Title IX and Universities

  • Thread starter Thread starter OnAJourney
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Regardless of whether the Obama era changes to Title IX resulted in significantly more false accusations and convictions, it absolutely eliminated key components of due process to the accused. No one in this country that believes in justice should be in favor of the reduction and elimination of due process. Reworking Title IX is absolutely the right move. The Obama also used Title IX to vastly expand what constitutes discrimination as well, and this should also be rolled back.
 
They are dealing with criminal allegations that should be in the legal system,
Which begs the question; why are universities handling cases of criminal acts that were allegedly committed? I don’t think universities should be handling these cases at all. It should be a matter of local law enforcement.
They should be in the legal system.
But, in addition, universities have the obligation to oversee conduct to safeguard its students.
The only reason universities handle these allegations in house is because they’re trying to cover their rear end. It’s not out of a sense of protecting either the accuser or the accused.
What actual evidence do you have for this claim?
 
Last edited:
t absolutely eliminated key components of due process to the accused.
These are not criminal proceedings but student conduct proceedings.
All university honors codes abrogate what would be called due process in criminal proceedings.
 
Why else would a university be handling allegations of rape and sexual assault? What possible reason could a university have in pretending to be the law? The process that these universities use in no way protects anyone. It’s a matter of who accuses another person of sexual assault to the title IX office first.
 
Not when it comes to crimes they don’t. Conduct is or at least should be a concern over people cheating their exams or false gossip about other students or bullying. Rape? That’s not a conduct issue. That’s a crime. And the justice system should handle it, not people who have zero interest in protecting accusers without giving a right for the accused to confront the accuser
 
Last edited:
Why else would a university be handling allegations of rape and sexual assault?
They are responsible for maintaining a safe environment for their students, and obliged to report the campus crime climate in detail to the Federal government. They therefore undertake to enforce disciplinary codes to improve the climate.
Conduct is or at least should be a concern over people cheating their exams or false gossip about other students or bullying
Yes they are.
Rape? That’s not a conduct issue. That’s a crime. And the justice system should handle it,
That does not preclude conduct issues, and campus sanctions, related to sexual assault and rape or any other crime.
people who have zero interest in protecting accusers without giving a right for the accused to confront the accuser
In the interest of fairness, I would say that there is insufficient evidence to support this broad charge.
 
There are multiple cases of this happening at Universities and colleges across the country. If I were a victim of rape I wouldn’t be seeking justice from a University. I’d be seeking it in the form of a court of law with a prosecutor and judge. Not a kangaroo court of university admins.
 
It’s not the responsibility to enforce penalties against rape at a college. And not only that, but they lack the authority of the law itself. All they’re doing is slapping people on the wrist for mere accusations.
 
I don’t think it’s the responsibility of the University to look after the individual safety of each and every student. They’re adults. They are not children. You can’t trust a college or university to look after your safety at a drunken frat party. You alone have to be responsible and be safe. And that means making rational decisions like drinking in moderation.
 
There are multiple cases
Of course there are, but the existence of cases doe not provide evidence that the people involved “have zero interest in protecting accusers without giving a right for the accused to confront the accuser”.
It’s not the responsibility to enforce penalties against rape at a college.
It is.
I don’t think it’s the responsibility of the University to look after the individual safety of each and every student.
I am confident that Universities and the vast majority of their clientele and stakeholders disagree with you.
You alone have to be responsible and be safe. And that means making rational decisions like drinking in moderation.
Universities advise responsibility and rational decision making. At the same time there sexual assault is sexual assult even at a drunken frat party.
 
They should be in the legal system.
But, in addition, universities have the obligation to oversee conduct to safeguard its students.
Then maybe you think they should go back to separate floors or dorms based on sex? This would give them rules to implement that safeguard students from assault, in their dorms at least.

However their current codes/rules fully support enabling sexual contact. if you condone or enable PDA and sexual contact then you must also let the law determine when laws are broken. You can’t have kangaroo courts creating their own definitions of “sexual assault”. The consequences of a Univ action can be quite severe on the suspect, it’s appropriate that they reference the outcome of actual legal proceedings.
 
Then maybe you think they should go back to separate floors or dorms based on sex?
That is offered as an option at many institutions, but it efforts to reduce sexual assault are generally focused on things that would make a difference.
you must also let the law determine when laws are broken.
Of course. Universities should not stop v
the consequences of a Univ action can be quite severe on the suspect, it’s appropriate that they reference the outcome of actual legal proceedings.
They can and they should. be severe - at the level of suspension, expulsions, and banishment from campus. But the idea that a university should not act unless there is a prior adjudication at the legal standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt for an action that constitutes a defined crime is not consistent with proper oversight of student conduct. Due process is critical, but the standard of preponderance of the evidence for defined misconduct is the proper one in university.
 
the standard of preponderance of the evidence for defined misconduct is the proper one in university.
That is an incredibly low bar to set for a serious charge such as sexual assault or rape. I’m sorry but we fundamentally disagree on this matter.
 
Not allowing someone with pending allegations to enter their dorms is perfectly reasonable, it safeguards the students. But suspending/expelling the student from the Univ should follow a finding by the legal system.

Schools allow sex offenders to attend, with restrictions. Why be more harsh on someone who isn’t convicted yet and may be completely innocent.
 
Last edited:
But suspending/expelling the student from the Univ should follow a finding by the legal system.
Universities, in consultation with their clientele and stakeholders, disagree.
 
Last edited:
Universities, in consultation with their clientele and stakeholders, disagree.
Yet they also allow convicted sex offenders to enroll and obtain their degree. Why the double standard for someone not even shown guilty of a crime or offense, just an allegation?

It’s #metoo gone too far
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top