The day after pill

  • Thread starter Thread starter ADiosgracias
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is FORBIDDEN by the Church - no exceptions.
If you would have minded what i say, you would have noted that i claim that fending of the rape attack or parts of it is not immoral and that preventing ovulation is one of the possible options. Edit: Obviously, that then does not fall under “contraception to prevent pregnancy” as the intent is different.

You could try to argue my position is wrong, but currently you just ignore it.
 
I repeat. When the** prime reason** for using it is prevention of pregnancy contraception is NOT PERMITTED under any circumstances (not even rape - despite what some bishops think).
That is the clear Church teaching.
Thistle, I have to ask, since the ‘pull-out method’ is a form of contraception, do you or do you not belive that it is moral for someone to end an act of rape once penetration has occured?
 
Wrong. The prime purpose of all contraceptives is to prevent pregnancy. Contraception does not prevent the act of rape. While rape is a vicious evil thing contraception by the rapist before the act or by the victim the day after does not justify contraception.
Contraception to prevent pregnancy is not permitted under any circumstances. That is the Church teaching, no matter if some Bishops disagree with the Church on this.
So, if a rapist puts on a condom (most likely to prevent dna collection and detection), should the victim tell him to take it off, it’s a sin?? Rape is not a voluntary sex act. The rapist’s sperm do NOT have the right to “find the egg”. If they do, then the resulting child is not responsible for his father’s crime, and must be protected and allowed to be born, but to insist that it’s immoral to prevent a rapist from impregnating a woman is ludicrous!

In Christ,
Ellen
 
Thistle, I have to ask, since the ‘pull-out method’ is a form of contraception, do you or do you not belive that it is moral for someone to end an act of rape once penetration has occured?
I’d also like to know this! Apparently once in, a rapist is a de facto spouse!

In Christ,
Ellen
 
So, if a rapist puts on a condom (most likely to prevent dna collection and detection), should the victim tell him to take it off, it’s a sin?? Rape is not a voluntary sex act. The rapist’s sperm do NOT have the right to “find the egg”. If they do, then the resulting child is not responsible for his father’s crime, and must be protected and allowed to be born, but to insist that it’s immoral to prevent a rapist from impregnating a woman is ludicrous!

In Christ,
Ellen
I would also like an answer to this question. Do you believe it is a moral obligation of a woman being raped to try and prevent her rapist from using a condom?
 
I would also like an answer to this question. Do you believe it is a moral obligation of a woman being raped to try and prevent her rapist from using a condom?
Well, not being raped would solve more problems, so I would say that wouldn’t be an issue. She needs to concentrate on not being raped, not preventing the rapist from using a condom.
 
Well, not being raped would solve more problems, so I would say that wouldn’t be an issue. She needs to concentrate on not being raped, not preventing the rapist from using a condom.
My question is specifically aimed at Thistle. I am trying to understand more about what he/she thinks and why he/she thinks that it is wrong to prevent conception from occuring from an act of rape. If he/she thinks it is always wrong to take an action against conception in the case of rape then logically he/she must also believe that it is a moral obligation of someone being raped to protest against the use of a condom by their aggressor. I think that is an absolutely ridiculous claim, but I am curious as to whether or not Thistle will follow his position out to his/her logical conclusion as well as whether or not Thistle thinks there is some subtlty in his/her thoughts on this which allows him/her to hold that it is morally permissable for a rape victim tobe complicit in her rapist using a condom while it is immoral for her to take any action against conception.
 
My question is specifically aimed at Thistle…
I think a better question would be to ask: “Where are you getting your source? What teaching specifically are you referring to?”

As far as I can tell, the CCC only talks about contraception in reference to marriage, not rape. The most applicable and authoritative thing I have seen on the subject thus far is the link to usccb.

I am no expert, and would like to see some conclusive authority on the matter. Following one’s conscience is important, but I do want to make sure I am seeing all sides of the issue, most importantly, that of the Church.

@Thistle:
I am not challenging you right now, I just want to see what Church teaching you are specifically referring to and where.
 
