State frees teachers to criticize evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter peregrinus_WA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Evolution is an Article of Faith to atheists and Modernist Catholics.
 
Evolution is an Article of Faith to atheists and Modernist Catholics.
I would say evolution expanded beyond the specific boundaries of the fossil record and expanded beyond the boundaries of physical evolution seems to be the grounding belief of every atheist I’ve every seen write about their personal atheism. This psuedo evolution seems to provide them with a false intellectual comfort in their materialism, that every phenomena can be explained by some mysterious principle of natural selection, e.g. love (agape) is explained because primates found it more adaptive to share than be selfish, that’s why Christ died on the cross. It is shameful and denigrating and has nothing to do with the physical science of evolution, but seems to provide the atheist with some sort of intellectual satisfaction that there is no life of the spirit.

Any phenomena on any aspect of reality is explained away by weaving a fable on how some tale of how primitive life found it efficient to act in a certain way. It becomes a malleable proof of everything via storytelling.

When man is shorn of his dignity in being the image of God and even having a spiritual life, all bets on conduct are off. Human life in terms of natural selection can quickly turn into any of a hundred nightmares, as history has shown all too frequently. When you see yourself as an animal in the social compact, you will be treated as an animal.

The danger is not the science of evolution, but the philosophy of evolution, which should be rigorously combatted in all public forums.
 
I’d like to see the proof of that.
Intelligent design is neither testable nor observable. I’m no proponent of teaching evolution only…and agree that science teachers should have the right to critique it…using the rules of science. However Intelligent Design, which I beleive in…sort of…is a philosophy, not a theory as defined by science.
 
I would say evolution expanded beyond the specific boundaries of the fossil record and expanded beyond the boundaries of physical evolution seems to be the grounding belief of every atheist I’ve every seen write about their personal atheism.
Too bad for them. But the truth shouldn’t be denied because some people migh misuse it.
This psuedo evolution seems to provide them with a false intellectual comfort in their materialism, that every phenomena can be explained by some mysterious principle of natural selection,
Perhaps if you learned what it is, and made it less mysterious for you, it would be better for you. As Everert Dirkson said, people are down on things they aren’t up on.
e.g. love (agape) is explained because primates found it more adaptive to share than be selfish, that’s why Christ died on the cross.
The love we have for each other is a poor imitation of God’s love for us. But why would you be offended if God gave us the capacity to love by natural means?
Any phenomena on any aspect of reality is explained away by weaving a fable on how some tale of how primitive life found it efficient to act in a certain way. It becomes a malleable proof of everything via storytelling.
Sounds just terrible. Maybe it would be good if you could give us an example of consensus in evolutionary theory that does this.
When man is shorn of his dignity in being the image of God and even having a spiritual life, all bets on conduct are off.
Fortunately, evolutionary theory does not do this. Even Dawkins, an enemy of faith if there ever was one, admits that evolution doesn’t rule out God.
Human life in terms of natural selection can quickly turn into any of a hundred nightmares, as history has shown all too frequently.
I bet you don’t know that almost all of the Nazi “Final Solution” was proposed by Martin Luther. I don’t think he was an evolutionist.

When you create a straw boogeyman, you allow the real monsters to roam free. Don’t do it.
 
Barbarian,

My post was in no way attacking the science of evolution or teaching it in the school system.

Your responses clearly indicates you do not understand the content or context of what I posted. Chopping up a persons post is more argumentative rather than creating dialogue. Try reading it again for what it says, not what you think I was trying to say and then simply move on, please.

Thank you.
mike
 
It is important to address why atheists find comfort in the threory of evolution as an issue in itself and not be sidetracked by the ongoing debates about the science of evolution. If we don’t listen to what atheists have to say how can we help them find the Truth?

The underlying issue in the evolution debate is not about the classroom, but why do atheists feel it buttresses their atheism and how can we work with them to save their souls?

How do we plant seeds of faith with such people? I’m not talking about Hitchens and Dawkens or someone hardened, but the average person working for a living who has bought into materialism like my friends. People can live their whole lives without considering whether they even have a spiritual life and when interviewed the majority of these people cite evolution as making God irrelevant.

Why? When the most important aspects of life are non-material, how can a material science render God irrelevant? What methods are the best that get them to think about a spiritual life, what it is, who they are. How can we cooperate with the Holy Spirit?
 
