There's a Lie on Your Lips

  • Thread starter Thread starter theBelgianDuke
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

theBelgianDuke

Guest
This question stems from a conversation I had with a friend recently. We were discussing what constitutes a lie of omission, but we were having trouble pinning it down.

It’s easy to pin down, for instance, in a case in which someone asks another person a direct question. If someone intentionally omits key details when answering a direct question, then it’s a lie of omission. Duh.

It’s harder, though, in cases where there is no statement.

For example, Tom isn’t a virgin when he marries Sally. She never asks about it, and Tom never brings it up because he doesn’t want her to know. Is that a lie of omission?

Doesn’t seem like it. Then again, maybe it is.

And that’s where my friend and I started going around in circles. Does anyone else have any thoughts?
 
For example, Tom isn’t a virgin when he marries Sally. She never asks about it, and Tom never brings it up because he doesn’t want her to know. Is that a lie of omission?
Unless Sally has given some hint that she wants to know, or there is a legal or cultural expectation that Tom share this info with Sally, it’s not a lie.

It might be poor judgment for this couple to not be 100 percent open with each other before marriage. Then again it might not be. Perhaps Tom has a past history of having been sexually abused in a prison camp and becomes very upset just thinking about his pre-Sally sex life let alone talking about it. Sally may understand there is some trauma in Tom’s past and tell him she doesn’t care and accepts him without asking questions. If it works for them, it works. Every couple is different, not all of them care about their partner’s past or virginity.
 
I think lie of omission has to do with hiding information that the other person should know or needs to know. Like if Tom never told Sally he is HIV positive. That’s going to affect her life. Or Tom never told Sally he had been married before and has children.
 
I think lie of omission has to do with hiding information that the other person should know or needs to know. Like if Tom never told Sally he is HIV positive. That’s going to affect her life. Or Tom never told Sally he had been married before and has children.
Right. Either of those situations would also create a legal or cultural expectation that Tom tell Sally. In a case where Tom has no HIV, no previous marriage, no kids by an old girlfriend, etc. there is no such expectation in Western culture.

Back in the day when men expected wives to be virgins and often just assumed that they were, there was perhaps a cultural expectation that a woman tell a man who she was serious about if she was not a virgin. Nowadays, many if not most men don’t just expect this and if either member of the couple feels strongly about knowing, they ask.
 
Last edited:
I would think it’s not a lie if he feels no guilt about it, if he does, he might then should tell her.
 
Lies are intentionally false communications. Thus, there can be no lie of omission, since not speaking is not a form of communication.

Withholding certain truths could be a species of immoral deception, however, or a lack of integrity.
 
Last edited:
Maybe a lie of omission has to come within communic@tion? For example, if Tom told Sally he’d been married but not that he had had children? Or if a person says they were in a gang, but not that they were the leader of the gang, or still in it?
 
Withholding certain truths could be a species of immoral deception, however, or a lack of integrity.
Two questions, then. First, what are the criteria to determine whether it is immoral to withhold one truth vs. another?

Second, what are the stakes? In other words is immoral deception sinful?

Also, disclaimer (for everyone): This is just a genuine discussion. There’s no personal situation in my life that I’m trying to work through regarding this topic.
 
I would think any type of omission (call it a lie or something else) is sinful if withholding truth brings harm in any way to another. In the example cited in the OP, if the woman doesn’t ask and accepts the young man as he is, no harm, no foul. If the young woman is driving down a road and the young man chooses not to tell her the bridge is out and she will go over the cliff and kill herself, that is sinful.
Sins of omission are probably the most common of all. Seeing starving children in Africa or disaster victims anywhere, while watching television, drinking beer and eating pizza, and doing nothing other than ordering another six pack and another extra large pepperoni with extra cheese, might not sit to well with a certain Carpenter from Nazareth that I’ve heard of.

“To whom much is given, much will be expected…”
 
People are allowed to have personal memories, because we are all, always, ‘in the middle of things’ as they say.

Unless the actions of his past will affect Sally, then he isn’t sinning. He might not consider it an issue. Perhaps it was a foolish teenage thing, or he was abused. But if he was loose and contracted some disease like herpes or HIV, then he is obligated to tell Sally because once married, they become one in the flesh - and she could contract it. She has every right to know about this.

He can’t forget something like that, and if she wakes up one morning and he says to her “oh, by the way, my duck, go get your HIV’s tested. I had a run in when I was sixteen” then he’s not really a proper husband.

