Study: Global warming skeptics know more about climate science

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
Are global warming skeptics simply ignorant about climate science?

Not so, says a forthcoming paper in the journal Advances in Political Psychology by Yale Professor Dan Kahan. He finds that skeptics score about the same (in fact slightly better) on climate science questions.

The study asked 2,000 respondents nine questions about where they thought scientists stand on climate science.

On average, skeptics got about 4.5 questions correct, whereas manmade warming believers got about 4 questions right.

foxnews.com/science/2015/02/12/study-global-warming-skeptics-know-more-about-climate-science/
 
This doesn’t surprise me at all. Most people that say they believe in AGW are simply going with the popular media story line and really no little to nothing about the subject of climate or science.
 
Are global warming skeptics simply ignorant about climate science?

Not so, says a forthcoming paper in the journal Advances in Political Psychology by Yale Professor Dan Kahan. He finds that skeptics score about the same (in fact slightly better) on climate science questions.

The study asked 2,000 respondents nine questions about where they thought scientists stand on climate science.

On average, skeptics got about 4.5 questions correct, whereas manmade warming believers got about 4 questions right.

foxnews.com/science/2015/02/12/study-global-warming-skeptics-know-more-about-climate-science/
If FOX News said it, it must be true!🤷

I would have looked for a better source than making this claim!

Does journal of advances in political psychology give you a clue?
 
If FOX News said it, it must be true!🤷

I would have looked for a better source than making this claim!

Does journal of advances in political psychology give you a clue?
That is ad hominem; if you cant deal with the facts then you are contributing nothing rational here.
 
The fact is that FOX is as trustworthy as the Daily Mail.
So it the Daily Mail considered the UKs “FOX News”. I considered it to have reliable articles in general, so that quote seems a little charitable to FOX News.
 
If FOX News said it, it must be true!🤷

I would have looked for a better source than making this claim!

Does journal of advances in political psychology give you a clue?
The study comes from a professor at Yale, Dan Kahan. It is a study piggy backing another study from 2012 that found the same thing. FOX News is simply reporting on it. Perhaps you should look better at the article before you shoot the messenger.
 
So it the Daily Mail considered the UKs “FOX News”. I considered it to have reliable articles in general, so that quote seems a little charitable to FOX News.
It’s not called the Daily Fail for nothing.

Not that I trust ANY media anymore.
 
If FOX News said it, it must be true!🤷

I would have looked for a better source than making this claim!

Does journal of advances in political psychology give you a clue?
Do you watch Fox News? Come on now. It’s a sin to tell a lie. 😉 I watch it and find a rather fair presentation on the news. The alphabet networks, on the other hand, appear to filter out points of view they consider politically incorrect.
 
The study comes from a professor at Yale, Dan Kahan. It is a study piggy backing another study from 2012 that found the same thing. FOX News is simply reporting on it. Perhaps you should look better at the article before you shoot the messenger.
Some people seem to think it is more fun to shoot Fox News then to check Fox’s sources. 😛 😃
 
Are global warming skeptics simply ignorant about climate science?

Not so, says a forthcoming paper in the journal Advances in Political Psychology by Yale Professor Dan Kahan. He finds that skeptics score about the same (in fact slightly better) on climate science questions.

The study asked 2,000 respondents nine questions about where they thought scientists stand on climate science.

On average, skeptics got about 4.5 questions correct, whereas manmade warming believers got about 4 questions right.

foxnews.com/science/2015/02/12/study-global-warming-skeptics-know-more-about-climate-science/
To put this result in perspective, consider that all this implies is that non-scientist skeptics do better on these specific 9 science questions than non-scientist AGW proponents. This says nothing about the relative abilities of scientist skeptics vs. scientist AGW proponents, which is the comparison that really matters. And this result doesn’t really say much about non-scientists either, because the 9 questions could not possibly be comprehensive enough to qualify as a reliable measure of the abilities of these respondents in climate science in general. Pick 9 different questions and you might get the opposite results. So overall this result is pretty useless.
 
To put this result in perspective, consider that all this implies is that non-scientist skeptics do better on these specific 9 science questions than non-scientist AGW proponents. This says nothing about the relative abilities of scientist skeptics vs. scientist AGW proponents, which is the comparison that really matters. And this result doesn’t really say much about non-scientists either, because the 9 questions could not possibly be comprehensive enough to qualify as a reliable measure of the abilities of these respondents in climate science in general. Pick 9 different questions and you might get the opposite results. So overall this result is pretty useless.
Now why do you want to bring common sense and a basic understanding of statistics into this thread? Silly, silly child, using your intelligence! 😃

Gertie
 
That is ad hominem; if you cant deal with the facts then you are contributing nothing rational here.
LOL…thanks…I’ll take your cheeky comment (no pun intended) and try and run any contributions I make by you first to make sure they meet your criteria for being part of the threads.🤷
 
Excuse me, but what’s everybody getting up in arms over? Sceptics know HALF A QUESTION more on average. That’s not a big difference. :rolleyes: Give me a break.

Furthermore, whether the public knows more or not - and it’s very clear they don’t - doesn’t change what is true. And what is true is that humans do have some impact on the environment. But it’s still on the table whether it’s a lot of impact, or only a minimal impact.
 
The study comes from a professor at Yale, Dan Kahan. It is a study piggy backing another study from 2012 that found the same thing. FOX News is simply reporting on it. Perhaps you should look better at the article before you shoot the messenger.
Tim, I seem to recall piggyback studies supporting the findings of Dr. Andrew Wakefield, too, and eventually he was discredited and drummed out of the medicine.

The trouble with studies often is that people reading them are blinded by the credentials of the author…too many researchers skew their data to meet their opinions.

Perhaps Kahan is write, but anyone who jumps on the bandwagon after 2 studies is a likely customer to anyone wanting to sell the Brooklyn bridge.🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top