One thought that kept on going through my head was this: how would a non-Catholic, or a non-religious person, watching this, make of it all?
catholicherald.co.uk/commentandblogs/2012/02/24/is-it-true-father-that-in-scotland-men-wear-skirts/
The next two parts are about women and children in the church. I expect those will largely be propaganda shows about women priests and yet more bashing the church over abuse.
However, I pray I am disappointed
