Taliban "revolving door"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why are we still in Afghanistan? We aren’t fighting terrorists we are creating more terrorists. At first the Afghans were happy we freed them from the Taliban and their medieval barbarianism, but now they are hating us. The more of our missiles that hit Afghan villages the more terrorists we create. And what will we get from staying there for another 10 years? NOTHING BUT DEBT
 
Having just returned from a year long mobilization to Afghanistan I will tell you the any characterization of the Taliban as brave guerilla fighters is pure nonsense. The Taliban regularly use 7 year olds to plant IEDs, threaten local villagers with death or dismemberment if they dare cooperate with ISAF or the Afghan governement. In addition, they are in league with Narco Terrorist and are the main supplier of Opium to Europe.

Also, the brave guerilla fighters you speak of were the Muhajaden (pardon the misspelling). Yes these men are still around and might be classified as war lords but are not generally part of the Taliban movement, which began in the Mid '90s in Kandahar.
 
Maybe you should reread his post. He was explaining the situation in Afgahnistan - not “justifying” the reason the US is there.
 
Why are we still in Afghanistan? We aren’t fighting terrorists we are creating more terrorists. At first the Afghans were happy we freed them from the Taliban and their medieval barbarianism, but now they are hating us. The more of our missiles that hit Afghan villages the more terrorists we create. And what will we get from staying there for another 10 years? NOTHING BUT DEBT
Yes, but some will profit VERY nicely from the erosion of our country…
 
That’s what this guy :rolleyes: is for!

A lot can change in 25 years. Friends become enemies, enemies become friends.
 
We ought not to forget that, Pres. Bush paid the Taliban millions to help suppress opium farming - which they did - and he offered to leave them alone if they helped get Osama Bin Laden - which they didn’t.
 
The Muslim idea of takiya would explain this. In the Cold War fight against the encroachment of the left in the Third World, the Soviets and the PLO and the like, those involved came up with the idea that fostering traditional Muslim groups would be an effective counter weight to the success of these third world leftist groups. The assumption was that religions were all basically alike, and that traditional Muslim groups would bring the same sort of values to their societies and Christians and Jews bring to theirs.

Instead all that was provided to these groups were eventually turned against the West. Friendship with any Muslim group is only pretense on behalf of these Muslim groups, until the time comes when your back is turned and it makes a good target for their knife.

This if course is not to say that the fight against the evil empire that was the Soviet Union was not a necessary one. It is just that the lingering belief that Islam is a religion of peace is a hopelessly naive one that we ought to divest ourselves of.

Any lesson learned here would make it wise to consider just who the rebels in Libya really are now too.
 
Why are we still in Afghanistan? We aren’t fighting terrorists we are creating more terrorists. At first the Afghans were happy we freed them from the Taliban and their medieval barbarianism, but now they are hating us. The more of our missiles that hit Afghan villages the more terrorists we create. And what will we get from staying there for another 10 years? NOTHING BUT DEBT
That’s right.
These two wars of Obama, Libya and Afghanistan, bring nothing but misery and death to innocent people in the world today.
 
We ought not to forget that, Pres. Bush paid the Taliban millions to help suppress opium farming - which they did - and he offered to leave them alone if they helped get Osama Bin Laden - which they didn’t.
Which was of course, why the heroin trade boomed shortly after the invasion of Afghanistan, because the Taliban was no longer suppressing it. Another side-effect of the war I guess; not to say that suppressing the heroin trade justifies everything the Taliban has done.
(name removed by moderator):
Terrorists become guerilllas, guerillas become terrorists. Freedom fighters become fanatics, fanatics become freedom fighters…
I think Jon Stewart offered the following definition of Fascism: ‘that thing other people do that I disagree with… not communism, the other thing.’ The same might be said about terrorism. There are no doubt horribly evil people who we call terrorists (as with Fascists) but while we throw the word around, we run into problems when we try to define it. What exactly makes a terrorist? Targeting civilians? But then what about the heroic RAF and “Bomber” Harris and his firebombing, or the the USAF in Japan? It’s a hard word to define.

Ugh, it’s 3AM and I’d better get back to my German essay due tomorrow.
 
But then what about the heroic RAF and “Bomber” Harris and his firebombing, or the the USAF in Japan? It’s a hard word to define.
What the RAF did, especially during the Battle of Britain when England essentially stood alone, is nothing short of heroic. Those men would fly mission after mission and the ground crews worked non-stop to keep planes flying even in the face of bombardment and parts shortages.

