The pill can kill: AIIMS study

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, I have several basic rules for survival on a Catholic board, one is: “Don’t talk about sex, don’t even talk about not talking about sex.” So, while I appreciate your zeal, as usual, in collecting internet references, I was merely noting something interesting in an AIIMS study.
Considering that there is what appears to be an increasing number of studies highlighting the risk that may come with taking contraceptive pills, shows the need for the need for women to be given more information about the potential risks.
 
History of abortion was also found to be positively associated with the risk of breast cancer with 6.26 times higher risk in women having a history of abortion. The risk of breast cancer increased 14.9 (95% confidence interval: 8.69, 25.7) and 3.29 (95% confidence interval: 2.15, 5.02) times in women having mean duration of breastfeeding less than 13 months and age at last childbirth more than 27 years, respectively [Table 2].
indianjcancer.com/article.asp?issn=0019-509X;year=2013;volume=50;issue=4;spage=316;epage=321;aulast=Bhadoria
 
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/
"Aspirin alone has been linked to numerous adverse side effects, including but not limited to: kidney failure, liver failure, ulcers, hearing loss and hemorrhagic stroke. A study conducted on the elderly in 2000 showed them to be even more at risk to being heavily affected, the study concluded that even when only taking an undersized 75mg/day dose significant changes were noted in their renal (kidney) functionality. The impact is not limited to the elderly however, as another study conducted in 2009 found 80% of individuals (previously qualified as perfectly healthy) experienced small intestinal toxicity, after just 14 days of low-dosage aspirin use. Ibuprofen seems to outshine aspirin in its adverse effects being regularly linked to: anemia, DNA damage, hearing loss, hypertension, miscarriage and even influenza mortality (6 of the over 24 adverse health effects its been connected with.) An article published in Reuters, even went as far as saying:
Long-term high-dose use of painkillers such as ibuprofen or diclofenac is ‘equally hazardous’ in terms of heart attack risk as use of the drug Vioxx, which was withdrawn due to its potential dangers."
If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
 
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/

If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
Well said Bob. The pill - like life generally - has risks. Pregnancy and childbirth - especially when repeated with the frequency which occurred in my grandmother’s day - carry very many more.

So on the basis of safety - if that had been the original poster’s genuine concern - we should actually be encouraging women to go on the pill…
 
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/

If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
Is ibuprofen, or aspirin classed as a group 1 carcinogen? Class 1 is the highest risk carcinogen group. I doubt whether most whether most women who are prescirbed the birth control pill or buy it for themselves, are told that is a class 1 carcinogen.

A poll from 2010 found
All women surveyed – regardless of contraceptive use – said that knowing “there is new evidence to suggest that taking hormonal contraceptives may increase the risk of breast cancer” would give them serious pause; 44% concluded they would be less likely to take them, and 3% would be more likely. Still, 44% said such research made no difference to them.
While 49% of women were warned by a friend or physician about weight gain and 23% of headaches, only 40% were told of blood clots and the risk of stroke and 19% of increased risks of breast cancer.
In a second question, 54% of women said that use of the Pill for pregnancy prevention would not be worth it if further research shows that there is a definitive link between use of hormonal birth control and cancer; 32% said the risk would be worth the benefits of pregnancy prevention.
lifenews.com/2010/12/03/nat-6908

It clear from that poll that most women are not told enough about the risk of taking the birth control pill, not just about breast cancer but about other risks. Women need to be informed be taking a medication that could have serious side effects.
 
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/

If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
Is ibuprofen, or aspirin classed as a group 1 carcinogen? Class 1 is the highest risk carcinogen group. I doubt whether most whether most women who are prescirbed the birth control pill or buy it for themselves, are told that is a class 1 carcinogen.

