TIME Magazine:Was John Paul II Euthanized?

  • Thread starter Thread starter snowgarden
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

snowgarden

Guest
How could they publish this bunk from someone with an ax to grind??

“The issue of euthanasia and the Church heated up in Italy last year after a man named Piergiorgio Welby, who’d been on life support for nine years from the effects of muscular dystrophy, asked for the right to die. Eventually, the life support was suspended and he died. But when his wife, a practicing Catholic, asked for a funeral in Church, the Vatican refused. Pavanelli says that this episode prompted her to revisit John Paul’s death.”

time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1664189,00.html?xid=rss-topstories
 
Because Time is part of the MSM. They hate anyone who does not subscribe to their perverted Secular Relativist agenda. Plus it is easier for them to go after someone who is dead (bullies are like that). :mad:
 
I remember after JP2 passed on ( :crossrc: ) hearing about the ritual of tapping a Pope who’s passed away on the forehead three times with a silver hammer or some such. And I though ‘hello, good opportunity for someone who doesn’t like the current Pontiff, eh!’

In all fairness I must point out that that was before my reversion, of course I’d never have such uncharitable thoughts today :whistle: :o
 
Because Time is part of the MSM. They hate anyone who does not subscribe to their perverted Secular Relativist agenda. Plus it is easier for them to go after someone who is dead (bullies are like that). :mad:
And here I thought they just wanted to make a buck.:coffeeread:
 
A few observations:

This isn’t a “Time” story, it is a story about a story. A report on a report. It may say something about “Time” for choosing to publish this story (instead of real news), but they can’t take credit (be blamed) for the story itself.

The Dr. bases her diagnosis on what she saw on T.V. A real Dr. would never dream of diagnosis based on such a thing. This is as bad as the Dr.'s writing about the condition of Terri Shivo without ever seeing her in person.

The Dr. appears to have a profound lack of understanding about palliative care. It is not euthanasia and it is not condemned by the Church.

Nohome
 
How could they publish this bunk from someone with an ax to grind??

“The issue of euthanasia and the Church heated up in Italy last year after a man named Piergiorgio Welby, who’d been on life support for nine years from the effects of muscular dystrophy, asked for the right to die. Eventually, the life support was suspended and he died. But when his wife, a practicing Catholic, asked for a funeral in Church, the Vatican refused. Pavanelli says that this episode prompted her to revisit John Paul’s death.”

time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1664189,00.html?xid=rss-topstories
Pope John Paul II was never denied air to breathe, water to drink, or food to eat. He also was not kept alive artificially.
 
A few observations:

This isn’t a “Time” story, it is a story about a story. A report on a report. It may say something about “Time” for choosing to publish this story (instead of real news), but they can’t take credit (be blamed) for the story itself.

The Dr. bases her diagnosis on what she saw on T.V. A real Dr. would never dream of diagnosis based on such a thing. This is as bad as the Dr.'s writing about the condition of Terri Shivo without ever seeing her in person.

The Dr. appears to have a profound lack of understanding about palliative care. It is not euthanasia and it is not condemned by the Church.

Nohome
The Dr. also appears to have a profound misunderstanding of Catholic teaching
Catholics are enjoined to pursue all means to prolong life.
Says who? There is a distinct difference between ‘not pursuing all means to prolong life’ and ‘hastening death’. My mother works in hospice, and there’s no question that there’s a difference between ‘not pursuing all means to prolong life’ (something that hospice patients have decided to do) and ‘hastening death’ (hello Dr. Kevorkian?)

Fact is that food and water do not prolong life in the very end stage. The body shuts down system by system and ceases to process the (name removed by moderator)ut prior to death–continuing to pump in food past that point merely causes additional discomfort to the dying person.

I’d also like to see a cite of the specific paragraph–I have a copy of Evangelium Vitae on my desk, and I can’t find anything that states we are required to use of ‘all modern means possible to avoid death’. We do, after all, believe that there is more than this life, so why treat death like something that must be avoided, kicking and screaming like it’s the worst possible thing to befall a soul? (Would that we all feared mortal sin as much as some people fear death …)
 
A few observations:

This isn’t a “Time” story, it is a story about a story. A report on a report. It may say something about “Time” for choosing to publish this story (instead of real news), but they can’t take credit (be blamed) for the story itself.

The Dr. bases her diagnosis on what she saw on T.V. A real Dr. would never dream of diagnosis based on such a thing. This is as bad as the Dr.'s writing about the condition of Terri Shivo without ever seeing her in person.

The Dr. appears to have a profound lack of understanding about palliative care. It is not euthanasia and it is not condemned by the Church.

Nohome
As my father-in-law used to say of some of his less favorite composers - *I don’t blame the idiot that wrote it; I blame the idiot that’s playing it. 😃 *
 
OK–finished my supper, and now I’ve located what I think are the relevant paragraphs from EV, and … surprise, surprise, the writer got it completely and absolutely wrong.
64 … Furthermore, when he denies or neglects his fundamental relationship to God, man thinks he is his own rule and measure, with the right to demand that society should guarantee him the ways and means of deciding what to do with his life in full and complete autonomy. It is especially people in the developed countries who act in this way: they feel encouraged to do so also by the constant progress of medicine and its ever more advanced techniques. By using highly sophisticated systems and equipment … not only to attend to cases formerly considered untreatable and to reduce or eliminate pain, but also to sustain and prolong life even in situations of extreme frailty …
So, here we do see the bit about ‘all modern means possible to avoid death’ but NOT as something which anyone is enjoined to pursue. In fact, if you read the entire paragraph (I’m not quoting the whole thing just because it is long! And I believe the whole text is available on-line, I just haven’t hunted for it since I have the paper copy here.), there’s a strong implication that this ‘constant progress of medicine and ever more advanced techniques’ is not seen that favorably.

