The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But I will never believe in the Eucharist…
Never say never.

Meditate on what Jesus tells his disciples in John 6. Consider the miracle of the multiplication of the loaves as a pre-cursor to the Eucharist. Read each of the Eucharistic institution narratives in Matthew, Mark, Luke, and in 1 Corinthians 11.

Especially meditate on Paul’s warnings to the Corinthians about receiving the Eucharist unworthily (1 Cor 11:27ff), and think about why such dire warnings would be needed about consuming a piece of bread unworthily.

Consider how on the road to Emmaus, the two disciples did not recognize him as he walked with them, but they finally did recognize him “in the breaking of the bread.”

Finally, consider that for the first 1,500 years of Christianity, no one doubted the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. It was and is and always has been a universal belief handed down from the Apostles.
 
Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you.
You ask if you have life within you. No one but God can answer. We do have what Jesus said.

Another has asked you provide proof that it is a metaphor. There is much proof that it was not. Where is your reasoning, not statement, that it is a metaphor?

Definition
1 a : a belief or practice resulting from ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation 2 : a notion maintained despite evidence to the contrary
Our belief does not fit the definition of superstition. To have one of our central belief of faith to be so labeled is an insult. I do encourage you to keep studying. It is obvious in reading this thread that you have little knowledge of the Bible or history. It is this lack of knowledge that plagues you. You ask you have gotten by without the Eucharist. How do you know what your life would be With the Eucharist? Jesus said it was necessary of course the devil wants you to believe otherwise. To give an example, a person can survive on candy and coffee. If they had no knowledge of good healthy food they would believe the same as you that they have survived so why do they need the healthy food?
God Bless you in your journey and I will add you to my prayers tonight.
 
It suddenly dawned on me that I have an idea for a new approach.

Ok, let’s try this.

What do you think the early church was like… say, from the death of Jesus to about 400 AD. Like, can you give me the highlights, major events, problems, and so on.

What I’m suspecting is that you have some misconceptions that might be coloring your opinion, but I could be wrong. But, if that’s the case, as a professional historian, I can shed some light on those.
 
Never say never.

Meditate on what Jesus tells his disciples in John 6. Consider the miracle of the multiplication of the loaves as a pre-cursor to the Eucharist. Read each of the Eucharistic institution narratives in Matthew, Mark, Luke, and in 1 Corinthians 11.

Especially meditate on Paul’s warnings to the Corinthians about receiving the Eucharist unworthily (1 Cor 11:27ff), and think about why such dire warnings would be needed about consuming a piece of bread unworthily.

Consider how on the road to Emmaus, the two disciples did not recognize him as he walked with them, but they finally did recognize him “in the breaking of the bread.”

Finally, consider that for the first 1,500 years of Christianity, no one doubted the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. It was and is and always has been a universal belief handed down from the Apostles.
But it is only bible scripture interpritations that makes one believe in the Eucharist actually becoming Christ body; hence that I don’t believe in it now…
 
It suddenly dawned on me that I have an idea for a new approach.

Ok, let’s try this.

What do you think the early church was like… say, from the death of Jesus to about 400 AD. Like, can you give me the highlights, major events, problems, and so on.

What I’m suspecting is that you have some misconceptions that might be coloring your opinion, but I could be wrong. But, if that’s the case, as a professional historian, I can shed some light on those.
The church was probably catholic still; with out any “split-offs” like protestant denominations, right?
 
This is the thing that bugs me the most; I thought I had actually grasp the belief in the Eucharist but for some reason the belief has gone as if it was never there. Now I am certain that it is just a faulse belief, it has nothing to do with christiany. A person could go a whole life time without ever taking the Eucharist (as I haven’t) and it makes no change in their christianity, so obviously it is an unnecessary act in a church.
You can only say this because you have not have not experienced the change that DOES come when one gives onself in complete trust to the Lord - Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity - in the Eucharist. You assume without cause that since you don’t believe, no one who does believe can be any different in the depth of their sanctity in Christ than you. That makes you and your experiences the reason and center of whatever faith you profess and not the Lord. If you continue in your refusal to assent in faith to this central article of Catholic Faith, then you must alert your pastor of this.
 
But it is only bible scripture interpritations that makes one believe in the Eucharist actually becoming Christ body; hence that I don’t believe in it now…
No; before a line of the New Testament was written the Church was celebrating the Eucharist. Scripture presents the reality of what the Church - His Body which He nourishes with the totality of His Incarnated Self - knew and experienced in its encounter with the Risen and Eucharistic Lord. Those who twist the Scripture toward unbelief in the Eucharist as the Church has known It from the beginning have lost knowledge of the Eucharistic Reality.
 
