To date or not to date...?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TOBaddict
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you completely ironclad 1000% sure you never want kids, or it it more like “eh, don’t really see motherhood in my future…”
 
I never, ever wanted children. EVER.

But when I converted and became Catholic I knew I had to discern what my vocation was. Was I meant to be a religious single? A single? Married?

I knew the most important part of discerning that was dating. So I dated. I kept things super casual, ended things super quick if the person I was dating appeared to be developing feelings and I wasn’t returning those feelings.

I prayed and prayed and begged God for clarity and suddenly, out of the blue, I wanted children. I just knew if I didn’t have a child, I would not be complete.

So I returned to dating, this time more seriously. Within two years I was married and within one month I am now pregnant.

So my advice is date to discern.

Don’t let things get serious though. If you are Catholic then you know marriage isn’t just about ‘love’, it’s about so much more and if you are not open to life (children) you cannot get married within the Church.

I think after dating for a bit you’ll figure out if your vocation is marriage or single life.

And if your vocation is to be single you can still hang out with people, go to dinner with people and etc. It just won’t be ‘dating’ and will be platonic friendships.
 
I’m open to the idea of children, but I have the same issue as you, lol. I am rather paranoid about similar situations with men who don’t share the faith. Do I immediately reject? What if I end up liking him if I don’t? Sigh
 
I ended up with a non-Catholic man who has Catholic morals. LOL. He’s my closet Catholic. He encourages me to go to Mass, takes me to Confession and supports me in my faith 100%.

Non-Catholic men can sometimes be good partners. It’s a case by case basis for sure.
 
For sure, but a large majority of men and women my age are not practicing Christians or Catholic (or any religion, really). I don’t mind atheists or anyone really, if they’re willing to respect my stance on a lot of issues. But many have extremely different views on a lot of things. I figured that if all of my friends are like that, the odds of me finding one partner that is like me…is way too slim. Maybe I should start looking up the single life, lol
 
It can happen. Took me 35 years and a lot of toads but I found a fellow who was the ideal match. Took a lot of patience though! haha.
 
Go for it. As long as you remember not to have any sexual relations with this person unless you marry. Who knows, you may even like this person so much you may change your mind and say “hey, maybe kids aren’t such a bad idea after all”
 
I think you shouldn’t date. You can go out with people, males if you feel you are strong enough to keep it platonic and you make it very clear that it is non negotiable. But believe me that could be tricky. I dont think you should even think of dating if you are not going to marry and be open to having children. I am sure this was a difficult decision for you and your own business. If you date you will only be opening yourself to the possibility of sin and temptation at the very least (which is by far easier to avoid by staying well clear than by jumping onto the slippery slope and trying to stay upright) and also you will be opening someone else up to sin and /or the temptation to sin, which is really unfair and a sin to boot. I suggest keeping busy with friends and family and activities until you are past child bearing years and then if you wish you could date and marry.
I am living a single life and older than you and I have a very fulfilled life and am exceedingly happy. Single life is not horrible or lonely, the parish is very much a part of my life as is my community and I have a chronic illness so I am some what limited, yet still, I love life and my singleness.
 
Last edited:
I’ve never had the option. Being completely honest, I have a chronic illness and barely leave my house. Most days bedridden. People leave because that’s “boring” or they’re too selfish. Don’t get me wrong, I have some awesome supportive friends who understand. Just unsure of the future.

Joining you, Bluebright, on the chronically ill single people train. Glad someone can relate! I do love being single and it’s never bothered me.
 
I wasn’t talking about you, I was just talking about myself.
 
(I have legitimate reasons, don’t hassle me)
Whoa, there Lassie, I wasn’t going to offer anything but support for you. I never wanted kids and never wanted to get married either. When I turned 23 I became convinced of one, then the other. 37 years later it seems to be working out. But no one is obliged to take part in these tribal expectations. My wife and I both agree that being married has been good but neither of us have any desire to go through it again. One of us will eventually be single, that’s just a fact, and both of us are fine with that. So do whatever you feel is best for you and pay no heed to the matchmakers and the wedding planners.
 
You can date. You probably should. It would help you learn a lot about yourself and others. A
I recall that the minor seminary (high school) not only sent the boys to a co-ed Catholic high school, but actually encouraged them to date.

hawk
 
Welcome to the chronically ill single lady train 😉 God has found great purpose for me in my life and given me the most amazing things I never could have dreamed of. If you ever need someone to chat to you are welcome to message me. I think my illnesses are likely not as bad as yours as I do get to care for myself and leave my house which sadly in my country is a mixed blessing but that’s beside the point and I got them later in life which just makes me the youngest retired person in my parish, lol.
 
And I know women who ended up with severely broken hearts and warped feelings toward the Church because they dated and fell in love with some of those young men, who went on to become priests. I guess it’s great for the young men to have had a chance to find themselves, but not so great for the women who they road tested.

The thing about dating is that it involves another person, and their hopes, dreams, fears and emotions. If you are certain you don’t want kids and therefore aren’t open to marriage, don’t waste the time, emotions and good will of someone who is seeking a life partner. That’s just not fair. I’ve heard this same advice given to people with same sex attraction, to date the opposite sex “just to see” and again hearts get broken and sometimes lives get destroyed.

The OP’s feelings might alter in time, but until then…what’s the point of seeking a mate if you never intend to mate? Pray for discernment, but don’t use others as a means to your own end.

I was taught not to advertise what wasn’t for sale.
 
Yeah, I agree. Dating isn’t just about you. There are two people involved. It’s somewhat selfish and reckless to date “just for fun”.
 
I think many people don’t want kids when they’re single but that changes when they love someone and they love them back

And I don’t think you should think a date is anything beyond just the date itself.
Yes to the first statement, exactly my story.
But the latter I see more critically. I’m not a fan of overweighting a date with future plans, but on the other side, it’s different than just meeting or getting to know a friend. Otherwise it would not be strange and not appropriate for a married person to date. The factor here must be, as a consequence, being free to marry. If being able to marry is the same as being free to marry? Maybe not. It depends on the OP’s reasons for not planning marriage.
 
Hello.

What are your goals in life? Is dating a way to reach them, or not?

You are in my prayers. Please pray for me.
 
And I know women who ended up with severely broken hearts and warped feelings toward the Church because they dated and fell in love with some of those young men, who went on to become priests. I
They were definitely not of marriageable age, and were quite clearly seminarians, arriving and leaving in a seminary bus each day (presumably the only bus at that school).

hawk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top