A poll from 2010 found
All women surveyed – regardless of contraceptive use – said that knowing “there is new evidence to suggest that taking hormonal contraceptives may increase the risk of breast cancer” would give them serious pause; 44% concluded they would be less likely to take them, and 3% would be more likely. Still, 44% said such research made no difference to them.
While 49% of women were warned by a friend or physician about weight gain and 23% of headaches, only 40% were told of blood clots and the risk of stroke and 19% of increased risks of breast cancer.
In a second question, 54% of women said that use of the Pill for pregnancy prevention would not be worth it if further research shows that there is a definitive link between use of hormonal birth control and cancer; 32% said the risk would be worth the benefits of pregnancy prevention.
lifenews.com/2010/12/03/nat-6908

It clear from that poll that most women are not told enough about the risk of taking the birth control pill, not just about breast cancer but about other risks. Women need to be informed be taking a medication that could have serious side effects.:confused:
 
😦
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/

If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
Is ibuprofen, or aspirin classed as a group 1 carcinogen? Class 1 is the highest risk carcinogen group. I doubt whether most whether most women who are prescirbed the birth control pill or buy it for themselves, are told that is a class 1 carcinogen.

A poll from 2010 found
All women surveyed – regardless of contraceptive use – said that knowing “there is new evidence to suggest that taking hormonal contraceptives may increase the risk of breast cancer” would give them serious pause; 44% concluded they would be less likely to take them, and 3% would be more likely. Still, 44% said such research made no difference to them.
While 49% of women were warned by a friend or physician about weight gain and 23% of headaches, only 40% were told of blood clots and the risk of stroke and 19% of increased risks of breast cancer.
In a second question, 54% of women said that use of the Pill for pregnancy prevention would not be worth it if further research shows that there is a definitive link between use of hormonal birth control and cancer; 32% said the risk would be worth the benefits of pregnancy prevention.
lifenews.com/2010/12/03/nat-6908

It clear from that poll that most women are not told enough about the risk of taking the birth control pill, not just about breast cancer but about other risks. Women need to be informed be taking a medication that could have serious side effects.:confused:
 
I’m one of the those Catholics who happen to agree with contraception for married couples,** as recommended by**** two committees set up by two popes , both of which included bishops and cardinals **if my memory is correct, before being unilaterally vetoed by the decision of one man, the Pope of the time (and he set up one of the committees himself).

In any case I’m not very impressed by claims of possible side effects due to the Pill since just about every pharmaceutical drug has potential side effects. I knew a bloke who permanently lost the left half of his vision due to the anaesthetic used in an operation to remove his appendix. Maybe they should have done the job without the anaesthetic?

We could also extend the argument to a lot of other factors - cars kill a lot of people, guns kill a lot of people, knives kill a lot of people, mains electricity kills people, pesticides kill people, swimming pools kill people - but not one of these things was designed with the intention of killing people, with the exception of guns and some knives. Recently a child died over here after swallowing a small button battery. Going to ban button batteries due to health risks for children?

Then we’ve got common pain killers like aspirin and ibuprofen, which themselves have a lot of potential side effects, as per the following link -

collective-evolution.com/2013/08/09/the-dangers-in-regularly-taking-aspirin-or-ibuprofen/

If you’re going to try to argue about contraception, then at least argue on ethical grounds, and not on a relatively small medical risk, which could be just as easily induced by some other medication.

As a personal example, I take Metformin for Diabetes II, and I don’t get any side effects from it that I know about.

But here is a link giving someone else’s experience with the drug, and she did get serious side effects. Should we ban Metformin because a percentage of people get serious side effects?

voices.yahoo.com/the-metformin-side-effects-experienced-why-i-906143.html
Is ibuprofen, or aspirin classed as a group 1 carcinogen? Class 1 is the highest risk carcinogen group. I doubt whether most whether most women who are prescirbed the birth control pill or buy it for themselves know that is a class 1 carcinogen.

A poll from 2010 found
All women surveyed – regardless of contraceptive use – said that knowing “there is new evidence to suggest that taking hormonal contraceptives may increase the risk of breast cancer” would give them serious pause; 44% concluded they would be less likely to take them, and 3% would be more likely. Still, 44% said such research made no difference to them.
While 49% of women were warned by a friend or physician about weight gain and 23% of headaches, only 40% were told of blood clots and the risk of stroke and 19% of increased risks of breast cancer.
In a second question, 54% of women said that use of the Pill for pregnancy prevention would not be worth it if further research shows that there is a definitive link between use of hormonal birth control and cancer; 32% said the risk would be worth the benefits of pregnancy prevention.
lifenews.com/2010/12/03/nat-6908

