The Future of Marriage

  • Thread starter Thread starter ZellieFan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe it’s time for a return to formal introductions, arranged introductions, arranged dates, discreet parental inquires about possible mates. Leaving things to just happen on their own doesn’t seem to work. As Zelie noted, men can’t be counted on anymore to make the first move. I know of several recent marriages in which there was a certain interest and friendship, but nothing happened until the woman took the initiative to show some interest, and in which it turned out the man had been interested for some time but never made a move!
Ultimately it is the woman who has the final say. Chances are the man probably showed interest and made moves, but the woman mightve been playing hard to get, until she finally gave the OK then things materialized.

The problem today with people meeting is immaturity on all parts. People play games, they dont say what they mean, and no one has the time to get to know anyone. I blame poor attention spans, shallow values, and not knowing how to communicate.
 
You wouldn’t think that if you received hundreds of messages, especially very short ones that might have been sent out to literally dozens of other people. “Hey, beautiful!” or “How are you?”

There’s also the issue that even if one sends out a longer, more customized message, if one sounds CRAZY, a lot of people are going to consider it more prudent not to engage.

I…
This is ALL the more reason why I do not agree with match sites. Just more objectification going on and on and on. (Which *is *violence by the way- the meaning of the word violence means to go against the law of God. If you are getting messages like that, then their purpose is not serving what God intends.) Its all wrong. I’ve found match sites to be hopeless, because the premise and set up is already starting at a slight moral decay level (at best) … like finding a piece of fruit on the ground, bruised, a few worms in it and saying this is acceptable and great stuff because this is the best I could do. (not talking about the people on these websites here, I’m talking about the usage and venue of match sites.) Its pretty much advertising a person’s desires. The Word of the Lord says we are to guard our heart.

I don’t believe God would be pleased at all with it. I know dating using match sites has been accepted in society as the norm, but that’s my own personal belief.
 
This is ALL the more reason why I do not agree with match sites. Just more objectification going on and on and on. (Which *is *violence by the way- the meaning of the word violence means to go against the law of God. If you are getting messages like that, then their purpose is not serving what God intends.) Its all wrong. I’ve found match sites to be hopeless, because the premise and set up is already starting at a slight moral decay level (at best) … like finding a piece of fruit on the ground, bruised, a few worms in it and saying this is acceptable and great stuff because this is the best I could do. (not talking about the people on these websites here, I’m talking about the usage and venue of match sites.) Its pretty much advertising a person’s desires. The Word of the Lord says we are to guard our heart.

I don’t believe God would be pleased at all with it. I know dating using match sites has been accepted in society as the norm, but that’s my own personal belief.
Well, my own opinion: I believe God is pleased with the many faithful Catholic marriages that have resulted from people using match sites. People are flawed and yes, some people don’t use the sites the right way. (Just like people who meet in real life don’t always treat the other the right way when figuring out if they should date or not.) But if one is looking for a spouse, I believe one should be open to many avenues, including online dating, and trust that God’s plan will unfold in His time. His plans are better than any of our own.
 
Ultimately it is the woman who has the final say. Chances are the man probably showed interest and made moves, but the woman mightve been playing hard to get, until she finally gave the OK then things materialized.

The problem today with people meeting is immaturity on all parts. People play games, they dont say what they mean, and no one has the time to get to know anyone. I blame poor attention spans, shallow values, and not knowing how to communicate.
I like what you have to say. I am in agreement. Both with you and Jim G’s comment. Its not working what we have now. Just letting things sort of free-flow is too chaotic for the tenderest of emotions.
 
Well, my own opinion: I believe God is pleased with the many faithful Catholic marriages that have resulted from people using match sites. People are flawed and yes, some people don’t use the sites the right way. (Just like people who meet in real life don’t always treat the other the right way when figuring out if they should date or not.) But if one is looking for a spouse, I believe one should be open to many avenues, including online dating, and trust that God’s plan will unfold in His time. His plans are better than any of our own.
I would agree with you in saying that God is probably pleased with the many faithful Catholic marriage that have resulted.
 