“Bomber” Harris on the other hand developed a bombing strategy that did little to shorten the war and terrorized and killed many German citizens. His theory was that if you kill the workers the plants won’t be able to function and that the people will become so demoralized they will demand an end to the war and possibly get rid of Hitler on their own. All he had to do was look at the experiences of the British people to know that scenario wasn’t likely. The British people absorbed nightime raids from the Luftwaffe and their morale didn’t waver – why he thought it would work on the Germans is beyond me.

He also targeted civilian areas because they were soft targets. The Luftwaffe had air superiority but they also had to rationalize their forces and try to protect certain sectors as best as possible. That meant that Berlin and factories and military installations received the most protection. Othere areas were still defended but not nearly as heavily. Harris wanted to protect his air crews as much as possible, which is admirable, but he ignored industrial targets in favor of civilian housing.

It was up to the USAAF to tackle the industrial areas and at night also (the Americans had better radar and were experimenting successfully with radar systems in planes at that point).

I believe the war could’ve been shortened and the German ability to make war curtailed even further if industrial targets were hammered both night and day by the RAF and USAAF.

ChadS
 
Everyone’s hindsight is 20/20. Can I play?

If not for European Colonialism the (name your country) would be…🤷
 
Terrorism defines a method of political-motivated violence, who most often operate without explicit state support. Any support that they get from a state is usually covert.

Certainly states themselves have used methods that are specifically designed to terrorize populations. Here though the state itself defines the enemy more than the method.

The confusion lies in using the term to define the enemy then.
The so-called War on Terror was never against the IRA or the Tamil Tigers. It was never against generic terror per se. It is a war against an Islamist supremacism that typically operates below the level of functioning states, often with the covert support of rogue and dysfunctional states that prefer to ‘order the hits’ rather than perform them, but never to the extent that it would be easy to tie the state to the specific acts of violence.

States may be held accountable for their action in the community of nations. States are bound by treaties and codes of conduct. And these codes of conduct change over time, as states collectively define new ways to make the conduct of war more humane.

Individual terror cells are not bound by such constraints. That is why they have been particularly useful to states such as Iran especially, who use these cells to cary out their actions, but in such a way that they do not appear to be responsible for them.

From the beginning, western countries have never really defined their enemy with any clarity. This has made the enemy no less real, but it has made it very difficult to fight that war with any clarity.

It is not a war on terror, really. This is only the politically correct term for the war against Islamist supremacists. To the extent that western democracies thought they had more in common with these groups than they did with leftist communism, western democracies were sadly mistaken. It is the leftists and the Islamists that have proven to be birds of a feather.
 
Anybody who wants to understand Afghanistan had better read more than just Time Magazine and USA Today! (or ANY political pundits, for that matter).

The book “The Kite Runner” is a jaw dropping portrait of Afghanistan and what the Soviet invasion and subsequent rise of the Taliban did to that country. Another resource is “Three Cups of Tea” by Greg Mortensen (the guy that DESERVED to win the Nobel Peace prize the year Obama usurped it). It is simply untrue to paint the bulk of the people there as simply Taliban breeders. Most of them detest the Taliban as much as we do.

The tragedy of this war is that a foreign occupation army can’t destroy the Taliban. I’m not sure what CAN, but I sure wish somebody would spend some time figuring out how every third world country on earth is loaded with automatic weapons. Ever price one of these things or the AMMO? How do people with no running water, no appliances and no economic base BUY these things? Something is very fishy.
 
Taliban can be defeated. Don’t confuse restained violence with no-quarter war. The idea is to preserve life not completely destroy it.

The area of concern is extremists and today the MB is very much a force in the manipulation of extreme islamic groups. It has been since 1928. A leopard doesn’t change its spots.

There are aspects with Obama which concern me also. Iraq concerns me more than anywhere else. And I would bet it concerns Israel also.

I believe Obama has crossed into a dangerous situation now which aligns him with radical Islam and the MB. The moves Obama has made in all his War choices I find questionable.

Not the idea that we need to fight evil on its own turf, he is right in this sense. But where he stratigically chose’s to place the greastest effort I see as, well not in the best interest of the US, Christ, or the Free-World.

Everyone looks back on Afghanistan and the success with Russia. Russia would have destroyed them had we not backed Afghanistan. Make no mistake about this.

As quick as Iraq fell, everyone of the middle eastern states would fall. We are not trying to wage a full blown war. Goverment defense in the US is ran at mininum today. Half its facilitys are warehouse’s at the moment. Placed on reserve in case of real War.

