M
Mr.Ex_Nihilo
Guest
Those are good points Peter. But if this is true then it need to be asked why the history of life on earth shows such a dramatically different story?If by evolution macro-evolution is meant then thanking God for it is not coherant with the Church’s magisterial teaching.
The Fourth Lateran Council (1215) doctrine on ex nihilo creation teaches that in the beginning all things, visible and invisible, were created in their whole substance by God alone out of nothing.
In canon 5 of Vatican I (1869-70) the words « whole substance » (i.e. both as to matter as well as to form) were used adding further confirmation of the incompatibility between the dogma and the theory of one kind evolving into another. Each thing was, as the doctrine quite clearly says, created in the beginning, in its whole substance, out of nothing:
Peter
I think, personally, that these councils were drawing on Augustine’s thoughts of a creation according to seminal principles-- which are very compatible with these declarations you’ve posted.
Creation According To Seminal Principles
I personally think Robert I. Bradshaw did a marvelous job with his research of the early fathers and I often come back to his pages when questions like this come forward…Several of the early church fathers believed that God created the universe in the form of seminal principles, including Hilary of Pontiers (c. 315-367),(33) Gregory of Nyssa(34) and Augustine.(35) As Augustine’s writings present the most developed version of this theory it is worth looking at them in some detail.
Saint Augustine:
More can be found here. Consequently, I think these thoughts from St. Augustine came be used as a bulwark for a theistic evolutionary model that fits within the council’s words you’ve quoted.With regard to certain very small forms of animal life, there is a question as to whether they were produced in the first creatures or were a later product of the corruption of perishable beings. For most of them came forth from the diseased parts or the excrement or vapors of living bodies or from the corruption of corpses; some also from decomposed trees and plants, others from rotting fruit.… it is absurd to say that they were created when the animals were created, except in the sense that there was present from the beginning in all living bodies a natural power, and, I might say, there were interwoven with these bodies the seminal principles of animals later to appear, which would spring from the decomposing bodies, each according to its kind and with its special properties, by the wonderful power of the immutable Creator who moves all His creatures.(51)