Syrian rebels behead Christian

  • Thread starter Thread starter latin_rite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sadly, what I see happening in Syria if Assad is overthrown, is alot of statements and lip service from the terrorists, that the new government recognizes and tolerates all religions. The new regime will get a big thumbs up from the US and the rest of the West, AND then we’ll begin to gradually hear the stories from news sources like the American Free Press, RT, and Catholic news agencies, that Christians, Alawites, and Shia in Syria now live in constant fear of being murdered by radical Islamicists.I pray that does not happen, and for that reason I pray for the total defeat of the Free Syrian Army… even if that puts me at odds with the US State Department.
 
The Islamic “rebels” started attacking the Assad government without any provocation. And they later justified it by the fact that he fought back. But what government wouldn’t fight back against a violent takeover attempt?
Without any provocation? Really? How about that 13 yr old boy whose badly mutilated and tortured body was released to his parents by the authorities in the days when people were simply marching in the streets? Oh, I forget, we can’t verify the story because Assad won’t let the press in.

Poor emperor-without-any-clothes, why didn’t someone suggest early on that he fling the doors of his country OPEN so that the world’s press could come see what bad guys the rebels were? Now I’m supposed to pity him because the “bad guys” are winning? Why should I? Some of them likely learned from him (who learned from his father) how to brutally repress people who are not on your side. How does anyone grow up to shell children in their homes and then selectively complain of ‘atrocities’? The targeting of innocents is the definition of atrocity.

The truth is not that hard to see: people subjected to atrocities rose up to fight and some of them (no evidence to show that it’s all of them) either turned into monsters or turned to monsters for help. Violence breeds violence, inhumanity breeds inhumanity and Assad is reaping the harvest he planted. Not that it helps Syria of course, but just some perspective.
 
When were they peacefully protesting. And what exactly were they protesting? It doesn’t matter because beheading a Christian completely destroys whatever facade of “peaceful protest” the mainstream media has given these savage Islamic “rebels”.
Oh, so that’s what makes Assad the good guy? His victims (of torture, shelling, and potentially even of chemical warfare) are not Christians?
 
Without any provocation? Really? How about that 13 yr old boy whose badly mutilated and tortured body was released to his parents by the authorities in the days when people were simply marching in the streets?
Source?

If by “people simply marching in the streets” you are referring to Daraa, nothing could be further from the truth. The “protests” in Daraa on March 17-18, 2011, were not spontaneous and were not peaceful. The initial reporting (like this report: israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/143026#.UOMhB28818E) suggest that many of the demonstrators were not demonstrators but rather terrorists involved in premeditated acts of murder and arson. The initial reporting also suggests that the police were outmatched at first and suffered a higher body count than the terrorists (7 police dead versus 4 terrorists)

A few days after the Daraa violence, on March 29, 2011 tens of thousands of Syrians gathered for a pro-government rally in Damascus. This rally was reported by Reuters (reuters.com/article/2011/03/29/us-syria-idUSTRE72N2MC20110329) but barely mentioned in the American Press. Instead, the American Media displayed the images and video of several pro-government events to convince international public opinion that there was a popular uprising against Assad.

There never was a popular uprising against Assad. It is a result of either gross negligence or disinformation on the part of the “Mainstream Media” (the same Media that has selectively downplayed the March for Life year after year). Not only was there never really a rebellion, but the majority of the massacres and atrocities that were originally blamed on Assad (with the cooperation of the American Media) later turned out to be committed by the rebels.
 
Source?

If by “people simply marching in the streets” you are referring to Daraa, nothing could be further from the truth. The “protests” in Daraa on March 17-18, 2011, were not spontaneous and were not peaceful. The initial reporting (like this report: israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/143026#.UOMhB28818E) suggest that many of the demonstrators were not demonstrators but rather terrorists involved in premeditated acts of murder and arson. The initial reporting also suggests that the police were outmatched at first and suffered a higher body count than the terrorists (7 police dead versus 4 terrorists)

A few days after the Daraa violence, on March 29, 2011 tens of thousands of Syrians gathered for a pro-government rally in Damascus. This rally was reported by Reuters (reuters.com/article/2011/03/29/us-syria-idUSTRE72N2MC20110329) but barely mentioned in the American Press. Instead, the American Media displayed the images and video of several pro-government events to convince international public opinion that there was a popular uprising against Assad.

