Teen says she's atheist

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucky3x
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ditto on the “calling it a phase” thing. Just don’t. It’s just makes teens and young adults feel like they aren’t being taken seriously. Talk to her, challenge her - but if she’s making a choice she believes is rational, respect that. I don’t mean that you must agree, but to engage her as a thinking rational person who can consider arguments.
 
He is very firm in his belief that God does not exist and is a myth that people made up before there was real science and have kept around to make themselves feel better. I try to educate him and make him understand that his beloved science and Christianity are not mutually exclusive. But if he is going to be stubborn then he is most certainly going to get his butt out of bed and do something useful.
Does he know the Pope is a a “man of science.” Pope Francis has a Masters degree in chemistry.
 
With atheists making up 93 percent of the American National Academy of Science, it doesn’t make sense to tally a count of scientists who are Christians in an attempt to argue for compatibility. Such a roster is easily overwhelmed by the converse, showing at best no direct linkage between faith and science, and objectively, that Christians making major contributions to science constitute a fringe well outside the mainstream.

On the other hand, in America, it is trivially simple to link anti-scientific ideation with Christianity. At one well-publicized example, the Creation Museum in Ohio, exhibit after exhibit directly contrasts the scientific position with what they see as proper Christian belief. It is instructive to note that these misrepresentations and deliberate falsehoods, easily pierced by freshman science students, lie beyond the ability of even the post-Galilean Catholic church to effectively quash, and that to this day there remain prominent Catholic apologists who still believe Galileo was wrong.

Beliefs in God or gods differentiate themselves from disbelief, atheism, by their acceptance of supernatural explanations, and it is this issue which must be addressed if one is to argue an atheist into any form of theism.

As ever, Jesse
 
Sadly, many Catholic schools, including the one in Scranton which my daughters attended donot engage in apologetics. Faith is not passed on through osmosis. Each person must choose, based upon the information they have.
May I suggest that you have your daughter read Lee Strobel’s magnificent set of books. I personally read Case for a Creator and Case for the Real Jesus. For me, they were page turners. I know at least one lovely young woman whose life was rescued from the abyss after reading Case for a Creator. Today, she leads religious programs for young people at her church. 👍 Rob
 
Does he know the Pope is a a “man of science.” Pope Francis has a Masters degree in chemistry.
I just passed on that info. I also mentioned that, since Catholicism and science are not mutually exclusive, maybe he could go to mass just to learn a moral lesson from the homily. Still no dice. I’ll keep at him, though. Eventually he’ll cave.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top