Task force calls for new NSA limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
The advisory board tasked with reviewing National Security Agency policies pushed Wednesday to rein in NSA spying on several fronts, recommending in its final report that the agency be stripped of its ability to store Americans’ telephone records.
foxnews.com/politics/2013/12/18/task-force-calls-for-reining-in-nsa-spying/

I really hope that the government adopts all of these recommendations. The spying has gotten to be way too widespread. Something definitely needs to be done. I can understand spying on serious criminals and potential terrorists but other than that I don’t see a reason for the spying. I also think that even for serious criminals and potential terrorists they must have a warrant from a court, preferably not a secret court, to do the spying.
 
This strikes me as just silly.

We are all required by law to share our tax records with the government, our family status, our health records, thanks to Obamacare, and each department affected can share with the other, in a cluster of access points we are assured are easy to hack. Criminal and even traffic ticket records are all on line for anybody to access. So are divorce records, records of family squabbles, records of complaints made to agencies about our child-rearing, records of any injuries we might have sustained, records of any insurance claims we might have made. And we have absolutely nothing we can do about it, and everybody accepts it. More than that, votes for the people who built it all. The privacy horse is so far out of the barn that his tracks can’t even be found anymore.

But a record of a call that might, immediately or later, be traced to some terrorist in Yemen or found later to have been in Minneapolis after a bomb goes off there and the perpetrator’s cell phone number is recovered? Oh no, can’t have that!

Worse than silly. It’s prohibiting potential investigation of potentially catastrophic events.

Who really fears this? People who make those calls to porn sites?
 
This strikes me as just silly.

We are all required by law to share our tax records with the government, our family status, our health records, thanks to Obamacare, and each department affected can share with the other, in a cluster of access points we are assured are easy to hack. Criminal and even traffic ticket records are all on line for anybody to access. So are divorce records, records of family squabbles, records of complaints made to agencies about our child-rearing, records of any injuries we might have sustained, records of any insurance claims we might have made. And we have absolutely nothing we can do about it, and everybody accepts it. More than that, votes for the people who built it all. The privacy horse is so far out of the barn that his tracks can’t even be found anymore.

But a record of a call that might, immediately or later, be traced to some terrorist in Yemen or found later to have been in Minneapolis after a bomb goes off there and the perpetrator’s cell phone number is recovered? Oh no, can’t have that!

Worse than silly. It’s prohibiting potential investigation of potentially catastrophic events.

Who really fears this? People who make those calls to porn sites?
There is a little matter of the fact that the Constitution prohibits what the NSA has been doing. If our own government agencies aren’t limited to the bounds set forth in the Constitution, then it’s only a few steps to either total anarchy, or total dictatorship.
 
There is a little matter of the fact that the Constitution prohibits what the NSA has been doing. If our own government agencies aren’t limited to the bounds set forth in the Constitution, then it’s only a few steps to either total anarchy, or total dictatorship.
Where in the Constitution does it empower the government to REQUIRE that our health records be digitized and given to a tax collecting agency? Where does it empower the government to REQUIRE that religious organizations violate conscience? Where does the Constitution empower state and federal agencies to access our bank records?

As I said, that horse left the barn a long time ago, and in much more important ways than in keeping records of who calls whom.
 
Where in the Constitution does it empower the government to REQUIRE that our health records be digitized and given to a tax collecting agency? Where does it empower the government to REQUIRE that religious organizations violate conscience? Where does the Constitution empower state and federal agencies to access our bank records?

As I said, that horse left the barn a long time ago, and in much more important ways than in keeping records of who calls whom.
“Everybody else is violating the Constitution in these areas; why not go ahead and violate it in one more?”

“Everybody else is jumping off the cliff; why don’t I go ahead and do it, too?”
 
40.png
Holly3278:
Quote:

The advisory board tasked with reviewing National Security Agency policies pushed Wednesday to rein in NSA spying on several fronts, recommending in its final report that the agency be stripped of its ability to store Americans’ telephone records.

foxnews.com/politics/2013…in-nsa-spying/

I really hope that the government adopts all of these recommendations. The spying has gotten to be way too widespread. Something definitely needs to be done. I can understand spying on serious criminals and potential terrorists but other than that I don’t see a reason for the spying. I also think that even for serious criminals and potential terrorists they must have a warrant from a court, preferably not a secret court, to do the spying.
How does one know who serious criminals and terrorists are without spying on them? They don’t wear signs.

All these restrictions are going to do is increase the funding for NSA tenfold. Its going to make their job much more difficult but their mandate hasn’t changed. It will simply result in increased manpower and technology, which is always good for business.

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
40.png
DaveBj:
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ridgerunner

This strikes me as just silly.

We are all required by law to share our tax records with the government, our family status, our health records, thanks to Obamacare, and each department affected can share with the other, in a cluster of access points we are assured are easy to hack. Criminal and even traffic ticket records are all on line for anybody to access. So are divorce records, records of family squabbles, records of complaints made to agencies about our child-rearing, records of any injuries we might have sustained, records of any insurance claims we might have made. And we have absolutely nothing we can do about it, and everybody accepts it. More than that, votes for the people who built it all. The privacy horse is so far out of the barn that his tracks can’t even be found anymore.

But a record of a call that might, immediately or later, be traced to some terrorist in Yemen or found later to have been in Minneapolis after a bomb goes off there and the perpetrator’s cell phone number is recovered? Oh no, can’t have that!

Worse than silly. It’s prohibiting potential investigation of potentially catastrophic events.

Who really fears this? People who make those calls to porn sites?

There is a little matter of the fact that the Constitution prohibits what the NSA has been doing. If our own government agencies aren’t limited to the bounds set forth in the Constitution, then it’s only a few steps to either total anarchy, or total dictatorship.
Isn’t whether or not this is a legal still yet to be determined hence the injunction?

Sadly, this is administration has shown that saying something violates the Constitution really doesn’t mean anything anymore; they can make it say whatever once and no one is going to stop them anyway.

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
I have nothing to fear from the government because I am not a criminal. I also definitely do not make calls to strange porn lines and such. However, I do fear that this spying could be used in an abusive manner. I fear that if the government were to become much more authoritarian or something that it could be used against people who oppose the government even in peaceful ways. I just don’t want us to become another China or North Korea. I’m not saying we’re anywhere near that bad because we aren’t. However, there is always the potential for abuse, even on a much more minor scale.
 
I have nothing to fear from the government because I am not a criminal. I also definitely do not make calls to strange porn lines and such. However, I do fear that this spying could be used in an abusive manner. I fear that if the government were to become much more authoritarian or something that it could be used against people who oppose the government even in peaceful ways. I just don’t want us to become another China or North Korea. I’m not saying we’re anywhere near that bad because we aren’t. However, there is always the potential for abuse, even on a much more minor scale.
Some of the people who oppose this administration and its movement and found themselves hounded by the IRS, OSHA or others, would probably tell you this government is as authoritarian as it wants to be at any given point in time or for reasons important to it.
 
“Everybody else is violating the Constitution in these areas; why not go ahead and violate it in one more?”

“Everybody else is jumping off the cliff; why don’t I go ahead and do it, too?”
Not my meaning. To work with the analogy a little, it’s more like being shoved off a cliff and not being nearly so concerned that your assailant took your wallet before he did it.

We have no secrets from the government. None. We gave that away a long time ago.
 
Some of the people who oppose this administration and its movement and found themselves hounded by the IRS, OSHA or others, would probably tell you this government is as authoritarian as it wants to be at any given point in time or for reasons important to it.
I would agree with them. I think our government has gotten more authoritarian in the past several years. However, I would not say that its anywhere near as bad as a place like China.
 
I would agree with them. I think our government has gotten more authoritarian in the past several years. However, I would not say that its anywhere near as bad as a place like China.
All the more reason for us the people to start rolling back the government’s control over our lives, starting with its blanket collection of communications information on U.S. persons, which is AGAINST THE LAW!!!
 
The agency they really need to check into is the NRO (National Recon. Organization).

It is said they have the ability to SEE everything, everywhere, that happens in the US, and possibly the entire world.(thru satellites Im assuming)

Their existence was only recently made public, but most people still do not know it exists, or what its agenda is…I would really like to know that, as well as the technology they have access to, I bet they use things that would make our jaws hit the floor!
 