There never was a popular uprising against Assad. It is a result of either gross negligence or disinformation on the part of the “Mainstream Media” (the same Media that has selectively downplayed the March for Life year after year). Not only was there never really a rebellion, but the majority of the massacres and atrocities that were originally blamed on Assad (with the cooperation of the American Media) later turned out to be committed by the rebels.
To my understanding, people - including children - were marching against the government in Syria for at least a year or so before the situation descended into civil war. So, unless that ***child *** was some dangerous terrorist who could not be subdued by any method other than mutilating his private parts…

Whether Assad directed the child’s jailers to do that, or whether he remained silent while other people did it (and I don’t remember him publicly addressing that particular outrage), as the country’s leader that makes him responsible.

You know, there is no God-given right that I know of (other than the institution of the Davidic dynasty in the OT) for a particular regime to rule ANY country. People DO have the right to protest - and sometimes when injustice is great - as history has documented from pre-Revolutionary America to the streets of Soweto, people legitimately can defend themselves by taking up arms if their government refuses to relinquish it’s determination to oppress them.

To my knowledge that’s all the Syrian people are doing. It is a complex situation, but that seems to be the crux of it. It’s a pity that human beings reject equality in favor of domination of one group against the other, but in that reality the circle goes round every now and again and the oppressed become the oppressors. Nothing is happening in Syria that has not been repeated ad nauseum throughout history, simply because people refuse to accept that God did not create them MORE SPECIAL than other groups of people.

We can rail against human nature, but there it is. As a parent I don’t think I could passively accept my babies being shelled and not turn to whoever or whatever represented my option to keep them alive. What is the option for those starving, dying, kids? Just hold hands, close eyes and prepare to die so that the entitled can continue to be entitled? I’m no theologian, but I think the blood of innocent children must cry out to God more loudly than that of adults determined at all costs to safeguard their spots on the totem pole.
 
Oh, so that’s what makes Assad the good guy? His victims (of torture, shelling, and potentially even of chemical warfare) are not Christians?
Assad is a medical doctor and consultant in Opthamology and was living in London with his British born and educated wife before his brother, who was ear-marked to take over after his father’s reign, was killed in a car accident. Hardly, the makings and upbringing of a tyrant and ‘would-be’ mass murderer.

I’ve no doubt he would have preferred to remain in London administrating his (minimally) 15 year hard-earned medical professional expertise to patients, rather that end up in his current ‘no-win’ situation.
 
To my understanding, people - including children - were marching against the government in Syria for at least a year or so before the situation descended into civil war. So, unless that ***child *** was some dangerous terrorist who could not be subdued by any method other than mutilating his private parts…

Whether Assad directed the child’s jailers to do that, or whether he remained silent while other people did it (and I don’t remember him publicly addressing that particular outrage), as the country’s leader that makes him responsible.

You know, there is no God-given right that I know of (other than the institution of the Davidic dynasty in the OT) for a particular regime to rule ANY country. People DO have the right to protest - and sometimes when injustice is great - as history has documented from pre-Revolutionary America to the streets of Soweto, people legitimately can defend themselves by taking up arms if their government refuses to relinquish it’s determination to oppress them.

To my knowledge that’s all the Syrian people are doing. It is a complex situation, but that seems to be the crux of it. It’s a pity that human beings reject equality in favor of domination of one group against the other, but in that reality the circle goes round every now and again and the oppressed become the oppressors. Nothing is happening in Syria that has not been repeated ad nauseum throughout history, simply because people refuse to accept that God did not create them MORE SPECIAL than other groups of people.

