The Immaculate Conception & Mary's Free Will

  • Thread starter Thread starter garysibio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear brother Gary,

Yes, I do.

What makes her so special in the eyes of Orientals (and Easterns, also) - what makes her the prime example of Christianity - is that she obeyed God willingly throughout her life.

That’s what is so special about her as far as her humanity is concerned.

That she was Theotokos is a distinct (though, of course, related) matter.

Blessings,
Marduk
I’m sorry. I asked that badly. I know, of course, why Mary is special. What I meant was, if she didn’t have any more graces than the rest of us, why was she able to avoid sin when no one else can?
 
I’m sorry. I asked that badly. I know, of course, why Mary is special. What I meant was, if she didn’t have any more graces than the rest of us, why was she able to avoid sin when no one else can?
I think the issue comes down to concupiscence. IIRC, the CCC explains it as the tendency or inclination to sin. Many (both Catholic and non-Catholic) translate this to mean “the will to sin,” and wrongly conclude that if Mary did not have concupiscence (i.e., the tendency to sin), then she did not have free will.

But that is not the patristic understanding of concupiscence. The tendency or inclination to sin does not mean “the will to sin.” Concupiscence is not about the will. Concupiscence affects the will, but is not the will itself. I think our more learned scholastics here in CAF can verify this. For my part, I will appeal to Pope St. Athanasius.

Our Father St. Athanasius taught that concupiscence is a consequence of the Fall and defined it as the diminished or darkened use of God-given Reason. Because of this, we are often “unable” to choose correctly, because choice is always governed by the faculty of Reason. So the Fall did not affect Free Will, but rather the use of Reason.

In other words, whether or not our Reason is perfect or our Reason is darkened, our Free Will always remains intact. Even one with the perfect use of Reason can choose to sin (as is evident from the examples of Adam and Eve).

Though Mary did not have concupiscence (i.e., she has the perfect use of God-given Reason), she still had to exercise her Free Will to choose to follow God’s will every day of her life.

I hope that helps.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
This argument still doesn’t address the issue that the only reason that Mary could remain sinless is because she was given a special grace which allowed her to stay pure. We don’t have that special grace so, when we choose not to murder, it is an act of the will. If Mary had this special grace, how could she ever will to sin. In that case she could not exercise free will.
Where does it say that the ONLY reason she stayed sinless is through special grace? mary was still able to excersize her will and give into desire. one of the gosples says that she had sex with joseph after the birth of jesus, that was her choice she could have lived in abstinence but she gave into the desire to give herself to joseph compleatly. the special grace never prevented her from sining it just gave the motivation and strenght of will not to sin.
 
Hello Everyone.

I know it’s been a while, but I’d like to add my own thoughts. I don’t mean to offend Eastern Christians (Catholic & Orthodox) but I honestly don’t see how anyone can reasonably say that Mary received no special/unique graces over and above the rest of us. To say so, to me, means that Mary was not truly human like us. Who can in our weaknesses, even after baptism, remain free of any post-baptismal sins? even venial?

Firstly, the fact that Mary was in the same “unfallen” state as Adam and Eve before the fall, w/out concupiscence, is already proof of “special”, because even at baptism, no saint has ever been put in that state. Only after long years of asceticism, prayer and sacraments and struggle to pursue God’s will, do we (read here the saints as the only available examples) ever come to the state of freedom from concupiscence, passions and slavery to sin. And even amongst the Saints, at the height of sanctity, we cannot say that venial sins are NEVER committed, even rarely. It seems that Mary’s grace was sufficient to “restore”, at conception, the proper human condition that it takes the Saints a life-time to do! Obviously no co-operation from her was required- She was a zygote/embryo. I don’t see how any one can say that this grace was not greater than what babies and everyone else gets at baptism.

Secondly, the Church, I think, also teaches that we do not all have equal degree or ultimate capacity for holiness/heaven/sanctity. None of us, not even our Lady with her perfect co-operation with grace can come anywhere near the Holiness of Our Lord’s sacred humanity. So while some may get a smaller “cup” due to failure to fully take advantage of grace, that’s not the only consideration. That’s our part, but there’s also predestination- God himself gives different measures to whom he may- What matters is that when we get to heaven, all our cups will be full to overflowing and none will lack anything- You’ll have no room for more! But Our Lord himself makes it plain that in heaven, there are those who are “least”, meaning there are degrees. Now Mary, created to be the mother of God, is, by divine decree fit to a much greater holiness and sanctity than any other thing under Christ. This greater call to Holiness or call to much greater holiness, obviously requires equal grace, because no creature (not even the Theotokos) can attain to that height w/out grace. In fact no holiness of any degree can be achieved w/out grace.

-So I agree that grace is ever-flowing from God, but I do not believe that God has given us all an equal capacity for it. Our Lord’s sacred humanity had the greatest possible that anything under God can have. Our Lady comes second (by an almost infinite distance). And Our Lady has an unimaginably greater one than the next holy thing. So her co-operation was perfect, certainly- but she also received more which she fully co-operated with.

Thirdly, I don’t see how anyone can say that grace takes away freedom of will, but this has been adequately argued on this thread. God did not create Adam and Eve with sin in their nature, but no one would say that they did not have free will because of that! Their sin is sufficient proof of that. Mary’s will was as free as Adam and Eve’s before the first sin, unencumbered by lusts of the flesh, the world and the Devil. Mary simply made a contrary choice of obedience.

Fourthly, I do not understand why people have problems with Mary “getting more” or “special”. Is there anyone else in History (excluding our Lord, of course) who had a more “special” or “unique” role/task/place than the woman who bore God in her womb, as her own son? Does anyone else share this special burden (and privilege) of God? Besides Mary was not just blessed for herself only but for the entire Human race- Her “Yes” to God was to be the “Yes” of Humanity to God’s salvation! Why on Earth would she not get extra help??? These two tasks- Bearing God and being his mother and accepting even his suffering as per her son’s divine will, on one hand and being the spokeswoman for fallen humanity needing salvation- They are both super-human tasks! The first one is even super-natural altogether! Unless she really was not genuinely human, why would we expect that she got no more help than we get?? That really puzzles me:shrug:.

Lastly, some Eastern Christians say that she was no different than any other human, only sinless. Since she obviously was not baptized before Jesus was born or ascended, how can they explain her sinlessness? Are they saying that no grace is needed for holiness? Are they saying that we do not access this grace from our lord’s sacrifice via sacraments? For Mary to be sinless, she must have accessed grace (The Gospels tell us she was full of it). How do they explain her acquiring this grace before the cross and church? Immaculate Conception is the acquiring of the grace for Catholics- How do the orthodox, who reject the doctrine, explain Mary’s getting this grace?

Peace
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top