The agency they really need to check into is the NRO (National Recon. Organization).

It is said they have the ability to SEE everything, everywhere, that happens in the US, and possibly the entire world.(thru satellites Im assuming)

Their existence was only recently made public, but most people still do not know it exists, or what its agenda is…I would really like to know that, as well as the technology they have access to, I bet they use things that would make our jaws hit the floor!
Probably do, but unless you are cleared and have a need to know, you won’t be finding out. Intel agencies are not in the habit of telling you what technology they use.

The entire community is a thankless one, moreso than the military or educators. Even prior to the NSA leaks, they only get brought into the news when there is a successful attack. They rarely broadcast the hundreds of thousands of attacks that get stopped. They get little credit, and heaps of blame.
 
All the more reason for us the people to start rolling back the government’s control over our lives, starting with its blanket collection of communications information on U.S. persons, which is AGAINST THE LAW!!!
Oh I completely agree with you Dave. We definitely need to roll back the government’s control over our lives. They have way too much control and their blanket collection of communications info is definitely unconstitutional even though they would argue that its not.
The agency they really need to check into is the NRO (National Recon. Organization).

It is said they have the ability to SEE everything, everywhere, that happens in the US, and possibly the entire world.(thru satellites Im assuming)

Their existence was only recently made public, but most people still do not know it exists, or what its agenda is…I would really like to know that, as well as the technology they have access to, I bet they use things that would make our jaws hit the floor!
I have heard of things like this before. I don’t know how true it is but I wouldn’t doubt it if they have that capability.
Probably do, but unless you are cleared and have a need to know, you won’t be finding out. Intel agencies are not in the habit of telling you what technology they use.

The entire community is a thankless one, moreso than the military or educators. Even prior to the NSA leaks, they only get brought into the news when there is a successful attack. They rarely broadcast the hundreds of thousands of attacks that get stopped. They get little credit, and heaps of blame.
I agree HappyCatholic01. The technology likely does exist. We’re probably spied on more than even Edward Snowden knows.
 
I have nothing to fear from the government because I am not a criminal. I also definitely do not make calls to strange porn lines and such. However, I do fear that this spying could be used in an abusive manner. I fear that if the government were to become much more authoritarian or something that it could be used against people who oppose the government even in peaceful ways. I just don’t want us to become another China or North Korea. I’m not saying we’re anywhere near that bad because we aren’t. However, there is always the potential for abuse, even on a much more minor scale.
Do you think its only criminals that are worried about secret Govt spying? LOL Im not a criminal either, but I would not want any Govt agency listening to or gathering info about me. They have no right to do this.

The US Constitution guarantees our right to privacy and freedom, but DOES NOT guarantee our safety, that is very important to remember. Being a US citizen will always have its inherent risks, that is just part of being a US citizen in the world, but that is why people living in the past, around the time of the revolution, actually were proud to be American and would risk their lives for the country, and would never expect something like this from their Govt!! This is not the case today though. The average citizen is not willing to go very far for the sake of the country in their lives, they do not want to be bothered.

The more laws and regulations our govt creates gets us that much closer to becoming the next china or north korea, more and more freedoms are being taken away here, and in the future, we probably wont have much freedom at all.
 
I have nothing to fear from the government because I am not a criminal.
We will be considered criminals once the left is able to get the laws to say that anyone who disagrees with homosexuality and so-called same-sex “marriage” is guilty of a “hate crime”. This has already happened in some countries. Leading up to this is Christians getting sued, businesses being forced to close, and people getting fired because they won’t say that homosexual behavior is normal.
 
We will be considered criminals once the left is able to get the laws to say that anyone who disagrees with homosexuality and so-called same-sex “marriage” is guilty of a “hate crime”. This has already happened in some countries. Leading up to this is Christians getting sued, businesses being forced to close, and people getting fired because they won’t say that homosexual behavior is normal.
I agree and IMO, we are right around the corner from people being jailed for being religious, well, if they are christian that is. I believe people will be asked if they believe God is their savior and likely some other questions and if they answer yes, they will be charged and jailed. Eventually, I think these people will be executed, but starting out, they will just be jailed indefinitely.

we are living in scary times and they are only going to get worse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top