Stunned!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Marie5890
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Marie5890

Guest
I have a family member by marriage who went thru entire education (k-12) in Catholic schools. Today we were talking about Christmas etc.

The question was ask of me, if Christ was Jewish then what is the connection between Judaism and Christianity. ?!?!

Even this family member didnt realize that Christ was the promised Messiah promised to Israel…

:eek:

I still dont even know how to react. I looked at him and asked him, having gone thru Catholic school system, he didnt know this???
 
I have a family member by marriage who went thru entire education (k-12) in Catholic schools. Today we were talking about Christmas etc.

The question was ask of me, if Christ was Jewish then what is the connection between Judaism and Christianity. ?!?!

Even this family member didnt realize that Christ was the promised Messiah promised to Israel…

:eek:

I still dont even know how to react. I looked at him and asked him, having gone thru Catholic school system, he didnt know this???
Very, very, very common. The Catholic school system didn’t teach the faith for years. These people don’t know the first thing about basic Christianity. I mean you could read one article in Reader’s Digest and know more than they do about it. The sad thing is that often they think they do and you can’t tell them anything. Be glad they know today is Christmas.
 
I have a family member by marriage who went thru entire education (k-12) in Catholic schools. Today we were talking about Christmas etc.

The question was ask of me, if Christ was Jewish then what is the connection between Judaism and Christianity. ?!?!

Even this family member didnt realize that Christ was the promised Messiah promised to Israel…

:eek:

I still dont even know how to react. I looked at him and asked him, having gone thru Catholic school system, he didnt know this???
In what era did he go through Catholic school? And what diocese? Yes, it matters. A lot of Catholic schools have failed their Catholic students in not teaching the faith, not even the basics (which this point definitely is!). Time to brush up on your apologetics so you can answer any other questions he has…

Is he actually Catholic? Convert? Cradle Catholic? It is the sort of question I would expect from an outsider to the faith, but not saying a Catholic cannot have the same lack of basic knowledge.

Did you suggest he read the Gospels?

🤷
 
In what era did he go through Catholic school? And what diocese? Yes, it matters. A lot of Catholic schools have failed their Catholic students in not teaching the faith, not even the basics (which this point definitely is!). Time to brush up on your apologetics so you can answer any other questions he has…

Is he actually Catholic? Convert? Cradle Catholic? It is the sort of question I would expect from an outsider to the faith, but not saying a Catholic cannot have the same lack of basic knowledge.

Did you suggest he read the Gospels?

🤷
No, no. If a person comes from evangelical or mainline protestantism, they know this stuff before they ever show up at a Catholic church. New agers and people who have never been Christian might not. I’m a convert from protestantism and very few protestants are that ignorant about general Christianity, which after all, is what she’s talking about here (connection between Judaism & Christianity, promise of the Messiah, etc).

My guess is that this person the poster is talking about is a cradle Catholic, because that’s the segment of the population most likely to have undergone 12 years of Catholic school (and come out as dumb as a rock). It’s expensive after all.
 
In what era did he go through Catholic school? And what diocese? Yes, it matters. A lot of Catholic schools have failed their Catholic students in not teaching the faith, not even the basics (which this point definitely is!). Time to brush up on your apologetics so you can answer any other questions he has…

Is he actually Catholic? Convert? Cradle Catholic? It is the sort of question I would expect from an outsider to the faith, but not saying a Catholic cannot have the same lack of basic knowledge.

Did you suggest he read the Gospels?

🤷
He is a cradle Catholics. He is in his mid 50s. His folks were Catholic too, as was his grandparents etc. He went K-12, etc etc. He had been an alter server too.

You are right. This is so basic. I was just stunned. If his folks were still alive I would have turned to them in almost seriousness and tell them that they should demand their money back.

His wife was the one who started up the conversation. It was about Christ. She has never had any religious faith formation of any kind. So coming from her I wasnt surprised when she told me she understands that Christmas is about Jesus’s birth. But she said, He was Jewish. I said “yes”. She told me she didnt understand how Christianity came about if He was Jewish. She said that her husband (the above mentioned family member) didnt know either even though his K-12 education was Catholic…

I just sat there in silence for a bit saying to myself…“wow, wow, wow, wow”

Then I explained it.
 
