Talking Darfur to Death

  • Thread starter Thread starter GregoryPalamas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

GregoryPalamas

Guest
What should a secular nations like those in North America and Europe do in the face of this when they have little or no spiritual authority? At least 2.5 million people, mostly Christians, have been butchered in Sudan over the last 25 years. We do nothing. Is there anything that can be done?

nytimes.com/2007/03/31/opinion/31sat1.html?th&emc=th

CDL
 
For a period of time some Canadians…Protestant? Catholic? were buying back the women and children that were taken in slavery. It was very productive. The government got money and whenever they wishedt they’d just kidnap the people again.

Short of military action what can we do? Should we try to recruit more missionaries?

CDL
 
What should a secular nations like those in North America and Europe do in the face of this when they have little or no spiritual authority?
This is the first post I have ever seen on these boards that calls the United States a ‘secular’ nation. So are we suddenly not a ‘Christian nation’ any more? Are we only ‘Christian’ as long as we’re not talking about our gigantic screwups? Yeah, sure, that’s all the secularists’ fault… wow, thanks.

No country has or even should have such a thing as spiritual authority. Governments are not in the business of saving souls. No spiritual authority is needed to condemn what’s going on in Darfur.
 
Greg, the 53 members of the African Union certainly have the geographical placement and “should” have an interest in security of the region.

One would have hoped neighboring Egypt had a conscience and would take the lead - but apparently they have ther have own interests to care about. It doesn’t include caring about people being slaughtered.
ORLANDO, Fla., Feb. 17 – President Bush on Friday called for doubling the number of international troops in the war-ravaged Darfur region of Sudan and a bigger role for NATO in the peacekeeping effort.

Bush has concluded that peace talks will not halt the violence that has left tens of thousands dead and more than 2 million homeless in Darfur and that a more muscular military response is required, administration officials said​

The change is essentially an acknowledgment that the previous policy did not stop the killings, which Bush had described as genocide. He had resisted calls for a bigger U.S. role and relied on the African Union to take the lead, with increased NATO assistance. U.S. officials had also pressed Sudan to rein in the militias.
 
This is the first post I have ever seen on these boards that calls the United States a ‘secular’ nation. So are we suddenly not a ‘Christian nation’ any more? Are we only ‘Christian’ as long as we’re not talking about our gigantic screwups? Yeah, sure, that’s all the secularists’ fault… wow, thanks.

No country has or even should have such a thing as spiritual authority. Governments are not in the business of saving souls. No spiritual authority is needed to condemn what’s going on in Darfur.
I gather you aren’t a student of history.

CDL
 
China and a shrinking bloc of nonaligned nations have repeatedly put the sovereign right of Sudan’s rulers to annihilate minorities ahead of the international community’s legal responsibility to prevent genocide and protect human rights.
Representatives of 118 developing nations meeting in Havana ended their summit with declarations supporting Iran and Sudan, condemning Israel, and criticizing some American policies.
cnsnews.com/ViewForeignBureaus.asp?Page=/ForeignBureaus/archive/200609/INT20060918a.html

I blame what’s going on in Darfur on the non-aligned nations. They probably have more power to do influence Sudan than we do, but they don’t seem to think that genocide is as bad as the actions of the USA and Israel.
 
“Non aligned” and “Havana” don’t seem to go together.

CDL
 
I gather you aren’t a student of history.

CDL
I am, in fact. That doesn’t mean I think the Holy Roman Empire or any other government in the course of history was actually interested in the spiritual wellbeing of its citizens. Those that have claimed to be interested in such have always had an obvious stake in something completely different.
 
I am, in fact. That doesn’t mean I think the Holy Roman Empire or any other government in the course of history was actually interested in the spiritual wellbeing of its citizens. Those that have claimed to be interested in such have always had an obvious stake in something completely different.
I’m not following. Please elaborate. I think you don’t know much about the Middle Ages, or for that matter much about pagan Rome or you are defining words differently than I’m used to.

CDL
 
I’m not following. Please elaborate. I think you don’t know much about the Middle Ages, or for that matter much about pagan Rome or you are defining words differently than I’m used to.

CDL
I am saying that no country currently has total ‘spiritual authority’ and that none should have such a thing. Sure, some governments made pretensions to it in the Middle Ages and before (and some even now are trying), but no successful government has ever had as its principal concern the spiritual health of its citizens. It’s not what they’re established to do. An occasional governor may have had it as a personal concern, like Justin II, whose reign gave rise to the term ‘enlightened despot’, but that’s personal and not governmental. Clear enough?
 
I am saying that no country currently has total ‘spiritual authority’ and that none should have such a thing. Sure, some governments made pretensions to it in the Middle Ages and before (and some even now are trying), but no successful government has ever had as its principal concern the spiritual health of its citizens. It’s not what they’re established to do. An occasional governor may have had it as a personal concern, like Justin II, whose reign gave rise to the term ‘enlightened despot’, but that’s personal and not governmental. Clear enough?
Clear, but I believe you are mistaken.

Now, back to the point of the thread. I would suggest that it is problematic that the Church could support anything any secular state chose to do about this horrible situation. With St. Paul’s position which had been followed by the Church and still is in the East that the temporal and the spiritual authorities are both subject to God and that all authority comes from God the Church did have much to say and they said it with much effectiveness. Since the Enlightenment the Church has been effectively neutralized except for moral suasion and the secular state is not open to any authority.

So, what can the Church do? I don’t believe that the Church has been any more effective in areas such as this than the state. In part both are ineffective because they do not recognize a common authority over them. God’s hosts and God Himself were not so neutered as they are now. Alas, there seems nothing to do.

CDL
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top