The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Zundrah, the Eucharist IS important and it’s important for salvation too.

St Paul says that if you receive it without discerning the Body and Blood of our Lord, it will only harm you, and he goes on to say that people have even died this way!!

if you become Catholic, please don’t receive the Eucharist if you don’t believe in it 😦

please read all the links we gave you… why did you say you’re not interested in reading them? would you say there’s no possibility that you’re wrong about this?
I almost feel like giving up because it just really isn’t sinking in! But I hope I am wrong about this too. The thing is this; I don’t need the Eucharist to aid my faith in christ do I? So how can it be so seriously important if I have never needed it so far?
 
it’s not a wafer, it IS God. It’s Christ’s Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. It only LOOKS like a wafer.
In my church we worshipped God and Christ through prayer and bible study, a wafer wasn’t needed then so why would it be needed now? 🤷
 
Zundrah, did you know that when in John 6, Jesus tells us to eat His Body and Blood, the word He chose for “eating” was one that meant “chewing”? it signified the physical action of eating… not metaphorical. That’s why the disciples were scandalized and left Him.
LOL - it is also the reason why I am thinking it too… but it was a metaphore!
 
In my church we worshipped God and Christ through prayer and bible study, a wafer wasn’t needed then so why would it be needed now? 🤷
According to the Early CHurch FAthers is was needed…it was the reformers who profaned it by making it unholy.
 
According to the Early CHurch FAthers is was needed…it was the reformers who profaned it by making it unholy.
Shortly after Peter and John left the church (died), the catholic church started to change what they taught to the public. That is evident by the last few sentences of revelation! Why would John feel the need to tell the church not to add or to take away from the book of revelation unless he caught them doing it before or he was worried that they would do it!?
 
I almost feel like giving up because it just really isn’t sinking in! But I hope I am wrong about this too. The thing is this; I don’t need the Eucharist to aid my faith in christ do I? So how can it be so seriously important if I have never needed it so far?
Just as we need physical food to nourish the body, so also we need Christ in the Eucharist to nourish our Faith in Him.
You may want to take a break from this forum in order to allow this teaching to “sink in.” It is going in circles.
I would repeat what has already been stated. You are welcome to join us in worship any day of the week. If however, you do not accept the teachings of the Magisterium on this matter, please do not receive the Sacrament Confirmation which completes the initiation process. Your Baptism in the Methodist church remains valid…
Perhaps, as you continue RCIA, what the Church holds as true will “sink in” and you will start to believe. RCIA begins as inquiry. It is a time of learning and a time of formation. The final step is a public profession of faith in what the Catholic Church teaches. Do not take this final step until and unless you are able to do so in all honesty.
 
…back to the main point, the eucharist is superstition and the scripture “this is my body and blood” was just a metaphore.
Zundrah,
I see now you have not come here to try to believe in the truth of the Eucharist. You have come here to try to convince us of what you believe, that the Eucharist is just a metaphor. Possibly a remembrance of what Jesus did.
It’s not. You are sadly misled. That the Eucharist is a quite literal teaching of Jesus Christ was accpeted from the first century. Even as I showed you, John Wesley, the great Anglican priest who began Methodiam knew it was really His body and blood.
I showed you where great Christians from the 1st century, 2nd and 3rd century proclaimed the teaching of what Our Lord stated. It is Jesus Christ’s body and blood truly in the Eucharist.
You refuse to accept the historical basis. That is too bad. But worse you refuse to believe the Lord who is God and He declared it to be so.
Zundrah,
our Church welcomes those who ask questions. But for those who ask with the agenda of proving the Catholic Church errant in this most basic belief speaks to me that you are not looking to become Catholic. So why not simply find a Methodist (Anglican, Presbyterian, Lutheran etc) church which makes no requirement of you regarding this teaching?
For those of faith no provinence is needed. For those of no faith, no provenence is sufficient.
 
