Stunned!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Marie5890
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If I read the OP’s original post, she was talking to the wife who said neither she nor her Catholic school educated husband knew Christ was Jesus. For the sake of clarifying how badly he was taught, she should ask him directly. I find it odd that a kid would sit through 12 years and not ask questions because, even if he wasn’t taught, he had to have questions about something. As an altar boy, he must have heard some sermons discussing Passover etc. There is a lot to be said for an enquiring mind. Did he not have discussions with his friends?
If he had asked questions he would have been told more of the nonsense he was told in the first place. He passed the classes, after all. A lot of people did, while knowing next to nothing about Catholicism. This was a very, very common thing. He’s certainly not the only one this happened to.
 
I was educated in the early 60s when they still used what I presume was a French version of the Baltimore Catechism. It was all question and answer and as long as you could spit back the answer that was as far as the course went. Asking a question of a teacher who has never been to college but grew up with the same type of catechism was not going to get you anywhere.

As for Jesus being Jewish, I know many Catholics who are horrified at that notion and will argue black and blue that he was the first Catholic. I don’t quite understand that mentality now but I think I was probably in my twenties before I understood that he WAS Jewish.

I was 14 before I actually held a Bible in my hands and it was at my parish’s 40 Hours Devotion when I was left alone in the church. They had recently installed a stand to permanently have a Bible present at the front of the nave so I went to get the big white Bible, fearful that I was doing something wrong but yet compelled, as a book-addicted teen, to read this book about which I had alway been very curious, and sat down to read what? oh, Leviticus, of course. Now there’s an introduction to the Bible for you! Try going home and talking to your mother about ritual purification when she’s also the product of a question and answer program taught by her mother, who’d learned it the same way!

Unfortunately, Catholics in those days didn’t have the resources that I only discovered in my mid 40s.
I believe it. I probably had much a much better training in scripture than any of you. My grandfather was a protestant minister. We used to commit passages to memory. I knew the 23rd psalm from the old KJV by heart before I started school. I started school when I was 4.
 
She had never heard the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation and she was going into her senior year at a Catholic HS and had been in Catholic schools since kindergarten!

so like me and a few others we were never really allowed to receive communion,

I mean isn’t that a necessity to receive communion is to believe in transubstantiation??

I need to be honest here as I still don’t. I believe the way I was taught to believe it.
Not really. I mean you’re supposed to learn that but many Catholics aren’t really aware of it, anymore than they’re aware that Christ was born Jewish or that he was the long-awaited Messiah.
 
Wow, the arrogance is pretty strong on this thread. I hope I have misunderstood the question and the thread, but I don’t think so. As you stated his question, I realized I had that same question just a few years ago. I realized I did not understand how Jesus was Jewish, and I was Catholic, and what that all meant. It has been mind-boggling to me the last few years how little I really know. I have been a firm Catholic all of my life, but once I realized how little I really knew, it started me on a journey, one of which is a very slow process.

As an adult, its not easy to learn these things and I would be horribly embarrassed to have been treated the way you treated this man and his wife. I definitely would never talk to you again about religion and would be careful in the future to bring up my supposed “stupidity” with other people. And that is exactly how you, and many others have come across. You think he and his wife are stupid. Instead of taking the time to just talk about it and give some helpful information which was obvious that they did not have (and in their shoes I would have greatly appreciated), you just stared at them dumbfounded and showed your shock at what you though was their “stupidity.” How can you hold it against them that they don’t know, as if it is their fault for not understanding?? Do you honestly think that most people have a really clear understanding? You sound like you treated them like idiots.

I have to say, I never understood most of our teachings until more recently when I have learned the same thing my children are learning. It wasn’t my fault that I wasn’t taught properly. Until recently, not only did I not know much, but I did not have a true desire to learn. So even if I had been taught (which I wasn’t taught much) then I’m not sure I would have really paid too much attention until I actually wanted to learn it.

Now I hope I misunderstood the entire concept of this thread and please correct me if so. Hopefully I’m having a bad day and just not reading carefully enough. But if not, then its no wonder why people are so judgmental of the Catholic Church … especially considering the arrogant attitudes of some of the members 😦
There’s a big difference between ignorance and stupidity. We’re not calling anyone stupid, but there is a ton of ignorance out there.
 
