S
shazirah
Guest
I’ve heard it taught that Bakkah (the ancient name for Mecca) and the valley of Baca are linked and that the Psalm is a reference to a pilgrimage road to Mecca. Admittedly there are some interesting coincidences involved.
Consulting Strong’s Hebrew, “baca” translates to “weeping” and metaphorically references balsam trees that weep precious sap. The etymology of Bakkah is not precisely known, but the most broadly accepted scholarship to my knowledge is that it comes from “bakka” - to crowd, and related to the concept of a narrow place like a valley- rather than “baka” - to have wept. It’s possibly a play on words. Hajar ran between the two hills desperate to find water for her son, who was crying from thirst. Interesting coincidence, if both valleys are related to “weeping” in one way or another. The reference to wells in the Psalm is also interesting because of the Zamzam Well in the valley of Mecca. So, another interesting coincidence.
Personally, I think that the geography and the textual context alone is enough to rule out this being an explicit reference to Mecca and the Kaaba (satellite map of the general area of Jerusalem included below for geographic context, btw, since the question of valleys was mentioned) and I kind of wish certain Islamic teachers would stop using it since it’s not a very convincing argument from an academic standpoint. I do think it might be a metaphorical reference or have a prophetic relationship, at least. Possibly an echoed remembrance of Ibrahim’s time that influenced a place name near Jerusalem.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
Just my two cents from what training I have, though, it’s not a subject I’ve researched in great detail. I’m not a fan of Zakir Naik or his brand of debate and exegesis, so my tendency is to be wary when I see his name pop up in relation to something.
Consulting Strong’s Hebrew, “baca” translates to “weeping” and metaphorically references balsam trees that weep precious sap. The etymology of Bakkah is not precisely known, but the most broadly accepted scholarship to my knowledge is that it comes from “bakka” - to crowd, and related to the concept of a narrow place like a valley- rather than “baka” - to have wept. It’s possibly a play on words. Hajar ran between the two hills desperate to find water for her son, who was crying from thirst. Interesting coincidence, if both valleys are related to “weeping” in one way or another. The reference to wells in the Psalm is also interesting because of the Zamzam Well in the valley of Mecca. So, another interesting coincidence.
Personally, I think that the geography and the textual context alone is enough to rule out this being an explicit reference to Mecca and the Kaaba (satellite map of the general area of Jerusalem included below for geographic context, btw, since the question of valleys was mentioned) and I kind of wish certain Islamic teachers would stop using it since it’s not a very convincing argument from an academic standpoint. I do think it might be a metaphorical reference or have a prophetic relationship, at least. Possibly an echoed remembrance of Ibrahim’s time that influenced a place name near Jerusalem.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
Just my two cents from what training I have, though, it’s not a subject I’ve researched in great detail. I’m not a fan of Zakir Naik or his brand of debate and exegesis, so my tendency is to be wary when I see his name pop up in relation to something.
Last edited: