The pill can kill: AIIMS study

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well said Bob. The pill - like life generally - has risks. Pregnancy and childbirth - especially when repeated with the frequency which occurred in my grandmother’s day - carry very many more.

So on the basis of safety - if that had been the original poster’s genuine concern - we should actually be encouraging women to go on the pill…
Eh what’s a few dead women anyway…it’s not like their lives are important or anything.

I do believe you’re missing a part of the equation. You have to look at the risks vs the benefits. Poison your body & risk death so that you can have consequence free sex vs get pregnant & risk death so that you can bring new life into the world. Seems to me that one is worth the risk, the other is not.

Right now, there is a campaign to have one form of birth control (Essure) pulled because of the large number of women have serious side effects. There have been numerous others pulled from the market over the last few years. How many dead/permanantly injured women does their need to be before these poisons are considered unsafe?
 
Well, don’t worry, because you’re wrong. 🤷

Also, there is no Catholic defense for use of the Pill outside of medical usage that is strictly NOT intended to circumvent pregnancy.

Always amazes me how many Catholics want to jump on the ol’ Pill Bandwagon. It would appear that, for these, trusting in God to know what He’s doing is dead as a doornail. Everyone wants to be their own God these days.
I take it that you think I have “jump[ed] on the ol’ Pill Bandwagon”, that I do not “trust in God” and that I “want to be [my] own god”. If you are, please explain why.
 
Because nothing has been said in this thread that could lead someone to that conclusion.
Ummm, you didn’t answer my question, which was why you think I **wanted **my statement to be true, even when I said that I hoped that it wasn’t.
 
I made the comment in one of my earlier posts that I’m one of those Catholics who believe the Contraceptive pill should be available for married couples as recommended by the committees set up to investigate just this matter by two Popes.

I’ll go further. I think the contraceptive pill was God’s idea, given largely through Catholic researchers, **at the very time population pressures were becoming a real problem in some parts of the world. **it even uses the body’s own natural processes as it’s method of effect.

Also note that we weren’t allowed to develop it, either for reasons of need, or technical ability, UNTIL population growth was becoming a real problem.

Take a look at the following link which shows the world population growth. Want to tell me where it’s supposed to stop?

google.com.au/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&docid=DrMNW1j136CFvM&tbnid=j-30KzCIz5CF3M:&ved=0CAUQjRw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.population-growth-migration.info%2Fpopulation.html&ei=rqzKUv6QEo_qlAWBiIHIAg&bvm=bv.58187178,d.dGI&psig=AFQjCNHULwKRcgUx7K3ZdCmwPeAVGo9tgA&ust=1389100589512398

Now here’s a world population clock - worldometers.info/world-population/

Note that today’s population growth alone has been 216,000, and rising. That means that **every day, if we are all to have an equitable economic distribuition, getting on for an extra **225,000 cars will need to be produced, 225,000 homes will need to be built, 225,000 people will need to be clothed, fed and educated etc.
 
Bob, the pill contains artificial hormones and messes with the natural woman cycle that GOD created. No one would ever suggest that the Pill, which is basically poison, was GOD’s idea…especially when it tosses HIM out of the creation of new life process. The Pill is SELFISH, while letting GOD join the process is SELFLESS.
 
I made the comment in one of my earlier posts that I’m one of those Catholics who believe the Contraceptive pill should be available for married couples as recommended by the committees set up to investigate just this matter by two Popes.

I’ll go further. I think the contraceptive pill was God’s idea, given largely through Catholic researchers, **at the very time population pressures were becoming a real problem in some parts of the world. **it even uses the body’s own natural processes as it’s method of effect.

Also note that we weren’t allowed to develop it, either for reasons of need, or technical ability, UNTIL population growth was becoming a real problem.

Take a look at the following link which shows the world population growth. Want to tell me where it’s supposed to stop?

google.com.au/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&docid=DrMNW1j136CFvM&tbnid=j-30KzCIz5CF3M:&ved=0CAUQjRw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.population-growth-migration.info%2Fpopulation.html&ei=rqzKUv6QEo_qlAWBiIHIAg&bvm=bv.58187178,d.dGI&psig=AFQjCNHULwKRcgUx7K3ZdCmwPeAVGo9tgA&ust=1389100589512398

Now here’s a world population clock - worldometers.info/world-population/

Note that today’s population growth alone has been 216,000, and rising. That means that **every day, if we are all to have an equitable economic distribuition, getting on for an extra **225,000 cars will need to be produced, 225,000 homes will need to be built, 225,000 people will need to be clothed, fed and educated etc.
Regarding the Pontifical Comission on Birth Control, I read about it before and original intention of the Comission was to analyse the impact of artifical birth control on the Church, to look at population and birth control. The intention was not to look at reforming Church teaching on artificial birth control.