I believe it. I probably had much a much better training in scripture than any of you. My grandfather was a protestant minister. We used to commit passages to memory. I knew the 23rd psalm from the old KJV by heart before I started school. I started school when I was 4.
Yes, but at 4 did you know what it meant? Could you break it down? Would you expect a 4 y/o to break it down?

I held the role of Lady McBeth full version, completly memorized at the age 11. Big deal. I couldn’t have analyzed that play at that age. It was just a play.

Not suggesting that learning prayers and psalms and such at a young age is a bad thing AT ALL. Just generally not fully understood.
 
Actually, she probably heard it. In the 2nd grade. When First Communion is done at Catholic school, in my day anyway. Those are some HUGE words for a 2nd grader don’t you think?

…

I actually picked up on this also. …
Upset because I could tell that the guy who didn’t know the first thing about basic Christianity was a cradle Catholic? I could do that because I’ve seen it soooo many times before. The pattern is broad and deep, impossible to miss. You can blame me, but it’s not my fault. Blaming me isn’t going to fix the fact that an incredible number of Catholics don’t know their faith, and that’s the truth.

Want me to be wrong? Then make sure that the Catholics you know understand the faith, so I (and all the people like me) stop hearing these horror stories and seeing the inevitable consequences everywhere we turn. That’s the solution to that.

Faithfully, most Christians learn a little bit as little kids, but no one learns everything as a little kid. You’re supposed to keep learning past grade school, and into your adult years. When people know the faith, they know it because they’ve worked on it for years AFTER 8th grade.

PS, faithfully, I couldn’t have broken the 23rd psalm down completely at the age of 4, no. But I learned it with my mother’s help, and she knew that eventually I would be able to break it down as I grew up into an adult. It was chosen for me because I loved it, a common thing for kids from devout protestant families. The idea is that you learn all your life, and you grow into what you know a little, until you know a lot.
 
Upset because I could tell that the guy who didn’t know the first thing about basic Christianity was a cradle Catholic? I could do that because I’ve seen it soooo many times before. The pattern is broad and deep, impossible to miss. You can blame me, but it’s not my fault. Blaming me isn’t going to fix the fact that an incredible number of Catholics don’t know their faith, and that’s the truth.

Want me to be wrong? Then make sure that the Catholics you know understand the faith, so I (and all the people like me) stop hearing these horror stories and seeing the inevitable consequences everywhere we turn. That’s the solution to that.
I’m not upset, nor do I “want you to be wrong.” You are right. It’s an absolute reality that the education has been lacking. Or rather, I suspect, so broad in attempt to cover so much, too general. And at the same time, things are taught when they really can’t be fully understood. Many details lost in translation.

At the same time, the most knowledgable Catholics I know, have been Catholic all their life. In fact, I’ve not MET a single priest, for example, who wasn’t. And honestly, I don’t KNOW that many converts. I didn’t know people who weren’t Catholic for most of my childhood. Perhaps the pool you draw from is smaller than those of some of us cradle Catholics. I seriously lived in a bubble for a while. Thinking anyone who didn’t believe Mary was the mother of God and a life long virgin must have been living in a cave when that news came out. LOL! I was more shocked at that point of view.

But there is NEVER room for rudeness. Starring at a person is shock of their lack of knowledge is RUDE. A person not knowing something is NOT a “horror story”. Horror stories are going to a Catholic school and learning the priest in charge of your school brutally abused a guestimation of some 20 boys. Nearly all of which LOST their faith. THAT’s a horror story. Boys that actually thought, and I QUOTE… “this is what the Catholic church is actually ABOUT.”

You as a Catholic have just as much an obligation as I to “make sure the Catholics you know understand the faith.” And it’s NOT SO you and people like you can quit hearing these “horror stories”. It’s more so for the safety of their soul… it should be done in charity.

I’m not sure why you think I would “blame” you for anything having to do with this. I’d have to think you were root of the problem for that. So, since that is impossible, I’m sure you realize I can not blame you for the lack of understanding of others.