One of the other threads asks the question of what a person would do to protect the Blessed Sacrament. Would a person sacrifice his/her life if he/she thought the Eucharist was merely a metaphor?
Some denominations teach a “once saved, always saved” theology. Catholics recognize salvation as a process. We need continued growth and nourishment. As already stated, we are nourished by both the Word of God through scripture and by Christ himself in the form of bread and wine in the Eucharist. Bread and wine are made from basic elements of wheat and grapes that come from the earth. As Catholics, we believe these are changed during the Consecration, although not in appearance. This belief in the transubstantiation of bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ requires Faith.
Food that nourishes the physical body becomes part of that body. The spiritual food that is the Eucharist on the other hand has the ability to transform us.
We were saved when Christ died upon the cross. We continue to be saved each and every time the Mass is celebrated anywhere in the world until the end of time.
 
The following is quoted verbatim from A Scriptural Rosary from New Hope Publications. The Luminous Mysteries were added by Pope John Paul II. The Fifth Luminous Mystery is The Institution of the Eucharist:

A final mystery of light is the Institution of the Eucharist, in which Christ offers his body and blood as food under the signs of bread and wine, and testifies “to the end” his love for humanity (Jn. 13:1), for whose salvation he will offer himself in sacrifice. Rosarium Virginis Mariae

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church
Jesus gave the supreme expression of his free offering of himself at the meal shared with the twelve Apostles “on the night he was betrayed.” On the eve of his passion, while still free, Jesus transformed this Last Supper with the Apostles into the memorial of his voluntary offering to the Father for the salvation of men…[610]

The Eucharist that Christ institutes at that moment will be the memorial of his sacrifice, Jesus includes the apostles in his own offering and bids them perpetuate it. By doing so, the Lord institutes his apostles as priests of the New Covenant “For their sakes I sanctify myself, so that they also may be sanctified in truth.” [611]

The Church is born primarily of Christ’s total self-giving for our salvation, anticipated in the institution of the Eucharist and fulfilled on the cross. [766]

When the Church celebrates the Eucharist, she commemorates Christ’s passover, and it is made present: the sacrifice Christ offered once for all on the cross remains ever present. "As often as the sacrifice of the Cross by which ‘Christ our Pasch has been sacrificed’ is celebrated on the altar, the work of our redemption is carried on. [1364]
 
Shortly after Peter and John left the church (died), the catholic church started to change what they taught to the public. That is evident by the last few sentences of revelation! Why would John feel the need to tell the church not to add or to take away from the book of revelation unless he caught them doing it before or he was worried that they would do it!?
They did this for two reasons.
  1. Revelation is a difficult book to understand. Even today, it’s hard to find agreement in what it means. Part of the warning refers to the fact that if anything in the book was changed, it would make even less sense. Many of the prophecies won’t be understood until the end times. Many early Christians found the book so impossible to understand, that they simply left it out of the Bible. John was also challenging them to leave it in.
  2. It wasn’t the Catholic Church that was making serious changes to doctrine. It was the Catholic Church that was warning people about groups doing this. For example, Ignatius of Antioch, the student of John, warned about this in 110 AD, just ten years after John died. In addition, the Bible is FULL of warnings about false teachings. Those warnings were for several heretical splinter groups that broke off. The Bible speaks of Simon Magus (Simon “the Magician”) as someone to be careful of. He was a probable leader of the group known as the Gnostics. This group believed that the Bible contained a “secret code”, that only a few select individuals understood. ONLY those that learned the code would make it to heaven. Thus, heaven was restricted to a tiny few members of society, and morality didn’t matter. It didn’t matter if you were Mother Teresa or Adolf Hitler. If you cracked the code, you were in. The Gnostics were also famous for rejecting many books now used in the New Testament, and adding their own, including new gospels, like the Gospel of Thomas. These were written much later than the other gospels, and were forged in such a way as to make them support their own doctrines. THIS type of re-write is what was being warned about. (The Gnostics are somewhat similar to today’s Scientologists.)
The other two big groups that threatened early Christianity were the Docetists and the Arians. The Docetists believed that all matter was evil, and only spiritual things, like the soul, were good. Therefore, it didn’t matter if people sinned, cause it couldn’t be prevented anyway. It was impossible to change, so why try? Further, since the physical world was evil, God couldn’t become a human, because He couldn’t become evil, so Jesus was an “illusion”, and His death on the cross was just an illusion. He simply pretended to die, but actually felt no pain, and there was NO sacrifice for the forgiveness of sins. The Arians, on the other hand, denied the Trinity. They claimed that Jesus was JUST a man, and NOT the Son of God. He could ask God to do miracles (like Moses), but He had no powers of His own. (The Arians are somewhat similar to today’s Jehovah’s Witnesses.)