However a lot can be said if Tom doesn’t WANT her to know. She really doesn’t NEED to know, but it would be virtuous that, within the union of marriage, one emptied his heart to the other - for God’s grace prevails within the sacrament of marriage.
 
The example given here is regarding: As Is. Men are never virgins. A virgin is a girl. The man is responsible to know if he may take a wife or not. What about the other women, we’re they ever lied to?
 
Not true.

“Aber die beste und sicherste Tarnung ist immer noch die blanke und nackte Wahrheit. Komischerweise. Die glaubt niemand.”

“The best way of hiding the truth is by telling it. Funnily enough, nobody ever believes it” (Max Frisch)
You’re talking about deception, not lying. As Twain said, “A truth that’s told with bad intent beats all the lies you can invent.” But truths do not stop being truths merely because they are told with the intent to deceive.
 
Personally, in this case, I think it comes down to respect and Jesus’ words ‘Love thy neighbour as thyself’. If Tom has the expectation that Sally is a virgin he should respect Sally and tell her he is not. Same goes for Sally. If she’s not a virgin but wants a virgin husband she should tell him out of respect.
I personally think couples should discuss all of this stuff and more in great detail before any wedding plans were made.
However, I have had people in my own family (not my husband fortunately or I would not have married him) who very clearly had a “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy about various personal areas and subjects. I also know that sometimes victims of past traumas do not tell their pasts easily and in fact may be looking for someone who will love them without caring about that stuff or making them talk about it. They may open up later, but it could take 10 or 20 years, and who wants to wait 20 years to get married.
 
Huh? Anything immoral is sinful.
lol no need to be cheeky, old sport. Just asking:) Not everyone operates on the same parameters.

As for “information one has a right to,” that strikes me as a little vague. Especially in cases of romantic relationships, it seems like (with enough imagination) anyone could extrapolate a right to such-and-such information.
 
Blues artist Mark “Porkchop” Holder sings
“Every body wants to hear the truth…
But everyone wants to tell a lie”

There are not lies of omission, but sins of omission. This is nuanced by the situation. Some to whom you speak have no right to the information. Those who do, however, should receive the disclosure.

From the Book of Tobit:
Tobit 12:11
“I will not conceal anything from you. I have said, ‘It is good to guard
the secret of a king, but gloriously to reveal the works of God.’
 
As for “information one has a right to,” that strikes me as a little vague. Especially in cases of romantic relationships, it seems like (with enough imagination) anyone could extrapolate a right to such-and-such information.
It was intentionally vague. It would take a long, long time to carefully explain what constitutes a right to the truth in all the various situation where it may apply. But since you seem to have romantic relationships in mind, here are a few examples:

(a) Anyone who has sex with a person (or is going to have sex with that person) has a right to all information about previous sexual encounters that person has had.
(b) Beyond that, nonmarried romantic partners have no more right to information than any other friend would.
(c ) Married persons have a right to know, in ordinary circumstances, any important facts pertaining to the couple’s children, and any important facts concerning the spouse’s fidelity.
 
Last edited:
40.png
theBelgianDuke:
As for “information one has a right to,” that strikes me as a little vague. Especially in cases of romantic relationships, it seems like (with enough imagination) anyone could extrapolate a right to such-and-such information.
(a) Anyone who has sex with a person (or is going to have sex with that person) has a right to all information about previous sexual encounters that person has had.
(b) Beyond that, nonmarried romantic partners have no more right to information than any other friend would.
(c ) Married persons have a right to know, in ordinary circumstances, any important facts pertaining to the couple’s children, and any important facts concerning the spouse’s fidelity.
Seems reasonable to me 👍
 
(a) Anyone who has sex with a person (or is going to have sex with that person) has a right to all information about previous sexual encounters that person has had.
Aaaaaand what if I do that, in the spirit of being open and honest, and it’s either a deal breaker or things just don’t work out…and "Anyone decides to share this detail with one of his friends, and it doesn’t stop there.

No, they do not have a right to that information.
 
Aaaaaand what if I do that, in the spirit of being open and honest, and it’s either a deal breaker or things just don’t work out…and "Anyone decides to share this detail with one of his friends, and it doesn’t stop there.

No, they do not have a right to that information.
I may have overspoke. What I mean is that they have a right to all information regarding sex acts that could have led to disease, including the number of times those acts have been engaged in.

But given that caveat, yes, I’m sticking to my guns on this. If you don’t want people to know about these things, you have two clear options: (1) Only have sex with people you really trust, or (2) Don’t have sex.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top