Ticked off Catholic looking for loving correction

  • Thread starter Thread starter Shylah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cooldude, Apogano, good suggestions… we did attend Latin Mass for Palm Sunday, and the proper solemnity was there, and it was really nice. Unfortunately, the family environment was even more lacking for some reason. 😦

Have you folks every attended an Eastern Mass? It’s really wild… First of all, there are no instruments. Everything is sung, even the readings. Our Church was all in English, and the singing was SO interesting… it’s a rhythm back and forth between the priest and the parish. The priest sings, we sing, the priest sing, we sing, and so forth, for so much of the Mass. Everything is so extraordinary… nothing worldly to focus on… no programs or projects… just for those few moments in time, when time itself seems to cease, there is just nothing but prayer and worship and a perpetual offering between our church and our Saviour. It is truly like Heaven on Earth. No distractions. The love between the people and the priest and the Saints and the Trinity is just so pervasive that for the first few weeks of my attending there it was so hard not to openly weep the whole time…
I’ve never attended an Eastern Mass, but I recently became friends with a woman who does. As far as I can ascertain, she converted in order to marry, and loves the Eastern Mass. Would your husband object to attending?
 
  1. what is the point of having a relationship with Christ if I can’t share that with anyone? What’s the point of living at all if I have lost my ability to love others? (please no one freak out … I’m not thinking of doing anything stupid… really, Job was saying similar stuff, so it isn’t about threatening doing something stupid, honest)
I don’t understand this. What’s standing in the way of your loving others? The entire purpose of the Church, BTW, is to help us grow in love, to fulfill the greatest commandments-there’s really nothing more-or less-to it than that. And it can be a lonely job in a way because this whole world of humans, Catholic or otherwise, doesn’t necessarily go along with the plan so well. But that is Gods’ plan and if the Church served no other purpose but to tell us about it and help get us there, that should be good enough, no?
 
Cooldude, it’s a great suggestion… have thought of that… What started off as minor frustration finding a new church home has turned into a spiritual crisis where I now think I am going to hell. How can I get involved in anything when I am so spiritually sick? I desperately need a doctor, and I can’t find one, and I am mad at God for this, and that’s why I am in this crisis and I don’t know what to do. All I can do is remember a time, now long past, when I was safe in a family who took care of me just by being there, by being who they were, keeping me close to Christ just by virtue of acting like a Covenant family, so that it was obvious that Christ cared about them and they cared about Christ. It wasn’t about high spiritual feelings like you get from singing praise and worship songs, or saying an eloquent prayer, or making a clever analogy to thump someone on the forehead about God’s Truth… it was just a family happy in Christ. If I don’t have that kind of family, then how am I spiritually safe?

You know I used to pray 6+ hours a day. Would wake up in the middle of the night to God’s loving call, and all I could was gaze on His beauty and no words could describe it. It wasn’t emotional. It wasn’t weird. It was just… no words could describe it. Awe is probably the only word that is appropriate. I would’ve done anything for Him. Quit my 6-figure job, donate my savings and become a nun… ANYTHING. I wanted to do nothing but evangelize, to somehow tell people that just a simple glimpse of the “other side” was enough so that no one should ever have to worry again about ANYTHING on this side. Would’ve given my life and then some. Had to figure out how to tell the story as a “picture frame” though… Nana always said the best frames for paintings were the ones you never notice. They frame the art, but if you notice the frame, it’s the wrong one. It always calls attention to the art itself. That’s what I wanted to be. A picture frame for Christ.

But now I am alone, without guidance, and scared to death that I am wasting what little life is left because I can’t hear God’s call anymore and I just don’t know what to do.

You know I taught a 4-week seminar on prayer once. The group loved it so much they begged me to make it permanent. My husband at the time was abusing me, my boss at the time was abusing me, and I had no peace either at work or at home. Just in Mass. I can’t tell you how many times I just wanted to lay on the floor and fall asleep in front of the Blessed Eucharist because it was the only place I felt safe. And still the people wanted me to continue teaching the prayer class. How could I? I just didn’t have the strength. The Holy Spirit gave me a lot, but my personal life was falling apart, and I failed my group as a result.