So, these are the three splinter groups that were historically around at that time. If the correct church ISN’T the Catholic Church (or the Orthodox Church), which of those three is, since those are the only other “Christian” groups that date to that era?
 
Just as an example of the “changing” of a text that John was warning about, here are the opening ten verses of the Gnostic Gospel of Thomas:
**
The Gospel of Thomas**

Here are the secret sayings which Jesus the Living spoke, and which Didymus Jude Thomas wrote down.

(1) And He said : “He who penetrates the meaning of these words will not taste death.”

(2) Jesus said : “Let him who seeks not cease to seek until he finds : when he finds, he will become troubled. When he is troubled, he will wonder, and he will reign over the All.”

(3) Jesus said : “If those who lead You say to You : ‘See, the Kingdom is in heaven !’, then the birds of the sky will be there before You. If they say to You, ‘It is in the sea !’, then the fish will be there before You. But the Kingdom is inside You and outside You. When You know yourselves, then You will be known, and You will know that You are the children of the Living Father. But if You do not know yourselves, then You dwell in poverty ; then You are that poverty.”

(4) Jesus said : “A person old in days will not hesitate to ask a child of seven days about the Place of Life, and he will live ! For many who are first will become last, and they will become one and the same.”

(5) Jesus said : “Know that what is before your face, and what is hidden from You will be revealed to You. For nothing hidden will fail to be revealed.”

(6) His disciples asked and said to Him : “Do You want us to fast ? How shall we pray and give alms ? What diet shall we observe ?” Jesus said : “Tell no lie and do not what You hate, for all things are plain in the face of Heaven. For nothing hidden will fail to be revealed, and nothing covered will remain without being uncovered.”

(7) Jesus said : “Fortunate is the lion which the man eats so that the lion becomes a man ; and cursed is the man whom the lion eats so that the man becomes a lion.”

(8) Then He said : “A man is like a wise fisherman who casts his net into the sea and drew it up from the sea full of small fish. Among them he found a fine large fish. The wise fisherman threw all the small fish back into the sea and chose the large fish without hesitation. He who has ears to hear, let him hear.”

(9) Jesus said : “See, the sower went out, filled his hand, and scattered the seed. Some fell on the road ; birds came and gathered them. Others fell on rocky ground, did not take root in the soil, and did not give ears of corn. And others fell among thorns ; they choked the seeds and worms ate them. And others fell on good soil and gave good fruit : it bore sixty per measure and a hundred and twenty per measure.”

(10) Jesus said : “I have cast fire upon the world, and see, I watch over it until it blazes up.”
 
Scripture Meditations
  1. Jesus said to them, “I am the bread of life; he who comes to me shall not hunger, and he who comes to me shall never thirst.” (Jn. 6:35)
  2. “For this is the will of my Father, that everyone who sees the Son and believes in him should have eternal life; and I will raise him up on the last day.” (Jn. 6:40)
  3. “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you.” (Jn. 6:53)
  4. “He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the the last day.” (Jn 6:54).
  5. Now before the feast of the Passover, when Jesus knew that his hour had come to depart out of this world to the Father, having loved his own who were in the world, he loved them to the end. (Jn. 13:1)
  6. And when the hour came, he sat at table, and the apostles with him. (Lk 22:19)
  7. And he took bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke it and gave it to them, saying, “This is my body which is given for you. Do this in remembrance of me.” (Lk. 22:19)
  8. And likewise the cup after supper, saying, “This cup which is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood.” (Lk. 22:20)
  9. As often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes. (1 Cor. 11:26)
  10. “And behold I am with you always until the end of the world.” (Mt. 28:20)
Fruit of the Mystery: Love for the Eucharist
 