Nor should you even stand up to take the blame, why would you do that? Help me with your logic in suggesting this.

The only thing I would look crosseyed at a fellow Christian for is treating a person with such ill respect because they don’t know something. Even if it’s something they should know. I would be blown away to run into such a person who can’t charitbly say, “you know, you’re not the first Catholic I’ve come across that thought that. I would love to share with you some information on that topic so you can speak to it with more knowledge.”

There really shouldn’t be a creation of us and them… cradle Catholics, and converts. Now should there?

Education, not just in religion is taking a hit EVERYWHERE. What’s stunning and shocking is high school graduates that can not read. Basic math skills do not exist.

The solution to this problem is to figure out WHY so many people don’t know what they should know. What is lacking in the education? WHO allowed this to happen? What needs to be done for correction. For the most part, it’s not really up to the lay person to teach. I think too much room for SERIOUS error.

As we know the church will be attacked. I imagine even from within. And we were also promised these attacks WILL NOT prevail. I often wonder if such lack of teaching is an attack. Wouldn’t that be a rather stratigic plan to bring the church down? Confusing its followers to the best of ability?

We don’t learn that the protestant church will be attacked and those attacks will not prevail. Or that Muslims, or Jews will face such attacks, and they will not prevail. Perhaps some churchs are just not bothered with. In fact, wouldn’t it be a GREAT idea to teach ANY other religion with such zeal that it’s quite difficult to bring such people to the TRUE faith?

Satan, of all people (of all people? That’s not right… you know what I mean) is quite thrilled with what goes on today. I think rather than be shocked and stunned, we need to be PREPARED as best we can, and fight the fight!
 
Faithfully, most Christians learn a little bit as little kids, but no one learns everything as a little kid. You’re supposed to keep learning past grade school, and into your adult years. When people know the faith, they know it because they’ve worked on it for years AFTER 8th grade.

PS, faithfully, I couldn’t have broken the 23rd psalm down completely at the age of 4, no. But I learned it with my mother’s help, and she knew that eventually I would be able to break it down as I grew up into an adult. It was chosen for me because I loved it, a common thing for kids from devout protestant families. The idea is that you learn all your life, and you grow into what you know a little, until you know a lot.
Cutting where you edited while I was writing… 😉

Sure that’s also true. So, tell me, as a convert (I’ve gathered you are a convert, right?)WHEN did you learn the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation.

I ask this, because most cradle Catholics hear these words at the age 7. Then they never hear them again. Converts tend to hear this in their adult years. When they will pick up the word and mull it around. They will study more deeply, because they are already in that mode.

Sometimes you don’t know what you don’t know, it’s not until you uncover something you SHOULD have known that studies get deeper and deeper. Usually leading to more knowledge.

The thing is you don’t NEED to know those words to believe. Nor to make it to heaven. Christ never said, ONLY if you know everything there is to know shall you be saved. One does NOT need to know that Christ was a Jew or Jewish to make it to heaven.

I’m willing to bet the man in question, from the original OP, NOW KNOWS he missed some info. He’s likely to spend some time diving in. Learning more. I don’t think it matters one bit that he’s in his 50’s. Perhaps today he is more prepared to learn and take it in than he was even last year.
 
She had never heard the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation and she was going into her senior year at a Catholic HS and had been in Catholic schools since kindergarten!

so like me and a few others we were never really allowed to receive communion,

I mean isn’t that a necessity to receive communion is to believe in transubstantiation??

I need to be honest here as I still don’t. I believe the way I was taught to believe it.
WAIT… hold the phone.

You claim to be a Catholic. and you don’t believe in transubstantiation? That’s a bigger problem than not knowing the word. You do realize that don’t you? That’s what I mean. Us cradle Catholics just “know” this, many of us will fail the vocabulary test!

You say you believe the way you were taught to believe it? You mean as a child? Do you not see that you do exactly what you condemn Cradle Catholics of: not furthing your education?

At this juncture, it won’t matter how much you can quote, and claim to be knowledgable of, you have missed the boat ENTIRELY.

Don’t worry, we’ll circle back around for you. You need to get on board FULLY! Keep up your studies… and many prayers for you!
 
Cutting where you edited while I was writing… 😉

Sure that’s also true. So, tell me, as a convert (I’ve gathered you are a convert, right?)WHEN did you learn the words transubstantiation or consubstantiation.

I ask this, because most cradle Catholics hear these words at the age 7. Then they never hear them again. Converts tend to hear this in their adult years. When they will pick up the word and mull it around. They will study more deeply, because they are already in that mode.

Sometimes you don’t know what you don’t know, it’s not until you uncover something you SHOULD have known that studies get deeper and deeper. Usually leading to more knowledge.

The thing is you don’t NEED to know those words to believe. Nor to make it to heaven. Christ never said, ONLY if you know everything there is to know shall you be saved. One does NOT need to know that Christ was a Jew or Jewish to make it to heaven.

I’m willing to bet the man in question, from the original OP, NOW KNOWS he missed some info. He’s likely to spend some time diving in. Learning more. I don’t think it matters one bit that he’s in his 50’s. Perhaps today he is more prepared to learn and take it in than he was even last year.
You should have heard the words “transubstantiation” and “consubstantiation” after the age of seven. Or you should have read them at least. That is exactly my point. Catholics need to keep learning and studying after the 8th grade! There is no excuse for not knowing the basics if a person can read.

PS. You do need to know some things to believe. There is no merit in being ignorant, and in fact not knowing can damage a person’s ability to live out the faith. This is why we have a BIBLE which would not be necessary if we just knew what to do.

PPS. Ignorance makes a person more gullible and more likely to believe non-truths. That’s what happened to the Arians, the Albigensians, the Manicheans, shall I go on.

The idea is not to “just make it,” by doing the bare minimum, I hope.

I first learned the words “transubstantiation” and “consubstantiation” when I was 13, BTW. But that’s certainly not the last time I heard or read them.
 
Interesting thread development 🙂

I don’t remember hearing the words consubstantiation or transubstantiation until I was about 16 - but I’m pretty durn sure I understood the beliefs right enough well before then.

I could tell you that Catholics believed the host was the Body and Blood of Christ and nothing but, even though it still looked like bread and wine. And I could tell you that some other Christians believed that somehow the bread and wine were still present along with the body and blood of Christ.

I don’t think the fact that I didn’t know the big complicated words for these beliefs for a while hindered my comprehension or my faith.
 
Hey there Luvstosew… I have your quote confused with “iloveangels”. So I realize NOW, that you don’t seem to be making issue about knowing certain vocabulary. SORRY ABOUT THAT! HOWEVER, you do need to still get on board. What do you think would help you with that? Perhaps someone here can point you in the right direction!
WAIT… hold the phone.

You claim to be a Catholic. and you don’t believe in transubstantiation? That’s a bigger problem than not knowing the word. You do realize that don’t you? That’s what I mean. Us cradle Catholics just “know” this, many of us will fail the vocabulary test!

You say you believe the way you were taught to believe it? You mean as a child? Do you not see that you do exactly what you condemn Cradle Catholics of: not furthing your education?

At this juncture, it won’t matter how much you can quote, and claim to be knowledgable of, you have missed the boat ENTIRELY.

Don’t worry, we’ll circle back around for you. You need to get on board FULLY! Keep up your studies… and many prayers for you!
 
I don’t know if anyone can help me really.

I just discovered not long ago what
transubstantiation really means, I have never doubted all my life the host was the body and blood of Christ, and I still believe that, but having a real difficult time with it is the actual flesh and actural blood, that the host turns into the flesh and blood of Christ.

And then to believe that flesh and blood of Christ is stored and Christ stays in it, in the adoration chapel.

efter all the reading and reading posts on it,it extremely hard to me to accept that. Now if maybe they had described it better when in Cathechism I would, but they never explained it that way. Just like we never doubted many things, like Mary being a virgin, etc.

I guess you could say I more believe like the Lutherns believe which I read up on, as I didnl’t know what anyone else believed.