It clear from that poll that most women are not told enough about the risk of taking the birth control pill, not just about breast cancer but about other risks. Women need to be informed be taking a medication that could have serious side effects
 
Is ibuprofen, or aspirin classed as a group 1 carcinogen? Class 1 is the highest risk carcinogen group. I doubt whether most whether most women who are prescirbed the birth control pill or buy it for themselves know that is a class 1 carcinogen.
Yes, actually. The following are examples of Class 1 Carcinogens:

Benzene (still used in aspirin, ibuprofen, and similar products containing acetaminophen)

Alcoholic Beverages

Wood Dust

Outdoor Air Pollution

Diesel Exhaust

Ethylene Oxide (used to ripen most of the fruits and vegetables sold in grocery stores)

Paint

Tanning Beds

The list goes on. Besides, while “the pill” may slightly increase the risk of developing breast cancer; it significantly decreases the risk of developing ovarian cancer.
 
Yes, actually. The following are examples of Class 1 Carcinogens:

Benzene (still used in aspirin, ibuprofen, and similar products containing acetaminophen)

Alcoholic Beverages

Wood Dust

Outdoor Air Pollution

Diesel Exhaust

Ethylene Oxide (used to ripen most of the fruits and vegetables sold in grocery stores)

Paint

Tanning Beds

The list goes on. Besides, while “the pill” may slightly increase the risk of developing breast cancer; it significantly decreases the risk of developing ovarian cancer.
And don’t forget the other item listed in the study: bisphenol A, which is in many plastics (think baby bottles and sippy cups) and the lining of cans for people and pet food.

In addition, women who use oral contraceptives have reduced risks of endometrial cancer.
 
I hope that I am wrong, but I am getting the feeling that some posters believe that breast cancer is God’s retribution for using birth control…🤷
 
I hope that I am wrong, but I am getting the feeling that some posters believe that breast cancer is God’s retribution for using birth control…🤷
I think that’s perhaps what you want to believe of some posters. 🤷
 
Yes, actually. The following are examples of Class 1 Carcinogens:

Benzene (still used in aspirin, ibuprofen, and similar products containing acetaminophen)

Alcoholic Beverages

Wood Dust

Outdoor Air Pollution

Diesel Exhaust

Ethylene Oxide (used to ripen most of the fruits and vegetables sold in grocery stores)

Paint

Tanning Beds

The list goes on. Besides, while “the pill” may slightly increase the risk of developing breast cancer; it significantly decreases the risk of developing ovarian cancer.
Risk of getting breast cancer because of oral contraceptives is higher than the decreased risk that you may get in a reduced ovarian cancer rate. Following article claims 27% reduced risk but the article I have posted above shows a much higher percentage for risk of breast cancer. Reduced risk of ovarian cancer has not been proven as the following article details

nbcnews.com/id/52124987/ns/health-cancer/t/pill-tied-lower-ovarian-cancer-risk

I was thinking earlier about the side effects of medication and take medication for asthma or diabetes, and the difference between that type of medication and possible side effects from oral contraceptive pill. Medication for asthma or diabetes, or for another health condition may stablise or may even save lives. Many people may not be able to live without those medications, so people have to way up the potential side effects of the medications with the fact that they have a health condition that they may need medication for.

With oral contraceptive pill, I would guess that most people take it for its contraceptive ability, not because it helps stablise or treat a health condition. Most people who take oral contraceptive pills could live without it.

Listing other carcinogens to make a comparison that those exist hardly makes the birth control pill appear fine. A carcinogen is a carcinogen and we need to be eliminating carcinogens from medications and products.
 
Risk of getting breast cancer because of oral contraceptives is higher than the decreased risk that you may get in a reduced ovarian cancer rate. Following article claims 27% reduced risk but the article I have posted above shows a much higher percentage for risk of breast cancer. Reduced risk of ovarian cancer has not been proven as the following article details