We can rail against human nature, but there it is. As a parent I don’t think I could passively accept my babies being shelled and not turn to whoever or whatever represented my option to keep them alive. What is the option for those starving, dying, kids? Just hold hands, close eyes and prepare to die so that the entitled can continue to be entitled? I’m no theologian, but I think the blood of innocent children must cry out to God more loudly than that of adults determined at all costs to safeguard their spots on the totem pole.
The mainstream media portrayed the Islamic “rebels” as peaceful. But obviously with the beheading of a Christian we can now know that, as usual, the mainstream media puts out lies and propaganda to suit their political agenda. The fact that a leader of a country isn’t a Christian or Jew doesn’t give anyone the right to violently overthrow them. And it doesn’t give the Islamic “rebels” a right to behead Christians who stand in their way. As recent history has shown in Iran, Iraq, and Egypt, what you and the rest who support these Islamic “rebels” will find out after the overthrow of Assad is that the new government will have zero tolerance for Christians whereas the perhaps soon to be former relatively secular Islamic government at least tolerated them and offered them some degree of protection.
 
Assad is a medical doctor and consultant in Opthamology and was living in London with his British born and educated wife before his brother, who was ear-marked to take over after his father’s reign, was killed in a car accident. Hardly, the makings and upbringing of a tyrant and ‘would-be’ mass murderer.
Oh, mass murderers have a single profile, do they? Ever heard of a mass-murdering doctor? Why not try responding to the specific criticisms of things that have actually happened in Syria these last couple years?
I’ve no doubt he would have preferred to remain in London administrating his (minimally) 15 year hard-earned medical professional expertise to patients, rather that end up in his current ‘no-win’ situation.
Then why doesn’t he go back to London to practice? He obviously is not up to the job requirements for his present post. 🤷
 
The mainstream media portrayed the Islamic “rebels” as peaceful. But obviously with the beheading of a Christian we can now know that, as usual, the mainstream media puts out lies and propaganda to suit their political agenda. The fact that a leader of a country isn’t a Christian or Jew doesn’t give anyone the right to violently overthrow them. And it doesn’t give the Islamic “rebels” a right to behead Christians who stand in their way. As recent history has shown in Iran, Iraq, and Egypt, what you and the rest who support these Islamic “rebels” will find out after the overthrow of Assad is that the new government will have zero tolerance for Christians whereas the perhaps soon to be former relatively secular Islamic government at least tolerated them and offered them some degree of protection.
I don’t care about the mainstream media and what they want or don’t want. I care that children have been tortured and killed and nobody seems to care unless they’re Christian. Christians have no greater right to protection than anyone else. As a Christian I would puke to think my child was safe in bed because someone else’s child was tortured.

Sorry, the beheading of a Christian is not the be-all and end-all of the conversation - any death in this conflict in one too many, because to my knowledge, the same Creator breathed life into each of the people from whom it is being brutally snatched. A conversation which could have gone differently if Assad had tried negotiation and compromise instead of leading the way with inhumane repression tactics. His big mistake? He thought it would work this time like it worked in the past. In my kid’s lingo: "epic fail".
 
I don’t care about the mainstream media and what they want or don’t want. I care that children have been tortured and killed and nobody seems to care unless they’re Christian. Christians have no greater right to protection than anyone else. As a Christian I would puke to think my child was safe in bed because someone else’s child was tortured.

Sorry, the beheading of a Christian is not the be-all and end-all of the conversation - any death in this conflict in one too many, because to my knowledge, the same Creator breathed life into each of the people from whom it is being brutally snatched. A conversation which could have gone differently if Assad had tried negotiation and compromise instead of leading the way with inhumane repression tactics. His big mistake? He thought it would work this time like it worked in the past. In my kid’s lingo: "epic fail".
[SIGN]Good Post[/SIGN]
 
I don’t care about the mainstream media and what they want or don’t want. I care that children have been tortured and killed and nobody seems to care unless they’re Christian. Christians have no greater right to protection than anyone else. As a Christian I would puke to think my child was safe in bed because someone else’s child was tortured.

Sorry, the beheading of a Christian is not the be-all and end-all of the conversation - any death in this conflict in one too many, because to my knowledge, the same Creator breathed life into each of the people from whom it is being brutally snatched. A conversation which could have gone differently if Assad had tried negotiation and compromise instead of leading the way with inhumane repression tactics. His big mistake? He thought it would work this time like it worked in the past. In my kid’s lingo: "epic fail".
Who tortured and killed the child you are talking about?