I am a big fat failure. and I just don’t know what to do. If I get into a class as a student, I’ll just argue with the teacher (like I did with the one who was trying to teach the Oriental “Centering Prayer” of nothingness that REAL contemplatives like Fr Dubay warn us against). I don’t want to argue with anyone. I don’t have the wisdom, I don’t have the patience, and all my virtues are in the pooper and I don’t know how to get them back.
 
Shylah, I completely understand. That I why, although we are attending, I have not joined or ben baptized into the Episcopal church. I hold too dearly the faith I was raised in. However, I was NOT getting anything out of it. 😦

Find me a CC where you’re a name and not a number and has a multitude of fellowship opportunities and I’m there!! 🙂

And the way you describe the Protestant church breathing down your neck and forcing their “truths” on you is exactly what I experienced at Catholic church. 😦 Our current church is the exact opposite of that.

I don’t know how long we’ll be here because I want to baptize any child we have in the Catholic Church, but I feel we’re home for now. Although there is one church id like to try to see how they are. I would just feel guilty leaving the current friends I’ve made relationships with.
If you have an Eastern Catholic Church in the area, try that for a while. It’s amazing, and it’s because the focus is solely on Christ.

Apostolic Tradition is what the Catholic Church teaches, and it is meant to provide a 2000-yr old anchor to the Apostles so we don’t misrepresent God’s Word.

Protestant churches are not safe. They will lead you astray. I know having a church home is important where you feel like you are more than cattle, and that’s why I am complaining here. But you may have access to a solution that I don’t: the Eastern Catholic Church.
 
I don’t understand this. What’s standing in the way of your loving others? The entire purpose of the Church, BTW, is to help us grow in love, to fulfill the greatest commandments-there’s really nothing more-or less-to it than that. And it can be a lonely job in a way because this whole world of humans, Catholic or otherwise, doesn’t necessarily go along with the plan so well. But that is Gods’ plan and if the Church served no other purpose but to tell us about it and help get us there, that should be good enough, no?
Because I can’t love people without REAL guidance and REAL support from the ones I am supposed to be in a Covenant relationship with.

BELIEVE ME, I am trying to be as loving as I possibly can be. My office adores me because I am always so positive, warm-hearted, helpful, encouraging, and cheerful in spite of being ripped to shreds on the inside. I prepare the most amazing meals for my diabetic hubby, and that’s not easy because of the limitations. BUT I did a ton of research and always think up ways to surprise him. I try to lift everyone up in my life that I know… But dangit WHY is there no one to help me FIX MY BROKEN SOUL?

Is it just about me and Jesus? Is that the message here? Should I go be a hermit and just offer myself to Christ and then we will have this wonderful relationship together without me doing any work for Him at all? That’s just great… then my mind could make up all sorts of things and I would have no one to keep me safe.
 
I used to know someone who was a melkiate Catholic, which apparently is in communion, though I think it’s considered “conversion”

Also be aware that you may simply be in the wrong area of the country. southerenrs tend to be more friendly. You also should take a step back. Just enjoy Mass, even with the wrong things just as parent would do for a kid who dosnt know.

You could also try some non-agressive methods such as voulenteer things and even paid parish trips. It will take a year or so before people ease up…its just human nature. Protestants are welcoming but the disillusiment factor is there…I have known few protestant churches that weathered chnged and I know many who split. So you trade welcome for stability.
Melkites are absolutely in communion with Rome… there is one 2+ hours away… my husband went once and said it was wonderful… maybe that’s the answer…
 
I’ve never attended an Eastern Mass, but I recently became friends with a woman who does. As far as I can ascertain, she converted in order to marry, and loves the Eastern Mass. Would your husband object to attending?
Actually when we were married in the Eastern Church, he was “automatically” received into the Eastern rite… and he loved it. We REALLY loved our church back at our old place, and every Eastern service we’ve been to has been wonderful and very family-oriented and properly focused on the Lord and Sunday as a rest day from plans, programs, projects, social justice, etc. Lots of time the rest of the week for these other things, but Sunday Mass was not the time. It was Heaven on Earth.
 