Former member Patty Crowley has since had involvement in an organisation which advocates a change to how the Church makes decisions and advocates female and married priests called Call to Action.
By the time the commission met in the spring of 1965, Grisez reports, 12 of 19 members of its theological section thought the Church’s teaching on contraception was “reformable” — it could be changed.
osv.com/TheChurch/MarriageandFamily/Article/TabId/659/ArtMID/13699/ArticleID/2023/Church-birth-control-commission-docs-unveiled.aspx
The study group, formally called the Pontifical Commission on Population, Family, and Birthrate, was actually established by Pope John XXIII on April 27, 1963, six months after the start of the Second Vatican Council. Contrary to popular belief, its purpose was not to consider whether the Church should change its teaching on contraception, but rather to assist the Holy See in preparing for an upcoming conference sponsored by the United Nations and the World Health Organization.
John XXIII died 37 days later and Cardinal Giovanni Montini was elected Pope on June 21, taking the name Paul VI. The new Pope was keenly aware of the problem posed to the Church by the new secular consensus in the West on birth control. Catholics were increasingly using contraception and European theologians were beginning to challenge the received teaching in scholarly journals. He was also undecided on the question of whether the birth control pill, because it did not interfere with the performance of sexual intercourse, was a form of contraception. Advisors from all sides were pressing upon him a sense of urgency about the issue and urging him to take up the topic for consideration.
The Pope agreed that the issue needed serious consideration, but thought that the Vatican Council, now in its second year, was not the proper place to undertake it. He thus decided to expand the membership of the Pontifical Commission, which he did on June 23, 1964, adding physicians, psychiatrists, demographers, sociologists, economists and married couples. Because he did not clearly specify the commission’s new mandate, its members redefined it on their own: to re-examine the content and status of the received teaching in the Catholic Church on the use of birth control.
ewtn.com/vnews/getstory.asp?number=113242

You say you think the contraceptive pill was God’s idea through researchers but contraception has a Biblical basis to prohibition, Onan. Prohibiting contraception is based on God’s word, the Bible.

As for population growth. Japan is facing a demographic crisis because of a declining ferility rate and has had to ease its immigration laws to allow more people to come into the country and take up jobs because Japan doesn’t have enough people. I watched a news story about Germany and Germans are having to go out of the country to find people to come and live and work in Germany, and it is not because overall the German people are not skilled enough for the jobs, but because there are not enough people in Germany. Chin does not have enougj people to fill the needed labor jobs and has an ageing population. There are many countries which are facing demographic problems because of not having a replacement fertility rate.

Consider
Example: If you put all 7 billion Earth Inhabitants in the State of Alaska,
each person would have an average of 2,271.60 square feet of land.
That area would be large enough to build a 4 bedroom house
for each of the World’s 7 billion inhabitants!
overpopulationmyth.com
 
Ummm, you didn’t answer my question, which was why you think I **wanted **my statement to be true, even when I said that I hoped that it wasn’t.
No, I think I did answer and I will repeat the answer: nothing has been said in this thread that even hints at anyone here wanting women who take the pill to get cancer, but for some reason, that’s where your thought process took you.
 
Oh please. :rolleyes:

First of all, this association has been documented before, it’s nothing new.

Secondly, AIIMS is a government hospital in India, and all government hospitals in India are very anti-life:

Here are some other “research projects” going on in this centre:
  1. “Comparison of miferpristone plus misprostol alone for inducing abortion at 13-20 weeks gestation: A double blind randomised multicentre trial”
  2. “Pretreatment with Misoprostol before vacuum aspiration versus MVA: double blind RCT- A pilot study”
  3. “Management of medical abortion in India by midlevel providers of physicians: A two arm randomised controlled trial”
Their “medical termination of pregnancy clinic” attended to 649 “new cases” in the last year (2011-2012). And that’s not counting the 10 “abortions” from in vitro fertilizations.

And let’s not forget the 420 packets of oral contraceptives they handed out, and the 875 tubectomies they performed (mostly on poor or lower middle-class women.)