Some people becoming Catholic have a problem with Mary , confession to the Priest, the Saints, and I’m surprised they easily accept the host is actual flesh and blood, and I’m a cradle Catholic, who never makes fun of another cradle Catholic as I understand many of them are like me.

So not sure I can be helped with this issue.
 
I’m not upset, nor do I “want you to be wrong.” You are right. It’s an absolute reality that the education has been lacking. Or rather, I suspect, so broad in attempt to cover so much, too general. And at the same time, things are taught when they really can’t be fully understood. Many details lost in translation.
One of the things that has upset me about the shortcomings in my education over the last few years wasn’t that it was so broad, but that it never covered the basics. Learning the Bible and the history of the Church is fine, but what good does it do if you leave out the basic tenets of the Church? I spent the bulk of my life believing that the bread & wine were symbols because that’s exactly what I was taught, and the notion of consubstantiation was never really even touched on. Growing up, I knew that Catholics having large families was an old stereotype. Later, I caught on that Catholics traditionally didn’t use birth control. It wasn’t until a couple years ago that I read anything about the concept of being open to life, or understood what that really meant. That was never covered in my 12 years of Catholic school or my laughably brief pre-Cana. I spent years believing that abortion was okay and eventually came to the conclusion that it wasn’t by reasoning out the arguments. It was only afterward that I read why the Church is against it. Sure, we were taught that it was wrong in high school, but that only came about because someone insisted on writing a paper saying it was okay. Up until then, the only time you’d even hear the word is if you went to the meetings about the walk for life. These are things that should have been drilled into us every year.

We never covered the 6 precepts of the church, at least not in any meaningful way. I knew we were expected to go to Mass, but I was never taught that missing Mass was a sin. We all knew about Confession, but we were never taught that we were supposed to go at least once a year. When I mentioned this to a couple family members recently, I was laughed and called a liar. I was never taught that we are required to receive Communion at least once a year, specifically during Easter. I also never knew that it was a sin to receive Communion while in a state of mortal sin, or that not being in communion with the beliefs of the Church put me in a state of mortal sin. We knew about not eating meat on Ash Wednesday and Fridays during Lent (and that it used to be every Friday), but that’s all we ever covered as far as fasting and abstaining go. I knew that I was expected to give regularly at Mass, but that knowledge came from my mother and was then reinforced when I enrolled my son in school. And as far as obeying the marriage laws of the Church, like I stated above, the vast majority of the information I received about that was completely wrong, even in my pre-Cana. Again, this is all stuff that should be covered every single year of a Catholic education (the full scope of the marriage laws being the only exception for younger kids).

It was never a case of information overload and stuff being lost in the shuffle; it was a complete lack of instruction of the basics of our faith. My son, who also had 12 years of Catholic education, is in pretty much the same boat I was at his age. He’s shocked by some of what I tell him, simply because it’s brand new to him. I’m doing everything I can to make sure my daughters don’t end up the same way. As cradle Catholics, born and bred in the faith, we should know these things like the backs of our hands.
 
Gordon,

I hear what your saying, there is one consolation in all this, to commit a Mortal sin one has to have full knowledge that it is a Mortal Sin , so like if you took and birth control pill and didn’t know it was a Mortal Sin , it wasn’t a Mortal Sin for you then., but now that you know it is a sin.

and if one is not to receive communion if one doesn’t believe its the flesh and blood, well then if they teach anything they should make sure everyone completely understands it, but they don’t teach it, so it reminds me since Christ told Peter whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, so well we did what we were taught.
 
The only thing I would look crosseyed at a fellow Christian for is treating a person with such ill respect because they don’t know something. Even if it’s something they should know. I would be blown away to run into such a person who can’t charitbly say, “you know, you’re not the first Catholic I’ve come across that thought that. I would love to share with you some information on that topic so you can speak to it with more knowledge.”
I completely agree. I can only imagine the look this poor guy got. If he didn’t know the things he was supposed to know before, being treated rudely isn’t going to make him any more interested. Being “stunned” about it and calling it a “horror story” is ridiculous. In my opinion, this would have been a good opportunity to treat someone kindly and do a little educating, but if I were this guy, I’d be irritated for being made to feel stupid.

