Obama’s speech was good… if you read it.
The crowd was inappropriate and disgraceful…cheering like a rock concert when 6 people died? Crazy.
Sadly… I think Obama was thrown off as well. I am sure he was expecting somber. Like a memorial should be.
The native American praying for all that slither on the earth and under the earth… was ridiculous. It could only go downhill from there.
T-shirts were also put on everyone chair? For a memorial? Weird.
Had Obama given that speech at a church or at least in front of adults… it would have been beautiful.
I personally liked His speech. Especially His call not to “Jump to Conclusions” or “Point Fingers” and not to Assume this Horrfying Tragedy was caused by “Lack Of Civility” BUT to discuss its Meaning in a Civil Way.
I also loved His emphasizing of the Victims, particularly Little Christina-Taylor Green. Very Moving and Dignified.
On a side Note, Daniel Hernandez, Giffords’s Intern who saved Her life, Emerged as one of the Most Provocative Speakers of the Evening. Especially His empahsizing he was NOT a hero.
And the whole “Gabby Opened Her Eyes” Statement is Sure (Hopefully) to be put as the Lead Headline in some Papers Tomorrow. Brought Down the House Almost.
OTOH, I DO agree the Whooping and Hollering brought the Service Down to the Level of a Pep Rally. Too bad.
But I agree with you, StJudePrayForUs. It is NOT Wise to have College Students be the Majority Part of an Audience Like this. Oh well, could have been FAR WORSE.
The Whole Indian Leader Routine WAS very Weird and Smacked of Political Correctness, I thought. Where were the Catholic/Protestant/Jewish Leaders to open the Service?

I would particuallry have liked to see the Catholic Bishop of Tucson there (Given Judge Roll’s Strong Devout Catholicism) and the Reform Rabbi of Geffords’s Congrgation, given her Strong Judaism.
Ultimately, I see it as Possible Political Correctness being Inserted into the Tragedy-------Possibly by the College.
What was remarkable was how Obama was able to quickly find a “Rhythm” to Adapt to the Crowd’s Behavior. I agree He went from Surprised at the Lack Of Somberness to Switching His Tone to match the Spirit Of That Particular Crowd.
Not Surprising—the “Respectful, Restrained” Applause for the Republican Governor Jan Brewer and the ENTHUSIASTIC One for Democrats (Particularly Former Arizona Governor Napolitano and Obama).
SOME things never Change.
I agree the Speech by Obama and its Delivery was Great----the Rest was a Mixed Bag.
VERY Mixed bag.