Of course, all this is legal in India. But though their study may bring some cheer to the “pro-life” movement, the rest of their conduct is sadly far from it. 😦

Source: aiims.edu/aiims/annual-report/Annual%20Report-2011-2012.pdf
 
Further to the discussions on overpopulation debate I feel that amongst catholics ‘abstinence’ and nfp is the answer. In my opinion (I have 8 children) I dont believe in ‘culling’ the population as we near the horizon of ‘the world is flat’ theorists of old! God said be fruitful which to me is that he is well able to do something wonderful if we reach full capacity! Will Jesus come back or will we have the technology to teraform another planet. As I said we can forever be in the mentality that the world is flat and get frightened as we near the horizon and not dare walk towards it!
When I say abstinence or nfp the answer for catholics I mean for those who are unable to recieve or feel they could cope with another baby-your choice. But overpopulation? Fill the earth as Faith and obedience gives you the confidence.
Sorry if this seems muddled as im not as articulate as some of you lovely posters!
 
I also feel that poverty is caused by corruption not lack of resources and is not an argument for contraception.i think developing countries with severe poverty have been at the end of global banking policies that have caused debt economies and it has suited to withdraw credit (keep the country in debt) to line the pockets of the major banking families. Abortion, euthanasia, birth control is an economic policy and a business plan of a small clique.
 
I also feel that all this huge effort to reduce populations (by evil) by culling through war, famine abortion, euthanasia is a tactic of the devil-its the last thing he wants you to see-over that horizon. When christianity has spread throughout the world and’the number’ is in what will happen? Certainly its the last thing satan wants. Satan will not hold back the kingdom of God advancing and these are desperate measures used against that advancement. If you cant cull by mass world war-the pill is a tactic.
 
Going through paramedic school we were warned to be careful of women taking the pill that they could get a pulmonary embolism or blood lot. I mean its out there, what else do they need
 
No, I think I did answer and I will repeat the answer: nothing has been said in this thread that even hints at anyone here wanting women who take the pill to get cancer, but for some reason, that’s where your thought process took you.
Think what you want.
 
There have been some colourful assertions about the use of the pill or other methods of birth control along the lines that women use them as part of a global business or government conspiracy…

I have never - make that NEVER - met anyone who decided on the number of children they wished to have - great or small - other than in reference to their own personal wishes and circumstances, and their ability to raise and love them.

I found the original poster somewhat disingenuous in that he appeared to be raising one concern (women’s health) when in fact his agenda was actually an attack on the use of the pill.

The side effects of the pill are certainly worth talking about - as is the possibility that some women are allergic to rubber, and others die during pregnancy or as a result of childbirth.

But it is safer to be on the pill than to produce a baby every year, so if you wish to discuss “artificial” contraception then it would be better and more honest to base your objections on perceived ethical grounds, than on misleading medical ones.

Finally I do understand how someone might get the impression that the possible side effect of cancer could be seen by those of an extremist persuasion as some sort of punishment for using the pill - although it certainly doesn’t explain the protective effect that it confers in respect of other cancers.

And there are those, sadly, who see children as the punishment for sex…

Personally I believe that the use of contraception between married people is proper and a decision for them alone. And far from being anti-life, I believe that the engendering of a child is far too important to be the result of a drunken fumble after a curry and glass of wine too many on a Saturday night…

Actually the night is irrelevant, my argument would hold Sunday to Friday too:)

I only dipped into this site because I write professionally on some of the issues raised here and was looking for some insight from the pews.

But I quickly realised that many of those who contribute are self-selected and - forgive me for saying this out loud but I am being as tactful as I can be here - really often rather odd and concerned about stuff I have never heard raised by a Catholic in real life.

I have also been somewhat alarmed by the seeming glee - and I say “seeming” as one can form an erroneous impression online - with which some posters refer to the certainty that most of humanity will be consigned to hell, for an eternity of torment, for the most trivial of “mortal” sins…

That’s me done.
 
I only dipped into this site because I write professionally on some of the issues raised here and was looking for some insight from the pews.

But I quickly realised that many of those who contribute are self-selected and - forgive me for saying this out loud but I am being as tactful as I can be here - really often rather odd and concerned about stuff I have never heard raised by a Catholic in real life.

