E
elts1956
Guest
You betcha. :extrahappy:I see, so this is just fun for you?
You betcha. :extrahappy:I see, so this is just fun for you?
I see, so this is just fun for you?
Catholics have a completely different definition of the word “Church” than Protestants, however. In order to be an actual “Church”, a denomination must have two things:But you catholics call our denominations a church without a capital C even though you will say; Roman Catholic Church with a capital C… Is that not offensive to me that you call my church a denomination rather then to recognise it as a Church?
…great, I’m glad you have found a way to delight your soul. How about some more poison from you, I’m feeling empty, so why don’t you spray me with more venom.You betcha. :extrahappy:
Did not!:tanning:Wrong, you did pray for me!I can feel it!
Or is my faith lying to me again?
To the Father, the Lord all Mighty;Catholics have a completely different definition of the word “Church” than Protestants, however. In order to be an actual “Church”, a denomination must have two things:
By this definition, the Eastern Orthodox Churches, the Oriental Orthodox Churches, the Assyrian Church of the East, The Polish National Catholic Church, and the “Old Catholic” Church are true Churches. They are the only other groups that fulfill these two requirements currently. All others are referred to technically as “Ecclesial Communities”, since they are most definitely “Christian”, but not actually a hierarchical church with a structure traced back to the Apostles. That said, most WILL be referred to as churches with a lower-case “c” out of politeness.
- Apostolic Succession. That means it’s clergy must be able to directly demonstrate that they were appointed by a successor of the Apostles. In other words, Peter appointed Linus as a bishop, who appointed Cletus, who appointed Clement, and so on… all the way down to Benedict XVI.
- A belief in the Real Presence at Communion.
ROLLTIDE #190
And I agree with him completely.
Wrong, you did pray for me!I can feel it!
Or is my faith lying to me again?
Obviously, when will you admit it? Venomnize? YOU??? Aw shucks.…great, I’m glad you have found a way to delight your soul. How about some more poison from you, I’m feeling empty, so why don’t you spray me with more venom.
Christ is our only joy and happiness, after; evreything good is from christ. So I guess your point of view is obviously right.
I’m not asking you to come in without skepticism! That would indeed be foolish. But many of your statements here have simply said “Communion IS symbolic”, rather than saying, "I’m open to the possibility that you are correct, but you’re going to have to convince me, and here’s what it will take. And sure, you can refute us back, but it should be more along the lines of, “Here’s what I was always taught about the Eucharist being symbolic, and your opinion has failed to convince me”, or “You made a good point there. It’s not enough to convince me, but I see your argument. Could you elaborate?” Something like that would be helpful.But if i just came in an open mind then I would have already been misslead by mormons… as they ask me to do the same thing too.
I enjoy winding up Catholics too. Just whacky old me.:whacky:To the Father, the Lord all Mighty;
I need your son,
you’re my everything.
Do you often enjoy winding up protestants?
Well, I will pray for you instead then.Did not!:tanning:
So do I, thank you for yur help Rolltide.I’m not asking you to come in without skepticism! That would indeed be foolish. But many of your statements here have simply said “Communion IS symbolic”, rather than saying, "I’m open to the possibility that you are correct, but you’re going to have to convince me, and here’s what it will take. And sure, you can refute us back, but it should be more along the lines of, “Here’s what I was always taught about the Eucharist being symbolic, and your opinion has failed to convince me”, or “You made a good point there. It’s not enough to convince me, but I see your argument. Could you elaborate?” Something like that would be helpful.
It does seem to me that the point you’re struggling most with is “Why is the Eucharist necessary?” “How does the sacrament help people?” What is accomplished by the Real Presence, at least with regard to our salvation?" “Why is it not enough that we just believe in Jesus?”
I’m NOT abandoning this thread, but I HAVE to get up and work tomorrow, so I must go to bed. I will respond further in the morning.
You are always free to PM me, btw. I hope you have a good day, and I hope your spiritual journey takes a turn for the better!
How long have you been catholic? (note how I use a lower case c now.)Obviously, when will you admit it? Venomnize? YOU??? Aw shucks.
I find that annoying mormons is much more fun.I enjoy winding up Catholics too. Just whacky old me.:whacky:
So please tell me what is so fun here?You betcha. :extrahappy:
Okay, the reason I highlighted my name is that “salty” is a term for people who use, shall we say, colorful language. It comes from sailors having fairly foul mouths.Your name is nothing to me, as is mine nothing to you. I don’t appreciate it when some one swears at me, what ever their name is.
…back to the main point, the eucharist is superstition and the scripture “this is my body and blood” was just a metaphore.Okay, the reason I highlighted my name is that “salty” is a term for people who use, shall we say, colorful language. It comes from sailors having fairly foul mouths.
And for the record, the “swear word” you accuse me of in PM starts with CR and ends with P. CAF just censors that word, so that was why you saw asterisks.
it’s not a wafer, it IS God. It’s Christ’s Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. It only LOOKS like a wafer.Hmm, you want me to bow down to a wafer and treat it like God or something!?
While the basic truths of Catholic Faith are indeed simple, there is a depth that cannot be fathomed in a single day. God is unfathomable. The more we learn, the more we discover we need to learn and grow in the faith that we have been given.I would hope not. However, you are at the very beginning of a faith journey that will take your whole life. I’m 38, and I learn new things about Catholicism every day! I know FAR from everything about Christianity. However, I’m always willing to learn with an open mind about my faith.
The situation is complicated, but take heart in that MANY have dealt with your situation before and successfully come to a resolution.
It is indeed a blessing that you felt the presence of God in the Catholic Church. What may be necessary for the next step is to do what Jesus commanded - to just drop everything, and follow Him where He leads. Don’t expect to understand Communion in a day.
Why don’t you let us work through all three ways of convincing you, and see where we end up after that? Remember to look at the evidence with an open mind. If you’re simply going to refuse to hear evidence, we can’t really do much, can we? We understand that a single fact is NOT going to convince you. Much like a court case, it’s going to take an overwhelming number of facts, taken together as a whole, to convince you beyond reasonable doubt.