The Luminous Mysteries

  • Thread starter Thread starter aquohn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

aquohn

Guest
Alright, so being a rather traditionally-minded Catholic, I tend to hang out around traditionalist sites quite a bit. And there’s one interesting opinion I’ve heard there: don’t pray the Luminous Mysteries. So naturally I was curious about the reasoning behind this, so I poked around a bit and found this: seattlecatholic.com/article_20021108_The_Twenty_Mysteries_of_the_Rosary.html

The argument actually seems quite convincing to me. I’d like to hear your opinions on it.
 
As I recall, they weren’t required, just suggested as a helpful addition. I find that they are helpful, esp. in praying for the lapsed baptized, marriage issues, spreading the Gospel, recognizing how Jesus fulfilled the law and the prophets, and thanking him for the Eucharist. Asa private devotion, it isn’t like the Mass or other liturgical celebrations exactly.
 
Alright, so being a rather traditionally-minded Catholic, I tend to hang out around traditionalist sites quite a bit. And there’s one interesting opinion I’ve heard there: don’t pray the Luminous Mysteries. So naturally I was curious about the reasoning behind this, so I poked around a bit and found this: seattlecatholic.com/article_20021108_The_Twenty_Mysteries_of_the_Rosary.html

The argument actually seems quite convincing to me. I’d like to hear your opinions on it.
I get the 3-part rosary. So much of it fits in with other tradtions. It works. But I also like the Luminous mysteries. I like the fact that the 4 part Rosary is so much more complete. It does not have this giant hole in the middle.

And I really like the fact that the prayer is up to individual (or local) choice.

Bottom line is that I can use whichever one I want. You can use whichever one you want, and I don’t mind.

“In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity.”
 
Where did you find that chair avatar?

OP- some good points, but I’d be cautious of any site that starts to enter the rabbit hole of the consecration of Russia.

The Rosary is and remains a private devotion. If you want to say the traditional mysteries, go ahead. If you’d like to add the Luminous, go ahead. I DOUBT Our Lady would be angry at/disappointed in you for meditating on those events. If you’d like to say all of the traditional mysteries, then ADD a second go-round on Thursdays for the Luminous, you could benefit with having more to contemplate and meditate upon without losing some of the original symbolism.
 
I don’t really have a problem if someone prefers the traditional mysteries for whatever reason…the reasons given by the symbolism of the website or any other reasons.

I do think though there is a problem when people bash the luminous mysteries, acts as if they are somehow harmful to the rosary, tries to say others shouldn’t pray them, or acts as though their personal opinion is more than that (in this area).

The reason I think this is very worrisome is this: Is this really the problem in the Church? More people meditating on Christ’s life? Is God sitting watching us saying “No! They must not be meditating on when I instituted the Eucharist or performed my first miracle!”
It is like the pharisees who became so worried about the letter of the law that they forgot about the spirit of the law. This is why they became blind and unable to see the light of Christ.

People who bash the luminous mysteries are nitpicking. Plus they act as though the Church must be stuck in the past. Anything the Pope does that is new or innovative in any way is necessarily bad to them! This is not good. The Church is always changing (not doctrine) because the Church is human.
 
Alright, so being a rather traditionally-minded Catholic, I tend to hang out around traditionalist sites quite a bit. And there’s one interesting opinion I’ve heard there: don’t pray the Luminous Mysteries. So naturally I was curious about the reasoning behind this, so I poked around a bit and found this: seattlecatholic.com/article_20021108_The_Twenty_Mysteries_of_the_Rosary.html

The argument actually seems quite convincing to me. I’d like to hear your opinions on it.
The argument is quite convincing. Changing the rosary never did feel proper.
 
Certainly the rosary is a private devotional, so there is no obligation to pray any given set of mysteries or even to pray the rosary at all.

That said, it still puzzles me how some are so adamantly opposed to the Luminous Mysteries. 🤷 They were put forward by a pope. How can you go wrong by utilizing them? It seems like some want to just pretend they don’t exist.
 
I love the 5th luminous mystery! The institution of the Eucharist was definitely a great Mystery to meditate on especially when one loves the Eucharist as I do!

But, since JPII said that it was up to the individual choice this means that it is required. Go traditional, but remember too much Traditional and you got problems.

I consider my self a Semi-traditionalist. I disagree with a lot of modern movements, and actually despise most of it. But, I’m under the authority of Christ’s Vicar and I’m all for progress in the Church as long as Tradition isn’t scratch!
 
