Together We Thrive: Tucson & America

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Gov Jan Brewer thanks Pres. Obama for coming. “Your presence is a reminder that we are not alone in our sorrow,” she says.

Also asks for God’s blessings

AZ Gov. Brewer: “There is no way to measure what Tucson and Arizona lost on Saturday.”
 
Now pool report that there are 27,000 people in Arizona Stadium watching the event on full screens. People who could not get inside McKale.
 
Obama’s speech was good… if you read it.

The crowd was inappropriate and disgraceful…cheering like a rock concert when 6 people died? Crazy.

Sadly… I think Obama was thrown off as well. I am sure he was expecting somber. Like a memorial should be.

The native American praying for all that slither on the earth and under the earth… was ridiculous. It could only go downhill from there.

T-shirts were also put on everyone chair? For a memorial? Weird.

Had Obama given that speech at a church or at least in front of adults… it would have been beautiful.
 
Obama’s speech was good… if you read it.

The crowd was inappropriate and disgraceful…cheering like a rock concert when 6 people died? Crazy.

Sadly… I think Obama was thrown off as well. I am sure he was expecting somber. Like a memorial should be.

The native American praying for all that slither on the earth and under the earth… was ridiculous. It could only go downhill from there.

T-shirts were also put on everyone chair? For a memorial? Weird.

Had Obama given that speech at a church or at least in front of adults… it would have been beautiful.
Yes, but he could not deliver his fine speech in such a small venue. He had to give it as he found it, and there were some 27,000 people of all sorts in the audience - the respectful as well as some jerks.

What is important is that the event was held and that recognition was given and the dead memorialized. We ought not look at it as a political moment, but as an American moment.
 
Yes, but he could not deliver his fine speech in such a small venue. He had to give it as he found it, and there were some 27,000 people of all sorts in the audience - the respectful as well as some jerks.

What is important is that the event was held and that recognition was given and the dead memorialized. We ought not look at it as a political moment, but as an American moment.
I wasn’t looking at it as a political moment. Where did you get that out of what I wrote?
 
I wasn’t looking at it as a political moment. Where did you get that out of what I wrote?
I didn’t mean you personally. I was using the encompassing sense of the word we. You’ve heard of “We the People.” That is an encompassing term, not referring to just the people hearing the speaker.
 
Excellent speech but I was perturbed by all of the whopping, hollering, and whistling at inapropriate times. I was also saddened that Boehner wasn’t where he should have been.
 
Excellent speech but I was perturbed by all of the whopping, hollering, and whistling at inapropriate times. I was also saddened that Boehner wasn’t where he should have been.
Read the speech. Its good when you read it. Obama did look like he didnt know what to make of the cheering. His speech is somber, which was appropriate.

I think the lesson… NEVER have a memorial at a college campus… and the college putting t-shirts out was weird.

Why would Boehner have to be there. Congress had a memorial today themselves.
 
Read the speech. Its good when you read it. Obama did look like he didnt know what to make of the cheering. His speech is somber, which was appropriate…
I detected a little irritation and bewilderment at some of the responses from the crowd.
I think the lesson… NEVER have a memorial at a college campus… and the college putting t-shirts out was weird.
I agree. At the beginning of the event I was questioning whether it was a memorial service for the trajedy that happened Saturday or a graduation ceremony complete with shout-outs to the University.
Why would Boehner have to be there. Congress had a memorial today themselves.
Boehner doesn’t necessarily “have” to be anywhere but it would have been nice for the leader of the House of Representatives to have been there as the minority leader was. I guess it’s not so much that he wasn’t there; moreso where he actually was. I think it was a little inappropriate for him to choose an RNC fundraising reception over the President’s offer to join him in Tucson.
 
Excellent speech but I was perturbed by all of the whopping, hollering, and whistling at inapropriate times. I was also saddened that Boehner wasn’t where he should have been.
The crowd was made up largely of college students. They got into line early. The older folks ended up in the stadium. That accounts for the wooping, hollering and whistling. That’s what college students do.

I had to leave the speech and come back to it a few minutes ago on reply. I thought the president did very well.

With the VP out of country, the Speaker of the House probably should not be traveling with the president places. It goes against the continuity of government guidelines. Might be the reason he wasn’t here.

I don’t care, and we don’t care. We don’t know him. We know Obama, Brewer, McCain, Kyl, Napolitano (remember she is one of us), and they were here. That is what counts for us.

The president of the united states came to us in our hour of hurt and talked to us about healing. He did it in person, not on TV. They got as many people with him as they could. You can’t beat that.
 
Obama’s speech was good… if you read it.

The crowd was inappropriate and disgraceful…cheering like a rock concert when 6 people died? Crazy.

Sadly… I think Obama was thrown off as well. I am sure he was expecting somber. Like a memorial should be.

The native American praying for all that slither on the earth and under the earth… was ridiculous. It could only go downhill from there.

T-shirts were also put on everyone chair? For a memorial? Weird.

Had Obama given that speech at a church or at least in front of adults… it would have been beautiful.
I personally liked His speech. Especially His call not to “Jump to Conclusions” or “Point Fingers” and not to Assume this Horrfying Tragedy was caused by “Lack Of Civility” BUT to discuss its Meaning in a Civil Way. 👍

I also loved His emphasizing of the Victims, particularly Little Christina-Taylor Green. Very Moving and Dignified.

