Syria resolution sets deadline, bars U.S. ground forces

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
The Senate resolution authorizing President Barack Obama to usemilitary force against Syria would bar American ground troops for combat operations and set a deadline for any action.

The Associated Press obtained a copy of the draft resolution that the Foreign Relations Committee will vote on Wednesday.

The measure would set a time limit of 60 days and says the president can extend that for 30 days more with congressional approval.
cbsnews.com/8301-250_162-57601219/syria-resolution-sets-deadline-bars-u.s-ground-forces/?tag=breakingnews

Proposed bill is here
dropbox.com/s/jmke29c5gl2qe9p/SFRC-Resolution-on-Syria.pdf
 
from the bill

(a) AUTHORIZATION-The President is authorized, subject to subsection (b), to use the Armed Forces of the United States as he determines to be necessary and appropriate in a limited and tailored manner against legitimate military targets in Syria, only to:

(1) respond to the use of weapons of mass destruction by the Syrian government in the conflict in Syria;

(2) deter Syria’s use of such weapons in order to protect the national security interests of the United States and to protect our allies and partners against the use of such weapons; and

(3) degrade Syria’s capacity to use such weapons in the future.

(4) it is in the core national security interest of the United States to use such military force;

(5) the United States has a military plan to achieve the specific goals of responding to the use of weapons of mass destruction by the Syrian government in the conflict in Syria, to deter Syria’s use of such weapons in order to protect the national security interests of the United States and to protect our allies and partners against the use of such weapons, and to degrade Syria’s capacity to use such weapons in the future; and

(6) the use of military force is consistent with and furthers the goals of the United States strategy toward Syria, including achieving a negotiated political settlement to the conflict.

(c) WAR POWERS RESOLUTION REQUIREMENTS-

(1) SPECIFIC STATUTORY AUTHORIZATION- Consistent with section 8
(a)(1) of the War Powers Resolution, 50 U.S.C. § 1541, et seq., the Congress declares that this section is intended to constitute specific statutory authorization within the meaning of section 5(b) of the War Powers Resolution, within the limits of the authorization established under this Section.

(2) APPLICABILITY OF OTHER REQUIREMENTS- Nothing in this resolution supersedes any requirement of the War Powers Resolution.
SECTION 3. LIMITATION. The authority granted in section 2 does not authorize the use of the United States Armed Forces on the ground in Syria for the purpose of combat operations.

SECTION 4. TERMINATION OF THE AUTHORIZATION FOR THE USE OF UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.

The authorization in section 2(a) shall terminate 60 days after the date of the enactment of this joint resolution, except that the President may extend, for a single period of 30 days, such authorization if –

(1) the President determines and certifies to Congress, not later than 5 days before the date of termination of the initial authorization, that the extension is necessary to fulfill the purposes of this resolution as defined by Section 2(a) due to extraordinary circumstances and for ongoing and impending military operations against Syria under section 2(a); and

(2) Congress does not enact into law, before the extension of authorization, a joint resolution disapproving the extension of the authorization for the additional 30 day period; provided that any such joint resolution shall be considered under the expedited procedures otherwise provided for concurrent resolutions of disapproval contained in section 7 of the War Powers Resolution (50 U.S.C. 1546).
 
SECTION 5. SYRIA STRATEGY.

Not later than 30 days after the date of the enactment of this resolution, the President shall consult with Congress and submit to the Committee on Foreign Relations of the Senate and the Committee on Foreign Affairs of the House of Representatives an integrated United States Government strategy for achieving a negotiated political settlement to the conflict in Syria, including a comprehensive review of current and planned U.S. diplomatic, political, economic, and military policy towards Syria, including:

(1) the provision of all forms of assistance to the Syrian Supreme Military Council and other Syrian entities opposed to the government of Bashar Al-Assad that have been properly and fully vetted and share common values and interests with the United States;

(2) the provision of all forms of assistance to the Syrian political opposition, including the Syrian Opposition Coalition;

(3) efforts to isolate extremist and terrorist groups in Syria to prevent their influence on the future transitional and permanent Syrian governments;

(4) coordination with allies and partners; and

(5) efforts to limit support from the Government of Iran and others for the Syrian regime.

SECTION 6. CONGRESSIONAL NOTIFICATION AND REPORTING.
(a) Notification and Provision of Information. Upon his determination to use the authority set forth in section 2 of this Act, the President shall notify Congress, including the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the House Foreign Affairs Committee, of the use of such authority and shall keep Congress fully and currently informed of the use of such authority.

