But I will never believe in the Eucharist…
If you are willing to try and accept the doctrine, and continue to study on it, then Catholicism may be right for you. If your problem was in the explanation of HOW the miracle happens, I might actually refer you to the Orthodox Church, since they simply leave the process as a mystery, although they believe in the Real Presence as fiercely as Catholics do. (Priests for both faiths have actually
died rather than let people profane the Eucharist, even in the recent past.)
If you truly believe that you will
never accept the doctrine, it would be
very hard for you to be a Catholic. The Mass, the very center of our Catholic worship, would mean nothing to you. Spiritual events like Adoration would become meaningless. It would affect your belief in the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick, since it involves the Eucharist. Your beliefs would be acceptable in something like the Anglican Church, where the Real Presence is an optional belief, but there again, some of your more Catholic beliefs would probably be in conflict with them.
This is indeed a spiritual issue that you will have to study and pray about a
great deal.
All I can say is that the
majority of Christians interpret the Bible literally on this point. The passage CAN be interpreted either way. But that said…
Virtually ALL documents from the earliest days of Christianity profess a belief in the Real Presence. Even the pagan ROMANS knew that Christians believed this, and criticized them for it! No one seriously challenged the doctrine for about 1200 years.
So, if you’re studying the evidence one way or another, it’s all stacked on one side of the issue. I find it hard to discount it.