Toddler critically burned during SWAT raid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So we can presume guilt before the arrest, but we do not presume guilt after…
:confused:
Totally agree…in the US, the police are supposed to treat people as innocent UNTIL proven guilty in a court of law and NOT guilty until proven innocent, it seems LE today prefers the latter though.

This is just more proof law enforcement is out of control when it comes to the ‘war on drugs’ It seems they are the last ones to realize this ‘war’ was lost many years ago LOL I mean, they take down a couple dealers here and there, and before the week is out, 5 more have sprung up to take their place…as long as there is a demand in this country, someone WILL always be there to supply them, its that simple.

I also have to question why LE continues on with this war on drugs after this many years and it has never really worked, the cartels are getting more than ever into the country right now, heroin use is an epidemic in many cities and states, I truly cannot believe LE is still going about this in the exact same way, trying to ‘arrest away’ the problem, when this has NEVER worked, did not work in alcohol prohibition and is not working now?

So this fact and many others suggest to me the Govt has another concern versus what they say publicly about drugs, and the safety of the public, if they were that concerned about safety, why is tobacco still legal, why is alcohol still legal? why arent more and more regulations and restrictions imposed (or at the very minimum, suggesting more) on these 2 things?

IMO, moderation is the key here, just with anything else, if more people could use in moderation, we would not have the problems we do, going after dealers and users with SWAT teams is only going to cause more problems for LE long term.

Personally I have no problem with someone choosing what chemicals to put in their own bodies, if they like the feelings it gives them, so be it, as long as they dont harm anyone else, I dont have a problem with it, and Govt in general also should not even be in the equation, drug addiction has PROVEN to be a disease, so why are they still trying to solve a medical problem using force? LOL doesnt make sense to me.
 
I know this may be a difficult concept for some, but the flash bang was not aimed at the child. The officers stated there were no signs of a child being present.
I know this may be difficult concept for some, but a playpen is a sign of a child being present.
 
So we can presume guilt before the arrest, but we do not presume guilt after…
:confused:
Guilt was not presumed.
I see nothing wrong with my statement.
Can you let me know what exactly you find a problem with?
I am sure the grenade going off next to the baby’s face was a distraction…

Flash bangs are not designed for baby faces. There was not intent to throw it in a crib. There has been no finding that the actions were contrary to policy and procedure. The police should not be assumed to be guilty. Even more to the point, I note that there is a reasonable understanding that the police used a flash bang, and that a child was injured as a result. Yet there is a lack of the same level of reasonable understanding that the man in the house had conducted the drug transactions that led to this raid. If we believe one, we should believe the other. If we want to focus on the innocence of the one dealing drugs, we should also focus on the innocence of the police. This is simple consistency.
 
I know this may be difficult concept for some, but a playpen is a sign of a child being present.
Yes, that would have been. From the article:
There was no clothes, no toys, nothing to indicate that there was children present in the home. If there had been then we’d have done something different,” Darby said
 
I also have to question why LE continues on with this war on drugs after this many years and it has never really worked, the cartels are getting more than ever into the country right now, heroin use is an epidemic in many cities and states, I truly cannot believe LE is still going about this in the exact same way, trying to ‘arrest away’ the problem, when this has NEVER worked, did not work in alcohol prohibition and is not working now?
Law enforcement continues this war because that is the law of the land. Just like police do not need to act like judge and jury, they also are not allowed to act as legislatures. Police are not responsible for the war on drugs. Politicians are. If we as a society see a need to change directions, then we need to elect leaders that are not pro-drug enforcement. This comes with a price though, as in our rather partisan environment, those that favor lessening drug enforcement usually support more unsavory and deadly issues.

For the record, I agree with the premise thought that the war on drugs is an unmitigated failure.
 
This was avoidable: the Intel that was gathered wasn’t thorough. I’m not talking about “not seeing evidence of a child being in the home” during an undercover investigation (which I’m hoping happened more than once) I’m talking about ongoing surveillance.

I’d like to hear a bit more about “Not seeing evidence of a child,” not just from visits to the house, but from ongoing, random checks, and proper surveillance. I don’t buy the “lack of funds or resources to watch a place,” since the department allocated funds for a raid. After all, the surveillance wouldn’t just be for occupants, but for the threat assessment for the safety of the police.

N.B: If the Intel that was gathered was thorough, the suspect would have been at home at the time of the warrant.

It was poor surveillance, cut and dry. The investigators didn’t know a child had been living in the home, because they didn’t watch the house. Even from the outside, you can find someone carrying in diapers, or mom coming in with baby and not leaving for the evening.

I’m really interested in how the department proved its due diligence. I don’t know how long they watched the house, when the child moved in, or the criteria for the threat assessment for the protection of the officers. I’m in the dark about a lot, here.

Conversely, I’ll speculate:
The poorly timed (suspect wasn’t even home) no knock warrant meant that the child was already in danger in that environment. We do know that the child had to be “hidden” during drug deals. We can be pretty sure that there were weapons (again, I speculate) that were most likely not secured properly. Strangers were in and out at all hours. The mother may have been doing the best she could with what she had, but the child’s safety (and hers) were already at a high risk if there was a warrant for an occupant.

This was a tragedy waiting to happen, with or without law enforcement.

I shudder to wonder how deeply Mom may have been involved in the goings on, and her anger and natural Mother’s Guilt at what happened.
 
Guilt was not presumed.
Yet they threw a grenade into a room without properly checking.

Seems to me actions that are more properly taken against enemy combatants in battle rather then a citizen who is not presumed guilty of anything.
 
I’d like to hear a bit more about “Not seeing evidence of a child,” not just from visits to the house, but from ongoing, random checks, and proper surveillance.
My understanding was the mother had a van with 4 car seats in it parked in front of the house.

It would also appear there were children present, not just the one child in the play pen.

I find it difficult to believe that there was no sign of a child in the house.
Particularly if there were multiple children.

Of course, the police did say it was dark and they could not see.
So is that an excuse for the tragedy or a reason not to use the grenade?
 
If we want to focus on the innocence of the one dealing drugs, we should also focus on the innocence of the police. This is simple consistency.
The police admitted to throwing in the grenade in the dark without knowing exactly what they would or would not injure.
 
I find it difficult to believe that there was no sign of a child in the house.
Particularly if there were multiple children.
Yet that is what the police said in the article. Therefore, since they are presumed to be innocent, they should be given the benefit of the doubt, at least at this time.
 
Yet that is what the police said in the article. Therefore, since they are presumed to be innocent, they should be given the benefit of the doubt, at least at this time.
A presumption of innocence does not at all mean that I must believe what they are saying.

The facts as they stand seem to indicate extremely poor surveillance.

Given that thorough surveillance is required for a ‘no-knock’ warrant, it is going to be interesting to see how this plays out in court.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top