I don’t really have a problem if someone prefers the traditional mysteries for whatever reason…the reasons given by the symbolism of the website or any other reasons.

I do think though there is a problem when people bash the luminous mysteries, acts as if they are somehow harmful to the rosary, tries to say others shouldn’t pray them, or acts as though their personal opinion is more than that (in this area).

The reason I think this is very worrisome is this: Is this really the problem in the Church? More people meditating on Christ’s life? Is God sitting watching us saying “No! They must not be meditating on when I instituted the Eucharist or performed my first miracle!”
It is like the pharisees who became so worried about the letter of the law that they forgot about the spirit of the law. This is why they became blind and unable to see the light of Christ.

People who bash the luminous mysteries are nitpicking. Plus they act as though the Church must be stuck in the past. Anything the Pope does that is new or innovative in any way is necessarily bad to them! This is not good. The Church is always changing (not doctrine) because the Church is human.
I tend to agree. The critics are often the same people who decry what they see as the stripped-back, over-simplified, less-is-more nature of many OF Masses, yet they criticise something that can only, unless perhaps one has some sort of irrational prejudice against meditating on central points in Christ’s ministry, add to and enrich their spiritual lives. In the same way that many of the critics will say Gregorian Chant, ornate vestments and the like do to the Mass. It’s taking a great thing and making it even better IMHO.
 
As far as I am concerned, if it is good enough to have been recited by Bl. John Paul II qne the subsequent two Popes, then it is all right by me.
 
“Seattle Catholic”? Not them again. Relentlessly negative. Depressingly negative. They are not even in Seattle. Deceptive. They are East Coasters, aligned with the so-called “Catholic Family News” that is purely anti-Vatican II as you can get.

I would advise you to avoid them at all costs! I believe that their disobedient, divisive and deceptive traits are harmful to faith and certainly harmful to unity. They are dividers, and the Holy Spirit does not divide.
 
“Seattle Catholic”? Not them again. Relentlessly negative. Depressingly negative. They are not even in Seattle. Deceptive. They are East Coasters, aligned with the so-called “Catholic Family News” that is purely anti-Vatican II as you can get.

I would advise you to avoid them at all costs! I believe that their disobedient, divisive and deceptive traits are harmful to faith and certainly harmful to unity. They are dividers, and the Holy Spirit does not divide.
Indeed! Site review: red, danger!
 
Alright, so being a rather traditionally-minded Catholic, I tend to hang out around traditionalist sites quite a bit. And there’s one interesting opinion I’ve heard there: don’t pray the Luminous Mysteries. So naturally I was curious about the reasoning behind this, so I poked around a bit and found this: seattlecatholic.com/article_20021108_The_Twenty_Mysteries_of_the_Rosary.html

The argument actually seems quite convincing to me. I’d like to hear your opinions on it.
While you don’t even have to pray the Rosary at all (its a private devotion), for those who do pray the Rosary there is no sensible reason not to pray the Luminous Mysteries. I am actually glad they exist because, in my opinion, it completes the Rosary. The public ministry of Christ was not included before.
 
“Seattle Catholic”? Not them again. Relentlessly negative. Depressingly negative. They are not even in Seattle. Deceptive. They are East Coasters, aligned with the so-called “Catholic Family News” that is purely anti-Vatican II as you can get.

I would advise you to avoid them at all costs! I believe that their disobedient, divisive and deceptive traits are harmful to faith and certainly harmful to unity. They are dividers, and the Holy Spirit does not divide.
Errrr…this term has been hurled around the Internet by so many people who don’t really know what it means it feels awkward using it, but this is an ad hominem argument. The source may be divisive and hostile etc., but that doesn’t mean that nothing they say holds water. I personally find the argument presented quite convincing, which was why I presented it for consideration here. There is no necessary link between the qualities you have mentioned and the quality of the argument in question. Asserting that there is is an ad hominem fallacy.

But thanks anyway for the advice. The employ of deception quite obviously undermines an argument’s cogency, so I’ll be on the lookout for it next time. But I do not detect any in the linked article.

Overall, this summarises my current opinion on the position:
The Rosary is and remains a private devotion. If you want to say the traditional mysteries, go ahead. If you’d like to add the Luminous, go ahead. I DOUBT Our Lady would be angry at/disappointed in you for meditating on those events. If you’d like to say all of the traditional mysteries, then ADD a second go-round on Thursdays for the Luminous, you could benefit with having more to contemplate and meditate upon without losing some of the original symbolism.
Or, even more laconically:
“In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity.”
 
