Support for Jews

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mystic_Warrior
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think support for the State of Israel is optional for Christians, not a biblical mandate like some think. I personally have a lot of sympathy for the Jews and I think the Arabs are dysfunctional and Islam a danger to the world. I’d rather the Holy Land be in the hands of the Jews.
 
I think that Jews think that Christians who support them are naive, useful idiots. The chosen people are those who believe in Jesus, not those who rejected him.
Many nations are in danger and they also need support.
It is wrong to justify killing and persecuting people in the name of Israel. I see no reason to support a Jewish nation that is so anti-Catholic. Why don’t you first try to support Catholics who are persecuted in many countries?
What you described above is a very naive, fundamentalistic, protestant point of view that doesn’t have much in common with the teaching of the CC.
God bless
I’m not sure if you were directing the post at me, but either way I wanted to respond.

I don’t agree with you assessment about the chosen people. I believe in the existence of the state of Israel with no land given to any other nation. That land was given to the Jewish people by God Himself.

And from what I have shared in my posts, I don’t see how it’s so fundamentalistic and naive. I admit that it’s a protestant view. I’m a protestant after all. If you look to the Bible it gives the answers to why we should support Jews. Genesis 12:3 is an example.

God has spoken. Let His Word go forth and not return void.

The thread was really directed towards Jews to begin with and I hoped to avoid mud-slinging. This is about dialogue and mutual understanding. It’s not about who is right and wrong.

Peace…

MW
 
I think support for the State of Israel is optional for Christians, not a biblical mandate like some think. I personally have a lot of sympathy for the Jews and I think the Arabs are dysfunctional and Islam a danger to the world. I’d rather the Holy Land be in the hands of the Jews.
Because God loves the Jews so much, how can I not do the same? The Arabs and Islam are a world threat. And yes, the Holy Land belongs to Jews. The Arabs are trespassers.

Peace…

MW
 
There is an organization called, “Christians United for Israel” that I thought was really great. Pastor John Hagee is a staunch supporter. I’m not a fan of his, but I agree with him on the issue of Jews and Israel.

MW
Here is the parodox I have never been able to resolve concering evangelicals support of Israel. They are supporting a people they are convinced are going to hell. I believe , given this, their support is based more on their belief the nation of Israel is necessary to bring about their version of end times , not out of any love for the Jewsih people themsleves.

I am not, of course, refering to you.
 
I hardly think the Arabs are tresspassers. They are indigenous people to the region.

But, I much more admire the Jews. They are a good group of people, hard working, law abiding, with sound ethics. You don’t hear about Jews blowing people up because of their religion. Their success is from working hard and playing by the rules.
 
I suggest you visit Palestine & speak to the people under occupation for 40yrs. Their land has been taken, their houses bulldozed; their orchards & olive groves destroyed.

To equate Israel with the Jewish people is a very naive idea - most Israelis are secular, even atheists. Many orthodox rabbis refuse to recognize the legitimacy of Israel since a Jewish state can only be founded when the Messiah appears.

The Holocaust happened in Europe not in the Arab or Moslem world where Jews lived happily for hundreds of years. Pograms occurred regularly in Russia & Poland but not in Iran where today the second largest world community of Jews live and even train in the Iranian army. One should never equate a religion with a State; particularly where the vast majority of the citizens are non-religious.

To many people outside US, Israel is an illegal, colonial power which refuses to comply with numerous UN decrees. There can never be peace until Israel returns to its '67 borders and gives the occupied land back to the Palestinians.

More & more moderate Jews are leaving Israel for Europe or US; believing they have much more in common with that culture than the ME. Another 20yrs will bring radical changes to that part of the world. Once the oil is gone US will no longer have any interest in the place & it will return to desert as in Biblical times. Probably a good thing.
 
Here is the parodox I have never been able to resolve concering evangelicals support of Israel. They are supporting a people they are convinced are going to hell. I believe , given this, their support is based more on their belief the nation of Israel is necessary to bring about their version of end times , not out of any love for the Jewsih people themsleves.

I am not, of course, refering to you.
It’s a broad statement to say that evangelicals think they are going to hell. I was never taught anything about their salvation, whether yea or nay. Through every Baptist church I was a part of, the Jewish people and Israel were revered because:
  1. Our Lord was Jewish - the promised Messiah came through the Jewish line
  2. God promised to bless those who blessed Israel and curse those who cursed them as supported by Gen. 12:3
  3. God gave them the Promised Land that no one should have except them.
Those were three basic reasons that I was always taught to support them and love them, not out of eschatology.

Peace…

MW
 
I suggest you visit Palestine & speak to the people under occupation for 40yrs. Their land has been taken, their houses bulldozed; their orchards & olive groves destroyed.
That land belonged to Israel way before the Arabs. They were taking back what rightfully belonged to them.
To equate Israel with the Jewish people is a very naive idea - most Israelis are secular, even atheists. Many orthodox rabbis refuse to recognize the legitimacy of Israel since a Jewish state can only be founded when the Messiah appears.
I realize it is a secular state, but at least in that part of the world they are the only ones who listen to reason. Perhaps one day that secular state will become a religious one.
The Holocaust happened in Europe not in the Arab or Moslem world where Jews lived happily for hundreds of years. Pograms occurred regularly in Russia & Poland but not in Iran where today the second largest world community of Jews live and even train in the Iranian army. One should never equate a religion with a State; particularly where the vast majority of the citizens are non-religious.
To many people outside US, Israel is an illegal, colonial power which refuses to comply with numerous UN decrees. There can never be peace until Israel returns to its '67 borders and gives the occupied land back to the Palestinians.
More & more moderate Jews are leaving Israel for Europe or US; believing they have much more in common with that culture than the ME. Another 20yrs will bring radical changes to that part of the world. Once the oil is gone US will no longer have any interest in the place & it will return to desert as in Biblical times. Probably a good thing.
Again, that land was decreed to the Jews by God himself. No man-made power has the right to make it different. It was by God’s providence was shown through the six-day war. I believe that number was signficant.

Peace…

MW
 
I hardly think the Arabs are tresspassers. They are indigenous people to the region.

But, I much more admire the Jews. They are a good group of people, hard working, law abiding, with sound ethics. You don’t hear about Jews blowing people up because of their religion. Their success is from working hard and playing by the rules.
The Arabs came later. Israel was given that land. Arabs took it. Israel takes it back. They were given the promised land and no one else should have it. Yes, I agree with your description of them. The owners of my company are Jewish and treated me well and with respect even though the company is very large.

Peace…

MW
 
It’s a broad statement to say that evangelicals think they are going to hell. I was never taught anything about their salvation, whether yea or nay. Through every Baptist church I was a part of, the Jewish people and Israel were revered because:
  1. Our Lord was Jewish - the promised Messiah came through the Jewish line
  2. God promised to bless those who blessed Israel and curse those who cursed them as supported by Gen. 12:3
  3. God gave them the Promised Land that no one should have except them.
Those were three basic reasons that I was always taught to support them and love them, not out of eschatology.

Peace…

MW
Every evangelical I have ever talked to takes it as a core doctrine that unless one accepts Jesus Christ as their personal savior they are going to hell. That would tend to exclude all jews from salvation. Am I incorrect in what Evangelicals believe?
 
The Arabs came later. Israel was given that land. Arabs took it. Israel takes it back. They were given the promised land and no one else should have it. Yes, I agree with your description of them. The owners of my company are Jewish and treated me well and with respect even though the company is very large.

Peace…

MW
Many lands in the world have changed hands. The Celts once ruled Britain, the Native Americans ruled N America, and so forth. Just because the Jews once ruled Israel, and it was recorded in the Bible, I don’t think gives them rights forever.

Still, I’d rather them be there, since as I previously said I basically think they are more civilised.
 
Every evangelical I have ever talked to takes it as a core doctrine that unless one accepts Jesus Christ as their personal savior they are going to hell. That would tend to exclude all jews from salvation. Am I incorrect in what Evangelicals believe?
I found a website that seems to clear this up from the standpoint of most evangelicals. It’s a quiet belief that Jews need to accept Jesus as the Messiah, while not aggressively seeking their conversion.

apologeticsindex.org/357-john-hagee-salvation

I suppose in my upbringing the Jews were a non-issue. They proclaimed that everyone needed Jesus without singling out one community of people, while implicitly they do. Regardless of their salvation or lack of it, the belief is that there is a Biblical mandate to support Jews and Israel.

Peace…

MW
 
Because of the nature of this thread I won’t belabor these points too much except to say that Israel expanded it’s UN boarders because it was attacked by 5 Arab armies on the day of its creation. The 1967 expansion was again due to aggression on the part of the Arabs.
So what? That is not excuse, even if it was completely true. Jewish settlers were mobilizing for war even before the UN mandate and official independance. Not to mention, even forming the state of Israel was a defacto declaration of war against the Arab states in the region, who retaliated based on justified concerned.
The Christians have more freedom of worship in Israel than in any other Mideast country.
And so what if they do? It is still very little, so i have every right to be unsatisfied. Just look at the horrible relations between the Israeli government and the Vatican. Or the recent bonfires of Books of Gospels organized by the Israelis.
Because God loves the Jews so much, how can I not do the same? The Arabs and Islam are a world threat. And yes, the Holy Land belongs to Jews. The Arabs are trespassers.

Peace…

MW
God loves the Jews? Yes, because he loves everybody. But the covenant that was Judaism was fulfilled. THE CHURCH is God’s new chosen people. Jesus satisfied, fulfilled, and ended Judaism. Christians are God’s people.
That land belonged to Israel way before the Arabs. They were taking back what rightfully belonged to them.
And before them, it was controlled by phoenecians. Lets revive phoenicia! Long live Phoenicia!
I realize it is a secular state, but at least in that part of the world they are the only ones who listen to reason. Perhaps one day that secular state will become a religious one.
Why would we want a jewish religious state any more than we would want a religious Islamic state. In many ways, Islam is even less heretical that Judaism! Besides, your assertion that Israel is the lone voice of reason in the region is ridiculous; there are arab countries there which are truly “western” and modern. But contemporary western values are ridiculous values to establish a society on anyways.
 
And so what if they do? It is still very little, so i have every right to be unsatisfied. Just look at the horrible relations between the Israeli government and the Vatican. Or the recent bonfires of Books of Gospels organized by the Israelis.
Did you learn the full story of the burning of the NTs?

Did you know that Protestant missionaries had DELUGED a very Orthodox town with them, on purpose?

Those religious Jews had every right to do what they did, because the missionaries went where they knew they were not welcome, and totally trashed the town with their materials!

How would you like it if a pizza delivery place dumped thousands of pizza flyers on your street? You might build a bonfire yourself!

Incidentally, the triumphalistic attitude, coming from Christians such as yourself (“the Jews are not the chosen people anymore, WE are!”) is merely the Christian version of the Muslim belief that only they have the truth, and everyone else be damned.

Until ALL religions (including segments of my own) get away from that cancerous mentality, we will never have peace between religious peoples.
 
The biggest reason for institutionalized antisemitism in Christianity has to do with St. Augustine, who started speculating that the Christian Church had replaced Israel; that the promises of G_D to Israel had been transferred to Christianity. Over the centuries this developed into Replacement Theology, which was never part of Catholic doctrine but did have a significant influence over the centuries. It began to fall out of favor after WW2, and it was implicitly rejected by Pope JP2.

<><
Could you give some more information on that? I believe that there is a new Israel and it has nothing to do with bloodlines or geography, is this not Catholic teaching? What did JP2 have to say about this? Thanks in advance.
 
Incidentally, the triumphalistic attitude, coming from Christians such as yourself (“the Jews are not the chosen people anymore, WE are!”) is merely the Christian version of the Muslim belief that only they have the truth, and everyone else be damned.

Until ALL religions (including segments of my own) get away from that cancerous mentality, we will never have peace between religious peoples.
First of all, that is a belief of our Church. We believe that Jesus fulfilled the Old Covenant, Judaism, and began the new covenant. The Lord opened up his Church to all, Jews and Gentiles. Jesus was the Jewish Messiah, so all jews should have followed him into the Church. Unfortunately, many did not. I’m sure there is a special place for them in God’s heart, but I’m also sure he wishes they would join his Church.

This an essential belief of the Church. What i dont understand about relativists like you is that you critisize my beliefs because you think they infringe upon the rights of other religions, yet IN SO DOING, you infringe upon MY religion’s right to hold its own beliefs.
 
First of all, that is a belief of our Church. We believe that Jesus fulfilled the Old Covenant, Judaism, and began the new covenant. The Lord opened up his Church to all, Jews and Gentiles. Jesus was the Jewish Messiah, so all jews should have followed him into the Church. Unfortunately, many did not. I’m sure there is a special place for them in God’s heart, but I’m also sure he wishes they would join his Church.

