Teachers Defend Tactics in Hoax DWI Program

  • Thread starter Thread starter peregrinus_WA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This was completely inappropriate.

Adults in authority should NOT lie to teenagers. As soon as the lies were exposed, everything truthful is going to be discounted from that source.

Yet, it was nothing more than a macabre, evil prank perpetrated by the Highway Patrol and the school authorities. You do not do evil (lying for the purpose of traumatizing others) because you think it MIGHT make a difference. Because unless evidence can be shown that exposing teens to lies about classmates being killed by a drunk driver (even in the lie that the classmate wasn’t at fault for the accident) will reduce fatalities due to drunk driving, there is zero justification for this behavior on the part of the adults.

I’m not sure that suing anyone would be the proper response, however.
C’mon. Evil pranks are done for the sake of being mean. This was to educate kids on the reality of drunk driving. I also don’t think it would as traumatic as you say. It’s not like they said their FAMILY was killed by a drunk driver.
 
I have been part of two anti-destructive decision demonstrations.

One was “ghost out” in which members of the school were “killed off” from various destructive decisions. The number of students who “died” coinsided with the number of ppl who would die during the course of the school day.

The other was when we staged a mock car accident outside the school. One car had rammed another and I was killed. Bloodily, I might add. We didn’t have a drunk driving incident that year.
 
VERY STUPID idea.

Kids, the problem isn’t underage drinking, it’s underage driving. Let a kid go to a bar at 16 and order a beer if he wants to, but don’t let him drive until he’s 18…and make him pay $1000 for the privelege of driving lessons…teen auto deaths due to alcohol will go down.

Face it, a car is far more dangerous than a bottle of beer. If kids don’t have to hide the fact that they’re drinking it quickly becomes no big deal…then, as they mature a bit…let them drive.
 
C’mon. Evil pranks are done for the sake of being mean. This was to educate kids on the reality of drunk driving. I also don’t think it would as traumatic as you say. It’s not like they said their FAMILY was killed by a drunk driver.
They use the name of a classmate. That classmate could very well be a close friend, or someone you’ve known since first grade or the sibling of a friend. It wrong, and it’s a lie. How do you teach reality by lying?
 
As long as they didn’t say it was my family(which I think would go way too far) I would be ok.
But what if it was your family? Some of the kids thought they had just lost a loved one. Teenagers often are closer to their friends than any one in their life. It is the time when peer ties are at their strongest. Are educators not aware of this?
 
They use the name of a classmate. That classmate could very well be a close friend, or someone you’ve known since first grade or the sibling of a friend. It wrong, and it’s a lie. How do you teach reality by lying?
By revealing the REAL feelings of what happens when people drive drunk. The only difference this time is that the kids have a chance to alter their choices so this doesn’t happen for real when there is so undoing the pain. These hours of sadness are better than a lifetime. You seem to be more upset about a demonstration that is over with than actions that could lead to death. The kds are ok now. Nobody died. That’s not the case with most drunk driving accidents.
 
I don’t see what harm this did. Drunk driving kills. Sometimes it takes drastic measures to show the reality of it. No one was out at risk here. Maybe it shocked the kids for a minute, but it’s not like they won’t recover. I’ve never driven drunk, but I would support this if it happened at my school because I realize other kids aren’t as responsible. As long as they didn’t say it was my family(which I think would go way too far) I would be ok.
How do you know this stunt worked?
 
But what if it was your family? Some of the kids thought they had just lost a loved one. Teenagers often are closer to their friends than any one in their life. It is the time when peer ties are at their strongest. Are educators not aware of this?
I think there is something seriously wrong if kids care more about their friends than their families. Sibling knew ahead of time. Besides, exercises like this are meant to save kids from the pain of losing loved ones. Maybe if some of the thousands of drunk drivers had experienced this they would realized the magnitude of their actions before killing someone. One of the girls who was told a close friend had died said that if it saves even one life it was worth it.
 
How do you know this stunt worked?
How do you know a public any public warning works? It sent the message that drunk driving tears apart lives. We’ll see if how many of these kids drive drunk after graduation this year.
 
How do you know a public any public warning works? It sent the message that drunk driving tears apart lives. We’ll see if how many of these kids drive drunk after graduation this year.
You’re beginning to see the point – they have no metrics, no way of measuring if what they did works. This is quite common – the Great Society is the Poster Child for a vast program with no controls or feedback.

Never buy the “If it saves one life” argument until you check to see if they are tracking how many lives are saved (if any) and that there is a mechanism to halt or alter the program if it doesn’t meet its numbers.
 
