The day after pill

  • Thread starter Thread starter ADiosgracias
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thats a whooper, the critical passage in human vitae is translated differently into at least 2 different languages:
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_25071968_humanae-vitae_en.html
“Similarly excluded is any action which either before, at the moment of, or after sexual intercourse, is specifically intended to prevent procreation—whether as an end or as a means. (16)”

vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_25071968_humanae-vitae_ge.html
"Ebenso ist jede Handlung verwerflich, die entweder in Voraussicht oder während des Vollzugs des ehelichen Aktes oder im Anschluß an ihn beim Ablauf seiner natürlichen Auswirkungen darauf abstellt, die Fortpflanzung zu verhindern, sei es als Ziel, sei es als Mittel zum Ziel (16). "

Same sentence from same document from official vatican page and one says “sexual intercourse”, which can (at least without context) include both rape and marital intercourse, while german version uses “eheliche Aktes”, which only includes marital intercourse,
dict.cc/?s=ehelich

Anybody with decent latin?
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_25071968_humanae-vitae_lt.html
“Item quivis respuendus est actus, qui, cum coniugale commercium vel praevidetur vel efficitur vel ad suos naturales exitus ducit, id tamquam finem obtinendum aut viam adhibendam intendat, ut procreatio impediatur.(16)”

If i get it correctly the relevant term would be “coniugale commercium”, which i guess from deit.dict.cc/?s=coniugale (claims ist “ehelich”, which would be “marital” in english) is more likely to mean (many terms similar in latin and italian language) marital intercourse.

Would be funny, if all that discussion boils down to some incorrect translation.
 
No, because if Church teaching only discusses the morality of contraception inside marriage and is silent about it outside marriage, your claim that Church teaches contraception is always forbidden is not supported, at least not by the passages discussing contraception inside marriage.
You claim was:
"The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception to prevent pregnancy is not allowed. "

From the passages i cited one can only support:
The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception inside marriage to prevent pregnancy is not allowed.

Just because the church teaches that under the circumstances A action B is evil, does not show that Church teaches that under circumstances non-A action B is evil as well.

First you must show, that your claim, that Church teaches that contraception is also wrong outside marriage, is supported by CCC. Only then the need arises to check, whether there is again exception for certain cases e.g. rape. But your claim is so far unsupported.
Are you serious?

Do you expect anyone to support your claim that the Church teaches contraception is forbidden within marriage but permitted outside marriage. Go and ask your priest and tell me if he laughs at you!
Contraception is FORBIDDEN. There is no only within marriage.
 
Are you serious?
Yes.
Do you expect anyone to support your claim that the Church teaches contraception is forbidden within marriage but permitted outside marriage.
My claim is that the Church teaches contraception is forbidden inside marriage and teaches that sex outside marriage is forbidden. I can name the relevant passages in the CCC.

Regarding whether the Church teaches that the use of contraception is forbidden for the faithful catholic in case of not permisseble sex outside marriage, i do not claim anything.

I cannot find for example any passage in the CCC or in humanum vitae discussing/regulating whether the use of contraception during forbidden sex is forbidden or not (and i am not surprised not to find it, because that would be like considering whether its permissable to use guns during murder or whether thats also in itself forbidden). Therefore i ask, whether someone can name such passage.
Go and ask your priest and tell me if he laughs at you!
Contraception is FORBIDDEN. There is no only within marriage.
Since i live in Germany and since many priest here often either have a rather strained definition of obedience or are mostly obedident towards their bishops (which just stated that contraception in case of rape is ok), i suspect that most priest in Germany will not laugh at me.

So please, if possible, cite a vatican document from which is about the subject of contraception outside marriage.
 
catholic.com/tracts/contraception-and-sterilization

Most of those quotes from earlier theologicans are also discussing it in the context of marriage.

Interesting especially this quote:
Augustine
“For, whereas that natural use, when it pass beyond the compact of marriage, that is, beyond the necessity of begetting [children], is pardonable in the case of a wife, damnable in the case of a harlot; that which is against nature is execrable when done in the case of a harlot, but more execrable in the case of a wife.”

The later part cleary says that according to Augustines opinion that some actions which are against nature are more sinful if happening inside marriage than if these actions happen outside marriage.If Augustine is correct with that, its at least possible that Church teaching can be different for contraception inside and outside marriage.

Furthermore, all seem to consider the use of contraceptives be linked to the sin of lust and all seem to consider cases of willing sex (e.g. Augustine speaks about harlots which indicates consent). With a raped women the use of contraception is not linked to the sin of lust, at least on her side.
 
This is so incorrect it is worth highlighting by itself.

If a Catholic is interested in what the Church actually teaches, Pope Paul VI’s Humanae Vitae is a good place to start. It acknowledges that Catholic couples have licit reasons to avoid pregnancy while still enjoying the unitive properties of martial sex. That is why NFP, which is historically viewed as contraception, can be used licitly.