Errrr…this term has been hurled around the Internet by so many people who don’t really know what it means it feels awkward using it, but this is an ad hominem argument. The source may be divisive and hostile etc., but that doesn’t mean that nothing they say holds water. I personally find the argument presented quite convincing, which was why I presented it for consideration here. There is no necessary link between the qualities you have mentioned and the quality of the argument in question. Asserting that there is is an ad hominem fallacy.

But thanks anyway for the advice. The employ of deception quite obviously undermines an argument’s cogency, so I’ll be on the lookout for it next time. But I do not detect any in the linked article.

Overall, this summarises my current opinion on the position:

Or, even more laconically:
Have you actually read their articles or done any research into them at all? I don’t think you would say this if you did. Now, if you are a sedevacantist, SSPX aficionado, or other form of schismatic, these folks are feeding you just what you desire. If you truly like what they say, then I have no idea why you would remain here at CAF. It’s just that simple.

They vehemently oppose Vatican II. They constantly criticize the recent popes. They hammer EWTN. We live in the spiritual realm and they are motivated by the spirit of division.

As to your quoted opinion on the luminous mysteries, you “doubt” that our lady would be upset if we meditate on Christ’s Baptism, the wedding feast, the proclamation of the Kingdom, the Transfiguration and the institution of the Holy Eucharist? Listen too yourself! Our lady supports anything and everything good and holy that leads a soul to a more intimate union with her Son.
“In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity.”
But, isn’t this the mantra of the protestants and non-denominationals?
 
Have you actually read their articles or done any research into them at all? I don’t think you would say this if you did. Now, if you are a sedevacantist, SSPX aficionado, or other form of schismatic, these folks are feeding you just what you desire. If you truly like what they say, then I have no idea why you would remain here at CAF. It’s just that simple.

They vehemently oppose Vatican II. They constantly criticize the recent popes. They hammer EWTN. We live in the spiritual realm and they are motivated by the spirit of division.

As to your quoted opinion on the luminous mysteries, you “doubt” that our lady would be upset if we meditate on Christ’s Baptism, the wedding feast, the proclamation of the Kingdom, the Transfiguration and the institution of the Holy Eucharist? Listen too yourself! Our lady supports anything and everything good and holy that leads a soul to a more intimate union with her Son.

But, isn’t this the mantra of the protestants and non-denominationals?
CAF is open to everyone. Even Catholic’s should beware of which threads they open. There was a thread, OP a Catholic, which has been deleted, that has wounded me soul deep. Perhaps I understand more the people who state that they believe in God but not religion. The church’s beliefs are not all in the catechism, did not believe that I would ever be so blindsided. Jesus, I trust in You.
 
Here is a very brief exposition of George Weigel’s take on Lumen Fidei: ncregister.com/blog/joan-desmond/weigel-on-lumen-fidei?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+NCRegisterDailyBlog+National+Catholic+Register&utm_content=Yahoo%21+Mail#When:2013-07-12%2016:49:01

And from John Vennari: cfnews.org/page88/files/58f88f069b52ce770f26d69715d26e66-126.html

Stark difference. I cannot help but see the contrast between obedience and disobedience, positivity and negativity, optimism and pessimism. Frankly, Vennari reminds me of Seventh Day Adventists. He divides his time between loving Christ and hating the Church. Vennari may have the Sacraments, but attitudinally, I see little difference.
 
Alright, so being a rather traditionally-minded Catholic, I tend to hang out around traditionalist sites quite a bit. And there’s one interesting opinion I’ve heard there: don’t pray the Luminous Mysteries. So naturally I was curious about the reasoning behind this, so I poked around a bit and found this: seattlecatholic.com/article_20021108_The_Twenty_Mysteries_of_the_Rosary.html

The argument actually seems quite convincing to me. I’d like to hear your opinions on it.
My opinion is it’s more proof there will never be a shortage of b**chy people in the Church, or on the 'net for that matter. The luminous mysteries were offered as an option for us to meditate on if we want, or not. He also offered other suggestions to help people pray the Rosary. I think that the people who get so worked up about it and try to cause division with it need to pull their heads out of their hind ends and get a clue. There are more than enough forces working against us (all Christians) that for something like this to divide people is, in my opinion, helping the devil do his dirty work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top