The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks, I will run through these now. But why are you making so much effort for me? I thought that you gave up on me?
No I never said I gave up. On another thread I said “But it is probable that it is not necessary to feel you need to convince her of Catholic teachings” in light of your insistence that “Religion and life are two different things.”
But on this thread you asked a theological question. So I am still here.
 
The whole liturgical life of the Church revolves around the Eucharistic sacrifice and the sacraments (CCC1113).
The Holy Eucharist is central to what we believe. The readings of today’s Mass (the 19th Sunday in Ordinary Time) all point to this reality.
As an RCIA candidate, do you have a copy of the United States Catholic Catechism for Adults? If so, please read chapter 17 which is all about this Sacrament that completes Christian initiation.
To call the Eucharist a fallacy is to call my personal faith a fallacy. As St. Paul said if what we believe is untrue, then we are indeed the most pitiful of persons.

The following are excerpts from the Guidelines for the Reception of Communion

*As Catholics, we fully participate in the celebration of the Eucharist when we receive Holy Communion. We are encouraged to receive Communion devoutly and frequently…

For Our Fellow Christians
We welcome our fellow Christians to this celebration of the Eucharist as our brothers and sisters. We pray that our common baptism and the action of the Holy Spirit in this Eucharist will draw us closer to one another and begin to dispel the sad divisions which separate us. We pray that these will lessen and finally disappear, in keeping with Christ’s prayer for us “that they all may be one.”

Because Catholics believe that the celebration of the Eucharist is a sign of the reality of the oneness of faith, life and worship, members of those churches with whom we are not yet fully united are ordinarily not admitted to Holy Communion…*

“All my other senses, cannot now perceive,
But my hearing, taught by faith, always will believe:
I accept whatever God the Son has said:
Those who hear the Word of God, by the truth are fed”.–St. Auquinas

If belief in the Divine Presence of Jesus Christ in the Holy Eucharist continues to be an obstacle, I suggest that you talk to the parish priest of the Catholic Church where you have been attending Mass.
Faith is hope in that which is not yet seen.
Just as the cross appears as an absurdity for those who do not believe, I suppose we could say the same is true for the Eucharist, the source and summit of our Faith.
I can understand what you are saying but …the eucharist is just ridiculous! :eek: (I said it…) How can you expect me to believe that a wafer will make me more of a christian if I have never needed it all my life!? 🤷
 
No I never said I gave up. On another thread I said “But it is probable that it is not necessary to feel you need to convince her of Catholic teachings” in light of your insistence that “Religion and life are two different things.”
But on this thread you asked a theological question. So I am still here.
You are confusing me… Why did you come on to my thread about child abuse and say to every this; “it is probable that it is not necessary to feel you need to convince her of Catholic teachings”
It seemed quite nasty to me…
 
I can understand what you are saying but …the eucharist is just ridiculous! :eek: (I said it…) How can you expect me to believe that a wafer will make me more of a christian if I have never needed it all my life!? 🤷
If you truly believe that the Eucharist is “ridiculous.” then it truly is a stumbling block to your faith and what the Catholic Church holds as true. I will repeat what I have said before, until and unless you can accept the truth of Christ in the Holy Eucharist, then do not make the final profession of faith that would bring you into full communion with the Catholic Church.
There are other separated denominations, such as the Mennonites and other Anabaptists, which deny the efficacy of the Sacraments.

In today’s gospel reading, the people of Nazareth saw only the human son of Mary and Joseph. They did not recognize as the Messiah. When you see the Host, all you see is a wafer or a piece of bread. What I see is the Bread of Life come down from heaven. I see Jesus Christ.
 