I think a better question would be to ask: “Where are you getting your source? What teaching specifically are you referring to?”

As far as I can tell, the CCC only talks about contraception in reference to marriage, not rape. The most applicable and authoritative thing I have seen on the subject thus far is the link to usccb.

I am no expert, and would like to see some conclusive authority on the matter. Following one’s conscience is important, but I do want to make sure I am seeing all sides of the issue, most importantly, that of the Church.

@Thistle:
I am not challenging you right now, I just want to see what Church teaching you are specifically referring to and where.
I hope you are not seriously implying that the Church only forbids contraception for Catholics within marriage and that it says its okay outside marriage and if you are not a Catholic. Please tell me that is not what you are suggesting.
Using your thought process if a husband rapes his wife then she is allowed to use the morning after pill.

The Church teaching applies to all contraception and it does not say there are exceptions for rape.
 
Thistle:

Sorry if there is a misunderstanding. I have not stated any opinion now, and that is for a good reason. I don’t know what the church teaches on this specific case. I would be grateful if you could provide a reference for your view.
Please tell me that is not what you are suggesting.
Don’t worry. Its not.

When I brought up marriage, I wasn’t talking about rape in marriage. I just wanted to point out that the Church speaks mainly about contraceptives within the situation of marriage. I am wanting to see a broader statement by the church, but right now I don’t know where to look.
 
I am still confused. Both sides seem to have a point on whether contraception (attempting to prevent pregnancy) is licit if done against an unjust aggressor/rapist.

My concern is that on one hand, the rape itself could be confined to the actual penetration, but after the act, it seems that the natural consequences of rape leading to procreation may not be part of it. Thus it may be licit to interrupt the penetration during rape (coitus interruptus/withdrawal), but prevention of ovulation may not anymore be self-defense.
On the other hand, potential conception can also be seen as a “continuing attack” from the aggressor if all of the consequences ensuing from rape is considered part of it.

Even if the US bishops already ruled the legitimacy of preventing conception in rape, Humanae Vitae said that any action intending to prevent procreation is illicit. Preventing ovulation intends to prevent procreation. This is different from using pills for another medical indication because the intention there is not to prevent ovulation. But I may be wrong in thinking that Pope Paul VI intended to rule that all forms of intended contraception, including that in rape, are illicit. I would gladly defer to the authority of the US bishops, if there isn’t a seeming contradiction vs Church doctrine. Is there any explicit clarification from the Vatican reg this issue, given that it is the only teaching authhority higher than that of the bishops?
 
Try reading this article.

sjvdenver.edu/site/files/957/123085/414027/565058/Is_Plan_B_an_Abortifacient.pdf

You’ll notice that there is no debate about whether or not emergency contraception may licitly be prescribed in cases of rape. On this point, Catholic moral theologians are unanimous. I don’t know of one reputable moral theologian who would suggest that a rape victim be denied emergency contraception. Frankly, i’d be stunned if someone can provide me a quote from any Catholic moral theologian anywhere who would support such a thing.

The debate in this article hinges on whether or not Plan B is an abortafacient. Fr. Austriaco argues that the science shows it to not be. This differs, for instance, from RU-486, which is certainly abortafacient and markets itself as such.

We have the right to defend ourselves against unjust aggressors. This by extension means the rapist’s sperm. Furthermore, a sexual act is both unitive and procreative. Rape, by definition, is not unitive. An act cannot at one and the same time be both an attack and uniting. Thus, the act need not be procreative either.
 
Thistle, you have not answered the question.
The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception to prevent pregnancy is not allowed. It does not list any exceptions.

Show me the CCC, Canon Law, or a Papal Encyclical which states rape or anything else is an exception to that teaching. A letter or article from some bishops does not count.
 
The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception to prevent pregnancy is not allowed. It does not list any exceptions.

Show me the CCC, Canon Law, or a Papal Encyclical which states rape or anything else is an exception to that teaching. A letter or article from some bishops does not count.
Would you mind citing the exact paragraph?