The idea it promote the civil Islamic way of life. Not the extreme which would like world domination and world wide Sharia Law. That equates to World Slavery. Thats about the same as Israel living in Egypt before the Exodus.

Its not going to happen. Don’t give Islam to much credit in its extremist sick thinking. None of the World Powers are Islamic. How do you suppose the Far East feels about world Islamic rule?

Taliban is a extreme World Rule based thinking but not the only one. There’s a conscious effort to promote this by much of Islam, and its not a unknown like many would believe in the civil world.

I don’t know that Obama is Islamic, nor is it my concern. MY concern is He is the President today. I just don’t like his overall War plan of the US at the moment.
 
is simply untrue to paint the bulk of the people there as simply Taliban breeders. Most of them detest the Taliban as much as we do.
Then these bulk of people need to make their majority heard.

IOW, they need to rid themselves of the Taliban.
 
Taliban can be defeated. Don’t confuse restrained violence with no-quarter war. The idea is to preserve life not completely destroy it.
Indeed. Afghanistan could be easily subdued by the military in a heartbeat, if subduing the country was the objective.
The area of concern is extremists and today the MB is very much a force in the manipulation of extreme Islamic groups. It has been since 1928. A leopard doesn’t change its spots.
This is a failing of the Obama administration and the left in general not to understand and acknowledge this basic point. There is a credible intellectual base behind the rise of Talibin-esque movements across the Islamic world.
There are aspects with Obama which concern me also. Iraq concerns me more than anywhere else. And I would bet it concerns Israel also.
Iraq can go either way right now.
I believe Obama has crossed into a dangerous situation now which aligns him with radical Islam and the MB. The moves Obama has made in all his War choices I find questionable.
He is a victim of his education. There is nothing in the curriculum if a western university that prepares our leaders to be able to adequately deal with radical Islam and the MB.
Not the idea that we need to fight evil on its own turf, he is right in this sense. But where he strategically chooses to place the greatest effort I see as, well not in the best interest of the US, Christ, or the Free-World. Everyone looks back on Afghanistan and the success with Russia. Russia would have destroyed them had we not backed Afghanistan. Make no mistake about this.
It would seem to me that America fought the Afghanistan War against the Soviets by taking a book out of the way that the Soviets and the Chinese fought the North Vietnamese war.
It was an effective strategy.
As quick as Iraq fell, every one of the middle eastern states would fall. We are not trying to wage a full blown war. Government defense in the US is ran at minimum today. Half its facilities are warehouse’s at the moment. Placed on reserve in case of real War.
The idea it promote the civil Islamic way of life. Not the extreme which would like world domination and world wide Sharia Law. That equates to World Slavery. That’s about the same as Israel living in Egypt before the Exodus.
The actual campaigns can be over almost before they begin. It is enabling a civil Islamic form of government that is treacherous, thankless, and difficult, given the baggage that all countries of the House of Islam carry with them.
Its not going to happen. Don’t give Islam to much credit in its extremist sick thinking. None of the World Powers are Islamic. How do you suppose the Far East feels about world Islamic rule?
Basically, as it stand now, the best that an Islamist country can hope to become is a parasite. There is nothing of substance within the ideology. It is at most a reactionary pipe dream of an Islam that would only be a force for backwardness in the modern world.
Taliban is a extreme World Rule based thinking but not the only one. There’s a conscious effort to promote this by much of Islam, and its not a unknown like many would believe in the civil world.
I don’t know that Obama is Islamic, nor is it my concern. MY concern is He is the President today. I just don’t like his overall War plan of the US at the moment.
It would seem that so much of western policy in general after 9/11 is based on illusions too. There was Bush’s illusion that Islam was a religion of peace, and that the average Muslim would rise up and take a strong stand against political Islamification, if give the chance. Now their is the Obaman illusion that there are pro-democracy, pro-freedom movements at the heart of this Arab spring.

Before freedom will ever take root in the ME, it must first be believed in. There is nothing in the leftist press of the Arab world, nor is the Islamist manifestos, nor in the western universities that are attended by so many Arab students, that fosters a belief in the freedoms that serve as the foundations of any civil society.

That is a big problem.
 
Then these bulk of people need to make their majority heard.

IOW, they need to rid themselves of the Taliban.
Read the books. Just how is a rural village that needs to save up for months just to buy a new goat going to throw out the Taliban when they show up in their Toyota pickup trucks with their mounted machine guns and guys with AK-47s? Throw rocks at them until they leave? Give them a frowny face?

Regular folks in virtually any country can’t afford that hardware. There’s more going on here than is generally admitted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top