C
Contarini
Guest
I think you’ve bought into some very destructive and unorthodox ideas about what a Christian is. A Christian is not a person who feels a certain way, and certainly not a person who never doubts or struggles. Whether or not you are a Christian is not between you and God, if by that you mean that it is a private, internal matter in your own consciousness. A Christian is someone who is baptized and continues faithful to the profession they made (or that was made for them) in baptism.I am just so confused right now. I know most Christians don’t doubt to the extent that I do. I’m getting frustrated. It seems like every Christian church is attacking at least one other church, calling the members heretics or “wolves in sheep’s clothing,” and stuff like that. I have actually been trying to do the right thing lately, and trying to be more genuine. Like I try to be more loving towards others. But I don’t feel like I am making a whole lot of progress. I still fall into sin and complain and get angry.
It’s like Paul said. I do the total opposite of what I want to do, which is following Christ. I feel like I have no self control, and am bearing little or no fruit at all. I am getting ticked off at myself and God. I feel like God does not want me to be a Christian and like he’s condemning me (I know it says, “No condemnation for those who are in Christ,” but I wonder, am I really in Christ? If I wasn’t, then I would be condemned.
I wonder, can any church be trusted anymore? Are things going to just get worse in the world? How can a believer stay a believer in these days? How do you not become distracted?
Don’t worry. I don’t see myself falling away from the faith, but I am struggling for understanding.
And everyone says, Whether you are or are not a Christian is between you and God. So if you are saved you should know. If you are not saved, you should know. So I should know but I’m not so sure I do.
What evangelicals call “being a true Christian,” Catholics call “being in a state of grace.” In Catholic theology, you can’t know for sure (though you can be reasonably confident) whether you are in a state of grace or not. This sounds scary to many folks, but in my opinion it’s actually comforting, because it makes the terrifying question you ask in the OP entirely pointless and unnecessary. You don’t need to delve into the depths of your soul to figure out if you are a “true Christian” or “have been saved.” You look to the death of Jesus on the Cross, the power of the Resurrection, and the sacrament of baptism in which you died and rose again with Jesus. That’s how you have been saved. Just keep looking to Jesus, not to your own soul.
By the way, what I’m telling you is not just Catholic and/or Anglican–much of it is taken from Luther, whose views of salvation were quite different from those of modern evangelicals precisely in this way!
Edwin