Nobody is a failure. We are all precious children of God, Who made us in His image and likeness, and Who continues to create us day by day.

You certainly know better than to believe someone without any Church authority when they have you start questioning whether you are going to hell. And you know better than to mistake emotion for spiritual intimacy with God.

I’ve been doing the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola under direction (nineteenth annotation,) for a couple of months now, and every time I think about how God loves me despite my sins, my failings, and my faults, and keeps calling me closer to Him, I am humbled in a wash of deep gratitude.

Ignatian spirituality may not be your thing, but at the very least, see if you can get away for a weekend retreat on your own, minus any influence from your husband. If you can do a silent or directed retreat, so much the better. What you really want to do is to step outside of the roles you play and re-encounter God as His precious daughter. I’m not saying that because I think your husband is a bad guy, which I don’t, but because ultimately each of us meets God on his or her own, and enters into relationship with Him as an individual.

Sometimes couples can get so enmeshed in each other that it is good to take a bit of a break to step back and recognize that before all else, we are individually children of God.

Vis a vis the premarital courses that the Church offers, it seems to me that the starting assumption is that two mature Christians are embarking on the state of matrimony, and that all the Church has to do is provide the road map. They do an okay job of that. But the contemporary early-to-mid twenties person in the US is more of an adolescent than an adult (no offense intended here,) and I think that more focus has to be placed on what adult love looks like in these seminars, with all the nitty-gritty of that, and without some of the schmaltziness that I recall from pre-Cana (if that reference gives you an idea as to how long ago I took that class!) Just my two cents on the matter.
 
Eastern Catholicism is COMPLETELY different. You show up at a church for the first time, and someone is inviting you over for dinner that evening… you will be swarmed with people after Mass… the kids will be crawling all over you as you’re chatting on the lawn… NO ONE leaves early because the Mass lasts as long as the priest decides it does, which could be anywhere up to 3 hours depending on the feast day… it’s just SO different…

WHY are western rite people so isolated from each other???
I could be wrong, but I suspect this may be cultural. Westerners, at least Americans, generally like things to be short and fast (cause they have somewhere to go :rolleyes:). They are not particularly friendly and welcoming (at least not in my lifetime - I understand maybe it used to be different). They tend to be pretty isolated from each other.

This is true in many contexts, not just church. It’s just sad that it seems to be true in our Catholic churches as well.
 
Student, you are probably right… it’s probably a cultural thing. I’m an Arab, and family is everything to us. Cousins and siblings are the same (I think I heard that the Bible refers to them as the same as well…?). Authority and hierarchy too… a fellow church member in his/her 60s is my elder, even though we just met… maybe that’s my problem.
 
Odile,

Awwwww I wish I knew you in RL. lol

Maybe I should seek out a retreat house out here somewhere… I admit that my hubby and I have been joined at the hip since getting married, and I don’t spend nearly as much time with Christ as I used to before getting married.

Reading Job has helped a lot. I love hearing thunderstorms… I almost feel like I can hear Our Father yelling at me. haha.

I just don’t want to disappoint Him… He deserves so much more than I give, and it’s because I have anxiety attacks every time I try to go to Sunday Mass with my husband. And if I don’t go to Mass, then how am I supposed to do anything right? If we don’t receive the Lord in the Eucharist, we won’t have any life in us. I’m living that. If I go to a retreat, will I just remember the relationship I used to have with Christ, only to go back to my life and live with the memory, now freshly renewed, of how my relationship used to be?

Why is it that my relationship with God suffers just because I don’t have a church family? I know the academic answer, but… why do I feel so unsafe when I have no spiritual friends?

Will spiritual exercises help with that?

Maybe I really do need to seek a third order…
 
Ummm… may I ask…

Do you regret a vocation of marriage instead of a vocation of a religious?