… As Zelie noted, men can’t be counted on anymore to make the first move. I know of several recent marriages in which there was a certain interest and friendship, but nothing happened until the woman took the initiative to show some interest, and in which it turned out the man had been interested for some time but never made a move!
Hmm… this is my conundrum right now. However, I’m pretty sure he did make a move and show interest, rather I am just so surprised by it I’m not sure, and thus, afraid to reciprocate in case I misread and I make a mess out of proper relations. Because I gave no reaction, I’m afraid he thought I blew off his interest though. I wish he would have been more clear and direct. Now I feel forced to be clear and direct to find out. I’m not sure that’s a good thing for our level of relation right now (we don’t know each other that well). Any suggestions? I want to be mature about this and would rather just clear the air and get things started if mutual attraction is there, and I feel fairly certain it is. Would it be too awful for a woman to be so forward ?

Hoping not to highjack the thread, but would like some advice on that.
 
Hmm… this is my conundrum right now. However, I’m pretty sure he did make a move and show interest, rather I am just so surprised by it I’m not sure, and thus, afraid to reciprocate in case I misread and I make a mess out of proper relations. Because I gave no reaction, I’m afraid he thought I blew off his interest though. I wish he would have been more clear and direct. Now I feel forced to be clear and direct to find out. I’m not sure that’s a good thing for our level of relation right now (we don’t know each other that well). Any suggestions? I want to be mature about this and would rather just clear the air and get things started if mutual attraction is there, and I feel fairly certain it is. Would it be too awful for a woman to be so forward ?

Hoping not to highjack the thread, but would like some advice on that.
You can get more attention by starting your own thread.
 
Hmm… this is my conundrum right now. However, I’m pretty sure he did make a move and show interest, rather I am just so surprised by it I’m not sure, and thus, afraid to reciprocate in case I misread and I make a mess out of proper relations. Because I gave no reaction, I’m afraid he thought I blew off his interest though. I wish he would have been more clear and direct. Now I feel forced to be clear and direct to find out. I’m not sure that’s a good thing for our level of relation right now (we don’t know each other that well). Any suggestions? I want to be mature about this and would rather just clear the air and get things started if mutual attraction is there, and I feel fairly certain it is. Would it be too awful for a woman to be so forward ?

Hoping not to highjack the thread, but would like some advice on that.
Sometimes clear cut and direct works. I had a niece who recently married. I was reading their wedding website which included stories from both of them about how they met. They were interested but just acquaintances. He came into her place of employment sometimes. She got tired of waiting. Next time she saw him in there, she yelled out in a loud voice “Hey Jeff! Hi! How are you?!” Everyone turned to look, Jeff included. It got them started on the right track.
 
GOD"S WORD: DO ONTO OTHERS AS YOU WOULD LIKE DONE ONTO YOU. I think its rude to think that its ok that you don’t have to respond. This is exactly what I’m talking about, that this sort of thing shows that you believe you can treat other people like objects, that they don’t matter and you can ignore them if you’d like. I think its the height of conceit not to answer someone who has taken the time to contact you. (Unless they are being violent.) You don’t have to do anything with them of course, like go on a date or talk for hours, but to ignore completely I think goes against GOD"S WORD.
Anne, thank you for sharing your thoughts and expanding upon so many issues that we’ve brought up. Please don’t construe disagreement with an attack, I wish and pray the best for you.

I’m sorry, but I really don’t compare ignoring an online message with going against God’s Word. Nor would I be offended if someone didn’t respond to me. May I ask how old you are or if you’re from a large city? It’s absolutely unrealistic to respond to every message some people receive, some people receive a staggering amount. Additionally, many messages are simply not “genuine”. There are lines people use, just casting a net, to see if anyone responds. There’s even automated apps/scripts/bots people can use to find others willing to engage in conversation. There are messages so crass, lame, offensive, or purely uninteresting that simply do not merit or warrant a response. Some people even consider it rude to respond with a not interested response. Ignoring an unsolicited online message, email, etc. is a far cry from rolling your eyes, giving a scowl, and walking away from someone in person who says hello.
 
You wouldn’t think that if you received hundreds of messages, especially very short ones that might have been sent out to literally dozens of other people. “Hey, beautiful!” or “How are you?”

There’s also the issue that even if one sends out a longer, more customized message, if one sounds CRAZY, a lot of people are going to consider it more prudent not to engage.

It’s also charitable not to waste people’s time with chit chat when one really is not interested.

There’s no moral duty to keep batting back pleasantries with strangers on the internet.