This psuedo evolution seems to provide them with a false intellectual comfort in their materialism, that every phenomena can be explained by some mysterious principle of natural selection, e.g. love (agape) is explained because primates found it more adaptive to share than be selfish, that’s why Christ died on the cross.
I agree with this and your other thoughts about how evolution is used as a support for atheism.
When you see yourself as an animal in the social compact, you will be treated as an animal.
Yes, and the problems with this are severe and manifold. However, I believe Darwinism teaches that human beings are animals – slightly more evolved versions of apes.
The danger is not the science of evolution, but the philosophy of evolution, which should be rigorously combatted in all public forums.
I totally agree about the rigorously combatting part of this. I’m seeing many more people swayed by evolution and losing faith as a result. I also believe that high-profile atheists are having a very significant effect, especially with younger Catholics who have not been well formed in the Faith.

That said, however, I don’t agree that the philosophy of evolution is something separate from the science of evolution. The so-called science of evolution emerges only from a philosophy of evolution which must be in place first.

My comment here supposes that you are not defining the term evolution to mean “modifications within a species occuring as a result of adaptation to external conditions”, but the bigger concept of “evolution” – sometimes called Darwinism.

p.s. I agree with your previous comment regarding posts that “cut up” the original. I did that here to separate a few key points.
 
Your responses clearly indicates you do not understand the content or context of what I posted. Chopping up a persons post is more argumentative rather than creating dialogue. Try reading it again for what it says, not what you think I was trying to say and then simply move on, please.
You simply expressed a lot of misconceptions about science in general and evolution in particular.

If you don’t want to pursue those ideas any further, so be it. As reggie suggests, teaching creationism is a serious error, since many people, when they learn that creationism can’t possibly be true, suppose that Christianity is wrong, and turn away from God.

The more errors that are spread regarding science, the more atheists we produce. The truth, as usual, is the best thing for Christianity.

Learn the truth. Please.
 
And what is the "theory of evolution?
Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population over time. Evolutionary theory is the theory that best explains it. Let’s go over that definition.

First is “change.” Evolution is about change over time. “Allele frequency” is the relative frequency of different alleles (different versions of genes) in a population. Note some important points; evolution doesn’t happen to individuals, it happens to populations. No individual evolves. Notice also that evolution comprises simple variation within a species, as well as the evolution of new kinds of organisms (both have been directly observed)

The theory of evolution is the currently accepted theory for diversity of life. It is Darwin’s theory, modified a number of times by new evidence.

Darwin’s theory (the basic ideas of which are still the best explanation available) are:
  • More are born than can live. Some will not have the resources they need to live long enough to reproduce.
  • All organisms are slightly different than their parents
  • Some of these differences affect the likelihood of living long enough to reproduce
  • The differences that make reproduction more likely tend to accumulate in the population, and these changes are responsible for the observed variety of life.
The first major revision of Darwin’s theory was genetics. It explains why variation occurs, why variation isn’t swamped like a drop of white paint in a barrel of red paint, and how the observed sorting of alleles occurs in nature.

The next major revision was neutralist ideas, primarily by Kimura, showing that genetic drift can cause directional mutation in the absence of selective pressure.

Population genetics added a rigorous mathematical analysis of evolution.

Punctuated equilibrium showed how evolutionary movement and stasis were related.

There are other elements in the Modern Synthesis, such as sociobiology and cladistics that are not quite consensus at this point.

An important concept in Darwin’s theory is natural selection. Natural selection is the process mentioned in the four points of his basic theory.

Note that if a population is well-adapted in an unchanging environment, natural selection will actually prevent evolution. This is why stasis is a common event in the history of a species.

The theory of evolution is massively supported by many lines of evidence, and by the many predictions of the theory that were later verified by observation.
 
Again, there’s a failure to understand the content of my posts and insist on the same tired polemics. The truth is important. A desire to find the truth for people immersed in materialism to the exclusion of their spiritual lives is the danger of evolution misused as a tool of atheist philosophy.