I personally got an excellent Catholic education, but there are still so many things I don’t completely understand or can’t explain well. We are not supposed to be arrogant about our faith- yes we need to figure out what is wrong with catechesis and do something about it, but acting like you’re better than someone else because you understand something they don’t? That’s likely to push people further away than where they started from.
 
I completely agree. I can only imagine the look this poor guy got. If he didn’t know the things he was supposed to know before, being treated rudely isn’t going to make him any more interested. Being “stunned” about it and calling it a “horror story” is ridiculous. In my opinion, this would have been a good opportunity to treat someone kindly and do a little educating, but if I were this guy, I’d be irritated for being made to feel stupid.

I personally got an excellent Catholic education, but there are still so many things I don’t completely understand or can’t explain well. We are not supposed to be arrogant about our faith- yes we need to figure out what is wrong with catechesis and do something about it, but acting like you’re better than someone else because you understand something they don’t? That’s likely to push people further away than where they started from.
Good point.
 
One of the things that has upset me about the shortcomings in my education over the last few years wasn’t that it was so broad, but that it never covered the basics. Learning the Bible and the history of the Church is fine, but what good does it do if you leave out the basic tenets of the Church? I spent the bulk of my life believing that the bread & wine were symbols because that’s exactly what I was taught, and the notion of consubstantiation was never really even touched on. Growing up, I knew that Catholics having large families was an old stereotype. Later, I caught on that Catholics traditionally didn’t use birth control. It wasn’t until a couple years ago that I read anything about the concept of being open to life, or understood what that really meant. That was never covered in my 12 years of Catholic school or my laughably brief pre-Cana. I spent years believing that abortion was okay and eventually came to the conclusion that it wasn’t by reasoning out the arguments. It was only afterward that I read why the Church is against it. Sure, we were taught that it was wrong in high school, but that only came about because someone insisted on writing a paper saying it was okay. Up until then, the only time you’d even hear the word is if you went to the meetings about the walk for life. These are things that should have been drilled into us every year.
I agree! Ok, below is part of my quote from earlier…above… I think your, OUR, above problems lie here, I really do!: Have you happened to read AA-1024. I have no idea if the story can/will ever be proved to be true. But there is something about it that rings so true, or possible. They suggest perhaps (in case you haven’t read it) a certain group of communist/athiests have infiltrated the Catholic church for the sole purpose of bringing it to its knees. We’re talking people with the hatred of satan, learning everything there is to know. That no person sent in would EVER know personally another person sent in so they couldn’t rat each other out, should they have a change of heart. That SOME of these people would make it all the way to Bishop. :eek: And they claim that some had. NOW, imagine a sex scandle!!! And a the “right” bishop making sweeping suggestions on how to handle it. This wasn’t something the Church had ever dealt with. I can see rather innocent minds “learning” from the wrong person as to what to do. I just can’t explain how so many “preists” turned out to be abusers. Or that our educators could be lulled into NOT making a bigger issue of the topics above! Without some sort of 'cause. It makes more sense to me that someone pushed these as reverse agendas. Just don’t talk about it. Let the secular world do the teaching. How many parents do you know that think NOT telling children about sex, or drugs, or whatever will prevent them from ever doing these things. It’s curious to me. No proof… But something I would consider.
As we know the church will be attacked. I imagine even from within. And we were also promised these attacks WILL NOT prevail. I often wonder if such lack of teaching is an attack. Wouldn’t that be a rather stratigic plan to bring the church down? Confusing its followers to the best of ability?

Satan, of all people (of all people? That’s not right… you know what I mean) is quite thrilled with what goes on today. I think rather than be shocked and stunned, we need to be PREPARED as best we can, and fight the fight!
 