He is a cradle Catholics. He is in his mid 50s. His folks were Catholic too, as was his grandparents etc. He went K-12, etc etc. He had been an alter server too.

You are right. This is so basic. I was just stunned. If his folks were still alive I would have turned to them in almost seriousness and tell them that they should demand their money back.

His wife was the one who started up the conversation. It was about Christ. She has never had any religious faith formation of any kind. So coming from her I wasnt surprised when she told me she understands that Christmas is about Jesus’s birth. But she said, He was Jewish. I said “yes”. She told me she didnt understand how Christianity came about if He was Jewish. She said that her husband (the above mentioned family member) didnt know either even though his K-12 education was Catholic…

I just sat there in silence for a bit saying to myself…“wow, wow, wow, wow”

Then I explained it.
Bingo. Had to be a cradle Catholic.
 
Very, very, very common. The Catholic school system didn’t teach the faith for years. These people don’t know the first thing about basic Christianity. I mean you could read one article in Reader’s Digest and know more than they do about it. The sad thing is that often they think they do and you can’t tell them anything. Be glad they know today is Christmas.
Yes. This is exactly what it was like. He knew NOTHING other than today was Christmas.

I gave a quick overview. But I was soo stunned it was limited.
 
Yes. This is exactly what it was like. He knew NOTHING other than today was Christmas.

I gave a quick overview. But I was soo stunned it was limited.
Yup. Been there, done that. Made me speechless too, both times. One of the people I talked is near 40 now; the other is about 30, and that happened recently.

A.m.a.z.i.n.g. But very, very, very common apparently.

I have a muslim friend from work who knows more than either of them knew about the Christian faith.

The Catholic church has nearly completely lost several generations. If and when some of them show up at Mass, they don’t know much about what’s happening. Bless their hearts for showing up.
 
Yup. Been there, done that. Made me speechless too, both times. One of the people I talked is near 40 now; the other is about 30, and that happened recently.

A.m.a.z.i.n.g. But very, very, very common apparently.

I have a muslim friend from work who knows more than either of them knew about the Christian faith.

The Catholic church has nearly completely lost several generations. If and when some of them show up at Mass, they don’t know much about what’s happening. Bless their hearts for showing up.
Thanks Iloveangels.

Makes me ill to be honest.

Is it any wonder people fall away from the Church?? If they dont even know the basic foundations, why bother with the Church, ya know.
If you dont even understand Who Jesus is, and why, and all of salvation history, it really is nothing more than just “some tradition”…

Lost several generations indeed. His children also went thru Catholic schools. Is it any wonder they too could care less. 🤷
 
Pope Benedict XVI has a great line in the introduction to YouCat declaring teaching at the local parish level has been poor for the past 40 years.

The answer to all of this is The Catechism of The Catholic Church. For teens, YouCat will be a sufficient introduction.

I would not blame their teachers or their CCD/school religious education program though. It is primarily the parents fault.
 
I guess I don’t feel so bad…I’m 54 and was away from the Church for 20+ years…I was not catechized since age 10 and I knew that basics of the Bible prophesy that pointed to Jesus as the promised Messiah of Israel, God’s people.

:rolleyes:

I think my generation, the one that would have grown up mostly post-Vatican II, in general was very poorly catechized.

😦
 
Pope Benedict XVI has a great line in the introduction to YouCat declaring teaching at the local parish level has been poor for the past 40 years.

The answer to all of this is The Catechism of The Catholic Church. For teens, YouCat will be a sufficient introduction.

I would not blame their teachers or their CCD/school religious education program though. It is primarily the parents fault.
No, it’s both. Parents paid the catholic schools to offer classes in religion and they really didn’t. They taught them something else, and that’s why students from Catholic schools don’t know their faith.

I used to be an algebra teacher. It wasn’t the parents’ fault if their kids didn’t get instructed in algebra. IT was their fault if they didn’t follow up and give their kids what-for for bad grades and goofing off, yes. But the content of the classes was my job as a teacher.

In like manner, if the catholic schools didn’t present the right material they are to blame for that part of the failure. And that’s what happened.
 