As far as the golden rule is concerned, there are lots of different ways to apply it. If I were a single person doing online dating, I would prefer that only actually interested people chatted with me.
Agree wholeheartedly, well said.
 
Hmm… this is my conundrum right now. However, I’m pretty sure he did make a move and show interest, rather I am just so surprised by it I’m not sure, and thus, afraid to reciprocate in case I misread and I make a mess out of proper relations. Because I gave no reaction, I’m afraid he thought I blew off his interest though. I wish he would have been more clear and direct. Now I feel forced to be clear and direct to find out. I’m not sure that’s a good thing for our level of relation right now (we don’t know each other that well). Any suggestions? I want to be mature about this and would rather just clear the air and get things started if mutual attraction is there, and I feel fairly certain it is. Would it be too awful for a woman to be so forward ?
What are you considering a “proper relationship”? If there’s not some formally established relationship such as an employer/employee, teacher/student, etc. than there’s not really a “proper” relationship guideline to follow. Just ask if you’re interested! People struggle with bouncing around topics when they’re uncomfortable or not confident. Please don’t be held back by fear or someone saying no or a feeling that you shouldn’t initiate because you’re a woman.
 
Here is how I started dating my future wife. We were barely acquaintances. Our families were in the same parish but not close friends. I had just returned from a stint in the USAF and was living with my parents, having just found a job. Future wife was working as a clerk in a large company which had an annual Christmas party to which spouses or dates were also invited.

One evening the phone rang. It was the younger sister. “Hey!” she said, “Are you going to take my sister to her company Christmas party?!”

“Uh, well, um, yeah, I guess. Why not?” was my firm and direct reply. “When is it?”

“Here! I’ll put her on! She can tell you!”

Well, that was the beginning of a beautiful friendship. And the party was okay too. Sometimes teenage sisters can be useful.
 
Anne, thank you for sharing your thoughts and expanding upon so many issues that we’ve brought up. Please don’t construe disagreement with an attack, I wish and pray the best for you.

I’m sorry, but I really don’t compare ignoring an online message with going against God’s Word. Nor would I be offended if someone didn’t respond to me. May I ask how old you are or if you’re from a large city? It’s absolutely unrealistic to respond to every message some people receive, some people receive a staggering amount. Additionally, many messages are simply not “genuine”. There are lines people use, just casting a net, to see if anyone responds. There’s even automated apps/scripts/bots people can use to find others willing to engage in conversation. There are messages so crass, lame, offensive, or purely uninteresting that simply do not merit or warrant a response. Some people even consider it rude to respond with a not interested response. Ignoring an unsolicited online message, email, etc. is a far cry from rolling your eyes, giving a scowl, and walking away from someone in person who says hello.
Oh, no offense taken Inigo… I just capitalized God’s Word because it is separate from mine or anyone else’s… I apologize if it came across as shouting or angry.

To each their own opinion I guess. I can’t help the way I feel about it. Its not going to change, nor do I wish to change other’s opinion. You had asked, so i wanted to share and explain my take on it. Iron sharpens iron. I enjoy the discussion and shared ideas.
 
You can get more attention by starting your own thread.
yeah, but I didn’t really want the attention . 😊 . just thought I’d sneak it in here somewhere… which I realize now I should not have done because it *will *hijack the thread. Zelliefan, I apologize! I’ll just make this my last post about it pertaining to it.

Just to answer back…

Inigo, what I meant by “proper relations” was that -how I know this man, -its not the kind of relation in which people are really free to express themselves in a chummy way. Proper tact would be needed.

Jim G… I love the story, Thanks! So sweet!
 
With the rapid degradation of traditional values and MANY Catholic and Christian singles who are LONGING to live God’s plan for human sexuality, why do so many languish in the state of singleness? Is it God’s will? Is it a spiritual attack from Satan that God allows? Why doesn’t He bring more couples together who will raise devout children? sigh
These are all very good questions…as a convert, I know firsthand that God will find a way to continue building His Church no matter what happens with marriage and family life in the decades to come. I’m single and getting on in years…and I know many out there reading right now are in the same boat…but as far as the Kingdom is concerned, sometimes we just have to remind ourselves that it’s more than taken care of, no matter how terrible it looks or feels from our perspective.