Ok, Now regarding below. My gut is things were not made clear. Many items below were practiced in your 12 years. But NOT explained. Which is a problem. We didn’t realize we had slid off the grid and were doing anything wrong. Who does ANYTHING the way it was done in school?
We never covered the 6 precepts of the church, at least not in any meaningful way.But they WERE covered. Most likely. I knew we were expected to go to Mass, but I was never taught that missing Mass was a sin.The third commandments And I bet you were taught breaking a commandment was a sin??? We all knew about Confession, but we were never taught that we were supposed to go at least once a year. Were you taken to confession a few times a year? We were. I didn’t realize we were DOING what we were supposed to. Not enough explanation.When I mentioned this to a couple family members recently, I was laughed and called a liarREALLY? A LIAR? That’s pretty harsh. I’ve brought things to the attn. of family, and it’s WHAT? REALL? SHOW ME!. I was never taught that we are required to receive Communion at least once a year, specifically during Easter.You did this, but not explained in those 12 years I also never knew that it was a sin to receive Communion while in a state of mortal sin, or that not being in communion with the beliefs of the Church put me in a state of mortal sin. Again, you were probably taken to confession and relieved of your sins. So again, DONE, not explained. And as a child, you probably were never in a state of mortal sin. That’s a guess for the “average”. We knew about not eating meat on Ash Wednesday and Fridays during Lent (and that it used to be every Friday), but that’s all we ever covered as far as fasting and abstaining go.This was the same for me. However, we are still not required to do more. More is a choice today (from food that is) I knew that I was expected to give regularly at Mass, but that knowledge came from my mother and was then reinforced when I enrolled my son in school.But there is no hard rule on amount. We are ASKED weekly to give (So you, in theory hear this at least 52 times a year. And they usually justify each request.). Not TOLD. I think our hearts are to guide us here. We know what we can afford. I’m not sure teaching this is necessary. HOWEVER, you were likely??? taught to “give” in other ways. Did you not participate in fund raisers for others? Or go and sing at a Vets home. Did you learn to “consider” others? Again, by way of doing? And not being told to? And as far as obeying the marriage laws of the Church, like I stated above, the vast majority of the information I received about that was completely wrong, even in my pre-Cana. Again, this is all stuff that should be covered every single year of a Catholic education (the full scope of the marriage laws being the only exception for younger kids).Can you be more specific? Other than birth control? Again, commandment 6 & 9. But I also know my classes were “lacking here”.

It was never a case of information overload and stuff being lost in the shuffle; it was a complete lack of instruction of the basics of our faith. My son, who also had 12 years of Catholic education, is in pretty much the same boat I was at his age. He’s shocked by some of what I tell him, simply because it’s brand new to him. I’m doing everything I can to make sure my daughters don’t end up the same way. As cradle Catholics, born and bred in the faith, we should know these things like the backs of our hands.
I agree. We have to, as adults, stand up and take back our church. Insist with our teachers they DO it right. And make sure they know HOW to do it right!

I think there is something to the statement PRACTICE WHAT YOU PREACH. In many cases we Practiced. But we weren’t PREACHED to. CRAZY! And again, it’s currently often not something we realize until we are adults. Which is what drives my batty with the “cradle Catholic” statement. It’s INSULTING. It’s not like we all chose to have failed education. And the comment is directed at the individual NOT their education. So it is infact insulting, and lacking in charity! It’s a true “holier than thou” statement. And honestly, it makes me think less of person who uses it.
 
I don’t know if anyone can help me really.

I just discovered not long ago what
transubstantiation really means, I have never doubted all my life the host was the body and blood of Christ, and I still believe that, but having a real difficult time with it is the actual flesh and actural blood, that the host turns into the flesh and blood of Christ.

And then to believe that flesh and blood of Christ is stored and Christ stays in it, in the adoration chapel.

efter all the reading and reading posts on it,it extremely hard to me to accept that. Now if maybe they had described it better when in Cathechism I would, but they never explained it that way. Just like we never doubted many things, like Mary being a virgin, etc.

I guess you could say I more believe like the Lutherns believe which I read up on, as I didnl’t know what anyone else believed.

Some people becoming Catholic have a problem with Mary , confession to the Priest, the Saints, and I’m surprised they easily accept the host is actual flesh and blood, and I’m a cradle Catholic, who never makes fun of another cradle Catholic as I understand many of them are like me.

So not sure I can be helped with this issue.
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_03091965_mysterium_en.html

This is a long write up. But read paragraph 17… perhaps that will help a bit?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top