Transgender with Catholic family?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anon97089806
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Meant to go back and edit my post last night, but ended up getting distracted.

Anyways, I didn’t really come here looking for approval of my “choices”, but more for of just advice on how to deal with the Catholics in my town(or just most of the Christians).

Sadly, from what I have gathered by just sitting in corners and listening, most of the Christians whom my parents want me to hang out with, are all homophobic or transphobic(saying it in the sense that they just hate anything to do with LGBT).

So yeah, was just looking for advice on that I guess, but anyways, got what I came for so I will likely stop posting and go back to lurking.
 
Avinia,

Thanks for bringing clarity to what it is you are seeking here.

In my experience many people who do not agree with same sex marriage and embrace the Catholic teachings on marriage etc or any Christian whether Protestant or Catholic are sometimes wrongfully thought to be homophobic just because they disagree with the others position.

In my opinion, you will find all kinds of people who are Christian whether Catholic or Protestant. Some will be homophobic and others just disagree with same sex marriage/unions/relationships but care deeply for their lgbt friends and family.

Some people will agree with your position, others will not. Some people will misunderstand you and not relate to you. Some won’t know how to respond to you. Some may hurt you either knowingly or unkowingly, some may reject you and others will accept you but may not know how to accept you as an individual while not affirming your choices. One thing is for sure, is that you will experience all of the above. As you have in this thread. Although, it’s safe to say that nobody here has rejected you or judging you in any way.

However that may be, I want to encourage you to engage in conversation here, if and when you feel like it. Don’t be a stranger here. We may be responding differently to our shared experiences but I don’t judge you. I care deeply for you and know that you’re in for a pretty rough journey. Some people are comfortable keeping the dialogue going while others are not. I might not agree with your choices but I respect you as a person.

In a Catholic Answers forum there has to be a Catholic voice on these issues, a Catholic voice that is in agreement with what the Catholic Church teaches but I also recognize that we all have our opinions, differing experiences, and even our own journey with God and that we’re all in differing places in our spiritual journey. We can only pray that we’ll experience all that God has for us and that we continue to draw near to Him.
 
Oh and one more thing…

How to deal with “homophobic” Catholic / Protestant:

Well, if I sense a person is really uncomfortable with or hates people who are gay or lesbian trans etc I don’t usually engage in meaningful conversation. I weigh everything I say to people. I get a sense as to where they are at in the dialogue. I also weigh in how much that persons relationship means to me.

For example, my dad - his opinion is " don’t ask, don’t tell" so I’ve never had that conversation with him. At the same time I know that my dad loves me in the way he can. I don’t take his "don’t ask - don’t tell " position as homophobic. He’s old school Catholic and perhaps he is a little homophobic but we have quite a few lgbt folks in our family so nobody in my family is actually blind to these things. We weigh every conversation. Sometimes we’ll have a friendly debate on things and have learned to know when to walk away in our conversations while still loving each other. We also recognize the fact that disagreements with each other is not an indication of our love for the other. Others are super accepting of it and it’s such a non-issue that I just continue living my life as congruently to my faith as possible. There are others who love to engage in dialogue or have a friendly debate and as you can tell I’m pretty eager to have these kinds of conversations.

I have a cousin who just recently came out. His parents, my aunt an uncle are having a rather difficult time with it. However, they love their son. My cousin hasn’t figured out yet that we all love him regardless so he’s still very guarded with us.

Point is this, sometimes you can be bold and just blurt it out. Sometimes you can say a few words here or there to test the water so to speak. Just be careful with how much you share with people. You have to be in a place where you are ready to encounter all kinds of responses including rejection. If you know the possibility of rejection would hurt so much it would nearly kill you then don’t rush into telling them. You have to weigh every conversation carefully. Gain needed support. Of course, I say get connected with Courage. You definitely need a support system before you talk to those who are closest to you. You need a good support system outside of your family because sometimes family is just too close to the situation.

And one thing I’ve learned is that we don’t have to actually say anything really because chances are family is family and family generally will have some indication to what it is you’re struggling with so don’t be surprised if they already know and are kinda dancing around the issue awkwardly and making a few mistakes along the way.

One rule of thumb is, I reflect the love to my family I’d like to receive from them… I extend a tone of grace and a tone of forgiveness although I have boundaries with my family. I can have such boundaries because I moved away from home at the age of 18. I worked on myself, I gained a support system. Sometimes we have to have the greater maturity to take into consideration those we’re sharing our story with. There will be some you won’t want to share everything with and others you might find are safe and that you’d be able to open up to them. There are people you shouldn’t trust with the most intimate details of your story so just use wisdom. If you’re unsure don’t rush into it. The conversation can wait and sometimes the conversation is not necessary. Like I said, I never really had to have the conversation with my family because for the most part they know but they also know my choices without me actually having to say anything. I also know that I’d be loved and accepted regardless so I feel no need to have “the conversation”.

Anyway, I sincerely hope that you won’t be a stranger on this forum. 🙂
 
I do agree with SjMel.

Be careful you dont stereotype Catholics or Christians and their views when it comes to the LGBT community. It’s as wrong as when people stereotype the LGBT community.

So, raise above and avoid stereotyping ANY group of people, and be open to dialogue. 🙂

God’s blessings to you as you go forward in your life. 👍
 
I had no problems being openly queer as my family is largely secular. I dated a trans girl for a while, and all of her trans friends seemed like nice enough people. One actually used money she made from being a sex industry worker to support homeless teen’s. A lot like the early S.T.A.R. folk.

I made the choice to be Catholic and follow the teachings of the church, but would never imagine to tell anybody else what to do. My advice would be to seek God in all things and look for truth. If the Church is the truth, as I believe, you’ll find her. I to was molested as an earlier person said, although I drank away those memory’s long ago. Not that that’s your case. I find the likelihood of every queer… ever… being molested, as some claim, to be so small as to be laughable.

If you decide to transition, witch I wouldn’t recommend. I’d suggest you stay away from ANYONE who fetishesizes you for being trans. Those kind of people don’t care about you, they just want control. If anyone ever makes you feel uncomfortable for going to Mass pity them. They likely have some defect that there covering by judging others.

Jesus be with you, and may the Blessed Virgin look out for all of God’s children. Good luck on finding financial independence!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top