(b) Reports. No fewer than 10 days after the initiation of military operations under the authority provided by Section 2, and every 20 days thereafter until the completion of military operations, the President shall submit to the Congress, including the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the House Foreign Affairs Committee, a report on the status of such operations, including progress achieved toward the objectives specified in Section 2(a), the financial costs of operations to date, and an assessment of the impact of the operations on the Syrian regime’s chemical weapons capabilities and intentions.

SECTION 7. RULE OF CONSTRUCTION. The authority set forth in Section 2 of this resolution shall not constitute an authorization for the use of force or a declaration of war except to the extent that it authorizes military action under the conditions, for the specific purposes, and for the limited period of time set forth in this resolution.
 
well, Gilliam, it looks like we are the only 2 voters so far. this all just makes me very nervous. so they are voting this Wednesday and this will be the only and final vote?

I thought every member of congress needs to vote. this is just the foresign relations committee voting?
 
It will be a hard sell in the house if this is any indication:

Out of 242 House members on The Fix’s whip count, more than half (127) are against military action or lean no. wapo.st/1dMskzh
 
well, Gilliam, it looks like we are the only 2 voters so far. this all just makes me very nervous. so they are voting this Wednesday and this will be the only and final vote?

I thought every member of congress needs to vote. this is just the foresign relations committee voting?
The Senate Foreign Relations Committee is just the first hurtle such a bill would have to clear. Eventually the full Senate and the full House would have to vote on it or a similar bill.
 
Well, this has the appearance of reality but I’m confident it isn’t and it can’t.
  1. Our National Interests are not being threatened.
  2. The goal appears to be to stabilize one governing power, and force negotiations. This could easily backfire.
  3. The primary “interest” is protecting our Allies, not the United States. The secondary objective is to take out as many terrorists as possible.
  4. This is a tiny operational window. The assumption being made is that targets will be taken out very rapidly using remote means, with no chance of resupply.
It will be interesting to see world reaction and the reactions of the various religious groups.

May God have mercy,
Ed
 
Well, this has the appearance of reality but I’m confident it isn’t and it can’t.
  1. Our National Interests are not being threatened.
  2. The goal appears to be to stabilize one governing power, and force negotiations. This could easily backfire.
  3. The primary “interest” is protecting our Allies, not the United States. The secondary objective is to take out as many terrorists as possible.
  4. This is a tiny operational window. The assumption being made is that targets will be taken out very rapidly using remote means, with no chance of resupply.
It will be interesting to see world reaction and the reactions of the various religious groups.

May God have mercy,
Ed
Another problem is that wars never end up as you originally hoped. Take for example, World War I. Egypt and Iraq are in chaotic situations now and who knows what Iran will do once the USA begins to bomb Syria. Britain has wisely decided not to go along with the bombing of Syria. Kerry says he is concerned about civilians who were killed by the gas. Of course this is something we have to be concerned about. But the answer is not to bomb Syria and kill even more people. The answer is a peaceful negotiated settlement, not more war and more killing of innocent people. But I guess that these political leaders are not intelligent enough to know how to promote peace. They just resort to war, to bombing and killing, to solve political problems.
 
It will also be interesting to see God Almighty’s reaction. I’m assuming that this will be an unjust war from our side, based on statements from Eastern Catholic Patriarchs, and Catholic monastic communities located in Syria.

Of course, it’s easy to think that nothing can hurt us, because we are the biggest and baddest boys on the block, because we have the most advanced weapons, and we can just fry anyone from a safe distance, lobbing cruise missiles into their yards while we are sipping coffee on our patios, and playing golf… That’s what the Babylonians thought, too, the very night before God destroyed their city, and their empire.

God have mercy on us! :signofcross:
 
Well, this has the appearance of reality but I’m confident it isn’t and it can’t.
  1. Our National Interests are not being threatened.
  2. The goal appears to be to stabilize one governing power, and force negotiations. This could easily backfire.
  3. The primary “interest” is protecting our Allies, not the United States. The secondary objective is to take out as many terrorists as possible.
  4. This is a tiny operational window. The assumption being made is that targets will be taken out very rapidly using remote means, with no chance of resupply.
It will be interesting to see world reaction and the reactions of the various religious groups.

May God have mercy,
Ed
Here is an interesting debate between Sec Kerry and Sen Paul … talks a little about these points. Best part is the comment from the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the end:
youtube.com/watch?v=fEcch-r28Bc
 
I am satisfied that Obama has taken this to Congress.

It is not something that I think is going to be effective unless overwhelming force is used to deliver the punishment, so it is not something that I would personally support.

America has no interest in delivering the kind of response that would be effective and humanitarian, and that is a big reason why Obama is in the WH in the first place.

A decision of Congress though brings the people into the decision, because Congressmen live or die with the way that the people respond to their decision. Obama did not really have a mandate to increase involvement in ME warfare. That was not part of his election platform. Congress can deliver him that mandate.

That is at least the democratic thing to do.
 
Well, this has the appearance of reality but I’m confident it isn’t and it can’t.
  1. Our National Interests are not being threatened.
More like our national influence (to make other countries not do things, like Iran not create a nuclear bomb)
  1. The goal appears to be to stabilize one governing power, and force negotiations. This could easily backfire.
Could, but probably won’t… big danger is it will do nothing to change what is happening but it will kill people.
  1. The primary “interest” is protecting our Allies, not the United States.
IMHO This is all about Iran and North Korea. Like punishing a gangster to stop other gangsters.
The secondary objective is to take out as many terrorists as possible.
We aren’t planning on doing that in Iran as far as I know. Any sources say different?
  1. This is a tiny operational window. The assumption being made is that targets will be taken out very rapidly using remote means, with no chance of resupply.
Targets are likely ones that will take some time to replenish. Fixed assets, buildings, airfields, aircraft, that sort of thing.
It will be interesting to see world reaction and the reactions of the various religious groups.
Especially if civilians are killed in the process.
 
Here is an interesting debate between Sec Kerry and Sen Paul … talks a little about these points. Best part is the comment from the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the end:
youtube.com/watch?v=fEcch-r28Bc
So according to Kerry it is not an act of war for the USA to go and bomb Syria? Apparently American politicians do not know the meaning of the term act of war. An act of war involves an act of aggression, such as bombing or invasion, by one country against another with which it is nominally at peace. For example, when Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, that was an act of war. But according to American politicians such as Kerry, if the USA bombs Syria, that would not be an act of war.
 
More like our national influence (to make other countries not do things, like Iran not create a nuclear bomb)

Could, but probably won’t… big danger is it will do nothing to change what is happening but it will kill people.

IMHO This is all about Iran and North Korea. Like punishing a gangster to stop other gangsters.

We aren’t planning on doing that in Iran as far as I know. Any sources say different?

Targets are likely ones that will take some time to replenish. Fixed assets, buildings, airfields, aircraft, that sort of thing.

Especially if civilians are killed in the process.
Civilians always get killed in the process and some targets will not be wearing standard uniforms. The goal is not to destroy infrastructure but to take out the enemy, no matter who that happens to be. Only air assets will be targeted. Stopping the resupply of the enemy will be job one. Unfortunately, this will be a test of a different type of warfare.

I sincerely hope that Congress blocks this. National sovereignty means national sovereignty. Iran can be attacked at any time so I don’t see how this fits into the current equation.

God have mercy,
Ed
 
Team Obama is going to War regardless of what the American People say. The Constitutional Process has officially been compromised: youtube.com/watch?v=nEjFLLlDFco

Now it is time for a few good men in the Military Brass to step up to the plate and defend the Constitution from this blatant Domestic Threat.
 
Civilians always get killed in the process and some targets will not be wearing standard uniforms. The goal is not to destroy infrastructure but to take out the enemy, no matter who that happens to be. Only air assets will be targeted. Stopping the resupply of the enemy will be job one. Unfortunately, this will be a test of a different type of warfare.

I sincerely hope that Congress blocks this. National sovereignty means national sovereignty. Iran can be attacked at any time so I don’t see how this fits into the current equation.

God have mercy,
Ed
Many civilians were killed in Syria. So the USA has the bright idea that it can go in and bomb the country, resulting in more civilians being killed and this is supposed to solve the problem? Or will it just create instability and retaliation and more deaths?
Why are American politicians against solving these types of problems by negotiated settlement?
 
It will also be interesting to see God Almighty’s reaction. I’m assuming that this will be an unjust war from our side, based on statements from Eastern Catholic Patriarchs, and Catholic monastic communities located in Syria.

Of course, it’s easy to think that nothing can hurt us, because we are the biggest and baddest boys on the block, because we have the most advanced weapons, and we can just fry anyone from a safe distance, lobbing cruise missiles into their yards while we are sipping coffee on our patios, and playing golf… That’s what the Babylonians thought, too, the very night before God destroyed their city, and their empire.

God have mercy on us! :signofcross:
My fears exactly. 😦

…Have mercy on us and on the whole world. :signofcross:
 
I would not vote for it. I would not vote for anything but no military action in Syria whatsoever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top