Many fail to understand the limits of evolution as a physical science as seen in a responses to my post regarding agape. Again, it’s hard to resist sidetracking attempts. I wanted to stay on point and not turn this into a “I’m so smart I can nitpick to 500 posts in the thread to parse whether Hitler was influenced by the eugenics movement”

Rather than posting for about the billionth time on this forum about the science of evolution, I was seeking to find out why the run of the mill agnostics and atheists invariably cite evolution as their reason for not believing in God.

However, it is apparently problematic to assay this topic, which is odd on a Catholic forum. The real issue faithful Christians should be concerned about is the impact of evolutionary dialogue in modern society on the spritual well being of those who are not hearing the Good News. This isn’t about the science which is important, just not in this context. The topic being broached in my posts is what do regular folks immersed in the dialogue’s effects see in evolutionary philosophy that makes for them God irrelevant–even making their own spirituality irrelevant.

I think this point is an important one and I may open up a thread on it, but despair of any thread with the word evolution in it being derailed by idealogues on both sides. I don’t think there is a more important issue concerning evolution than the impact of the dialogue on evolution on the prevailing materialism held by the agnostic and atheist population who have either rejected the Good News or simply do not bother to try it out beyond a Beatles song given the negative press formalized religion (to include Christ’s Catholic Church) receives in the secular world.

My suspicion is that the atheists and agnostics co-opting of evolutionary philosophy into their materialism is not defensible, but a systematic refutation would be a book in itself; hence, I have begun asking the question. Perhaps one useful purpose was served by my bringing it up again: It made me stop and consider the formulation of the question as an initial step on a much needed journey.
 
It tool a law to allow freedom of opinions in Education.As usual, the left are the ones who want to stiffle dissenting opinions. Yet they say us on the right want to censor people. The Orwellian doublespeak is mind boggling.
Scopes Monkey Trial trial was the result of the narrow minded right.

Jim
 
Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population over time. Evolutionary theory is the theory that best explains it. Let’s go over that definition.

First is “change.” Evolution is about change over time. “Allele frequency” is the relative frequency of different alleles (different versions of genes) in a population. Note some important points; evolution doesn’t happen to individuals, it happens to populations. No individual evolves. Notice also that evolution comprises simple variation within a species, as well as the evolution of new kinds of organisms (both have been directly observed)

The theory of evolution is the currently accepted theory for diversity of life. It is Darwin’s theory, modified a number of times by new evidence.

Darwin’s theory (the basic ideas of which are still the best explanation available) are:
  • More are born than can live. Some will not have the resources they need to live long enough to reproduce.
  • All organisms are slightly different than their parents
  • Some of these differences affect the likelihood of living long enough to reproduce
  • The differences that make reproduction more likely tend to accumulate in the population, and these changes are responsible for the observed variety of life.
The first major revision of Darwin’s theory was genetics. It explains why variation occurs, why variation isn’t swamped like a drop of white paint in a barrel of red paint, and how the observed sorting of alleles occurs in nature.

The next major revision was neutralist ideas, primarily by Kimura, showing that genetic drift can cause directional mutation in the absence of selective pressure.

Population genetics added a rigorous mathematical analysis of evolution.

Punctuated equilibrium showed how evolutionary movement and stasis were related.

There are other elements in the Modern Synthesis, such as sociobiology and cladistics that are not quite consensus at this point.

An important concept in Darwin’s theory is natural selection. Natural selection is the process mentioned in the four points of his basic theory.

Note that if a population is well-adapted in an unchanging environment, natural selection will actually prevent evolution. This is why stasis is a common event in the history of a species.

The theory of evolution is massively supported by many lines of evidence, and by the many predictions of the theory that were later verified by observation.
That is a fantastic summary Barbarian. Thanks. 👍 Is it your own, or did you cut/paste? If it is your own, may I have permission to use it in other other locations if/when the need arises?
 
That is a fantastic summary Barbarian. Thanks. Is it your own, or did you cut/paste? If it is your own, may I have permission to use it in other other locations if/when the need arises?
Thank you for your kind words. Yes, it’s my statement, although the ideas are of course from many great biologists. Feel free to use it.
 