In peace, xoxo
 
Ummm… may I ask…

Do you regret a vocation of marriage instead of a vocation of a religious?

In peace, xoxo
Ugh. no you may not. lol

The thought crossed my mind… but a) was on the path of discernment when I realized that being a dedicated single was probably more appropriate than entering into religious life, b) the thought of being in a wedding dress to become a nun made me sad and told me I really wanted to be married, and c) after an hour long conversation with my hubby to be when we first met, I felt so sad that I couldn’t find someone like him to marry because I was going through a divorce and didn’t think I could ever be happy with someone as wonderful as him and… bleh. Anyway, now the thought of *not *sharing the rest of my life with my hubby is unthinkable. We are like two peas in a pod, and I’m sorry I didn’t state this earlier, but he feels TERRIBLE about how his past complaints have hurt me and my relationship with the CC. He’s really a wonderful man, with a heart of gold, EXTREMELY smart, hilariously funny, and is just as concerned as I am about remaining on the right path toward our Savior.

You know, in the Eastern Rite, married priests are allowed, and yes, the option is on the table…

Nothing would make me happier than to support a priest, to devote my whole life to serving a parish, even if it means giving up everything worldly I have.

It’s just hard to discern ANYTHING without the benefit of a religious mentor. I’m not that wise, neither is he, and as much as we know God is the steward of all wisdom, that isn’t going to help us if we are too dense to understand His messages.
 
Ugh. no you may not. lol

The thought crossed my mind… but a) was on the path of discernment when I realized that being a dedicated single was probably more appropriate than entering into religious life, b) the thought of being in a wedding dress to become a nun made me sad and told me I really wanted to be married, and c) after an hour long conversation with my hubby to be when we first met, I felt so sad that I couldn’t find someone like him to marry because I was going through a divorce and didn’t think I could ever be happy with someone as wonderful as him and… bleh. Anyway, now the thought of *not *sharing the rest of my life with my hubby is unthinkable. We are like two peas in a pod, and I’m sorry I didn’t state this earlier, but he feels TERRIBLE about how his past complaints have hurt me and my relationship with the CC. He’s really a wonderful man, with a heart of gold, EXTREMELY smart, hilariously funny, and is just as concerned as I am about remaining on the right path toward our Savior.

You know, in the Eastern Rite, married priests are allowed, and yes, the option is on the table…

Nothing would make me happier than to support a priest, to devote my whole life to serving a parish, even if it means giving up everything worldly I have.

It’s just hard to discern ANYTHING without the benefit of a religious mentor. I’m not that wise, neither is he, and as much as we know God is the steward of all wisdom, that isn’t going to help us if we are too dense to understand His messages.
Oops! 😊 I understand a bit better now. Blessings to both you and your husband! I will continue to pray for you!
 
I noticed you have taken the time to look at the Book of Job which has great wisdom for Suffering. I would also suggest looking at the Book of Jonah. This was an adjunct reading to some of the SFO formation materials when I first started with my first Fraternity before I made my first move. It has a great lesson about Joyful Obedience and God’s purpose not always being our own purpose.
 
Hi,

You have said a lot, and yet it is unclear to me what you are really complaining about?
My apologies, if I cannot get back to this site, but, if I do not, you are sounding like one who heard God, and now she does not.

If that is the case read on…If that is not the case, cease as this does not apply to you.

I cannot be perfect. I’ll try. You are maybe mistaken in the reasons why God has ceased to talk to you.

Hearing God’s real voice interiorly, or exteriorly, is a high gift of God. Mother Theresa had this and then she had no contact after that. When she wanted more, I heard, nails came down from heaven in response. Yet, she and all others who face what I remember is called, the dark night of the soul, go on, from what God had told them prior to the cessation of conversation.

If the dark night of the soul, and its purpose, the beautification of your soul, is what is happening to you, it is indeed harsh, yet, you are not going to get God to do things your way, and would you want to?