I have to disagree with your interpretation here. NFP is not contraception. Contraception violates natural law and opposes the nature of love.
 
This thread has provided a very interesting discussion.

I agree that contraception can be used in the case of rape if ovulation has not taken place.

But now questions have been raised whether Plan B can sometimes be an abortifacient.

As I understand it, the Catholic Church requires an ovulation test before Plan B can be administered to rape victims in Catholic facilties.

Recent articles have cited “new” studies which claim that Plan B doesn’t really interfere with implantation (contrary to earlier declarations by the manufacturer and government agencies).

I know there’s been a lot of back and forth on this.

But it’s important to resolve this issue.

The question has consequences not just for Church policy in general. For example, some lawsuits against Obamacare assume that Plan B is sometimes an abortifacient.

Of course, the Catholic Church is fighting Obamacare because it requires contraceptive coverage. So the Church’s position wouldn’t change if it is scientifically determined that Plan B is not an abortifacient.
 
addendum:

If Plan B and “Ella” can now be bought over-the-counter, it would seem that they are no longer prescription drugs, and therefore would not be part of the contraception coverage mandated by Obamacare - because health insurance policies usually do not cover over-the-counter items.

But I’m not sure about this.

However, if employers are indeed required to cover Plan B and “Ella” in their health insurance policies, even if this goes against their conscience, the Church would oppose this part of Obamacare.

It’s important to note that the Church’s legal argument against Obamacare does not require that we prove that contraception is morally wrong. It’s more formal than that - the Church is citing the fundamental freedom of religion guaranteed by our Constitution.

Even if there were no Obamacare, the government could still try to force Catholic facilities to provide “emergency contraception” to rape victims without first testing for ovulation.
This is one reason why it’s important to resolve the issue whether Plan B or “Ella” sometimes works as an abortifacient.
 
Essentially, if a drug simply prevents conception after a rape BUT DOES NOT destroy a zygote/whatever, it can theoretically be allowed by the Church, since such a thing is not an abortion.
No, contraception is evil, no exceptions according to the Church…
 
Is it not wrong to obstruct God’s path to creating life, even in extreme circumstances? Can God not create good out of evil?

If a procedure were done after a rape case to prevent her from getting an STD and by happenstance prevents pregnancy from occuring, I believe that would be considered okay since the purpose of the procedure is not to obstruct life but to ensure the health of the woman. If a procedure were conducted for the SOLE PURPOSE of preventing pregnancy, I can’t see how that would not be considered a sin.
 
No, contraception is evil, no exceptions according to the Church…
Can you please name any Church teaching/document from which one can conclude that the Church teaches that the use of contraception is forbidden for the faithful catholic in case of not permissable sex outside marriage?

Plase also take note of:
catholic.com/tracts/contr…-sterilization

“For, whereas that natural use, when it pass beyond the compact of marriage, that is, beyond the necessity of begetting [children], is pardonable in the case of a wife, damnable in the case of a harlot; that which is against nature is execrable when done in the case of a harlot, but more execrable in the case of a wife.”

The later part cleary says that according to Augustines opinion that some actions which are against nature are more sinful if happening inside marriage than if these actions happen outside marriage.If Augustine is correct with that, its at least possible that Church teaching can be different for contraception inside and outside marriage.
 
No, contraception is evil, no exceptions according to the Church…
I’ll take this opportunity to make my first post on these forums 😃

As carn has pointed out before, the Catechism refers to contraception in the context of the conjugal act between spouses. It is, in fact, mentioned under the section titled “The fecundity of marriage.” The Catechism does not say the act of fornication (sex outside of marriage) shall be ordered to life. Here’s my take on why: How much sense does it make to forbid fornication, and then lay down rules for committing the very act you just forbade? To teach as such would almost implicate that its okay to commit the sin as long as you follow the subsequent rules.

A woman that has been raped has not consented to the act, and is therefore not morally culpable to it. My opinion (take it for what it’s worth) is, as she has not engaged in the conjugal act (which is within the context of marriage), the condemnation of preventing a subsequent pregnancy does not apply.

Anything beyond that, such as the knowing and willful abortion of any life that has been created because of the act, is a different matter.
 
Yes.

My claim is that the Church teaches contraception is forbidden inside marriage and teaches that sex outside marriage is forbidden. I can name the relevant passages in the CCC.

Regarding whether the Church teaches that the use of contraception is forbidden for the faithful catholic in case of not permisseble sex outside marriage, i do not claim anything.

I cannot find for example any passage in the CCC or in humanum vitae discussing/regulating whether the use of contraception during forbidden sex is forbidden or not (and i am not surprised not to find it, because that would be like considering whether its permissable to use guns during murder or whether thats also in itself forbidden). Therefore i ask, whether someone can name such passage.

Since i live in Germany and since many priest here often either have a rather strained definition of obedience or are mostly obedident towards their bishops (which just stated that contraception in case of rape is ok), i suspect that most priest in Germany will not laugh at me.

