Study: Moral Beliefs May Sway Docs' Care

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rach620
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Rach620

Guest
I just came across this article about a recent study on doctors’ beliefs and patient care.
A disturbing number of doctors do not feel obligated to tell patients about medical options they oppose morally, such as abortion and teen birth control, and believe they have no duty to refer people elsewhere for such treatments, researchers say.
Doctors describing themselves as very religious, particularly Protestants and Catholics, were much less likely than others to feel obligated to tell patients about controversial treatments or refer them to other doctors, and were far more likely to tell patients if they had moral objections.
One big problem area, Magnus said, involves emergency room doctors and emergency contraception for rape victims. He said it is considered standard care to offer the morning-after pill, but that is not done in some Catholic hospitals, according to one small study. Ecker said doctors opposed to emergency contraception should avoid working in an ER for that reason.
I personally don’t find this as ‘disturbing’ as the AP apparently does. Doctors shouldn’t be obligated to provide or recommend ‘treatments’ which are contrary to their moral beliefs, even if they might be the ‘standard of care’. It disgusts me that people want to force Catholic hospitals to provide the morning after pill to rape victims.
 
I personally don’t find this as ‘disturbing’ as the AP apparently does.
Yes, I was surprised by the word “disturbing”, as well. But in defense of the writer, she did quote the support of two persons who are professionally involved in medical ethics. Still, I am left wondering if this is a consensus position.
It disgusts me that people want to force Catholic hospitals to provide the morning after pill to rape victims.
The writer seems to blame individual doctors for opposing the morning after pill, assuming that the hospital would not have an institutional policy opposing that drug.
 
By the journalist’s “logic,” every divorce attorney would be required to remind a client that assassins do exist, and can be hired, if allimony is just too much trouble.

You don’t believe in assassination? Don’t force your morality on me!
 
Yes, I was surprised by the word “disturbing”, as well. But in defense of the writer, she did quote the support of two persons who are professionally involved in medical ethics.
What makes “persons who are professionally involved in medical ethics” any more ethical than the rest of us? Why should we accept their dicta over that of the Church?
 
This article really burns my britches! :mad: It’s totally slanted

msnbc.msn.com/id/17026169/

From the article…

A disturbing number of doctors do not feel obligated to tell patients about medical options they oppose morally, such as abortion and teen birth control, and believe they have no duty to refer people elsewhere for such treatments, researchers say.

The survey of 1,144 doctors around the country is the first major look at how physicians’ religious or moral beliefs might affect patients’ care.
 
Yes, I was surprised by the word “disturbing”, as well. But in defense of the writer, she did quote the support of two persons who are professionally involved in medical ethics. Still, I am left wondering if this is a consensus position.
Didn’t you get the memo? Morals aren’t dictated by God anymore :eek:
 
If it’s the first study, if it’s going to be worth anything, there needs to be more. Who knows, it could be biased.
 
A disturbing number of doctors do not feel obligated to tell patients about medical options they oppose morally, such as abortion and teen birth control, and believe they have no duty to refer people elsewhere for such treatments, researchers say.
If the doctor or nurse is a atheist, is it then okay not to tell a patient they are going to die in a few hours on the grounds that it is against the doctor’s or nurse’s morality of not making one lose hope? Of course then they would not ba able to call a priest for last rites. Or is it okay for a Jehovah Witness physician not to tell a very sick person that they will die without a blood transfusion?

Your personal beliefs are secondary to the state’s laws for certain things for the very reason that society would totally breakdown otherwise. Remember: Render unto Caesar …
  • Kathie :bowdown:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top