Would you want to, like Job, contend with God, over your right and his wrong? Even if God allowed this as he did with Job, do you think you’d fare better than Job, who merely missunderstood the reasons? Do you think you know the reasons why? Yet, even with Job, cannot it not be said, that Job’s contention with God, was not also what God wanted.

(Job contending with God, knew nothing of God’s conversations with Satan. He knew afterwards merely by seeing God. He knew nothing before. God merely let Satan prove himself wrong twice. So, Satan contended with himself and lost. He said Job would budge. Job would say what is wrong about God. Job did not. Satan tried to be right, twice. He failed. Twice he failed. God, then met Job, told him nothing of what took place in heaven, yet Job knew after he had seen God. He then wrote The book of Job. He knew afterwards, what had happened between God and Satan in heaven. He did not know before. God rewarded Job, God doubled even the number of children he had, implying that the ones taken by what was called death, and were no longer on the earth are still alive to God. He did not tell Job of his conversations beforehand, yet Job knew of this conversation, after merely meeting God. We also learned other things, like Job’s friends not being right. We learned of the limitation of the power of Satan by God, showing he is not that powerful. We were not told why God rewarded Job. We are told he was. One reward, knowing, was not mentioned, yet it was there. It seems that rewared happened just like Paul’s did, by merely seeing God and God’s presence being made visible to him. )

Do you think this should end…now, your separation from God’s voice? Tell God this. Maybe He will respond. If He does not, you have to wait. If He does, you will know, and you will be rewarded probably, just like Job.

Others before you have in their frustration and panic, assigned the worst possible human motives for what God is doing. They believe their own worst thoughts and or fears. The best, is happening, if you are in The Dark Night Of The Soul. If you are not, there is something else going on. What is is???

The Holy Roman Catholic Church under testing shows no errors typically. Sure Mark 9: 38-42 forbade one of their mistakes. Sure they have made two more mistakes and have published them. Yet, for roughly 2000 years everything else has stood. All of the Ex-Cathedra work, they say has never needed to be changed, and it is implied as guraranteed to be accurate, by The Holy Spirit and what Jesus said about the church. I have never heard of anyone ever showing any ex-cathedra statement, has ever been wrong.

Does it bother you that maybe a more holy, a more saintly path is being given to you? Are you in error with the church, you love, and do not admit this to yourself? Are you rather like a saint who was told by God, there was a doctor, not a priest or a nun, who was holier than he was. The doctor helped the poor. The saint, living at the time, must have been taken aback. Yet, he learned something wonderful also from his experience.

Years ago, I could have written precisely on this subject. Now, many years later my memory, the feelings, the content fails me. It is harder now and I make mistakes. The above is what I hope I remember correctly about, God talking, and then leaving.

Is that what happened to you???

He is still there, by His own words, like I will never leave you. Even if your mother could leave you I will not.
 
Shylah, I’ve went through something similar… it seems that maybe you and your husband would really like the Latin Mass, is there a parish like that near you? The Mass is definitely very reverent, not shallow, there, there catechesis is good and the homilies, etc… I’ve went to an FSSP parish for a year and now that I’ve moved, I really miss it! It’s not wrong to want a more deep liturgy… there are certain things we see in parishes today that are the result of the crisis in the Church and would eventually not be there anymore. But - there’s sometimes a temptation to be very critical and constantly think and talk about the shortcomings of the typical parish Mass instead of praying, thinking of your own spiritual growth, and focusing on the Eucharist. When you’re at Mass, try to just pray and focus on the Eucharist. If things bother you, just close your eyes and pray. Don’t get distracted or become critical because that won’t be really helpful to you spiritually. But if you can find a Latin Mass parish (in communion with Rome) or an Eastern Rite Catholic Church, you would probably like it there more 🙂 please don’t leave the Church though 🙂 God bless!
 