nbcnews.com/id/52124987/ns/health-cancer/t/pill-tied-lower-ovarian-cancer-risk
The link is a 404 error. Furthermore, there is conflicting information on whether or not oral contraception actually increases the likelihood of breast cancer; which is why the FDA did not reccommend the inclusion of that as a potential side effect on the warning labels.
I was thinking earlier about the side effects of medication and take medication for asthma or diabetes, and the difference between that type of medication and possible side effects from oral contraceptive pill. Medication for asthma or diabetes, or for another health condition may stablise or may even save lives. Many people may not be able to live without those medications, so people have to way up the potential side effects of the medications with the fact that they have a health condition that they may need medication for. With oral contraceptive pill, I would guess that most people take it for its contraceptive ability, not because it helps stablise or treat a health condition. Most people who take oral contraceptive pills could live without it.
No one has ever said that oral contraceptives are the right choice for everyone; no medication is. And, yes, it is more beneficial for some than it is for others. A person with a family history of breast cancer may need to think twice about it; but a person with a family history of ovarian cancer would be more inclined to use it. There are plenty of class one carcinogens we could all live without, but as I mentioned before; its about weighing the benefits and the risks.
 
The link is a 404 error. Furthermore, there is conflicting information on whether or not oral contraception actually increases the likelihood of breast cancer; which is why the FDA did not reccommend the inclusion of that as a potential side effect on the warning labels.

No one has ever said that oral contraceptives are the right choice for everyone; no medication is. And, yes, it is more beneficial for some than it is for others. A person with a family history of breast cancer may need to think twice about it; but a person with a family history of ovarian cancer would be more inclined to use it. There are plenty of class one carcinogens we could all live without, but as I mentioned before; its about weighing the benefits and the risks.
Many people who take the birth control pill do not know about the breast cancer risk, as was shown in the poll I posted, so it is very important to get the information out there that the pill can have this isk.

Here is another link

freemalaysiatoday.com/category/leisure/2013/06/07/the-pill-tied-to-lower-ovarian-cancer-risk

Highlighting the risk that may produce from taking the birth control pill or abortion, not on only cancer risk, but for other health risks, is important in the debate about birth control pill and abortion.
 
Planned Parenthood says on their website
Q. Does having an abortion really lead to breast cancer?
A. No. No. No. No. No. There is no truth to this at all. It is one of those nasty myths invented by anti-choice organizations to frighten women away from having an abortion.
“Two years ago, the federal government put together a team of researchers to review the many studies that have been done on this over the years. They decided that there were flaws in the studies that linked abortion and breast cancer. The best studies, including one of 1.5 million women in Denmark, have found no link between cancer and abortion — none.”
plannedparenthood.org/health-topics/ask-dr-cullins/cullins-ab-5508.htm

Not every study has found a link between breast cancer and abortion. An article I posted says 21 of 23 did. Just because one study didn’t find a link doesn’t mean there is not. This is why it is so important to highlight the studies that have found a link, because look what Planned Parenthood says on their website.
 
I hope that I am wrong, but I am getting the feeling that some posters believe that breast cancer is God’s retribution for using birth control…🤷
Well, don’t worry, because you’re wrong. 🤷

Also, there is no Catholic defense for use of the Pill outside of medical usage that is strictly NOT intended to circumvent pregnancy.

Always amazes me how many Catholics want to jump on the ol’ Pill Bandwagon. It would appear that, for these, trusting in God to know what He’s doing is dead as a doornail. Everyone wants to be their own God these days.
 
Well said Bob. The pill - like life generally - has risks. Pregnancy and childbirth - especially when repeated with the frequency which occurred in my grandmother’s day - carry very many more.

So on the basis of safety - if that had been the original poster’s genuine concern - we should actually be encouraging women to go on the pill…
If this were a secular website, one could have this debate.

But this is a Catholic website. What is the point?

If studies showed that taking contraceptives increased one’s life expectancy by 100 years, it wouldn’t matter. “Look at that juicy tree in the middle of the garden, Eve!” It’s addressed in one of the first chapters in the bible for pete’s sake.

When God has spoken, our thoughts or opinions are neither welcome nor needed. If we want to ask “why” the Church staunchly has maintained a certain truth, that is quite different than debating whether the Church is wrong.

For God, it is a lot like dealing with toddlers. Parents are much more receptive when a toddler asks “why” and genuinely wants to understand their rules versus telling them “no” and explaining to them why our rules are wrong.

In the end, it is as useful as creating topics to defend why water isn’t wet. It is wet, and arguing otherwise is pointless. Go try and understand why instead.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top