The Harsh Truth About Progressive Cities

  • Thread starter Thread starter ucfengr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Racism is not “integral” to the United States. Integral means it is an essential part. Racism is not necessary for the United States to exist. Racism has been and is a part of the history of the US, and the more this diminishes the better. But it is not “integral”.

Nor is racism “integral” to capitalism. As I am sure you are aware, capitalism is merely the explanation for the free exchange of goods between people. Racism is not an integral part of this. Words have meaning.

In fact, all you need for Racism to exist, across all societies and all economic systems, is people.
 
I remember the guy from SNL called Boston racist and people objected.
That was Micheal Che. The “Daily Show” had a segment by Roy Wood Jr. last week on the same thing.


LOL I have patients who contribute to all the “liberal” causes[…]
Oh, and they refer to them as The Help or The Girls.

But somehow, being a republican makes me a racist.
I have some coworkers that could be your patients!

The company I worked for went through a merger and I find myself reorganized into a department of people that are very much unlike me. If I don’t quit first I’m going to be laid off for not fitting the culture of the department This department has kept itself isolated from the rest of the company to protect their identity and their culture. Whereas my old department had people of varying backgrounds this new department is more homogenized while at the same time having people that like to celebrate how diverse they are. They recently made a guideline that we are to avoid gendered language. They frowned on the consumption of anything from Chick Fil-A…until they found out about some business that was won making Chick Fil-A a client. I’m okay with someone deciding not to buy products for moral reasons but that felt a bit hypocritical. But so does claiming diversity while aiming for homogeneity.

When ever someone here on CAF labels me as liberal/progressive I always imagine they are saying that I would fit in with this group of people.
 
Will have to remember that. The other day someone likened another person to “Mr. Clean.” The person later apologized to the group since the label “Mr.” might have made the women feel excluded.
 
I have seen institutionalized racism but not in the present day Western world. However, people who say Affirmative Action is a form of institutionalized racism, are in all probability, correct.

It also exists in Asia and one good example is Malaysia, where the target of that racism are Chinese immigrants.
 
Last edited:
Other than again filling us in on your wife’s nationality and heritage, what does this tell us other than that Russian rulers have sometimes victimized or enslaved other peoples? Was it Lenin who called the Russian empire the “prison house of nations”? There are those who think it remains so today. Likely few Chechens would say otherwise.

It’s true some Ukrainians think of themselves as Russians. But Russian colonization of the lands of others might account for all of that. Occasional intermarriage within Russia does not really relate to de facto racial segregation in northern U.S. cities.

 
Last edited:
Thanks Jharek.

I was particularly trying to address this statement by Regular Atheist:
Modern “scientific” racism is certainly a phenomenon that emerged under capitalism. Capitalism required the exploitation of much of the non-western world in order to fuel its growth, and it was in this context that racial identities and racist theories emerged. Much of American racism towards those who are black is rooted in New World slavery, an institution which was fundamental to the early development of capitalism.
Racism is not unique to capitalism. (Rowandan atrocities, Japan/Koreans, French/Muslims, etc.). And it is not always due to economic necessity.
 
It’s true some Ukrainians think of themselves as Russians. But Russian colonization of the lands of others might account for all of that. Occasional intermarriage within Russia does not really relate to de facto racial segregation in northern U.S. cities.
This is due to Stalin deporting Ukrainians to Siberia and other industrialized cities and replacing them with Russians. Stalin destroyed the Ukrainian culture. He banned their religion, language, and cultural institutions.
 
I think it’s more accurate to see racism as a response within the Enlightenment West as to why black and brown peoples ought not to be afforded the same freedoms as other people; in other words, it’s a countervailing response to and defense of imperialism and colonialism within a Western civilization that would seem to be founded on values that are antithetical to slavery, imperialism, etc.
 
I think it’s more accurate to see racism as a response within the Enlightenment West as to why black and brown peoples ought not to be afforded the same freedoms as other people; in other words, it’s a countervailing response to and defense of imperialism and colonialism within a Western civilization that would seem to be founded on values that are antithetical to slavery, imperialism, etc.
How would that explain the racism of the Japanese against Koreans? Hutus against Tustsis? American blacks against “whitey?”

Now I’ll bore you with my family history. My mom is French. The French hated Germans. (Well, the French do think they’re better than everybody else). 😊 The French called the Germans “monsters.” They called them “Fritzs”. Haha, at the end of the war was over, she met my dad (German-American) who’s name was Fritz. 😍

It is more likely that people just don’t like “other.”
 
The Japanese have had their own form of racial superiority, to be sure. They did admire Chinese civilization, but viewed it as decadent. The Hutu and Tutsi problem largely exists because of the Belgians, who basically picked the Tutsi as the “winners”, over the much more numerous Hutu. I think any distrust of American whites by African American probably stems from a few centuries of slavery and then another century of either overt white persecution in the South or the less visible but every bit as entrenched institutional racism in the northern states.
 
One of my childhood friends was the child of slave laborers (Poles) in Germany during WWII, who came here as “Displaced Persons”. Ultimately, he joined the army, was stationed in Germany and married a German woman.
 
Well for one thing I’m talking about scientific racism as an idea whereas I think you’re talking about racial discrimination. Once the idea that there is a hierarchy of races becomes entrenched it doesn’t take much for a group to make a claim to being top of the hierarchy.
 
The Japanese have had their own form of racial superiority, to be sure. They did admire Chinese civilization, but viewed it as decadent. The Hutu and Tutsi problem largely exists because of the Belgians, who basically picked the Tutsi as the “winners”, over the much more numerous Hutu. I think any distrust of American whites by African American probably stems from a few centuries of slavery and then another century of either overt white persecution in the South or the less visible but every bit as entrenched institutional racism in the northern states.
That is an interesting observation. Anecdotal of course, but it seems to me there is more black on white racism today than ever. Even black on black. I’ve heard darker skinned blacks are made to feel inferior to lighter skinned blacks.

I wonder how the Irish and the Italians managed to overcome discrimination/racism carried out against them? Certainly they were discriminated against due to their ethnicity.
 
This seems extremely anecdotal. Care to provide some statistics? I suspect this is going to devolve in to Black Lives Matter being some sort of supremacist organization bent on beating on white people.
 
This seems extremely anecdotal. Care to provide some statistics?
Just speaking from personal experience. The majority of our employees are African-American. Race relations seem worse than ever. The older ones are respectful, like in any race. The younger ones not so much, again as in any race, but they like to call on the race card if they are written up for infractions.
I suspect this is going to devolve in to Black Lives Matter being some sort of supremacist organization bent on beating on white people.
Actually not.
 
I wonder how the Irish and the Italians managed to overcome discrimination/racism carried out against them? Certainly they were discriminated against due to their ethnicity.
Most of the Irish could already speak English when they got here. Their institutions were British, as were ours. They were not physically distinguishable from natives for the most part. Many, many of them migrated westward where there wasn’t much in the way of hostility toward them.

I remember talking to a Russian woman here, an immigrant and part of a smallish immigrant community of Russians and Ukrainians. She halfway lamented the fact that their children instantly “became Americans” here, indistinguishable by all measures but name, from their schoolmates.

Might interest you to know that was in Sedalia, Mo. There are a number of them there. Why Sedalia? Because, they said, it reminds them of Ukraine. The seasons are not too different, and the place is (to an Ozarker like me) flat as a table top. Good soil too, unlike the Ozarks.

I can’t say much about Italians, generally, because my Italian ancestors were from the North of Italy; practically in Austria.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top