Again, there’s a failure to understand the content of my posts and insist on the same tired polemics. The truth is important. A desire to find the truth for people immersed in materialism to the exclusion of their spiritual lives is the danger of evolution misused as a tool of atheist philosophy.
Remember, even if people misuse the truth, it’s still the truth.
Many fail to understand the limits of evolution as a physical science as seen in a responses to my post regarding agape.
It might be best to listen to scientists then; they have been telling everyone who will listen that science can’t comment on the spiritual.
Again, it’s hard to resist sidetracking attempts. I wanted to stay on point and not turn this into a “I’m so smart I can nitpick to 500 posts in the thread to parse whether Hitler was influenced by the eugenics movement”
If you’ve been watching the Ben Stein thread, you probably know that one wouldn’t work out so well.
Rather than posting for about the billionth time on this forum about the science of evolution, I was seeking to find out why the run of the mill agnostics and atheists invariably cite evolution as their reason for not believing in God.
I know the answer to that one. It’s because they were raised to believe that creationism was an essential Christian doctrine. And, when they discovered that creationism could not be true, their faith went down also, because it was chained to that foolishness.
However, it is apparently problematic to assay this topic, which is odd on a Catholic forum. The real issue faithful Christians should be concerned about is the impact of evolutionary dialogue in modern society on the spritual well being of those who are not hearing the Good News. This isn’t about the science which is important, just not in this context. The topic being broached in my posts is what do regular folks immersed in the dialogue’s effects see in evolutionary philosophy that makes for them God irrelevant–even making their own spirituality irrelevant.
It won’t be so for any Catholic who hears the teaching of the Church.
My suspicion is that the atheists and agnostics co-opting of evolutionary philosophy into their materialism is not defensible, but a systematic refutation would be a book in itself; hence, I have begun asking the question. Perhaps one useful purpose was served by my bringing it up again: It made me stop and consider the formulation of the question as an initial step on a much needed journey.
It’s a reasonable question. Creationism is a powerful atheist-maker. But notice that even atheistic or agnostic scientists like Gould or Dawkins have said that science cannot rule out God.

I suspect that some atheists, like many creationists, simply seize on whatever they can to make their point, relevant or not.
 
Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population over time. Evolutionary theory is the theory that best explains it. Let’s go over that definition.

First is “change.” Evolution is about change over time. “Allele frequency” is the relative frequency of different alleles (different versions of genes) in a population. Note some important points; evolution doesn’t happen to individuals, it happens to populations. No individual evolves. Notice also that evolution comprises simple variation within a species, as well as the evolution of new kinds of organisms (both have been directly observed)

The theory of evolution is the currently accepted theory for diversity of life. It is Darwin’s theory, modified a number of times by new evidence.

Darwin’s theory (the basic ideas of which are still the best explanation available) are:
  • More are born than can live. Some will not have the resources they need to live long enough to reproduce.
  • All organisms are slightly different than their parents
  • Some of these differences affect the likelihood of living long enough to reproduce
  • The differences that make reproduction more likely tend to accumulate in the population, and these changes are responsible for the observed variety of life.
The first major revision of Darwin’s theory was genetics. It explains why variation occurs, why variation isn’t swamped like a drop of white paint in a barrel of red paint, and how the observed sorting of alleles occurs in nature.

The next major revision was neutralist ideas, primarily by Kimura, showing that genetic drift can cause directional mutation in the absence of selective pressure.

Population genetics added a rigorous mathematical analysis of evolution.

Punctuated equilibrium showed how evolutionary movement and stasis were related.

There are other elements in the Modern Synthesis, such as sociobiology and cladistics that are not quite consensus at this point.

An important concept in Darwin’s theory is natural selection. Natural selection is the process mentioned in the four points of his basic theory.

Note that if a population is well-adapted in an unchanging environment, natural selection will actually prevent evolution. This is why stasis is a common event in the history of a species.

The theory of evolution is massively supported by many lines of evidence, and by the many predictions of the theory that were later verified by observation.
Charles Darwin was the L. Ron Hubbard of his day.
 
It’s because they were raised to believe that creationism was an essential Christian doctrine. And, when they discovered that creationism could not be true, their faith went down also, because it was chained to that foolishness.
I think you have part of the answer here. Maybe it’s more than just creationism, but the fact that Christianity (Catholicism) goes unexamined. When it is unexamined, people hear things like there’s nothing unique about Christianity, it’s just a myth, the scandals and just a whole burbling of views that lack depth. It becomes very easy to dismiss the Good News–the love of God Who showed us his human face and became for us a model for living. That examination takes work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top