Nobody has any power to make other people behave in a certain way. All anyone can do is make suggestions - whether those suggestions will be followed or not is up to the people themselves.
Try telling that to your boss at work. Seriously! Does this argument really hold any water?
It’s not the priest who decorates the Church; it’s the decorating committee - and they will do it the way they were taught to do it by their grandparents way back in 1964, and they may or may not consider the suggestions of the priest.
The priest does not give “suggestions”. I mean, he may give suggestions, but if the pastor wants it a certain way, then it should be like that, unless there is something morally wrong with what he is asking.
If volunteers do not want to follow the priest’s instructions, then that is their own problem. Of all of these supposed “committees” and “councils”,
the priest has the final say. The council is only there to advise the priest, not take his instructions as “guidelines”. They are there to assist him.
Sometimes when I’m serving Mass for priests of a more [cough] liberal [cough] slant, I don’t always like what they ask me to do (such as not ring the bells, or whatever), but as long as there is nothing wrong with what he is asking of me, I obey him, because
my role is to assist him, not push my agenda. Same with the parish council.
The priest is in a bind in that if he fires them, no one else will volunteer out of fear of being criticized for their work.
Is this the same attitude people have when getting a job? If I get hired, and get “criticized” because I don’t do what my boss says, or don’t show up for work, or whatever, does that mean my boss is a bad boss because he told me what to do?
I know a group of priests near me that shortly after arriving switched the server program to altar boy only, eliminated EMHCs, and corrected many abuses, with the full support of the bishop, I might add. Yes, people got mad. People got ticked off because they didn’t always listen to the “rulings” of the parish council. Some people even left. But guess what: it doesn’t matter. Many disciples left the Lord Jesus when he got into the more difficult teachings.
They turned the parish around 180 degrees, and now many more people love them for their heroism, because they told the people not what they wanted to hear, but what they needed to hear. And now even more people attend their parish, because of this. They now have one of the best parishes in the whole diocese.