Spotlight on BBC Series About Catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic_Press
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Catholic_Press

Guest
What’s it like being a Catholic in today’s British society? Finding the answer to that question is the main aim of a new TV series by the BBC that seeks to portray the complex reality of being Catholic and how this identity shapes peoples’ lives. Starting on Thursday February the 23rd, the 3-part series is called “Catholics” and is produced and directed by prize-winning documentary film-maker Richard Alwyn. He spoke to Susy Hodges about the project and the message he is seeking to get across in this ground-breaking series.

More…
 
Did anyone watch this?

Knowing how much the BBC loves the church I was afraid to watch it. But my curiosity won and I was very pleasantly surprised. I thought it was excellent. They focused on important things, did not push an agenda and they interviewd the seminarians. It really gave a sense of what it is like to prepare for priesthood. One of the seminarians they showed was an altar server in my parish. I felt proud 😃

I wonder what other 2 episodes will focus on.
 
Unfortunately, I don’t think those of us in North America have had the opportunity to watch the program. I’m not sure about New Zealand or Australia.

However, the program sounds like it was worth watching. Here is a bit of the Telegraph’s review:
It was brave of Richard Alwyn to begin Catholics (BBC Four) with an hour focused entirely on young men training for the priesthood. The other two films in his series look at the place of children and women in the Roman Catholic church, and as such are more outward looking, more accessible to the casual viewer than this deep-delving piece on the rarefied, largely enclosed world of Allen Hall, one of just three remaining Catholic seminaries in England.
telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/9100313/Catholics-episode-one-BBC-Four-review.html

Anyone in the UK who missed the program have the next 20 days to watch it online.
bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01cm9rv
 
Unfortunately, I don’t think those of us in North America have had the opportunity to watch the program. I’m not sure about New Zealand or Australia.

However, the program sounds like it was worth watching. Here is a bit of the Telegraph’s review:

telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/9100313/Catholics-episode-one-BBC-Four-review.html

Anyone in the UK who missed the program have the next 20 days to watch it online.
bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01cm9rv
Dale, if you get wind of a BBC documantary you’d like to watch, keep an eye on an Australian TV channel called SBS, which stands for Special Broadcasting Service and it has a multicultural focus. It frequently puts to air documentaries from the BBC.

Its documantaries are also available online, through its website. Just go to SBS Documentary and see what’s available.

The BBC doco in question isn’t there yet. However, a while back SBS showed a wonderful BBC series on the Bible, highlighting the Bible’s importance to western civilisation. Frequently, SBS has BBC documentaries fairly quickly after they are announced.

At present there are two really good docos available on-demand online. One is The Code, which examines all the numbers and patterns that govern our world and the other is God In America, which is about ow religion shaped America. Part 1 is only available for 7 more days. Be quick!
 
Dale, if you get wind of a BBC documantary you’d like to watch, keep an eye on an Australian TV channel called SBS, which stands for Special Broadcasting Service and it has a multicultural focus. It frequently puts to air documentaries from the BBC.

Its documantaries are also available online, through its website. Just go to SBS Documentary and see what’s available.
Thank you very much for this tip! 🙂

I apologize for not replying sooner. Somehow I missed the updated thread. However, I will be sure check out that channel!
 
The UK’s Catholic Herald also gave a favorable review to the program.
What was conveyed, implicitly rather than explicitly, behind the voices of these ordinary young men and their priest mentors and guides, was that the Gospel is still good news; quite a feat for the BBC to manage this. Any temptation to sensationalism was strictly rejected. The question of recent clerical sex abuse scandals was only mentioned in passing; the rule of celibacy was talked about soberly in a class in which the priest leading the discussion made it clear that in his day the rule had been imposed from outside; there was no question of seminarians learning to embrace it for themselves. The overall impression gained from the hour was that seminary training today prepares young men better for the modern world than the old model.
The programme adopted an unobtrusive, fly-on-the-wall technique, with the commentator’s voice in the background; Jeremy Paxman it was not. At Mass practice, a fifth-year candidate said that the Mass “means everything.” This made the sight of a new young priest, celebrating Mass after ordination in Westminster Cathedral, moving and indeed awesome; a Catholic viewer, if not the programme-makers, could feel again through him the uniquely extraordinary gift of the Mass.
catholicherald.co.uk/commentandblogs/2012/02/24/thank-you-bbc-for-a-sympathetic-portrayal-of-our-faith/
 
Hi everyone,

I saw the program. It can be watched retrospectively on BBC iplayer, but I am not sure if North American viewers can get it.

Try here:

bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01cl83g/Catholics_Priests/

I was personally left unsure about the program. I liked that it showed the seminarians discussion topics like their vocation/celibacy, abortion etc - it didn’t preach the Catholic viewpoint, but gave enough of the discussion such that viewers could clearly understand the Catholic stance.

I didn’t like other aspects so much. The creepy background music they would often play - as if to suggest the students were odd / quirky - the large amount of time given over to spurious topics - quizzing the students about their clothes / vestments etc, it seemed to me to try to portray them as trite fashion victims or something.

I did like hearing from the students themselves, one was especially sardonic - really not the stereotypical image of a Catholic seminarian.

I think parts of the show played somewhat to anti-Catholic stereotypes: the men were portrayed in debates / offering opinions etc, talking about the style of robes they would be wearing etc, and this was then juxtaposed with prolonged footage of a lone woman cleaning an empty church building.

I guess I give it a neutral review overall - I liked bits, others not. I think it received some favourable reviews mainly because it was a noticeable break from the normal of overwhelmingly negative coverage of Catholicism.

The (UK) Guardian gave it a typically derisory review, saying the priests training comprises “water sprinkling and frock buying” and even managing to mention sex abuse in their review of the show.
The UK’s Catholic Herald also gave a favorable review to the program.
Hi Dale,

I saw that article you linked to, but note that another columnist for the paper was left a bit cold, like me: (he only gives it a quick paragraph or two mention, in a larger article).
I myself did not know what to make of the documentary. There were certain things I found distinctly odd about it, such as the background music, which made my spine tingle a bit – perhaps it was meant to. And the camera did dwell at considerable length, or so it seemed to me, on various items of religious statuary; and there was an awful lot about vestments and clerical dress. One thought that kept on going through my head was this: how would a non-Catholic, or a non-religious person, watching this, make of it all?
catholicherald.co.uk/commentandblogs/2012/02/24/is-it-true-father-that-in-scotland-men-wear-skirts/

The next two parts are about women and children in the church. I expect those will largely be propaganda shows about women priests and yet more bashing the church over abuse.

However, I pray I am disappointed 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top