I voted yes, I think it was in very poor taste. Now the issue is the hoax, not even the issue itself anymore.

I was in high school 10-15 years ago, and sad to say, most classmates used to make fun of these sorts of attempts to scare or dramatize issues.

It just didn’t seem to make a difference when Friday/Saturday and no supervision rolled around.
 
But what if it was your family? Some of the kids thought they had just lost a loved one. Teenagers often are closer to their friends than any one in their life. It is the time when peer ties are at their strongest. Are educators not aware of this?
And they found out before they left school that there freinds were OK and I am sure they felt a huge amount of relielf when they found out. Hopefully the next time they decided to drive after drinking or see a freind who wants to drive after drinking they will remeber the pain they felt when they thought their friend was dead.

My best friends son was killed last October by a drunk teenager who ran a red light. i wish that teen had suffered a few hours of agony at his high school thinking a friend was dead -might have kept him from getting behind the wheel.

I
 
I think there is something seriously wrong if kids care more about their friends than their families.
Yes, there is. It’s called being a teenager. It is part of nature’s way of kicking them out of the nest.

This sort of gimmick goes beyond the scope of secondary education, which is education. I understand sentencing kids to some sort of scared straight program as alternative sentencing. What did these kids do to deserve being treated like their feelings are of no consequence? I notice you are quick to point out in your earlier post how wrong it would be if someone did this to you claiming you lost a family member.

If nothing else this sort of lunacy underscores the importance of getting kids away from being guinea pigs of the public school system and into homeschooling or Catholic schools.
 
I voted yes as its a stupid attempt to scare students.

I wouldn’t sue as its not something you should sue. I think the school officials should be raked over the coals at the next School Board meeting and so should the Law authorities that were involved in this.

As for the message that they wanted to convey it is completely lost. You can put students into 2 groups with regard to this issue. Those that wouldn’t drink and drive, and those that do, who think its okay. Its for the latter that this exercise was done for. However, the authorities lost any credibility with those students when they lied. The message was gone, as they will use that lying as a means to avoid REAL responsibility.

A better message for those students would have been to take all of them to a scene of a DWI accident or show a realistic video of the after effects of a DWI.

Also, I wonder if the parents of these teenagers knew about this hoax and doesn’t the school have an obligation to tell them?
 
It just didn’t seem to make a difference when Friday/Saturday and no supervision rolled around.
I think you understand teenagers better than these teachers. The last thing they think about after a few beers is what happened at school. Alcohol is not compatable with sound judgment.

Even if there was some benefit, which is highly doubtful, one can not escape that the program was one of lies and deceit. It is based on a blatant disregard of God’s moral law, not that public schools give a hoot about obeying God’s moral law.
 
Yes, there is. It’s called being a teenager. It is part of nature’s way of kicking them out of the nest.

This sort of gimmick goes beyond the scope of secondary education, which is education. I understand sentencing kids to some sort of scared straight program as alternative sentencing. What did these kids do to deserve being treated like their feelings are of no consequence? I notice you are quick to point out in your earlier post how wrong it would be if someone did this to you claiming you lost a family member.

If nothing else this sort of lunacy underscores the importance of getting kids away from being guinea pigs of the public school system and into homeschooling or Catholic schools.
It only lasted for a few hours. Everyone is fine now. Their feelings would be a lot worse had their freind actually been killed by a drunk driver.

Here is a video of some of the kids involved. They look alive and well now:

publish.vx.roo.com/muscatine/portal/?channel=USA+News&clipId=926783
 
It only lasted for a few hours. Everyone is fine now. Their feelings would be a lot worse had their freind actually been killed by a drunk driver.
Of course, but this is a false logic of either/or. They still may know this anguish, even though they had this fraud perpetrated on them. If there had been no program, then they might never have a friend killed by a drunk driver anyway.
 
I think you understand teenagers better than these teachers. The last thing they think about after a few beers is what happened at school. Alcohol is not compatable with sound judgment.

Even if there was some benefit, which is highly doubtful, one can not escape that the program was one of lies and deceit. It is based on a blatant disregard of God’s moral law, not that public schools give a hoot about obeying God’s moral law.
The exact same excuses we hear when they are passing out condoms and teaching safe sex-we just dont understand teenagers.
 
Besides, why not also stage a school shooting to try and discourage that activity. Then the next week they could stage a gang fight that kills kids. The week after it could be a kid killed on a bicycle that didn’t wear a helmut. The next week, a suicide.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top