Too Religious to Home-School?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Abyssinia

Guest
Brenda Voydatch leafs through her daughter’s school books inside her single-story home in Meredith, New Hampshire.

“These are her math and science books,” she says.

Like many parents who home-school, Voydatch believes in the importance of teaching the basics of reading and writing. But she also believes in the importance of a religious education.

“I believe it’s a parents fundamental right to teach a child the beliefs within their home,” she says as she looks up at the painting of Jesus holding a child. “I believe that’s every parent’s right.”

It was that religious education that led to her ex-husband’s objections. It also led to a New Hampshire judge to order Brenda’s 11 year-old daughter Amanda to attend public school.

It’s an order her attorney, John Anthony Simmons, calls a clear Constitutional violation.

“The judge,” explained Simmons, “said that Amanda reflected her mother’s rigidity in matters of Faith, and that because of that rigidity she needed to be ordered into government run schools. “

Read more: liveshots.blogs.foxnews.com/2011/01/27/too-religious-to-home-school/#ixzz1CKTTlazK
 
It seems this case is not about the state objecting to religion, but the ex-husband. It seems that the debate is more of a variation on a custody battle than whether religion is appropriate in a home school setting. I wonder how this is usually settled. If one parent is Christian and the other Jewish, and they both wish their child to be not raised in the others belief system, is it simply decided by who gets custody?

The only way that someone might be too religious for homeschooling is if they were the sort of people who would deny their child medical care for religious reasons. At least in a public school setting there would be some possibility that untreated medical conditions would be detected and there could be intervention on behalf of the child.
 
Well ignoring for the time being the ex-husband factor the state cannot order a child into public schools as opposed to a private religious school (Pierce v. Society of Sisters surpeme court decision)

I dont know about home schooling though.
 
Here is a news story from the Concord Monitor:
High court hears home school case
Attorneys for the divorced parents of a Meredith girl argued before the state Supreme Court yesterday about whether a lower court was right to order the girl from home schooling to public school.
The daughter of Brenda Voydatch and Martin Kurowski has attended public school in Meredith since September 2009, after a Belknap County judge ruled in a dispute between the parents about how to educate the girl. Voydatch had taught their daughter, Amanda, at home since she was in first grade. After Kurowski, who shares decision-making responsibility, charged that Voydatch had not consulted him about educating their daughter at home, the parents agreed to a court hearing to decide where Amanda would be taught.
In ordering the parents to send Amanda to public school last year, the court observed that while her curriculum compared to that of the local public schools and she seemed sociable and academically prepared, she also “appeared to reflect her mother’s rigidity on questions of faith.” The order states that the court considered evidence about Amanda’s religious faith only because she was "unhappy that her father did not love her enough to want to spend eternity with her by adopting her faith.
The court didn’t butt in uninvited just to violate this woman’s freedom of religion, it’s a parental rights case. You may agree with the judge or not but both of them brought the case to court.

Also, just imagine you’re a divorced Catholic father and every time you pick up your daughter for visitation she warns you that you’re going to Hell and then your ex yanks her out of school (not what you had agreed to) so she can brainwash her 24/7.
Maybe you’d hire a lawyer, no?
 
Here is a news story from the Concord Monitor:

The court didn’t butt in uninvited just to violate this woman’s freedom of religion, it’s a parental rights case. You may agree with the judge or not but both of them brought the case to court.

Also, just imagine you’re a divorced Catholic father and every time you pick up your daughter for visitation she warns you that you’re going to Hell and then your ex yanks her out of school (not what you had agreed to) so she can brainwash her 24/7.
Maybe you’d hire a lawyer, no?
Or if that isn’t enough for most on here imagine if the Ex yanked her out to raise her as a Neo-Pagan, Satanist or Muslim.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top