Without any direct evidence of who was responsible for that torture, one must make an educated guess.

Given the modus operandi of “the rebels” during this conflict, I would put my money on “the rebels”.

These “rebels” were behind the massacres that were originally blamed on Assad. These “rebels” have committed war crimes against the Syrian POWs. These “rebels” do not wear uniforms. They are terrorists. They even boast of their terrorism and post videos on Youtube of their demonic cruelty. They currently hold two Russians, an Italian, and a Ukrainian hostage. They have threatened to murder the female Ukrainian hostage numerous times. These “rebels” are not really rebels and not really Syrian. They are Islamic extremist terrorists. They have come from around the Middle East to depose the last secular, stable ruler in the Middle East. Before they were in Syria they were in Libya taking down Gaddafi. They go where their Western masters beckon them. They consist of al-Qaeda who happen to be our sworn enemy in time of war. The U.S. State Department knows this yet Obama has now officially backed these “rebels.” In a normal universe, Congress would be holding impeachment hearings and conducting a criminal investigation to find out why we have officially supported some of the most violent, dangerous men on the planet, some of them our sworn enemies in time of war.
 
Who tortured and killed the child you are talking about?
According to the (unverified) video I saw, it was the Syrian authorities who returned the child’s mangled body to his parents. The strategy at that time was reportedly to scare people into submission.

Of course there is no verification of the incident, because Assad the Great quivers in fear of any press that is not his personal mouth organ.
Without any direct evidence of who was responsible for that torture, one must make an educated guess.
My educated guess is quite opposite of yours.
Given the modus operandi of “the rebels” during this conflict, I would put my money on “the rebels”.
This happened long, long before the armed conflict began. At that time, not even Assad was claiming that the rebels were killing anyone. So who does that leave? Take an educated guess again.

I remember crying after watching the video clip and coming to the firm conclusion that Assad would be soundly defeated. At that time, no one in the MSM seemed to think so. But I know the One who made that child - and I know there is only so much that He tolerates.
These “rebels” were behind the massacres that were originally blamed on Assad. These “rebels” have committed war crimes against the Syrian POWs. These “rebels” do not wear uniforms. They are terrorists. They even boast of their terrorism and post videos on Youtube of their demonic cruelty. They currently hold two Russians, an Italian, and a Ukrainian hostage. They have threatened to murder the female Ukrainian hostage numerous times. These “rebels” are not really rebels and not really Syrian. They are Islamic extremist terrorists. They have come from around the Middle East to depose the last secular, stable ruler in the Middle East. Before they were in Syria they were in Libya taking down Gaddafi. They go where their Western masters beckon them. They consist of al-Qaeda who happen to be our sworn enemy in time of war. The U.S. State Department knows this yet Obama has now officially backed these “rebels.” In a normal universe, Congress would be holding impeachment hearings and conducting a criminal investigation to find out why we have officially supported some of the most violent, dangerous men on the planet, some of them our sworn enemies in time of war.
Dangerous violent men being attacked by dangerous violent men makes one side the good side? How so? In a “normal universe”, the so-called men who prove their strength against harmless kids would be thrown into the deepest, darkest prison cells.

And let’s not forget the “peace” Assad sowed among neighboring nations (some in our universe would call THAT terrorism) in “better” times. Yes, we know men (real or fake) by the fruit they produce.
 
According to the (unverified) video I saw, it was the Syrian authorities who returned the child’s mangled body to his parents. The strategy at that time was reportedly to scare people into submission.

This happened long, long before the armed conflict began. At that time, not even Assad was claiming that the rebels were killing anyone. So who does that leave? Take an educated guess again.