Lately, I’ve been thinking about how I might channel my own single angst (which does get better with age 👍) into something more productive. For instance, I’ve recently learned about how much more difficult it is for single men and women living in poverty to access services, assistance, safe housing, etc…what can we do to help those individuals specifically? Or how we might pray for lonely men and women in the Church…or for the Church to continue to grow (in essence, “children”), in the manner He sees fit.
 
I think the future of marriage will be that there will be no marriage any longer, as we know it. Brothers will be marrying sisters, brothers marrying brothers, sisters marrying sisters, fathers and sons, fathers and daughters, mothers and sons, mothers and daughters, human beings and animals, eventually, if we get that far.
 
This story is being widely shared (Deo Gratias) but I think it will come down to prayer, the intercession of the Saints and grace:

dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3100094/California-woman-marry-Vatican-Swiss-Guard-Pope-s-personal-blessing-praying-meet-chivalrous-knight.html
This story is sweet and all but…notice that she is blonde, thin, apparently well-off enough to be traveling to Rome frequently and well-connected enough to be doing English readings at the Papal Christmas Mass (check her Twitter). As I’ve gotten older, I’ve noticed that even with these Catholic I-prayed-to-Saint-so-and-so miracle stories you tend to see women who reflect society’s very narrow physical ideals and both women and men of higher socio-economic levels. Show me a true “tough cases” story-- we’re talking Tobias-and-Sarah tough- and I’ll forward that baby faster than you can say “match made in heaven”!
 
Gonna stick my nose in the tent regarding online dating. One must recall that in the pre-internet days, this sort of thing was preceded by personal ads placed in various media, mostly newspapers and magazines. Which probably exhibited as much exasperation on the part of the participants except perhaps in much slower motion.

For those who think it’s inappropriate for Catholics to participate in this style of finding mates, I give you this side comment quote I found in an article published in Spirit Daily in 2012: “… the pontiff’s parents met through an advertisement placed in a Marian publication”. Keep in mind we are talking about Benedict, the former Joseph Ratzinger. He likely would never have been born without that ad. Unfortunately the article can no longer be found, but I found that quote significant enough to save in my email. So there … my take is that the motive found in your heart is what counts in the end. Whether it is of the Spirit or of the world we live in.

Online dating may not be for everyone; it didn’t work that well for me, but I’m not upset about that. Some Catholics can and do meet this way. They might even get married. Good for them! For the rest of us including yours truly, if online dating doesn’t work, got to do something else.

Back to your previously scheduled programs …
 
Gonna stick my nose in the tent regarding online dating. One must recall that in the pre-internet days, this sort of thing was preceded by personal ads placed in various media, mostly newspapers and magazines. Which probably exhibited as much exasperation on the part of the participants except perhaps in much slower motion.

For those who think it’s inappropriate for Catholics to participate in this style of finding mates, I give you this side comment quote I found in an article published in Spirit Daily in 2012: “… the pontiff’s parents met through an advertisement placed in a Marian publication”. Keep in mind we are talking about Benedict, the former Joseph Ratzinger. He likely would never have been born without that ad. Unfortunately the article can no longer be found, but I found that quote significant enough to save in my email. So there … my take is that the motive found in your heart is what counts in the end. Whether it is of the Spirit or of the world we live in.

Online dating may not be for everyone; it didn’t work that well for me, but I’m not upset about that. Some Catholics can and do meet this way. They might even get married. Good for them! For the rest of us including yours truly, if online dating doesn’t work, got to do something else.

Back to your previously scheduled programs …
Hmnmmm… Not the same thing as what we have today.

Just for the record, I’m not ‘upset’ over any personal unfortunate use of a dating website. I would not say anything at all if that were the case. I am concerned over the fact that people are growing too use to the idea that other people are commodities to be used. Pope John Paul the second spoke about such thing and how its a great detriment to humanity when people fail to recognize what is true charity.
 
How sad that this is the only way for people to meet. How sad that its come to picking and choosing people like they are some sort of order on a menu.

What do I suggest? A church that is alive, active, and vibrant the way its supposed to be, the way it used to be.
And when that’s not an option? That’s part of the problem, for many of us, there are no churches like that. Take dating completely out of the picture. I haven’t had a Catholic friend since I got old enough so that my mom stopped arranging play dates with her friends’ kids. In some areas, unfortunately, church is just something you go to on Sundays to receive the Eucharist. There’s no participating at all beyond that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top