This needs to repeated over and over again!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lys
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So why can’t you admit you got a fact wrong, eh?
I can. And I have.

Can you admit that you misinterpreted my post and somehow saw an error of fact that wasn’t there?

The last two Republicans elected POTUS did not win a plurality of votes for President in their first run. That
The last two Republicans elected POTUS did not win a plurality of votes for President in their first run. That …
If you want to accuse me of bad writing to have such indefinition in the antecedent of “That” in the second sentence, I would have to agree. It is not great writing that the entire sentence is the antecedent.

Normally, however, people can manage to figure out the meaning, by the context.
That = last two Republicans assuming the Presidency without a voter plurality, is, as indicated, unprecedented, has not gone unnoticed by those talking about the electoral college of late, and makes what follows true. And btw - last two inherently means in a row. :roll_eyes:
 
Last edited:
That’s the irony though is that the EC doesn’t function like it was intended. It was intended as a deliberative body, a sort of a congress for picking the President and Vice president, but if it ever really functioned that way, it was broken by the 12th amendment and the baking of the two party system into the political framework of the nation.
 
Perhaps.

But the way forward is via an amendment to the Constitution.
 
Sure you got one fact right. I can admit that. See that wasn’t so hard. But you also got one fact wrong. But admitting that without deflection is really really hard for you. To show just how hard that was for you, it took you until this last post I’m replying to for you to openly admit you got anything wrong and you still used sort of weasel language around your admission. You spent the preceding posts trying to deflect us away from that, hence the “shifting goalposts” comment which in my opinion is well deserved.

Multiple posts and walls of text to eventually say what you could have said in one post with a couple of sentences at most the first time you were called on the inaccuracy. Perhaps like this: “ok I got that one fact wrong, but I don’t want you to lose the point I’m trying to make here”?

😏 :roll_eyes:
 
Last edited:
But you also got one fact wrong.
My indefinite antecedent? Already stipulated.
Anything else is your imagination. You might like to take a tendentious reading of my post to suggest that I am ignorant of junior high American history. I am not sure why you or anyone would chose to do so, but a fair reading of my post does not support such an idea.
 
I read your post fairly. Took you three posts to so stipulate. With a fair number of $50 words.

I’d keep rolling my eyes, but that’s a bit uncharitable and not in keeping with the Christmas spirit so have a good Christmas.
 
I read your post fairly.
No. You read it uncharitably. It was easy to see what I meant, which was not the least bit incorrect., Instead a choice was made to interpret in a way that suggest that I was grossly ignorant of junior high history. Generally speaking such a dissonant interpretation is a good indication that the interpretation misses the mark.
Took you three posts to so stipulate.
It is taking me more than three posts to convince you that your interpretation was faulty, in a way that should have been obvious. But if wish to be stubborn in posting that way - forum rules aside - that is your prerogative. It is shame, however, that a decent topic about the electoral college, was hijacked to make the thread about things that you imagine in order to offer detraction about me.
 
Last edited:
Allow me to offer a rewording that would have made your point the first time through and avoided all of this. Heck you could have offered this rewording the first time another poster mentioned those previous elections, but you chose to deflect instead when a little directness would have helped you far more than the drawn out pile of big words upthread:
The last two Republicans elected POTUS did not win a plurality of votes for President in their first run. While taking into account that Presidents have won elections before without a plurality of the votes, I want to point out that this has not occurred with any regularity until the first elections of each of the last two Republican Presidents. It would be odd if people didn’t reflect on the Electoral college in that situation.
You may want to reflect on the log in your own eye while you point out the log in mine.
 
Last edited:
Allow me to offer a rewording
I have already stipulated that the wording could have better. But it was by no means impenetrable.
At long last, you seem to have gotten it - even though starting sentence two with a subordinate clause the recapitulates sentence is also material for re-write. I should think that by now, if there is a sentence whose meaning seems unclear or that suggests gross ignorance, you might give fellow posters the benefit of the doubt, and if you cannot figure it out, ask for a clarification., Or you could stretch for a tendentious conclusion and triumphantly exclaim the discovery of an error. Up to you.
You may want to reflect on the log in your own eye
Lol. I am very careful to ask for clarification rather than make assumptions about meaning. Even when there seems to be no alternative meaning, I will discuss what “seems” to be the meaning. I make these circumlocutions, frankly, because it is a requirement the board to be polite and to post charitably. The response to them, sadly, has been discussions of sea-lions.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top