I remember crying after watching the video clip and coming to the firm conclusion that Assad would be soundly defeated. At that time, no one in the MSM seemed to think so. But I know the One who made that child - and I know there is only so much that He tolerates.
What video of torture are you talking about? There are many videos floating around the internet claiming to depict the Syrian security forces torturing teenagers and children. Not one of these videos has been verified as accurate. In fact, the one video I have seen on Youtube purporting to show a stripped teenager being humilitated and beaten comes from Youtube user “UgaritNews”, one of the “Syrian Rebels” channels. Give me a break! These are the same “Syrian rebels” that were blaming massacres that they had staged on Assad, like at Houla. The Western Media (CNN, NBC, ABC, CBS, FOX, etc.) simply rejurgitated and relayed the rebel propaganda on Houla without ever doing their own investigation. Later, after the leading German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ) did an independent investigation into Houla, we find out that it was the “rebels” who were behind Houla all along.

The only videos that have in fact been verified actually show the “rebels” committing war crimes against uniformed Syrian Army POWs.
 
What video of torture are you talking about? There are many videos floating around the internet claiming to depict the Syrian security forces torturing teenagers and children. Not one of these videos has been verified as accurate. In fact, the one video I have seen on Youtube purporting to show a stripped teenager being humilitated and beaten comes from Youtube user “UgaritNews”, one of the “Syrian Rebels” channels. Give me a break! These are the same “Syrian rebels” that were blaming massacres that they had staged on Assad, like at Houla. The Western Media (CNN, NBC, ABC, CBS, FOX, etc.) simply rejurgitated and relayed the rebel propaganda on Houla without ever doing their own investigation. Later, after the leading German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ) did an independent investigation into Houla, we find out that it was the “rebels” who were behind Houla all along.

The only videos that have in fact been verified actually show the “rebels” committing war crimes against uniformed Syrian Army POWs.
Maybe I didn’t make it clear enough, but I can try again.

This is Al Jazeera’s version of the boy’s story.

This is SANA’s version, as per the Atlantic Wire. (my apologies for not being able to provide a direct link but I guess SANA is down or blacked out or something).

Either way, it is clear the government was not claiming the boy was not killed by their forces. Now that we’ve cleared up the who of this story, I figure we can make educated guesses about the what and how of the incident.

I guess every country has it’s own way of dealing with protesting kids armed with ‘sharp’ objects: whether it be with school suspension, kiddie boot camp, juvenile hall, bullets or torture…
 
Mother Agnes Mariam of the Cross apparently is keeping busy.

fanoos.com/society/mother_agnes_mariam_of_the_cross.html
Interesting…
Mother Agnes Mariam of the Cross has received a lot of support by the Syrian people, especially the Arab nationalists who still believe in one united strong Arab “umma” where all the different ethnic and religious elements can live together in one beautiful harmony.
What’s kept said ‘nationalists’ from realizing this “beautiful harmony” they desire? Seems to me like Syria had many years of stability before the last few years.
 
Maybe I didn’t make it clear enough, but I can try again.

This is Al Jazeera’s version of the boy’s story.

This is SANA’s version, as per the Atlantic Wire. (my apologies for not being able to provide a direct link but I guess SANA is down or blacked out or something).

Either way, it is clear the government was not claiming the boy was not killed by their forces. Now that we’ve cleared up the who of this story, I figure we can make educated guesses about the what and how of the incident.

I guess every country has it’s own way of dealing with protesting kids armed with ‘sharp’ objects: whether it be with school suspension, kiddie boot camp, juvenile hall, bullets or torture…
Okay, now we are on the same page.

You are referring to the death of Hamza Ali Al-Khateeb. You link to articles that do nothing more than allege without evidence that he was tortured by the Syrian authorities. The Syrian authorities dispute that allegation:

In response to Al Jazeera’s story, the chief of Syria’s medical examiners association, Dr. Akram El-Shaar, denied that Hamza was tortured. El-Shaar said that he supervised the autopsy in Damascus and that the boy did not have any sign of torture. He also claimed that Hamza had been shot in the Daraa riot and that all signs of disfigurement were due to decay. (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Hamza_Ali_Al-Khateeb#Alleged_torture)

You will notice similar pattern with this Hamza Ali Al-Khateeb story - a pattern that fits the modus operandi of the rebel propaganda: they take advantage of (or in some instances stage) the casualties of war and then accuse the Syrian authorities of committing the very thing that they are doing. Western media takes the bait and fails to take the time to take an independent look at the evidence. Upon further review, these “rebel” propaganda stories usually fall apart by themselves.
 