On a side Note, Daniel Hernandez, Giffords’s Intern who saved Her life, Emerged as one of the Most Provocative Speakers of the Evening. Especially His empahsizing he was NOT a hero.

And the whole “Gabby Opened Her Eyes” Statement is Sure (Hopefully) to be put as the Lead Headline in some Papers Tomorrow. Brought Down the House Almost. 🙂

OTOH, I DO agree the Whooping and Hollering brought the Service Down to the Level of a Pep Rally. Too bad.

But I agree with you, StJudePrayForUs. It is NOT Wise to have College Students be the Majority Part of an Audience Like this. Oh well, could have been FAR WORSE. 🤷

The Whole Indian Leader Routine WAS very Weird and Smacked of Political Correctness, I thought. Where were the Catholic/Protestant/Jewish Leaders to open the Service?:confused:
I would particuallry have liked to see the Catholic Bishop of Tucson there (Given Judge Roll’s Strong Devout Catholicism) and the Reform Rabbi of Geffords’s Congrgation, given her Strong Judaism.

Ultimately, I see it as Possible Political Correctness being Inserted into the Tragedy-------Possibly by the College.

What was remarkable was how Obama was able to quickly find a “Rhythm” to Adapt to the Crowd’s Behavior. I agree He went from Surprised at the Lack Of Somberness to Switching His Tone to match the Spirit Of That Particular Crowd. :o

Not Surprising—the “Respectful, Restrained” Applause for the Republican Governor Jan Brewer and the ENTHUSIASTIC One for Democrats (Particularly Former Arizona Governor Napolitano and Obama).
SOME things never Change. :rolleyes:

I agree the Speech by Obama and its Delivery was Great----the Rest was a Mixed Bag.

VERY Mixed bag. 👍
 
But at a time when our discourse has become so sharply polarized – at a time when we are far too eager to lay the blame for all that ails the world at the feet of those who think differently than we do – it’s important for us to pause for a moment and make sure that we are talking with each other in a way that heals, not a way that wounds.
Scripture tells us that there is evil in the world, and that terrible things happen for reasons that defy human understanding. In the words of Job, “when I looked for light, then came darkness.” Bad things happen, and we must guard against simple explanations in the aftermath.
For the truth is that none of us can know exactly what triggered this vicious attack. None of us can know with any certainty what might have stopped those shots from being fired, or what thoughts lurked in the inner recesses of a violent man’s mind.
It takes political courage for Obama to say this. Much of his base smells blood as they once again can see a means to slander the right as ‘scary’.

But for Obama, truth and dignity were a higher priority than poltical advantage. He paid full homage to the solemnity of the dead and wounded, and sought the higher ground to help make their lives meaningful and purposeful in spite of this heinous, despicable act.

Obama rose to the moment. He was President of the United States today, and not the cog in the Chicago political machine.

God bless President Obama.
God bless the United States of America.
 
I didn’t get a chance to watch it, but I googled it up and started browsing through random forums. From what I gather the a lot of the people are saying that it was ridiculous how people were making all kinds of disrespectful noises, that it was almost like Obama was starting his re election campaign with the slogan and the shirts.

Tuscon has a big native American population, other than that I don’t know why there was an Indian praying. Doesn’t really matter though, they are just as strong in their beliefs as anyone else I reckon.

Doesn’t sound like people really cared for it much since it didn’t seem like a memorial but another Obama speech.

Those aren’t my opinions, just what I gathered.
 
Please don’t condemn the cheering and such that occurred at this memorial. If this was in a church–it would have been uncalled for. But we all needed a release and this was a venue where we all could come together and focus on the good and release the tensions of the past week. I think the cheering and the stomping and all was a good thing!

And to hear scripture and “God” come from our politicians–is a GOOD thing too!!!

A lot of good is coming out of this tragedy…people are coming together and supporting each other in ways that would never had occurred before. God is making good out of something tragic.

God bless,

Barbara
 
It takes political courage for Obama to say this. Much of his base smells blood as they once again can see a means to slander the right as ‘scary’.

But for Obama, truth and dignity were a higher priority than poltical advantage. He paid full homage to the solemnity of the dead and wounded, and sought the higher ground to help make their lives meaningful and purposeful in spite of this heinous, despicable act.

Obama rose to the moment. He was President of the United States today, and not the cog in the Chicago political machine.

God bless President Obama.
God bless the United States of America.
I completely agree. I commend the President for excellent leadership in regards to this tragic and heinous crime. He did an excellent job expressing that this atrocity should and does go far above and beyond political bickering and finger pointing by those who just want to slander others they disagree with. The focus was on the victims and their families as it should be.

I am a libertarian leaning conservative, and I say: Excellent speech and excellent job in handling this terrible event in our country Mr. President.
 
I completely agree. I commend the President for excellent leadership in regards to this tragic and heinous crime. He did an excellent job expressing that this atrocity should and does go far above and beyond political bickering and finger pointing by those who just want to slander others they disagree with. The focus was on the victims and their families as it should be.
👍
am a libertarian leaning conservative, and I say: Excellent speech and excellent job in handling this terrible event in our country Mr. President.
👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top