If you truly believe that the Eucharist is “ridiculous.” then it truly is a stumbling block to your faith and what the Catholic Church holds as true. I will repeat what I have said before, until and unless you can accept the truth of Christ in the Holy Eucharist, then do not make the final profession of faith that would bring you into full communion with the Catholic Church.
There are other separated denominations, such as the Mennonites and other Anabaptists, which deny the efficacy of the Sacraments.
But when next easter comes and my priest wants to comfirm me, what do i say to him!? :(🤷 I am worried because i don’t want to make a fuss by telling him at the last minite that I don’t believe in the eucharist (probably just as he puts the wafer in my mouth!) :eek:
 
Here are some things to consider…

What did all the offerings and animal sacrifices that the ancient Israelites were required to give mean? Well, there were several meanings:
  1. It was a recognition of God’s sovereignty over creation: “The earth is the Lord’s” (Ps 24:1). Man acknowledged this fact by giving back to God what is ultimately His. Thus, sacrifice praised God from Whom all blessings flow.
  2. A sacrifice could be an act of thanks. Creation is given to man as a gift, but what return can man make to God (see Ps 116:12)? We can only give back what we ourselves have received.
  3. Sometimes, sacrifice served as a way of solemnly sealing an agreement or oath, a covenant before God (see Gen 21:22-32).
  4. Sacrifice could also be an act of renunciation and sorrow for sins. The person offering sacrifice recognized that his sins deserved death; he offered the animal’s life in place of his own.
Ponder this for a little while, and then I’ll show you where I’m going with it.
 
But when next easter comes and my priest wants to comfirm me, what do i say to him!? :(🤷 I am worried because i don’t want to make a fuss by telling him at the last minite that I don’t believe in the eucharist (probably just as he puts the wafer in my mouth!) :eek:
Don’t wait until the last minute. Tell him now that you have difficulty with this aspect of the Catholic Faith.

I edited my last post after your reply. In today’s gospel reading, the people of Nazareth saw only the human son of Mary and Joseph. They did not recognize the Messiah. They did not see the bread of life come down from heaven. As you read the story of Jesus in his hometown, you find that He could perform few miracles because of their lack of faith and disbelief.
What you see as merely bread, as a wafer, I see as the Bread of Life come down from heaven. I see Jesus Christ. I see the gift that He has given us, the gift of Himself on the Cross. I see the cup of the New Covenant.

You have just begun your journey. You may need to take a break from this thread in order for the truth to “sink in.” . Read the links and related materials provided. Do not expect to understand everything in one sitting. Faith is a lifelong journey.
 
But when next easter comes and my priest wants to comfirm me, what do i say to him!? :(🤷 I am worried because i don’t want to make a fuss by telling him at the last minite that I don’t believe in the eucharist (probably just as he puts the wafer in my mouth!) :eek:
The Catholic Church requires such a long period of study before entering the church precisely because it wants people to truly know and understand what Catholicism teaches, and then to believe it of their own accord, not because they’re telling you to. If you cannot do that, you may back out of RCIA at any time, even up to the final day. You are free to re-enroll in RCIA and continue your studying, and you’d just be confirmed when you are ready. I’ve seen it happen, and they won’t say anything.

That said, you should know whether you’re ready to convert well before the Easter Vigil Mass is underway…
 
The Catholic Church requires such a long period of study before entering the church precisely because it wants people to truly know and understand what Catholicism teaches, and then to believe it of their own accord, not because they’re telling you to. If you cannot do that, you may back out of RCIA at any time, even up to the final day. You are free to re-enroll in RCIA and continue your studying, and you’d just be confirmed when you are ready. I’ve seen it happen, and they won’t say anything.

That said, you should know whether you’re ready to convert well before the Easter Vigil Mass is underway…
They have already forgotten who I am on a few occasions; they have almost given me the wafer but I stopped them by putting my arm over my chest and tilting my head down for the blessing.
 
They have already forgotten who I am on a few occasions; they have almost given me the wafer but I stopped them by putting my arm over my chest and tilting my head down for the blessing.
Well, you did the right thing. I’m a professor, and it’s hard enough for me to learn the names of 100 new students each semester. I can’t imagine having to try to learn the names of the thousands of people within most parishes! Such things can happen.
 