Okay, now we are on the same page.

You are referring to the death of Hamza Ali Al-Khateeb. You link to articles that do nothing more than allege without evidence that he was tortured by the Syrian authorities. The Syrian authorities dispute that allegation:

In response to Al Jazeera’s story, the chief of Syria’s medical examiners association, Dr. Akram El-Shaar, denied that Hamza was tortured. El-Shaar said that he supervised the autopsy in Damascus and that the boy did not have any sign of torture. He also claimed that Hamza had been shot in the Daraa riot and that all signs of disfigurement were due to decay. (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Hamza_Ali_Al-Khateeb#Alleged_torture)

You will notice similar pattern with this Hamza Ali Al-Khateeb story - a pattern that fits the modus operandi of the rebel propaganda: they take advantage of (or in some instances stage) the casualties of war and then accuse the Syrian authorities of committing the very thing that they are doing. Western media takes the bait and fails to take the time to take an independent look at the evidence. Upon further review, these “rebel” propaganda stories usually fall apart by themselves.
I doubt that we are on the same page:
  1. No government is going to admit to torturing a child even if many are yellow-bellied enough to do it - so unless that autopsy was done by an impartial third party, it amounts to no more than a hill of beans.
  2. The desire to clamp down protest by instilling fear in people is a well-known tactic, historically in Syria. It fits the modus operandi of Assad’s house to a T.
  3. I don’t know what your experience has been in that regard, but in civilized nations it’s generally not accepted that children be shot for protesting with ‘sharp weapons’ - unless of course their army is full of wimps and grossly lacking in gonadal fortitude…
No, weirdly enough, I believe that story now more than the first time I saw it, because Assad has lived up to that reputation. Now I guess, I’ll be told that it wasn’t him shelling innocent civilians while refusing initial efforts to defuse the crisis, it was the oh, so well armed and trained rebels…

Well you know what? If a leader could allow rebels to take over his country and outgun/outfight his forces, neither he nor his army are worth their salt. I guess their only strength can be shown when they mow down children…
 
I doubt that we are on the same page:
  1. No government is going to admit to torturing a child even if many are yellow-bellied enough to do it - so unless that autopsy was done by an impartial third party, it amounts to no more than a hill of beans.
  2. The desire to clamp down protest by instilling fear in people is a well-known tactic, historically in Syria. It fits the modus operandi of Assad’s house to a T.
  3. I don’t know what your experience has been in that regard, but in civilized nations it’s generally not accepted that children be shot for protesting with ‘sharp weapons’ - unless of course their army is full of wimps and grossly lacking in gonadal fortitude…
No, weirdly enough, I believe that story now more than the first time I saw it, because Assad has lived up to that reputation. Now I guess, I’ll be told that it wasn’t him shelling innocent civilians while refusing initial efforts to defuse the crisis, it was the oh, so well armed and trained rebels…

Well you know what? If a leader could allow rebels to take over his country and outgun/outfight his forces, neither he nor his army are worth their salt. I guess their only strength can be shown when they mow down children…
I would hazard a guess that any country in the world could be taken over by ‘rebels’, which are well supported, both monetary and weapon wise, by other ‘rich’ and influential countries/nations.

timesofisrael.com/gulf-countries-to-financially-aid-syrian-rebels/

*ISTANBUL (AP) — Participants at a conference on Syria say Saudi Arabia and other Gulf countries are creating a multimillion-dollar fund to pay salaries to members of the rebel Free Syrian Army and soldiers who defect from the regime and join opposition ranks.
reuters.com/article/2012/08/01/us-usa-syria-obama-order-idUSBRE8701OK20120801

*(Reuters) - President Barack Obama has signed a secret order authorizing U.S. support for rebels seeking to depose Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and his government, U.S. sources familiar with the matter said.

Obama’s order, approved earlier this year and known as an intelligence “finding,” broadly permits the CIA and other U.S. agencies to provide support that could help the rebels oust Assad.*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top