I only find:
vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a6.htm
"The conjugal love of man and woman thus stands under the twofold obligation of fidelity and fecundity. "

"* The fecundity of marriage

2366 Fecundity is a gift, an end of marriage,

…
2370 Periodic continence, that is, the methods of birth regulation based on self-observation and the use of infertile periods, is in conformity with the objective criteria of morality.158 These methods respect the bodies of the spouses, encourage tenderness between them, and favor the education of an authentic freedom. In contrast, “every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible” is intrinsically evil:159
Code:
Thus the innate language that expresses the total reciprocal self-giving of **husband and wife** is overlaid, through contraception, by an objectively contradictory language, namely, that of not giving oneself totally to the other. This leads not only to a positive refusal to be open to life but also to **a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality.** . . . The difference, both anthropological and moral, between contraception and recourse to the rhythm of the cycle . . . involves in the final analysis two irreconcilable concepts of the human person and of human sexuality.160 "
Same in humanae vitae:
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_25071968_humanae-vitae_en.html
"14. Therefore We base Our words on the first principles of a human and Christian doctrine of marriage when We are obliged once more to declare that the direct interruption of the generative process already begun and, above all, all direct abortion, even for therapeutic reasons, are to be absolutely excluded as lawful means of regulating the number of children. (14) Equally to be condemned, as the magisterium of the Church has affirmed on many occasions, is direct sterilization, whether of the man or of the woman, whether permanent or temporary. (15)

Similarly excluded is any action which either before, at the moment of, or after sexual intercourse, is specifically intended to prevent procreation—whether as an end or as a means. (16)

Neither is it valid to argue, as a justification for sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive, that a lesser evil is to be preferred to a greater one, or that such intercourse would merge with procreative acts of past and future to form a single entity, and so be qualified by exactly the same moral goodness as these. Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good," it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it (18)—in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general. Consequently, it is a serious error to think that a whole married life of otherwise normal relations can justify sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive and so intrinsically wrong. "

In both cases the issue is discussed of contraception is discussed regarding marriage.
And marriage comes with the “obligation of fidelity and fecundity.” And contraception is not in accord with the later, as it “requires a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality.”

A women raped is not required to give herself in personal totality. If anything, she is required to deny the attacker anything of her, which can be denied (therefore a gun is a good tool for her in such case). She does not falsify the inner truth of conjugal loveby using contraception, she denies part of her, which she is certainly allowed to do (and maybe even required because if a women does not resist the attaacker and deny herself in all possible ways, she might accidentally help him, which should be avoided).

Where is contraception in case of sex outside marriage discussed in the CCC?
 
Would you mind citing the exact paragraph?

I only find:
vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a6.htm
"The conjugal love of man and woman thus stands under the twofold obligation of fidelity and fecundity. "

"* The fecundity of marriage

2366 Fecundity is a gift, an end of marriage,

…
2370 Periodic continence, that is, the methods of birth regulation based on self-observation and the use of infertile periods, is in conformity with the objective criteria of morality.158 These methods respect the bodies of the spouses, encourage tenderness between them, and favor the education of an authentic freedom. In contrast, “every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible” is intrinsically evil:159
Code:
Thus the innate language that expresses the total reciprocal self-giving of **husband and wife** is overlaid, through contraception, by an objectively contradictory language, namely, that of not giving oneself totally to the other. This leads not only to a positive refusal to be open to life but also to **a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality.** . . . The difference, both anthropological and moral, between contraception and recourse to the rhythm of the cycle . . . involves in the final analysis two irreconcilable concepts of the human person and of human sexuality.160 "
Same in humanae vitae:
vatican.va/holy_father/paul_vi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-vi_enc_25071968_humanae-vitae_en.html
"14. Therefore We base Our words on the first principles of a human and Christian doctrine of marriage when We are obliged once more to declare that the direct interruption of the generative process already begun and, above all, all direct abortion, even for therapeutic reasons, are to be absolutely excluded as lawful means of regulating the number of children. (14) Equally to be condemned, as the magisterium of the Church has affirmed on many occasions, is direct sterilization, whether of the man or of the woman, whether permanent or temporary. (15)

