Student In Need of Help

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Pupil
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, this may sound awful, but I wouldn’t mind doing some things with him, if you know what I mean. English is one of the sexiest subjects, along with Chemistry. I’m not a bad person, but he is extremely attractive in more ways than one.
You really don’t give a damn about what anyone here is telling you, do you? You’re an immature little girl who is about to get yourself in a world of hurt. I’m done here. You don’t want advice. You are creating your own little soap opera with us here. You think that this little game is funny and you really are not seeking advice or help or else you would have at least commented on one of the responses. You wouldn’t mind doing some things with him?? And what is this forum supposed to do with that mindset of yours?? I’m sorry if I sound so harsh, but you are so immature that it’s crazy. I’m sure that you are the only “love” in his life and he’s saving himself just for you…Give me a break!

I’m done with this thread. You do what you want. You have everyone here telling you that what you and he are doing is wrong. You need no more advice. Someday you will answer to God. It’s between you and Him, my dear and hopefully you catch no diseases or bring some innocent child into this mess that you created…that’s it. I’m done…teachccd:banghead:
 
We’re meeting at Starbucks again next Friday to discuss Wilde. Yes, Starbucks…Thanks everyone.
 
You do know that you could potentially cost your favorite teacher his job right? Even though you’re 18, he is still your High School teacher and if the school district found out if could have huge ramifications for him.
 
We’re meeting at Starbucks again next Friday to discuss Wilde. Yes, Starbucks…Thanks everyone.
You are setting yourself up to commiting a mortal sin. Is a little flick, a good time that lasts for a short time worth your eternal soul?? Don’t be a fool. The Apostle Paul said that fornicators will NOT inheret the kingdom of God and it doesn’t matter if you are Protestant or Catholic, or whatever, it IS still a grave sin.

1 Cor 6:9 “Do you not know that the unjust will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived; neither fornicators nor idolaters nor adulterers nor boy prostitutes nor sodomites”

The choice is yours. God loves you but He is also a just God. If you choose to live that life then you have chosen to be apart from Him, and if you die without love for God, then you CHOOSE to go to hell. Is it really worth it?
 
My English teacher and I are very alike. We both love the human mind, Objectivism, and writing. He is 10 years my senior, as our ages are 28 and 18. Since the first day of class we have been noticing our unique similarities. We are both huge fans of Kerouac! The other day after class he asked me to stay a bit later. My teacher then asked me if I wanted to come to his house this coming Friday. He said that we could read some poetry and that he would make us dinner. Do you think that I should go? :confused:
NO.

He is your teacher, you are his student. This is an inherently unequal relationship.

He is showing some very poor judgment by asking you to come to his house, and you would be showing equally poor judgment to go alone to a man 10 years your senior’s house to “read poetry”.

You need to steer clear of him, and if he hits on you again report him to your college.
 
Well, this may sound awful, but I wouldn’t mind doing some things with him, if you know what I mean. English is one of the sexiest subjects, along with Chemistry. I’m not a bad person, but he is extremely attractive in more ways than one.
Please get some counsel from your priest.

And, you need to tell your parents about this little scheme of yours.

You are on a bad path here, and it cannot lead to good things. Clearly you aren’t interested in good, solid advice since you have gotten lots of posts full of it and ignored it.

I hope you’ll snap out of it. If not, you’re going to learn some very painful things the hard way.
 
Whoa, I’m sorry. All I can honestly say to you is that I believe I am a good person and I try to be a helpful member of society. I have over a 4.0 GPA, which means that I do schoolwork constantly. I’m not Protestant??? How is that relevant? I’m not trying to be rude by asking.
Because most Protestants are not taught an examination of conscience as Catholics are in preparation for the Sacrament of Reconciliation. As a Catholic, a well catechized person of your age would recognize that you would be putting yourself in the near occasion of sin. "doing things’ outside of marriage is a mortal sin, and will cause eternal separation from God (put you on the road to Hell).

As a teacher I can tell you that it is grossly inappropriate for him to ask you over. A teacher should NEVER interact with a student in any way that could be construed as influencing the grade that teacher must give. How would the principle and the other students feel, if you went to his house?

I can give you three “tests” that can be used in making ethical decisions. The first one is what I mentioned above, and is called the “test of publicity”. How would he or you feel if the whole details were printed in the morning paper?

