The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The priest will never take me seriously unless I am comfirmed. I don’t want to just get a blessing at communion as if i am not even a christian.
A blessing at Holy Communion is not a denial that the one being blessed is a Christian. But, why should anyone take a liar seriously?
 
The catholic church is the opposite direction?
Sin is the opposite direction. If you knowingly and willfully sin then you are making a choice to move further from God, not closer to Him.
 
Sin is the opposite direction. If you knowingly and willfully sin then you are making a choice to move further from God, not closer to Him.
I am doing it to be closer to him! You even say that with out the Eucharist I will have no life in me!
 
…I haven’t thought about that one, but the Eucharist is just a small object that i need to pass to be catholic.
The problem is that if you lie, and then take the Eucharist unworthily, you will be in a state of mortal sin, and mortal sin can condemn us to hell. Even if you go to confession, according to what you say right now, you won’t really be sorry that you received the Eucharist and that you didn’t believe in it, and so the confession will be invalid, even if the priest grants you absolution. In order for your sins to be truly forgiven during Confession, you need to be truly sorry. You will continue to remain in a state of mortal sin unless you continue to abstain from the Eucharist voluntarily…

That said, you can’t even do that forever, because Catholics are obligated to receive the Eucharist at least once a year on Easter Sunday.

For Protestants, worship is about the sermon.
For Catholics and Orthodox, worship is about the celebration of the Eucharist.
 
I am sorry, but you are in error. The Eucharist is the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Christ. THe Eucharist is not just something that neds to be “passed” like it is some test or something. If you do not believe this foundational doctrine, then you cannot consider yourself Catholic. Yes you can be confirmed and go throught the motions. But if you do not believe then you are missing the point. Simply neing a member of a Church does not save you, believing what the True CHurch teaches does.
I am not prepaired to worship a wafer…
 
The problem is that if you lie, and then take the Eucharist unworthily, you will be in a state of mortal sin, and mortal sin can condemn us to hell. Even if you go to confession, according to what you say right now, you won’t really be sorry that you received the Eucharist and that you didn’t believe in it, and so the confession will be invalid, even if the priest grants you absolution. In order for your sins to be truly forgiven during Confession, you need to be truly sorry. You will continue to remain in a state of mortal sin unless you continue to abstain from the Eucharist voluntarily…

That said, you can’t even do that forever, because Catholics are obligated to receive the Eucharist at least once a year on Easter Sunday.

For Protestants, worship is about the sermon.
For Catholics and Orthodox, worship is about the celebration of the Eucharist.
Aww… catholic superstition!
 
Because apparently it is the one true church; I believe that but not a wafer…
You also don’t believe that the things it calls sins are actually sins.

You also believe it is heretical.
 
The sin will be worth it!
Zundrah! You love God. You love the Catholic Church, I think. Why do you think it would be good to spit at both? Honestly, to adelphi mou, to seperate yourself from Christ so willingly seems to me to be the worst apostasy you can ever perform. Please don’t do this… for your sake please!
 
The Vigil Mass was about the Eucharist oddly enough.

Anyway, what is the rush for Zundrah to come to a different view than she has right now?

Nothing good happens when you rush. Unless God tells you to pack your bags, move and don’t look back, I think taking your time on these things is honorable, not despicable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top