T
theBelgianDuke
Guest
This question stems from a conversation I had with a friend recently. We were discussing what constitutes a lie of omission, but we were having trouble pinning it down.
It’s easy to pin down, for instance, in a case in which someone asks another person a direct question. If someone intentionally omits key details when answering a direct question, then it’s a lie of omission. Duh.
It’s harder, though, in cases where there is no statement.
For example, Tom isn’t a virgin when he marries Sally. She never asks about it, and Tom never brings it up because he doesn’t want her to know. Is that a lie of omission?
Doesn’t seem like it. Then again, maybe it is.
And that’s where my friend and I started going around in circles. Does anyone else have any thoughts?
It’s easy to pin down, for instance, in a case in which someone asks another person a direct question. If someone intentionally omits key details when answering a direct question, then it’s a lie of omission. Duh.
It’s harder, though, in cases where there is no statement.
For example, Tom isn’t a virgin when he marries Sally. She never asks about it, and Tom never brings it up because he doesn’t want her to know. Is that a lie of omission?
Doesn’t seem like it. Then again, maybe it is.
And that’s where my friend and I started going around in circles. Does anyone else have any thoughts?