Well, you did the right thing. I’m a professor, and it’s hard enough for me to learn the names of 100 new students each semester. I can’t imagine having to try to learn the names of the thousands of people within most parishes! Such things can happen.
But people on CAF have stressed to me that i could die if i take the Eucharist while not believing? Is this true? 🤷
 
They have already forgotten who I am on a few occasions; they have almost given me the wafer but I stopped them by putting my arm over my chest and tilting my head down for the blessing.
How many people are in the church? When a person approaches, the natural assumption is that they are in line to receive the Eucharist. You are right to cross you arms over your chest for a blessing. You might consider not waiting. I have seen people walk completely up the aisle with their arms over their chest. That way it is seen immediately. Many of us who receive Holy Communion on a regular basis have been taught to walk with our hands in prayer position. If that is how you are approaching the person distributing Communion, then, yes, it can create confusion.
Now, while I say you are right in approaching with arms cross, other posters will tell you to remain in your seat and not even approach the altar. It is a discussion that has been exhausted on other threads. Do what your priest tells you.

When I was visiting other churches in my small town in WI, many thought I belonged to them. When asked if I was going to participate in a particular social event, I would have to ask for which church.
 
How many people are in the church? When a person approaches, the natural assumption is that they are in line to receive the Eucharist. You are right to cross you arms over your chest for a blessing. You might consider not waiting. I have seen people walk completely up the aisle with their arms over their chest. That way it is seen immediately. Many of us who receive Holy Communion on a regular basis have been taught to walk with our hands in prayer position. If that is how you are approaching the person distributing Communion, then, yes, it can create confusion.
Now, while I say you are right in approaching with arms cross, other posters will tell you to remain in your seat and not even approach the altar. It is a discussion that has been exhausted on other threads. Do what your priest tells you.
This is a big shock to me!
other posters will tell you to remain in your seat and not even approach the altar
Personaly I know for a fact that my priest would be upset if I didn’t go up at communion. He wants me to go up. 😃

xxx zundrah xxx
 
But people on CAF have stressed to me that i could die if i take the Eucharist while not believing? Is this true? 🤷
Not in the literal sense. It is, however, considered to be a sacrilige and a mortal sin to receive the Eucharist unworthily. Even the Didache, the earliest non-Biblical Christian document, written while the Apostles were still alive as a type of early Catechism, speaks to this.

From the Didache (written around 70 AD):

9:5 And let none eat or drink of your Eucharist but such as have been baptized into the name of the Lord, for of a truth the Lord hath said concerning this, Give not that which is holy unto dogs.

14:1 But on the Lord’s day, after that ye have assembled together, break bread and give thanks, having in addition confessed your sins, that your sacrifice may be pure.

14:2 But let not any one who hath a quarrel with his companion join with you, until they be reconciled, that your sacrifice may not be polluted,

14:3 for it is that which is spoken of by the Lord. In every place and time offer unto me a pure sacrifice, for I am a great King, saith the Lord, and my name is wonderful among the Gentiles.

So, some of the earliest requirements for receiving the Eucharist were that you had to be baptized in the faith, you could not have a mortal sin on your soul (you had to go to confession first), and you had to believe what the church taught (“let not any one who hath a quarrel with his companion join with you, until they be reconciled” is talking about his Christian companion).
 
How many people are in the church? When a person approaches, the natural assumption is that they are in line to receive the Eucharist. You are right to cross you arms over your chest for a blessing. You might consider not waiting. I have seen people walk completely up the aisle with their arms over their chest. That way it is seen immediately. Many of us who receive Holy Communion on a regular basis have been taught to walk with our hands in prayer position. If that is how you are approaching the person distributing Communion, then, yes, it can create confusion.
Now, while I say you are right in approaching with arms cross, other posters will tell you to remain in your seat and not even approach the altar. It is a discussion that has been exhausted on other threads. Do what your priest tells you.

When I was visiting other churches in my small town in WI, many thought I belonged to them. When asked if I was going to participate in a particular social event, I would have to ask for which church.
Some people here at CAF have even told me not to to go to catholic church!? And they said that catholicism isn’t right for me!!! :eek: Some people say and think very strange things… I have even been told; “go back to your methodist church”. The people in my church didn’t say this to me, but catholics here on CAF have said it to me quite a few times… 😦 That’s odd since they say that the catholic church is the one true church… (hypocrits)…
 
By the way, isn’t it interesting how the Didache speaks of the Eucharist as a sacrifice, not as a symbol? This is the oldest existing non-forged Christian document besides the Bible. It was written while the Apostles were alive. The only reason it didn’t make it into the Bible (and MANY early Christians DID included it) was because it was considered primarily as an instruction manual for those new to the faith, rather than as something inspired in and of itself. Almost all scholars agree that the document is authentic.
 