So please, if possible, cite a vatican document from which is about the subject of contraception outside marriage.
So do you think an unmarried couple who are having sex and using contraception should only confess the unmarried sex?

I Have to say that I see Thistle’s point. If something is immoral then it is immoral. As soon as you make exceptions the entirety of the Church’s teaching about contraception falls. So does abortion by the way. The Church does not teach that abortion is ok in cases of rape. Rape is an evil so is contraception.
 
I’ll take this opportunity to make my first post on these forums 😃

As carn has pointed out before, the Catechism refers to contraception in the context of the conjugal act between spouses. It is, in fact, mentioned under the section titled “The fecundity of marriage.” The Catechism does not say the act of fornication (sex outside of marriage) shall be ordered to life. Here’s my take on why: How much sense does it make to forbid fornication, and then lay down rules for committing the very act you just forbade? To teach as such would almost implicate that its okay to commit the sin as long as you follow the subsequent rules.

A woman that has been raped has not consented to the act, and is therefore not morally culpable to it. My opinion (take it for what it’s worth) is, as she has not engaged in the conjugal act (which is within the context of marriage), the condemnation of preventing a subsequent pregnancy does not
Anything beyond that, such as the knowing and willful abortion of any life that has been created because of the act, is a different matter.
ok but where do we draw the line. If she was not complicit in the Rape then can she abort? Can she kill her three year old? At what point do we say she has moral obligations of action?

You must agree that contraception is a grave matter. So is abortion, so is murder. At what point do we make a distinction.
I’m afraid in this matter it IS all or nothing.
 
ok but where do we draw the line. If she was not complicit in the Rape then can she abort? Can she kill her three year old? At what point do we say she has moral obligations of action?
It’s rather straight forward for me. It is never okay to end the life of an innocent, be it by murder or abortion (which are, really, the same thing anyways). The matter of discussion here, however, isn’t abortion, but rather contraception to prevent the fertilization after one has been raped.
You must agree that contraception is a grave matter. So is abortion, so is murder. At what point do we make a distinction.
I’m afraid in this matter it IS all or nothing.
I agree that contraception is a grave matter, but I revert back to my point that contraception is something that is discussed within the context of the conjugal act. In the case that someone has been raped, and there has been no fertilization, I believe there are no moral qualms to taking contraceptive action.

I’m not arguing that there is an “exception”, as you fear in your previous post. There is no exception. It’s not okay to use contraceptives during fornication because fornication is prohibited. In fact, I would argue that there would be a great confusion among people if the church made a clarification stating all sexual acts, including fornication, shall be ordered to procreation. I think many people would take that to mean fornication was okay as long as you didn’t use contraceptives…
 
So do you think an unmarried couple who are having sex and using contraception should only confess the unmarried sex?
You mean they have less to confess, when they did not contracept?

I do not mean anything in any direction. I do not know and have not yet seen anyone reffering to church teaching regarding contraception not in the context of marriage.
I Have to say that I see Thistle’s point. If something is immoral then it is immoral.
Please show with church teaching that contraception is in itself immoral. The only passage i can find, show that contraception within marriage is immoral.

And i found Augustinus saying that some things are outside marriage less severe than inside marriage.
As soon as you make exceptions the entirety of the Church’s teaching about contraception falls.
Since nobody has shown, that contraception is taught to be evil independent of the context of marriage, there is so far no rule for which this would establish an exception.

Only have sex with the person you are married to and do not use contraception with the intent to prevent new life during such sex. I cannot find any rule beyond this.

Furthermore it is permissable to use necessary medication, even if it has contraceptive side effects and this medication can even be something that is normally used as contraception.
So does abortion by the way. The Church does not teach that abortion is ok in cases of rape.
For abortion always being wrong, even in case of rape or life threat for the mother, we have church teaching. For the latter there is even a saint, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gianna_Beretta_Molla .

So sorry, not the same thing.

Furthermore,
You must agree that contraception is a grave matter. So is abortion, so is murder. At what point do we make a distinction.
Again, the documents i know, show contraception is a grave matter in the context of marriage. They are silent about it outside marriage. For abortion they are not silent about outside marriage and equally condemn it, whether inside or outside marriage.

And this distinction is crucial, remember that although church condemns murder under all circumstances, it does not condemn under all circumstances putting a gun in someones mouth and pulling the trigger. And yet intuitively, we would consider putting a gun in someones mouth and pulling the trigger to be at least morally problematic.

Yet, Church teaching is probably entirely silent about putting a gun in someones mouth and pulling the trigger and furthermore from this silence we can conclude that whenever putting a gun in someones mouth and pulling the trigger is not murder, it is permissable. So we have to very precise, what the church does teach and forbid, because the things about which church teaching are silent can easily be entirely different from what our intuitution says.

edit:
Furthermore, im german, so i have in moral and religious matters submit myself to what german bishops say, unless i have real good evidence they talk rubbish. And they said contraception in case of rape is ok. So i need good evidence to the contrary, otherwise i have to accept that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top