The second test is universality. Would the teacher, or you, recommend that all teachers everwhere engage in this behavior with students? If not, why not?

The third is justice. Would the teacher engage in this behavior with all students? Would you behave this way with all teachers? If you are being treated with separate values, what is the reason for that? Is it fair to others?

I am very skeptical if your situation if for real, since it is June, and I think high school is not in session, and if you are 18, you probably graduated a month ago.
 
Everyone, I thank you for your concern and for taking the time to give me your advice. I will try my best to live as a proper Christian. I believe that I am a very good person and a produtive member of society. I am always looking for ways to help my fellow man. I am an excellent student, and I will later be pursuing a Phd. My English professor is nearly complete with his. For now, we’ll probably continue to go to places like Starbucks…I don’t know about the future. All I can say is that I’ll be safe and act responsibly.
 
Everyone, I thank you for your concern and for taking the time to give me your advice. I will try my best to live as a proper Christian. I believe that I am a very good person and a produtive member of society. I am always looking for ways to help my fellow man. I am an excellent student, and I will later be pursuing a Phd.
All of these things are “nice”… they aren’t *relevant *to the question you asked and the situation you’ve put yourself in

None of these things gives you permission to go and do as you please. None of these things makes up for doing something you know is wrong.

Clearly you already knew this was a bad idea-- and possibly leading you into sin-- why else would you (a) hide it from your parents and (b) post on a moral theology forum asking opinions.
For now, we’ll probably continue to go to places like Starbucks…I don’t know about the future. All I can say is that I’ll be safe and act responsibly.
To act responsibly would be to tell him you cannot meet him any longer.

So why, exactly, did you post here?
 
Everyone, I thank you for your concern and for taking the time to give me your advice. I will try my best to live as a proper Christian. I believe that I am a very good person and a produtive member of society. I am always looking for ways to help my fellow man. I am an excellent student, and I will later be pursuing a Phd. My English professor is nearly complete with his. For now, we’ll probably continue to go to places like Starbucks…I don’t know about the future. All I can say is that I’ll be safe and act responsibly.
What good will it do you to gain the whole world, and lose your soul?🤷

Do you realize you don’t get to heaven by trying to be a "good person’ and a productive member of society?
 
People, don’t feed the trolls! She quotes Ayn Rand…do you think ‘she’ or whoever cares about what a bunch of obedient Catholics have to say on the matter??
 
People, don’t feed the trolls! She quotes Ayn Rand…do you think ‘she’ or whoever cares about what a bunch of obedient Catholics have to say on the matter??
No, but since there are four times more lukers than posters, it might do someone else some good. 👍
 
Whoa, I’m sorry. All I can honestly say to you is that I believe I am a good person and I try to be a helpful member of society. I have over a 4.0 GPA, which means that I do schoolwork constantly. I’m not Protestant??? How is that relevant? I’m not trying to be rude by asking.
No you are wrong. You are NOT a good person just because you have a hight GPA or are a member of society. You are a sinner in need of God’s mercy and love and redemption, see Romans 3:23. It says “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” Romans 8:28 says “the wages of sin is death.” When Paul in scripture mentions the word “sin” he is speaking of the eternal consequences of that sin. And you are planning in your mind and heart to do acts that have grave eternal consequences as well as temporal ones; you could contract a sexually transmitted disease (STD) like herpes or even AIDS. You really need to rethink your potential actions.
 
People, don’t feed the trolls! She quotes Ayn Rand…do you think ‘she’ or whoever cares about what a bunch of obedient Catholics have to say on the matter??
Only God and her know the answer to that question, however, we as the body of Christ have to take her at her written word which was very direct. She perhaps is playing a game, but you never know if she in the back portions of her conscience is really crying out for help even though she is masking over it with her immaturity. Everyone was created to worship God and everyone needs Jesus Christ whether they acknowledge it or not!
 
I suggest you do go if: 1) Your parents agree, 2) your priest agrees, and 3) the high school principal agrees. Otherwise, stay away. You should meet him outside of school only under the same conditions.
 
I think he pretty much implied that it would just be the two of us.
Find a polite way out. Teachers should never have romantic relationships with their students, even at the college level. Teaching is a sacred calling that cannot survive such adulteration. College professors know that. Some are morally and ethically adrift, thanks to their chronic liberalism. Don’t do it. Be strong. Maintain your integrity. Help him maintan his.👍
 
Pupil–this man is trying to “pick you up.” Nothing good can come out of this situation.