I have also been somewhat alarmed by the seeming glee - and I say “seeming” as one can form an erroneous impression online - with which some posters refer to the certainty that most of humanity will be consigned to hell, for an eternity of torment, for the most trivial of “mortal” sins…

That’s me done.
Other than the Catholics on this forum not being as poorly cathecized as those you come across “in real life”, what is your point?

catholic.com/tracts/birth-control
 
I think the above comments a bit baffling. ?..I didnt get the impression on this site that these self selected people feel that anyone is doomed to hell for a trivial mortal sin or that children are a punishment. I think that as a catholic being open to life is a positive part of our faith and not a ‘numbers’ game ie more children the more faith. Many catholics and other people of other faiths also feel that family important. My points above -probably does sound a bit over the top for this thread-is that I think through govts there really has been an over the top promotion of contraception, abortion etc and countries for example russia are actually worried because of lack of population as a result of govt policies. I agree with you that in marriage your family decisions are private but I think the pill and attitudes to sex outside marriage in society has taken its toll on steering kids through their teens. There are loads of issues that come up when the pill comes up for discussion and I have rambled on to be honest but I do believe there is evil in this world and the family and children have taken a huge hit as a target.
I used to take the pill before I was a catholic in marriage-I had v good health but felt quite ill trying to come off the pill for quite some time. People are concerned about taking medication especially if its a daily thing and people do need to have more facts.
 
There have been some colourful assertions about the use of the pill or other methods of birth control along the lines that women use them as part of a global business or government conspiracy…
Where?
I have never - make that NEVER - met anyone who decided on the number of children they wished to have - great or small - other than in reference to their own personal wishes and circumstances, and their ability to raise and love them.
So personal wishes and circumstances can never be selfish or misguided? And honestly, if people can’t raise kids when they’re married, they ought to think twice about getting married in the first place, or else they’re just rooming together with an official certificate that entitles them to benefits best reserved for those who ARE interested in continuing to create and raise our young ones.
I found the original poster somewhat disingenuous in that he appeared to be raising one concern (women’s health) when in fact his agenda was actually an attack on the use of the pill.
An attack on a class 1 carcinogen? The horror! :rolleyes:
The side effects of the pill are certainly worth talking about - as is the possibility that some women are allergic to rubber, and others die during pregnancy or as a result of childbirth.
Rubber is a non-sequitor. Pregnancy is a natural function of the body that cannot intrinsically or logically be compared to a carcinogen.
But it is safer to be on the pill than to produce a baby every year, so if you wish to discuss “artificial” contraception then it would be better and more honest to base your objections on perceived ethical grounds, than on misleading medical ones.
Prove this, please.
Finally I do understand how someone might get the impression that the possible side effect of cancer could be seen by those of an extremist persuasion as some sort of punishment for using the pill - although it certainly doesn’t explain the protective effect that it confers in respect of other cancers.
Punishments are not the same as consequences. And it only takes one sort of cancer to kill you, so it doesn’t do the Pill much good to help prevent some when it raises the risk of others. I mean, riding with no helmet down the highway on a motorcycle greatly reduces my risk of dying in a plane crash that day, but does that mean that I shouldn’t wear a helmet while I’m driving?
And there are those, sadly, who see children as the punishment for sex…
Yup. And those folks turned around and helped the Pill to grow.
Personally I believe that the use of contraception between married people is proper and a decision for them alone. And far from being anti-life, I believe that the engendering of a child is far too important to be the result of a drunken fumble after a curry and glass of wine too many on a Saturday night…
Quite an assumption you make, there. Are all children not “planned” as such classified by you as drunken mistakes? I have to say, the more I read, the more your sheer credibility on this matter is going right down the toilet.
I only dipped into this site because I write professionally on some of the issues raised here and was looking for some insight from the pews.
Ah, the Media. Much is suddenly clear. Welcome to CAF.
But I quickly realised that many of those who contribute are self-selected and - forgive me for saying this out loud but I am being as tactful as I can be here - really often rather odd and concerned about stuff I have never heard raised by a Catholic in real life.
You can’t have known many actual Catholics, then.
I have also been somewhat alarmed by the seeming glee - and I say “seeming” as one can form an erroneous impression online - with which some posters refer to the certainty that most of humanity will be consigned to hell, for an eternity of torment, for the most trivial of “mortal” sins…
And this is you simply stating what you choose to believe, regardless of the wealth of information on the matter here on this site. Color me completely unimpressed.
That’s me done.
Indeed. Have a nice career feeding the masses exactly what they want to hear. I’m sure you’ll be wealthy and prosperous in life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top