Grace, what can I tell you about the first part? I can only smile and nod. And as for your question, yes, I do believe many women are attracted to difficult men. You mentioned stubbornness. I would say women are both attracted and pushed off by it, much like men react to being stood up and talked back to.
And now for what you refer to me, I’m sorry for stealing so much attention, as it seems. I was deliberately being obscure.
To keep it short, she had had a bf when we worked together, but it ended before she looked me up on the Internet. This isn’t really a question of standards or judgement. I will be the first to say that a small thing doesn’t merit a big penalty, but sometimes, in the romantic area, small things can be signs of rather big incompatibilities. The song contained most probably an irreverent use of a divine name in the name of either the song or the band. I wouldn’t dare to make any moral conclusions out of this one fact, but as far as compatibility is concerned, I think it’s an important clue if merely because of the way it made me feel and the likelihood of there being more things that I would found disagreeable. Such things generally have a dead fish effect on me when it comes to dating.
This doesn’t mean the possibility is permanently closed or anything like that, but from open until closed it’s switched to closed until opened. I would need to be convinced to open a dating prospect, rather than being open to it and needing to be convinced to close it.
I had similar inhibitions when, talking to a dear acquaintance from when we were both 18 and oh-so-much-more-sparkly, I heard she didn’t agree with the Church on things, from which it seemed it was an independence choice. That was very likely a sign of progress from simply a less informed position, a sign of a critical mind that could be put to great use. A position similar to the one I once held myself. But as I was relatively fresh after being broken up with by an agnostic fallen-away Catholic girl I much cared for, I took it as a red flag not as to the value of the person, but as to the prospects between her and me. There are just some things I wouldn’t like to have to deal with.
This has nothing to do with the value of respective persons, which in many cases probably far exceeds my own, for all the faults I have. It may seem hypocritical that I know I have my own problems of which the gravity is rather higher, but at the same time I see a problem in living with someone else’s perhaps smaller thoughts, but this is a compatibility issue. Morality doesn’t translate to compatibility that well.
You know, after all, one could be an ascetic person giving up bathing as a means of mortification. For instance. We could admire the person, but we couldn’t stand being in the same room for too long a time.
Now I’m not saying you should adopt a similar attitude to my own, but some situations call for choices. I’m a lawyer, so reconstructing chains of causes and results comes rather natural and easy to me. I do not shy away from making a conclusion based on a small piece of data as long as the inference is valid. On top of that, I catch fast and my intuition has sometimes been better than my deduction.
So, I see small things, I see connections between them and I see what else they could be connected with. I abstain from judging because that is not enough for judgement and a person’s moral state or “worth” is not my business and as far as I go, I wish that it were the highest. But I make a fast date-or-not-date call on sometimes small signs which could seem shocking to people.
One thing to bear in mind when this touches on compatibility and matters of the romantic life, any little thing that doesn’t sit well with you must be multiplied by 20, 30, 40, 50 years of daily coexistence. In this light, even tooth-brushing habits suddenly acquire importance.
So some of my “quick” inferences may seem cruel, but in the long run they are possibly similar to the break-up that was better than a possible difforce after several years into marriage. Or a life of having to put with a lot.
But we’re talking about you, not about my dating habits.
It is perfectly normal that you are heartbroken. We always are if we lose someone we care for and especially so, I guess, if we need to give that person up ourselves. You felt you had to give Mohammed up because that relationship wouldn’t help you get to heaven. This concern outweighed all others. It doesn’t mean the others were not important and it’s natural that you feel the loss of them. However, it is correctly the most important thing and you made your choice basing on it. Consequences of doing the right thing or what we see as the right thing can be rather painful. But that is part of the charm of the right thing (in jaded speak), or perhaps a trial that accompanies the moral choices that we need to make (a more Christian outlook perhaps). Doing the right thing is not easy. Everyone would be doing the right thing if it were easy or convenient.
As for jaded, I don’t think you are. When someone said he was tired of jaded girls, he probably meant he was tired of girls who were unable to be happy, who expected every good thing to be short-lasted, who looked for a bad thing in everything that was good, who had made up their mind about men as a whole, who expected nothing good from men and so on. That kind of attitude can indeed be tiring. However, I don’t really see it in you, even now.
As for ending up alone in your life, I don’t think that. However, looking in the right places and rethinking your preferences might help. Love doesn’t choose, but if we reflect on what’s important for us, on our values, well, needs, expectations, it affects the choices we make and even who we are attracted to (in any sense more than merely physical, and even that one sometimes).