In my church we worshipped God and Christ through prayer and bible study, a wafer wasn’t needed then so why would it be needed now? 🤷
As I suggested before, read The Early Church Fathers and The Mass of the Early Christians ie. long before Luther. In fact from the time of the Last Supper, early Jewish Christians celebrated the Mass in the form of a sedar,(which is what the Last Supper was) a community meal. Bread and wine was consumed as the Body and Blood of Christ. The apostles always believed and taught this, especially after Pentecost when the Holy Spirit increased their Faith and understanding.

In some Eastern rites, honey and milk was also given at communion on special occasions.
 
I almost feel like giving up because it just really isn’t sinking in! But I hope I am wrong about this too. The thing is this; I don’t need the Eucharist to aid my faith in christ do I? So how can it be so seriously important if I have never needed it so far?
A baby could ask the same thing at the time of weaning. 🙂

Jennifer, you started an earlier thread on the same topic and seemed to be making progress:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5501912&postcount=47

What happened between then and now to bring about this regression?
 
As I suggested before, read The Early Church Fathers and The Mass of the Early Christians ie. long before Luther. In fact from the time of the Last Supper, early Jewish Christians celebrated the Mass in the form of a sedar,(which is what the Last Supper was) a community meal. Bread and wine was consumed as the Body and Blood of Christ. The apostles always believed and taught this, especially after Pentecost when the Holy Spirit increased their Faith and understanding.

In some Eastern rites, honey and milk was also given at communion on special occasions.
I will second the recommendation of your book. It provides a great history lesson, as well as good historical evidence. I would add The Lamb’s Supper by Scott Hahn. It contains the best argument I can think of on the Eucharist and it’s Biblical basis. It’s where I’m drawing a lot of my responses from, actually.
 
I almost feel like giving up because it just really isn’t sinking in! But I hope I am wrong about this too. The thing is this; I don’t need the Eucharist to aid my faith in christ do I? So how can it be so seriously important if I have never needed it so far?
Never give up.Faith is a journey and lots of time there are stop signs,u-turns and traffic that is confusing.Doubt is apart of faith.there is an ancient Buddhist saying that goes"little doubt, little faith.Big doubt, big faith.“And it’s very true.
I think that what got people’s goats was the use of the word “superstition” for the Eucharist.It seems like a lack of basic respect for something so sacred to us.I would never use the word superstition as far as anyone’s belief.I think it fosters misunderstanding and blocks true understanding.
Having said that I think many people have difficulty understanding the Real Presence.As it was with the disciples it is with many people.
What do we believe in as Catholics?We believe in John3:16.We believe in the Gift of the Holy Spirit.We believe in Jesus’ grace, His goodness,His love,His salvic work, His abiding presence.
A sacred meal was an essential part of Judaism and Christianity.Most sacrifices were not oblations(entirely consumed). The choicest parts went to the Lord but the rest of the meat wascooked and consumed in a sacred meal.Covenants were sealed with a sacred meal ,binding al lto the god and to each other.
Inchristianity the eArliest practice was to go to the temple on Saturday and Sunday to go to the agape meal A meal that ties us to God and to each other. To us the Eucharist is one more Gift,an abiding physical presence-that is what I meant about Love and the Eucharist.A love so wide wonderful beyond all constraints, beyond thought or cultural prejudices, a love unbound by human limitations, beyond human understanding.
I teach and serve at a very large church- so I am an Extraordinary minister of the Eucharist.When I give out the Eucharist,I see pain and anxieties and I say to myself as I distribute the host,“this is love that I’m handing to them, this is healing.”
Then I see people who are full of anticipation and joy,and I see bread and food for their journey-fortifying ,intense ,sustaining &life giving. I also see those who don’t get it who are rather blank and I think"they really don’t know what they are missing” and i feel sad for them.
When I go into other churches, I look , I see their beauty, I respect them- but I don’t ‘feel’ anything. Our church feels like that after the Eucharist is removed during Holy week.It’s still beautiful but empty.Where the Tabernacle is ,where the Eucharist is where the “Presence” is felt is where He is in the Flesh.
Peace be with you now and forever.
 