Similarly excluded is any action which either before, at the moment of, or after sexual intercourse, is specifically intended to prevent procreation—whether as an end or as a means. (16)

Neither is it valid to argue, as a justification for sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive, that a lesser evil is to be preferred to a greater one, or that such intercourse would merge with procreative acts of past and future to form a single entity, and so be qualified by exactly the same moral goodness as these. Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good," it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it (18)—in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general. Consequently, it is a serious error to think that a whole married life of otherwise normal relations can justify sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive and so intrinsically wrong. "

In both cases the issue is discussed of contraception is discussed regarding marriage.
And marriage comes with the “obligation of fidelity and fecundity.” And contraception is not in accord with the later, as it “requires a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality.”

A women raped is not required to give herself in personal totality. If anything, she is required to deny the attacker anything of her, which can be denied (therefore a gun is a good tool for her in such case). She does not falsify the inner truth of conjugal loveby using contraception, she denies part of her, which she is certainly allowed to do (and maybe even required because if a women does not resist the attaacker and deny herself in all possible ways, she might accidentally help him, which should be avoided).

Where is contraception in case of sex outside marriage discussed in the CCC?
You are trying to play games. The teaching on contraception does not refer to sex outside marriage because the Church also teaches that no sex is allowed outside marriage so your point is irrelevant.
As I asked before and no answer was give please show me where in the CCC, Canon Law or a Papal Encyclical does it specifically list rape as an exception to the teaching. What you have quoted above does not do this.
 
You are trying to play games. The teaching on contraception does not refer to sex outside marriage because the Church also teaches that no sex is allowed outside marriage so your point is irrelevant.
No, because if Church teaching only discusses the morality of contraception inside marriage and is silent about it outside marriage, your claim that Church teaches contraception is always forbidden is not supported, at least not by the passages discussing contraception inside marriage.
You claim was:
"The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception to prevent pregnancy is not allowed. "

From the passages i cited one can only support:
The Church teaching is clear in the CCC. The use of contraception inside marriage to prevent pregnancy is not allowed.

Just because the church teaches that under the circumstances A action B is evil, does not show that Church teaches that under circumstances non-A action B is evil as well.
As I asked before and no answer was give please show me where in the CCC, Canon Law or a Papal Encyclical does it specifically list rape as an exception to the teaching. What you have quoted above does not do this.
First you must show, that your claim, that Church teaches that contraception is also wrong outside marriage, is supported by CCC. Only then the need arises to check, whether there is again exception for certain cases e.g. rape. But your claim is so far unsupported.
 
From the USCCB, note specifically #36.

usccb.org/issues-and-action/human-life-and-dignity/health-care/upload/Ethical-Religious-Directives-Catholic-Health-Care-Services-fifth-edition-2009.pdf

From the National Catholic Bioethics Center

ncbcenter.org/page.aspx?pid=1314

Note specifically this part:
The issue of sexual assault is not addressed in the new bioethical document, Dignitas Personae, so sound moral reasoning has to be used to determine which protocol is morally acceptable for the administration of emergency contraceptive drugs.
Thistle, I did a very quick check of a few sources. You are correct…I don’t think well find something in Canon Law, the Catechism, or a Papal encyclical explicitly permitting emergency contraception in cases of rape. But, this bar seems to be too high of a standard and not in keeping with the tradition of sound moral theology and sound moral reasoning. The link above, well as the earlier one i provided for you quoting the bishops of the state of Connecticut, explicitly state that emergency contraception may be administered to rape victims.

Furthermore, like I said earlier, I know of no reputable moral theologian who would support your stance, not Bill May, not Janet Smith, not Germaine Grisez, not Christian Brugger, not Fr. Nicanor Austriaco, not Fr. Richard Giertech, not Fr. Tad Pacolzych (spelling?)…none.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top