But, if you want further evidence as to just how wrong the author got it–let’s consider this snippet:
65 For a correct moral judgment on euthanasia, in the first place a clear definition is required. Euthanasia in the strict sense (emphasis original) is understood to be an action or omission which of itself and by intention (emphasis mine) causes death, with the purpose of eliminating all suffering … Euthanasia must be distinguished from the decision to forego so-called “aggressive medical treatment” … In such situations, when death is clearly imminent and inevitable, one can in conscience “refuse forms of treatment that would only secure a precarious and burdensome prolongation of life…”…It needs to be determined whether the means of treatment available are objectively proportionate to the prospects for improvement. To forego extraordinary or disproportionate means is not the equivalent of suicide or euthanasia; it rather expresses acceptance of the human condition in the face of death…
I just might clean up this post and my prior one for a Letter to the Editor to dear old Time …
 
Euthanasia must be distinguished from the decision to forego so-called “aggressive medical treatment” … In such situations, when death is clearly imminent and inevitable, one can in conscience “refuse forms of treatment that would only secure a precarious and burdensome prolongation of life…”…It needs to be determined whether the means of treatment available are objectively proportionate to the prospects for improvement.
So euthanasia is ok then?
 
So euthanasia is ok then?
Euthanasia refers to the active taking of suffering life - whether the patient takes their own life or another does it for them. Taking an overdose of their pain pills or what have you.

Refusal of medical treatment at a stage where death is imminent (very very near) as well as inevitable (zero or next to zero chance of either cure or substantial prolonging of life) is entirely different to hastening death well before it’s imminent, or when it’s not inevitable, or by a positive action.
 
*17-September-2007 – Catholic World News Brief * ewtn.com/images/printer.gif Doctor Denies Suspending Treatment for John Paul II
Code:
     Rome, Sep. 17, 2007 (CWNews.com) - The physician who cared for Pope John Paul II has rejected claims that the late Pontiff rejected medical treatment in the last hours of his life.
Dr. Renato Buzzonetti issued a heated public response to suggestions that Pope John Paul requested withdrawal of treatment as his death approached. The claims circulated in Italy during the past week, as part of a wide public debate on euthanasia and end-of-life medical treatment.
Pope John Paul received appropriate medical treatment throughout his final illness, Buzzonetti insisted. “Whoever thinks otherwise is mistaken,” he said; “his treatment was never interrupted.”
[Click here to share this news story with a friend.](http://www.ewtn.com/vnews/share_story.asp?headline=Doctor+Denies+Suspending+Treatment+for+John+Paul+II&number=82146)
 
So euthanasia is ok then?
The difference between not using every means possible to preserve life and taking life is a little more obvious than this. There are instances that are tough to call and they are debated regularly.

In this case, a very old man, in failing health, expired. Even if he refused treatment, you are talking about extending life by hours or days rather than months or years. He didn’t need a few more hours, he needed peace in his final hours.

Nohome
 
So euthanasia is ok then?
Absolutely not. I don’t know how you could possibly draw that conclusion from even the snippets I provided above. But just to be perfectly clear:
65 *Euthanasia in the strict sense *(emphasis original) is understood to be an action or omission which *of itself and by intention *(emphasis mine) causes death, with the purpose of eliminating all suffering … Taking into account these distinctions {the aforementioned distinction between euthanasia and foregoing aggressive treatment in addition to a discussion on palliative care}, in harmony with the Magisterium of my Predecessors and in communion with the Bishops of the Catholic Church, I confirm that euthanasia is a grave violation of the law of God (emphasis original), since it is the deliberate and morally unacceptable killing of a human person. This doctrine is based upon the natural law and upon the written word of God, is transmitted by the Church’s Tradition and taught by the ordinary and universal Magisterium.
Depending on the circumstances, this practice involves the malice proper to suicide or murder.
So, in summary:

euthanasia = suicide or murder (obviously illicit)

foregoing aggressive treatment = licit
palliative care to decreased consciousness even with risk of ancillary shortening of life = licit

Using every possible treatment which may defer death is not required of Catholics, nor is the refusal to use every possible treatment equal to euthanasia.

Depriving a non-dying person of nutrition and hydration with intent of causing the person’s death is euthanasia (as the case with Terri Schindler-Schaivo, and apparently Piergiorgio Welby as well). However, there does come a time when even nutrition and hydration are of no benefit to the dying and can even be said to be detrimental to the dying person’s condition, and it becomes licit to discontinue that treatment in the face of imminent death.
 
Sorry everyone.

I got a bit confused about the term “euthanasia”.

No offence intended.
 
I had just found this story and was gonna post it… man why do I always get beaten by like 5 seconds with these threads 🤷
 
Sorry everyone.

I got a bit confused about the term “euthanasia”.

No offence intended.
None taken. I think you had a legitimate question and Melissa did a great job of answering it.

Nohome
 
None taken. I think you had a legitimate question and Melissa did a great job of answering it.

Nohome
Why thank you.

Elric, I’m sorry if my irritation seemed personalized. What truly has riled me about this article (in Time) is that it seems to slander both the late John Paul II as well as the Church as a whole, in addition to completely misrepresenting Catholic teaching on end-of-life issues, and that may well have colored my response without my realization (it’s really hard to read what I’ve written as though reading from someone else’s perspective).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top