Never give up.Faith is a journey and lots of time there are stop signs,u-turns and traffic that is confusing.Doubt is apart of faith.there is an ancient Buddhist saying that goes"little doubt, little faith.Big doubt, big faith.“And it’s very true.
I think that what got people’s goats was the use of the word “superstition” for the Eucharist.It seems like a lack of basic respect for something so sacred to us.I would never use the word superstition as far as anyone’s belief.I think it fosters misunderstanding and blocks true understanding.
Having said that I think many people have difficulty understanding the Real Presence.As it was with the disciples it is with many people.
What do we believe in as Catholics?We believe in John3:16.We believe in the Gift of the Holy Spirit.We believe in Jesus’ grace, His goodness,His love,His salvic work, His abiding presence.
A sacred meal was an essential part of Judaism and Christianity.Most sacrifices were not oblations(entirely consumed). The choicest parts went to the Lord but the rest of the meat wascooked and consumed in a sacred meal.Covenants were sealed with a sacred meal ,binding al lto the god and to each other.
Inchristianity the eArliest practice was to go to the temple on Saturday and Sunday to go to the agape meal A meal that ties us to God and to each other. To us the Eucharist is one more Gift,an abiding physical presence-that is what I meant about Love and the Eucharist.A love so wide wonderful beyond all constraints, beyond thought or cultural prejudices, a love unbound by human limitations, beyond human understanding.
I teach and serve at a very large church- so I am an Extraordinary minister of the Eucharist.When I give out the Eucharist,I see pain and anxieties and I say to myself as I distribute the host,“this is love that I’m handing to them, this is healing.”
Then I see people who are full of anticipation and joy,and I see bread and food for their journey-fortifying ,intense ,sustaining &life giving. I also see those who don’t get it who are rather blank and I think"they really don’t know what they are missing” and i feel sad for them.
When I go into other churches, I look , I see their beauty, I respect them- but I don’t ‘feel’ anything. Our church feels like that after the Eucharist is removed during Holy week.It’s still beautiful but empty.Where the Tabernacle is ,where the Eucharist is where the “Presence” is felt is where He is in the Flesh.
Peace be with you now and forever.
This sacred meal binding God and man brings us back to the Fifth Luminous Mystery of the Holy Rosary of the Blessed Virgin Mary which is the Institution of the Eucharist.
And He took bread, and when He had given thanks, He broke it and gave it to them saying “This is My body which is given to you”…And likewise the cup after supper, saying, “This cup which is poured out for you is the new covenant in My blood.” (Luke 22: 19-20)
We love because God first loved us and it is this love which leads us to adoration.
The Eucharist is the source and summit of Catholic faith. It is at the heart of all that we believe.
On Holy Thursday, the Eucharist is removed and the altar laid bare. The Eucharist may be moved to a special place such as a side chapel where the faithful gather to “spend an hour” with our Lord. We are reminded of the question Christ asked his disciples when he found them asleep after praying in the Garden of Gethsemane.
If you hear about a person spending a Holy Hour, it is this hour spent in adoration before the Holy Eucharist to which they are referring.
 