This an essential belief of the Church. What i dont understand about relativists like you is that you critisize my beliefs because you think they infringe upon the rights of other religions, yet IN SO DOING, you infringe upon MY religion’s right to hold its own beliefs.
You can hold those beliefs all you want, but they are not solving anything.

The message is ultimately the same, whether it comes from the Vatican, Jerusalem or Brooklyn, or Mecca. 🤷

There are some in my religion that have the same triumphalistic mentality, and don’t think I find that any less cancerous to the body of the human race. Its the same everywhere…“When the Messiah comes, they will see that we were right and they were wrong”…“When Christ comes back, they will see that we were right and they were wrong”…“When Allah brings about the End, they will see that we were right and they were wrong”…“When the final Avatar comes, they will see that we were right and they were wrong”…and on it goes.
 
Did you learn the full story of the burning of the NTs?

Did you know that Protestant missionaries had DELUGED a very Orthodox town with them, on purpose?

Those religious Jews had every right to do what they did, because the missionaries went where they knew they were not welcome, and totally trashed the town with their materials!

.
I hope you dont really mean this? 🤷 (I’ve been guilty of shooting off emails or post responses I didn’t really mean and have regretted). I’m a Jew who believes in Christ as the Messiah (call me a Christian or a Jewish believer, I’m not a label person). To me, this book burning was hauntingly reminicent of book burnings in Germany. There is never really any excuse for burning another’s holy scriptures - its not a Jewish, or Christian, thing to do.

I understand, from your other posts, that you are a Jewish antimissionary - I respect your right to expound your views, share your literature and engage in respectful debate. I’m happy to do the same - and maye be we can learn from each other?

Blessings,

Brian
 
Incidentally, the triumphalistic attitude, coming from Christians such as yourself (“the Jews are not the chosen people anymore, WE are!”) is merely the Christian version of the Muslim belief that only they have the truth, and everyone else be damned.

Until ALL religions (including segments of my own) get away from that cancerous mentality, we will never have peace between religious peoples.
Hello Sepharad,

The owners of these so called " triumphant attitudes" can be seen quite differently by the members of this forum ( I am one )

I believe YOU as well as all the Jews are indeed the chosen people. ( not because YOU INSIST on it but rather the bible tells me so.

Then there is the rest of the story ( the next 2000 years or so )
I appreciate your different belief on this and I hope you can appreciate mine.

I believe that the OT and all the prophets were indeed fullfilled by Jesus Christ, I also will add that, in my view, my faith of christianity is directly rooted ( not in conflict with ) in Judaism.

God Bless,
Carl
 
I hope you dont really mean this? 🤷 (I’ve been guilty of shooting off emails or post responses I didn’t really mean and have regretted). I’m a Jew who believes in Christ as the Messiah (call me a Christian or a Jewish believer, I’m not a label person). To me, this book burning was hauntingly reminicent of book burnings in Germany. There is never really any excuse for burning another’s holy scriptures - its not a Jewish, or Christian, thing to do.

I understand, from your other posts, that you are a Jewish antimissionary - I respect your right to expound your views, share your literature and engage in respectful debate. I’m happy to do the same - and maye be we can learn from each other?

Blessings,

Brian
I actually work more in volunteer exit counseling…helping Jews who want to return to Judaism from other faiths. But countermissionary work is something I also do, as the need arises.

As for the burning of the NTs, perhaps burning was not the proper way to dispose of them. But I am friends with a woman who has a daughter who lives in that town, and she sent her pictures of the blanketing of the town with the Christian literature and NTs…they must have spent a fortune getting THAT much stuff printed up, just to dump it all in a small town where NO ONE wanted it. They had to have realized what they were doing. This is an ULTRA-Orthodox town.

Would you have rather they thrown the NTs in the trash dumpster? What should they have done with them, since the quantity was massive?

What would you do if a religious cult or other religion you disagree with (that is known for aggressively proselytizing Catholics) dumped a similar quantity of their tracts and Bibles onto your street or town? What would you do with the materials?

I think very religious Jews are just plain tired of always having Christian views foisted upon them, and then when they react, THEY are the ones blamed for “intolerance”. I understand how they feel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top