By the way, isn’t it interesting how the Didache speaks of the Eucharist as a sacrifice, not as a symbol? This is the oldest existing non-forged Christian document besides the Bible. It was written while the Apostles were alive. The only reason it didn’t make it into the Bible (and MANY early Christians DID included it) was because it was considered primarily as an instruction manual for those new to the faith, rather than as something inspired in and of itself. Almost all scholars agree that the document is authentic.
I read John chapter six (as told to by my priest) but it didn’t convince me about the Eucharist.

P.S. I am sorry for not spelling Eucharist with a capital E. I will from now on.
 
Some people here at CAF have even told me not to to go to catholic church!? And they said that catholicism isn’t right for me!!! :eek: Some people say and think very strange things… I have even been told; “go back to your methodist church”. The people in my church didn’t say this to me, but catholics here on CAF have said it to me quite a few times… 😦 That’s odd since they say that the catholic church is the one true church… (hypocrits)…
What they have meant is that belief in the Eucharist is absolutely central to the Catholic faith. The Eucharist is the whole point of the Mass, NOT the homily. Virtually all Catholic worship is centered on it. If you cannot believe in this MOST critical doctrine, then it would be very hard for you to be a good practicing Catholic. That’s what people are trying to say.

It’s like saying “I believe in EVERY SINGLE law in the United States, and I want to be an American… except for that ONE law on free speech. I’m going to crack down at work and make sure no one who disagrees with me can express their ideas, and I’m going to make sure my business is biased toward my views.” Now, they may indeed be an American citizen, but they’re going to have a VERY hard time functioning within the restrictions of our society. They may not end up very happy in the end.
 
What they have meant is that belief in the Eucharist is absolutely central to the Catholic faith. The Eucharist is the whole point of the Mass, NOT the homily. Virtually all Catholic worship is centered on it. If you cannot believe in this MOST critical doctrine, then it would be very hard for you to be a good practicing Catholic. That’s what people are trying to say.

It’s like saying “I believe in EVERY SINGLE law in the United States, and I want to be an American… except for that ONE law on free speech. I’m going to crack down at work and make sure no one who disagrees with me can express their ideas, and I’m going to make sure my business is biased toward my views.” Now, they may indeed be an American citizen, but they’re going to have a VERY hard time functioning within the restrictions of our society. They may not end up very happy in the end.
But I will never believe in the Eucharist…
 
But I will never believe in the Eucharist…
If you are willing to try and accept the doctrine, and continue to study on it, then Catholicism may be right for you. If your problem was in the explanation of HOW the miracle happens, I might actually refer you to the Orthodox Church, since they simply leave the process as a mystery, although they believe in the Real Presence as fiercely as Catholics do. (Priests for both faiths have actually died rather than let people profane the Eucharist, even in the recent past.)

If you truly believe that you will never accept the doctrine, it would be very hard for you to be a Catholic. The Mass, the very center of our Catholic worship, would mean nothing to you. Spiritual events like Adoration would become meaningless. It would affect your belief in the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick, since it involves the Eucharist. Your beliefs would be acceptable in something like the Anglican Church, where the Real Presence is an optional belief, but there again, some of your more Catholic beliefs would probably be in conflict with them.

This is indeed a spiritual issue that you will have to study and pray about a great deal.

All I can say is that the majority of Christians interpret the Bible literally on this point. The passage CAN be interpreted either way. But that said…
Virtually ALL documents from the earliest days of Christianity profess a belief in the Real Presence. Even the pagan ROMANS knew that Christians believed this, and criticized them for it! No one seriously challenged the doctrine for about 1200 years.

So, if you’re studying the evidence one way or another, it’s all stacked on one side of the issue. I find it hard to discount it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top