I guess I don’t feel so bad…I’m 54 and was away from the Church for 20+ years…I was not catechized since age 10 and I knew that basics of the Bible prophesy that pointed to Jesus as the promised Messiah of Israel, God’s people.

:rolleyes:

I think my generation, the one that would have grown up mostly post-Vatican II, in general was very poorly catechized.

😦
Yup, you were robbed.
 
Very, very, very common. The Catholic school system didn’t teach the faith for years. These people don’t know the first thing about basic Christianity. I.
this statement is way out of line and does not answer OP’s situation. It makes huge global assumptions about all CAtholic education everywhere which is simply not borne out by facts. We have no ideal what the school taught her relative, we have no idea who taught there and what they know or don’t know. We don’t know if the curriculum was excellent, and the student failed to listen or benefit from instruction. We don’t know of the student learned these things but has forgotten or rejected them.
 
I guess I don’t feel so bad…I’m 54 and was away from the Church for 20+ years…I was not catechized since age 10 and I knew that basics of the Bible prophesy that pointed to Jesus as the promised Messiah of Israel, God’s people.

:rolleyes:

I think my generation, the one that would have grown up mostly post-Vatican II, in general was very poorly catechized.

😦
I am 53 and was not raised catholic but I do understand that Jesus was the Messiah rejected by his own people (at least most of them).

I do like the parallels to Jewish tradition. Passover - those doors not marked with the blood of the lamb are lost. How could you be Jewish today and not undersyand that Christ is the promised one to lead us to the promised land.

Peace,
John
 
I wouldn’t say he was Jewish - God is the object of faith rather than a practitioner 🙂
 
Very, very, very common. The Catholic school system didn’t teach the faith for years. These people don’t know the first thing about basic Christianity. I mean you could read one article in Reader’s Digest and know more than they do about it. The sad thing is that often they think they do and you can’t tell them anything. Be glad they know today is Christmas.
I was in the Biblical School run by my Archdiocese when an older woman, a staunch cradle Catholic who, when the instructor mentioned that Jesus was Jewish, objected strongly that of course He was not, He was a Christian!

So the instructor patienty explained. For a long time. Finally, the woman subsided with this comment,“Well, maybe He was Jewish but His mother was a Christian!”

And who can argue? We moved on. 😃
 
I was in the Biblical School run by my Archdiocese when an older woman, a staunch cradle Catholic who, when the instructor mentioned that Jesus was Jewish, objected strongly that of course He was not, He was a Christian!

So the instructor patienty explained. For a long time. Finally, the woman subsided with this comment,“Well, maybe He was Jewish but His mother was a Christian!”

And who can argue? We moved on. 😃
my great aunt was a staunch Methodist, old school, bible-reading, no drinking, dancing or card playing allowed, and like the rest of the family, horrified when my mother married a CAtholic and converted, mainly because of our more liberal attitude toward alcohol. When scripture passages about Christ drinking wine, wedding at Cana etc. were pointed out to her she grudgingly admitted they did drink wine, but humphed, “I would have had more respect for him if he had been temperence [dry].”

so anyone is capable of finding support for preconceived notions in scripture.
 
It’s interesting to read this thread. My parents-in-law, born in the '50s, are very ignorant of their own faith. They were not taught a lot or some things by some rogue teachers “This is an outdated teaching and we really don’t do this anymore.” They say they were not exposed to anything anti-artificial contraception. They were encouraged to not ask questions, etc.

So I began this faith journey to learn about my awesome new family’s faith. Now that we are deciding to baptize their grandson in the Church next year my in-laws are saying, " oh but why? Your old church [Anglican] is nice. Just do it there. WHY would you do that to that kid?"

:eek:
 
this statement is way out of line and does not answer OP’s situation. It makes huge global assumptions about all CAtholic education everywhere which is simply not borne out by facts. We have no ideal what the school taught her relative, we have no idea who taught there and what they know or don’t know. We don’t know if the curriculum was excellent, and the student failed to listen or benefit from instruction. We don’t know of the student learned these things but has forgotten or rejected them.
Yeah, and that’s how come so many catholics don’t know their faith. I’m telling you–too many people have noticed what’s happened for that to fly anymore, puzzleannie. What happened, happened.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top