So now I HATE going to Mass. Mass seems shallow, and it seems like no one cares about anyone outside of their immediate families or cliques, and it seems like it’s all about rules without relationships.
I thought that was normal. I just started to go to Mass regularly a few years ago. I always go by myself. I never had any connection to anyone in the Church. A good friend of mine who lives in a different area mentioned that he used to go to a Church hoping to get in contact with others from that Church but he felt like he was intruding as the “newbie”. He switched his Church but I don’t think he meets any people there either.
I kind of assumed that is normal.
At the end of the day I go to Church because of God and not to meet new people but it is kind of odd that you can go to the same Church for a long time and not know anybody:shrug:
 
Because I can’t love people without REAL guidance and REAL support from the ones I am supposed to be in a Covenant relationship with.

BELIEVE ME, I am trying to be as loving as I possibly can be. My office adores me because I am always so positive, warm-hearted, helpful, encouraging, and cheerful in spite of being ripped to shreds on the inside. I prepare the most amazing meals for my diabetic hubby, and that’s not easy because of the limitations. BUT I did a ton of research and always think up ways to surprise him. I try to lift everyone up in my life that I know… But dangit WHY is there no one to help me FIX MY BROKEN SOUL?

Is it just about me and Jesus? Is that the message here? Should I go be a hermit and just offer myself to Christ and then we will have this wonderful relationship together without me doing any work for Him at all? That’s just great… then my mind could make up all sorts of things and I would have no one to keep me safe.
Well, Jesus persevered in perfect truth and humility and love -and it got Him crucified. The world isn’t necessarily going to congratulate you for doing the right thing-but, then again, the world should stand convicted of sin (it actually does stand convicted of sin)-of not valuing truth and love above all else-by the act of the One who actually had to experience suffering and death in order to redeem it.

So we have to ask whether or not we’ll choose the world’s ways-or if we’ll choose Gods’. Gods way is the path of humility and love-that’s the heart of Jesus. The world’s way runs pretty much counter to that-even the most humble and loving of us are still pretty arrogant and selfish compared to Him. It’s about perseverance, and it sounds like you’ve been doing that all along. Keep going-one foot in front of the other-and pray that God gives you the knowledge of what’s right-and the courage/fortitude to live according to it. That’s my prayer for myself and I’ll pray it for you too. I know it ain’t easy.l
 
I thought that was normal. I just started to go to Mass regularly a few years ago. I always go by myself. I never had any connection to anyone in the Church. A good friend of mine who lives in a different area mentioned that he used to go to a Church hoping to get in contact with others from that Church but he felt like he was intruding as the “newbie”. He switched his Church but I don’t think he meets any people there either.
I kind of assumed that is normal.
At the end of the day I go to Church because of God and not to meet new people but it is kind of odd that you can go to the same Church for a long time and not know anybody:shrug:
I am very familiar with the OP’s concern and what you said above.

I remember for many years I felt my family and I were an island in our parish. We attended Mass, we went home, without even saying “Hi”, and “Bye” to anyone. I thought about taking the initiative to reach out. So I taught faith formation class, hoping to have some interactions with the parents. But, no, all I got was “Hi” and “Bye” when parents dropped and picked up their kids. I was still an island.

Not until I participated in different church groups such as SCC (small church community), Sunday night Bible Study, and other volunteer works, I started to know many people. Yes, many. Now when I go to church I say “Hi” and chat with different people right and left. And I even made a few good friends.

It seems to be a norm that we Catholics are very confined to ourselves and our family while attending church. I did not give up during those long lonely years. I concentrated on worshiping God instead of longing for social fellowships. Indeed we need to be a God’s family like Shylah and many others hoped and professed. And we can do our part to change this culture.

When we sit in the same pew with some familiar faces, have we ever introduced ourselves to them, learned their names and tried to make friends? Are we waiting for others to reach out to us or are we willing to reach out to others? If we dislike something, have we done anything constructive to help? Can we take the first step just to learn the names of people sitting around us? They may be surprised and thrilled by such an unexpected kind gesture. That actually could be an action of charity. We can build some contact by initiating this simple step.

There is a long way to go, of course. But we can start from ourselves. If we don’t start the single step by greeting others and making efforts to remember other’s name, if we only expect others to do so, then we will be forever waiting.

God bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top