I will second the recommendation of your book. It provides a great history lesson, as well as good historical evidence. I would add The Lamb’s Supper by Scott Hahn. It contains the best argument I can think of on the Eucharist and it’s Biblical basis. It’s where I’m drawing a lot of my responses from, actually.
I haven’t read anything by Scott Hahn, but know of good things about him. I will check on The Lamb’s Supper. Thanks for reminding me.,
 
I haven’t read anything by Scott Hahn, but know of good things about him. I will check on The Lamb’s Supper. Thanks for reminding me.,
Something to tak into consideration about hios book: Dr. Hahn does not say that Revelation is just about the Mass! It is also about historical events. It is also an apocolyptic vision. It is also about the good vs. evil struggle of Chriastian life. It is all of these things.
 
Of course, I’m a ‘cradle’ Catholic (though my father was Episcopalian and my one grandmother converted from the Lutheran faith when she married my Catholic grandfather, and we won’t even get into what my sibs, cousins etc. have come up with in the last 40 years, let’s just say that I have heard basically every argument one could think of ‘agin’ Catholicism from those whose opinions I may disagree with but whose personal integrity and honesty is without question).

But even had I come from a nonCatholic background, when in my reading of the history of Christianity I had come across the unquestioned certainty, the FACT, that the early Christians all the way from the time of Christ until the 16th century, had believed in the Real Presence --when in my reading of the Bible I read John 6 and saw that not only was the original language regarding the ‘eating of the flesh’ specifically given as ‘chew or gnaw’, and that, unlike any other part in the New Testament where Christ had spoken ‘symbolically’ the context made it clear that it was symbolic, and that He specifically EXPLAINED the passages in question to His apostles when this was so – but did nothing of the kind here and even asked His apostles if THEY would go away too–

I would believe in the Real Presence. The evidence is so much in the favor of this being true and authentic Christian teaching. . .and the evidence is extremely, exceptionally clear the other way too – that this teaching of ‘metaphor’ and ‘symbolism’ is equally that of human MEN, long, long after the teaching of Christ, unpracticed by Christians throughout history UNTIL these men came along, unaccepted even by those who protest Catholic teachings on OTHER subjects, and above all unsupported by Scriptural evidence. . .that unless I was willing to argue against it only because, "if it IS true then the Protestant faith of a symbolic Eucharist I’m professing is false’. . .there is no way a reasonable and rational person would NOT accept the doctrine of the Real Presence.

But I fear the case here is very much of that stamp. Once accept that something your Church teaches is ‘wrong’ and the Catholic teaching is right–and the whole case ‘against’ Catholicism will crumble, slowly, inexorably. And that must be terrifying, especially to the very sincerely religious person.

To be at the point where one knows that ‘something’ is just not right in one’s own faith–yet to be afraid of accepting that the other faith is true because then one must make a final stand, make the leap. . .and accept all the other things that one has so far ‘swept under the rug’ because until a decision is made they need not be ‘thought of’. . .must be terrifying. One would feel rudderless, afraid that one is making the ‘wrong’ decision. One would start to feel more fond memories of one’s ‘Protestant’ church, thinking of all the fine and decent people it contained. . .and contrast that to the "Catholic Church’ with all of its supposed inequities and its abusing priests, ‘idolatrous’ laity, and ‘mean posters’. . .and then one would grasp at the tiniest of straws. All it would take is one ‘nasty poster’ to (for now) convince the skeptic that “I was right, Catholics are awful and THEREFORE the Real presence is bunk.” And then even more frantically one would keep on repeating all the canards, all the ‘you’re wrong’, even at the end , "you’re evil’ remarks, remarks made to shore up the still wavering and terrified ‘decision’.

You’d think it would only take one ‘nice poster’ to work the other way, but unfortunately in a situation like this, while one ‘nasty’ person can make the waverer jump back, you need at least one HUNDRED nice posters to make any sort of dent. Humanity is like that. You could go outside and have 100 men tell you you looked beautiful, and one man say you looked awful, and most women would be more influenced by the ONE NEGATIVE VOTE.

So let’s keep praying.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top