Sunday Blessings, Palmas,
I am very pleased that you would not act if you were not sure the inspiration came from the Holy Spirit. Has this happened to you ? Would you say that other Charismatics also admit the possibility that not all manifestations are real?.
You probably remember the scripture that we must always test the spirit to see if it is from God. That is not an easy process to learn, and I have spent years, personally, trying to do this. So did holy St. Ignatius of Loyola. I am grateful his long struggles in discernment were transmitted to us as his precious teachings. (I have a thread on a few of his principles in “Spirituality.”)
Some of the charismatics I have met are among the most sincere, devout, commited Catholics I know. Others are green behind the ears, sometimes proud, sometimes mistaken, but they are part of me in the Body of Christ, and I cannot disown them because they are immature. God has timetables of growth, and we are all on different steps. A tiny branch, withered, storm-battered, is still as much a part of the tree as the mighty branch that supports many smaller shoots. This is why I say, we cannot judge, for if they belong to God, and were baptized into His Spirit, we offend God by despising any of His little ones.
Also, since many if not most of the manifestations these days seem to be of the speaking in tongues variety, would you think it possible that the Holy Spirit is trying to effect a change in the Mass itself? It does appear that much of the speaking in tongues occurs during Mass.
That is because tongues are so foreign to the majority who hear them, and therefore seem so prominent. Yet there are other charisms that are probably more widely used, but the faithful do not recognize them as such because of their scanty education. Unless the average Catholic in the pew has studied this, they would not know when one of these gifts is being manifested.
For example, St. Paul advises us to strive after the spiritual gifts, but “
especially that you may prophesy!” (1 Cor. 14:1-3) “For he who prophesies speaks to men for edification and encouragement and consolation.” Our Lord frequently inspires His servants with this gift on this very forum, for I have seen hundreds of wonderful posts where edification and encouragement are dispensed, “giving others their ration of food in due time.” Many would not recognize it as prophecy, though, because often their concept of prophecy is foretelling the future. Not at all!
So far, have not yet seen anyone writing here in tongues.
http://forum.catholic.com/images/smilies/ani/rotfl.gif
As to your question about the Holy Spirit effecting a change in the Mass … I like this paragraph from the CCC:
1098 The assembly should *prepare *itself to encounter its Lord and to become “a people well disposed.” The preparation of hearts is the joint work of the Holy Spirit and the assembly, especially of its ministers. The grace of the Holy Spirit seeks to awaken faith, conversion of heart, and adherence to the Father’s will. These dispositions are the precondition both for the reception of other graces conferred in the celebration itself and the fruits of new life which the celebration is intended to produce afterward.
What I believe is the general disposition of hearts at a charismatic liturgy is one of profound praise within those who are authentically prepared to worship. Even should a ruling come about that would force silence of their praise to God outwardly in tongues, they will still praise Him inwardly, with deep unction and worship. So God still sees their heart, either way. Why this bothers some people is hard for me to understand, honestly. Even though I do not speak in tongues, I respect all outward honor and praise to God, and it does not infringe on my ability to do likewise. There are certainly numerous moments within Mass that tongues are not used, which affords the assembly personal prayer time.
I’m thinking for the moment of the prophet Balaam, who was hired to curse the Israelites, but he could not do so, even after three attempts, saying, “How can I curse whom God has not cursed?” (Num. 23:8) So, my friend, neither can I be upset with charismatics.
I hope this was somewhat helpful for you.
Carole