Traditional Anglican Communion (TAC) wait for Vatican ruling

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chellow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
-When the Maronites joined up with the Catholic church, we got to keep our married priests. So what’s the problem there?
The problem is that the TAC has a few married bishops, and that’s NOT permitted by the Catholic Church.
 
The problem is that the TAC has a few married bishops, and that’s NOT permitted by the Catholic Church.
Do they have valid orders? i.e. was an Old Catholic or Orthodox Bishop present at their ordinations? I know many traditional “Anglo-Catholics” have done this type of thing to preserve apostolic succession.

If they don’t have valid orders, they would have to be ordained as Catholic Priests, which does not present a problem, but could not be Bishops.

If they are already validly ordained, there is no way for them to stop being Bishops. They would have to agree to function as priests (probably could make them Monsignors as an additional honorific), but would still have the powers of a Bishop.

God Bless
 
Do they have valid orders? i.e. was an Old Catholic or Orthodox Bishop present at their ordinations? I know many traditional “Anglo-Catholics” have done this type of thing to preserve apostolic succession.

If they don’t have valid orders, they would have to be ordained as Catholic Priests, which does not present a problem, but could not be Bishops.

If they are already validly ordained, there is no way for them to stop being Bishops. They would have to agree to function as priests (probably could make them Monsignors as an additional honorific), but would still have the powers of a Bishop.

God Bless
It is questionable whether Anglicans have valid Orders. Some may, but knowing which ones is difficult. The claim of apostolic succession has to be unravelled for centuries, the validity of each ordainer’s orders proven. Early on the Anglicans lost their succession, because they denied it themselves. Later when they reailized this was a mistake they tried to rebuild the succession back to a Catholic bishop to reconnect the chain. Its a mess to figure out. When they are ordained as Catholic priests they receive the sacrament conditionally as are some people conditionally baptised. There may have been a valid baptism, but that can not be certain. In the past when Anglican bishops became Catholic and ordained they were ordained as priests. None have claimed the title bishop. The Church has no power to ordain women in any sacramental Orders. A woman Angican bishop converted and became a lay person recognizing the invalidity of her orders or attempt at them. Similarly, no married Anglican bishop would expect to be recognized. The Church does not consecrate married men to the office of bishop.
 
Far as I know…
-Last time I read this discussion someone said they couldn’t create an Anglican rite because one already existed. What’s up with that? Why don’t they just use the existing one?
-When the Maronites joined up with the Catholic church, we got to keep our married priests. So what’s the problem there?
There is no problem with married priests. Episcopalian priests who convert to Catholicism, even if married, can be ordained and serve as priests in the Catholic Church. They cannot become bishops, and unmarried priests cannot mary after ordination, but married men can and do serve as Priests in the Catholic Church.
 
i’m aware of this. i believe this was to accommodate parishes that convert in whole to the catholic church. i don’t think its intent was to recognize a distinct “anglo-catholic” rite in the church.

the anglican use liturgy is more reverent than your typical novus ordo parish–i believe they celebrate ad orientem. i hope commuion with TAC works out. their liturgy will be a welcome addition to our church.

still, the extraordinary form is the best. the sarum rite would be even better.
Agree 10 tens over. 🙂 And most likely prefer to attend an Anglo-Catholic service.
The problem is that the TAC has a few married bishops, and that’s NOT permitted by the Catholic Church.
In the early days of the church we had bishops that were married but not allow to be remarried.
 
There is no problem with married priests. Episcopalian priests who convert to Catholicism, even if married, can be ordained and serve as priests in the Catholic Church. They cannot become bishops, and unmarried priests cannot mary after ordination, but married men can and do serve as Priests in the Catholic Church.
We have a local Catholic priest who is married…he is convert from Episcopal church…
 
I’m new here, but here is the latest from ROME, if anyone is interested:

25th July 2008
From the Primate of the Traditional Anglican Communion
Subject: Unity with the Holy See

His Grace, Archbishop John Hepworth has released the following message to the College of Bishops, Vicars General and those assisting the TAC to achieve unity with the Holy See.

“My Dear Fathers, Brothers and Sisters,
It is my great pleasure to be able to attach a copy of a letter I received this morning (25 July 2008) from Cardinal Levada, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, via the Apostolic Nuncio in Australia. It is a letter of warmth and encouragement. I have responded, expressing my gratitude on behalf of “my brother bishops”, reaffirming our determination to achieve the unity for which Jesus prayed with such intensity at the Last Supper, no matter what the personal cost this might mean in our discipleship.

This letter should encourage our entire Communion, and those friends who have been assisting us. It should also spur us to renewed prayer for the Holy Father, for Cardinal Levada and his staff at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and for all our clergy and people as we move to ever closer communion in Christ with the Holy See.

I am particularly thankful to the Cardinal Prefect for his generous mention of “corporate reunion”, a pathway seldom travelled in the past, but essential for bringing about the plea of our Master to His Father “May they be completely one”’.

The Traditional Anglican Communion
Archbishop John Hepworth
Primate

the letter:

themessenger.com.au/News/20080725.htm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top