This guy is simply looking for a one night fling. It isn’t worth getting involved at all with this person–drop him like a hot potato.

If this 28 year-old man wanted to date you, he would have initially asked for a date, like going out somewhere in public when he first approached you to get to know you better. Instead he asked you to come to his house for a dinner and conversation; that’s just modern language talk for: do you want to come over and have sex.

I wouldn’t meet the creep at Starbucks either; his first inital request shows that this person is only interested in sex; he just wants to use you and then will get rid of you.

And the fact that your in high school and he’s a teacher says it all.
Public schools, we’ve all read stories in the newspaper, are filled with teachers who are sexual predators and prey on their students.

I can almost guarantee 100% that asking you to come over to his house after school for “dinner” and discuss whatever, broke the school district’s teacher ethics policy, and would wind this joker into some trouble with the Principal and school district administrator.

This man knows all this already as a teacher from his education classes; and since you say your a serious student and want to go to graduate school, once you sleep with this guy, he’s going to control your life until the class ends. And hope you don’t have to take another class with him. If you don’t do what he says he might give you a bad grade / bad recommendation and harass you in class.

If he did want to invite you and a group of students, male and female, with your parents knowing and approving of you coming over to his home, that **might have **been different. I still wouldn’t have done it.

You say you’re a student of literature; read between the lines.

Given all the info you gave us, from the get go and just by his initial proposal, this is not a serious relationship for this man. No decent 28 year-old man would ask an 18 year old girl that he was interested in dating and marrying on their first social meeting to come to his house for dinner.

This alone speaks volumes, and raises a million zillion red flags.
It is absolutely absurd from this initial request to think that this man is serious about you or even cares for you as a person.

Secondly, analyze your age differences. It is vast. No decent 28 year old man would be interested in socializing with an 18 year-old girl who’s still in high school, especially if that man is your teacher ! Only indecent 28 year old men would be interested in doing so, and for one thing only.

Keep your relationship professional. Teacher / student–no fornication, no nothing. You’re already kind of in a bind because you’ve agreed to meet him at Starbucks. No matter what, you must not go. Don’t do it. Just tell him your relationship needs to remain professional, teacher / student, no socializing. He should get the message and leave you alone.

If he retaliates by dropping your grades in class immediately (and only a real creep would do that), go to the Principal and report the harassment right away. Even if you get one bad grade, it’s better than getting involved with this creep.

Once you’re through taking classes forever or about to graduate, go to the school principal with a parent and tell her / him what happened. This man needs to be reported. He’ll be asking young girls to his home for dinner as long as he is a teacher.

You owe it to him and to prevent future students from becoming victims to have the courage to tell the Principal what this guy asked you to do. Have your mom or dad go with you to talk with the Principal and had make sure you write what happened on a piece of paper signed by you and a parent. The Principal will give him a warning and at least school officials will be put on notice, and there will be a paper trail.

At your age, you should be dating people your own age, not men who are way older than you are. Chances are, you’ll find someone your own age in college.

And just one more thing readers, Ayn Rand’s pop philosophy of Objectivism (better known as Libertarianism) is opposed to religion. It’s essentially incorporates Karl Marx’s ideas about religion but under a Capitalist, not a Marxist, economic philosophy. Objectivism teaches that Capitalist economic theory is the “objective” real truth, and not Catholicism. It is opposed to Catholicism and religion in general.
 
Bring your dad!

And you three can ‘nerd out’. I wouldn’t recommend leading him on at all though.
 
Yeah, I wonder if some of the people who post at Catholic.com are just spamming the site with really odd questions.

I’ve seen just about everything on this site running the whole gamut, especially in the moral theology section.

I wonder if some of the posters are just prankster teenagers pulling our legs.

Well, if you are, I hope your gaining a lot of personal pleasure and yuck yucks from doing so. Isn’t it self-fulfilling?

There seems to be a lot of questions like these and others that maybe Catholic Answers could form into a great book. You know, a Best of the Threads, or Guide to Every Day Living for Catholics which would go over all the oddball questions on the Catholic Answers threads.

Karl Keating could edit the questions, or perhaps a priest could and one to three of the best answers people wrote in (edited for size) could be selected, with some editing by Karl or the priest could be provided.

That would help a lot of people out there; and be easier to read. My eyes get a little blurry after a while on the net.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top