You can only say this because you have not have not experienced the change that DOES come when one gives onself in complete trust to the Lord - Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity - in the Eucharist. You assume without cause that since you don’t believe, no one who does believe can be any different in the depth of their sanctity in Christ than you. That makes you and your experiences the reason and center of whatever faith you profess and not the Lord. If you continue in your refusal to assent in faith to this central article of Catholic Faith, then you must alert your pastor of this.
My pastors are not interested; I told them that i am protestant and they didn’t even batter an eye lid…
 
No; before a line of the New Testament was written the Church was celebrating the Eucharist. Scripture presents the reality of what the Church - His Body which He nourishes with the totality of His Incarnated Self - knew and experienced in its encounter with the Risen and Eucharistic Lord. Those who twist the Scripture toward unbelief in the Eucharist as the Church has known It from the beginning have lost knowledge of the Eucharistic Reality.
The difference between eating the wafer or not eating it at all; nothing…
 
Do you understand Tradition and Scripture? Tradition is those teachings received by Jesus Christ by the Apostles and passed on to us intact because they are protected by the Holy Spirit. The Eucharist is one such teaching. Scripture comes out of Tradition. Each sheds light on the other. Tradition is entrusted to the Magisterium, or teaching authority of the Church. The Magisterium is comprised of the Pope and bishops, successors of the original Apostles.
As Catholics we read the Old Testament in light of the New Testament and the New Testament in light of the Old Testament.
Tradition (with a capital T) is not the same as tradition (small t) which are regional customs.
While this may take the thread off topic, it is written to help perhaps shed light on the approach that Rolltide is taking.

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came to be through him, and without him, nothing came to be. What came to be through him was life, and this life was the light of the human race; the light shines in the darkness.

I want to return to the analogy of food as one in which a person may not know their need.
We know that sailors often developed scurvy. They accepted this as a matter of course. It is only after they found that limes and oranges could prevent scurvy that they understood their need for citrus fruit. Even if a sailor who had never tasted an orange, lemon, or lime never developed scurvy, does that mean that he did not need the Vitamin C that citrus fruit provides?
 
To be comfirmed. 😃
What is there to be grinning about? That you would be living a lie? That you are seeking confirmation in a Faith whose worship is centered on the Eucharistic Sacrifice and reception of the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of the Lord Jesus while you totally deny this article of faith?!
 
To be comfirmed. 😃
If this is what you want, and if you continue to believe there is no difference between a wafer and the Eucharist, then you are not ready.
Again, do not waste any time. Talk to your priest and tell him you are having difficulty with this central truth of our Faith.
As Rolltide as already stated, you can always return when you are ready. Your decision must come from your heart. We would not want your profession of faith in what the Catholic Church teaches to be a lie.
 
Do you understand Tradition and Scripture? Tradition is those teachings received by Jesus Christ by the Apostles and passed on to us intact because they are protected by the Holy Spirit. The Eucharist is one such teaching. Scripture comes out of Tradition. Each sheds light on the other. Tradition is entrusted to the Magisterium, or teaching authority of the Church. The Magisterium is comprised of the Pope and bishops, successors of the original Apostles.
As Catholics we read the Old Testament in light of the New Testament and the New Testament in light of the Old Testament.
Tradition (with a capital T) is not the same as tradition (small t) which are regional customs.
While this may take the thread off topic, it is written to help perhaps shed light on the approach that Rolltide is taking.

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came to be through him, and without him, nothing came to be. What came to be through him was life, and this life was the light of the human race; the light shines in the darkness.

I want to return to the analogy of food as one in which a person may not know their need.
We know that sailors often developed scurvy. They accepted this as a matter of course. It is only after they found that limes and oranges could prevent scurvy that they understood their need for citrus fruit. Even if a sailor who had never tasted an orange, lemon, or lime never developed scurvy, does that mean that he did not need the Vitamin C that citrus fruit provides?
This is my plan; I will let the priest think that I am in belief in what is going on at Easter comfirmation. I will just go along with it until I am comfirmed. That way I will be a real member at my Catholic chruch, that way I will really belong to my church! 😃 Even if i must eat the Eucharist I will!
 
I don’t care if you think that I am not catholic, I am going to stay at my church and get comfirmed any, I need to.
 
If this is what you want, and if you continue to believe there is no difference between a wafer and the Eucharist, then you are not ready.
Again, do not waste any time. Talk to your priest and tell him you are having difficulty with this central truth of our Faith.
As Rolltide as already stated, you can always return when you are ready. Your decision must come from your heart. We would not want your profession of faith in what the Catholic Church teaches to be a lie.
The Eucharist is my only ticket to the roman catholic church. The only way that they will accept me properly.
 
What is there to be grinning about? That you would be living a lie? That you are seeking confirmation in a Faith whose worship is centered on the Eucharistic Sacrifice and reception of the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of the Lord Jesus while you totally deny this article of faith?!
I will finally feel like I belong to the church, that is seriously something to grin about! 😃
 
This is my plan; I will let the priest think that I am in belief in what is going on at Easter comfirmation. I will just go along with it until I am comfirmed. That way I will be a real member at my Catholic chruch, that way I will really belong to my church! 😃 Even if i must eat the Eucharist I will!
Whatever your age, Jennifer, it’s time to grow up! You may fool the priest, but you are also fooling yourself. The Lord, however, will not be played for a fool. Dishonesty is hardly the spirit in which to come to Him.
 
This is my plan; I will let the priest think that I am in belief in what is going on at Easter comfirmation. I will just go along with it until I am comfirmed. That way I will be a real member at my Catholic chruch, that way I will really belong to my church! 😃 Even if i must eat the Eucharist I will!
This does not make one ounce of sense. What are you doing?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top